Mac Audio & Acoustical Consultants Pty Ltd (in liq) v Eddy

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

MAC AUDIO & ACOUSTICAL CONSULTANTS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)  v  EDDY & THE TRUSTEE OF THE ESTATE OF MORPHETT
[1999] SASC 443

Magistrates Appeal:  Civil

  1. WICKS J          This is an appeal against an order of a Magistrate that the plaintiff provide security for the defendants’ costs. The order to provide security was made in the course of an action in the Magistrates Court for damages for various alleged breaches of directors’ duties contrary to s232 of the Corporations Law.   A brief overview of the history of this matter will suffice to place this appeal in context.

  2. Graham Wallace Morphett (“Morphett”) and Robert Alfred Eddy (“the first defendant”) were the directors of the plaintiff company Mac Audio Acoustical Consultants Pty Ltd.  Leslie Helen Eddy, the first defendant’s wife, was an employee of the plaintiff.  On 12 July 1991 the plaintiff, by its directors Morphett and the first defendant, entered into a contract for the sale of real property owned by the plaintiff.  Upon settlement of the contract on 6 September 1991 the plaintiff alleges that the proceeds, or part thereof, were paid into the plaintiff’s fully drawn advance account and cheque account.  Subsequently Morphett and Leslie Eddy received payments from the company which represented backpay to December 1990.  The plaintiff further alleges that from 30 June 1991 to 31 January 1992 the first defendant and Morphett authorised the payment of additional wages to themselves and Leslie Eddy.  According to the plaintiff, at the time these payments were made, the company was trading at a loss and was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due.

  3. On 10 June 1992, this Court ordered that the plaintiff be wound up and that a liquidator be appointed. By Statement of Claim filed in the Magistrates Court on 11 July 1997, the plaintiff claims $42,860.22 damages for various alleged breaches of directors’ duties under s232 of the Corporations Law.  As Morphett died on 4 June 1996, the claim is brought against his estate.  A defence and a further amended defence were filed on 26 May 1998 and 29 July 1998 respectively.

  4. The trial was scheduled to commence on 2 March 1999.  On 22 February 1999 the defendants filed an application for security for costs marked specially returnable.  The application was heard on 25 February 1999, 3 days prior to the scheduled commencement of the trial and the learned Magistrate delivered his ruling on the same day.  An order for security of costs was made against the plaintiff.

  5. By application dated 11 March 1999 the plaintiff sought leave from this court to appeal against the Magistrate’s order for security for costs.  Leave was granted by a Judge of this Court on 9 April 1999.  The Notice of Appeal dated 13 April 1999 sets out the following grounds of appeal:

    “1..... That the learned Magistrate wrongfully exercised his discretion in ordering that the plaintiff provide security for costs and acted against the weight of the evidence.

    2That the learned Magistrate wrongfully exercised…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mac Audio & Acoustical Consultants Pty Ltd (in liq) v Eddy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 443
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mac Audio & Acoustical Consultants Pty Ltd (in liquidation) v Eddy and The Trustee of the Estate of Morphett was an appeal heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia concerning an order made by a Magistrate requiring the plaintiff to provide security for the defendants' costs. The plaintiff, a company in liquidation, had filed a claim against the defendants for damages related to alleged breaches of directors' duties under section 232 of the Corporations Law. The case involved the former directors of the plaintiff company, Graham Wallace Morphett and Robert Alfred Eddy, as well as Leslie Helen Eddy, who was an employee of the plaintiff. The plaintiff alleged that the proceeds from the sale of its property were misappropriated, and that the defendants had authorised payments to themselves and Leslie Eddy during a period when the company was insolvent. The trial was scheduled to commence, but the defendants applied for security for costs, which was granted by the Magistrate. The plaintiff subsequently appealed this decision.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Magistrate had wrongfully exercised his discretion in ordering security for costs, and if so, whether the order should be set aside. The court considered whether the Magistrate had failed to give sufficient weight to the delay in bringing the application, the impecuniosity of the plaintiff, and the effect of the order on the proceedings. The court also examined whether the Magistrate had sufficient evidence before him to grant security for costs in the amount of $10,300.

In determining whether an order for security for costs should be made, the court noted that there is no pre-disposition in favour of granting security when the plaintiff is unable to meet the defendant's costs in the event that the action should fail. While impecuniosity is a factor to be considered, it is not given special weight. The court held that the Magistrate had failed to consider the fact that the plaintiff was in liquidation and that a liquidator had been appointed, which distinguished this case from previous decisions. The court also found that the Magistrate had not considered the position of those behind the plaintiff, who may have been able to provide security. The court concluded that the Magistrate had erred in not considering these matters and that, in light of the error, the appeal could be determined by the court on its own discretion.

The court set aside the order for security for costs made by the Magistrate, finding that it should not have been made. The appeal was allowed, and the matter was to be heard for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WICKS J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WICKS J

Full text does not contain this section.