LZMX and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

LZMX  and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 378 (26 February 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/7627

Re:LZMX

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member B J Illingworth

Date:26 February 2021

Place:Adelaide

The decision under review is affirmed.

...................[SGND]........................

Senior Member B J Illingworth

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – whether support is reasonable and necessary – whether NDIA should fund a lift –  whether cost of support is reasonable – whether funding a lift is consistent with the Supports for Participants Rules and Operational Guidelines – whether a lift is a reasonable and necessary support within the context of s 34(1)(c) and (e) – Decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

CASES

KLMN & National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 1815.

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency and Another (2017) 252 FCR 121.

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] 233 FCR 201.

NDIA v WRMF 378 ALR 449; [2020] FCAFC 70.

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013.

Including Specific Types of Supports in Plans Operational Guideline, National Disability Insurance Agency. 

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member B J Illingworth

26 February 2021

Introduction

  1. The Applicant sought review of an internal review decision of a delegate of the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) (the Respondent) dated 17 September 2019. That decision affirmed a reviewable decision made pursuant to s 100(6) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The Applicant was represented by his daughter SH, and the Respondent was represented by Mr d’Assumpcao on instructions from the Respondent. The Tribunal was greatly assisted by both the Applicant’s representative and counsel for the Respondent through their diligent and professional presentation of their respective cases.

  3. The Applicant was a double leg amputee. He and his wife owned a residence that was unsuited to the Applicant’s disability including wheelchair use. Their surrounding suburb was also not suited to wheelchair use. The application related to the question of reasonable and necessary supports in a NDIA plan for building and renovation costs to a property, purchased by a company of which the Applicant’s daughter and her partner were directors, and into which the Applicant and his wife intended to move and occupy as tenants.

  4. The premises had a dual function. Downstairs was converted into the daughter’s business premises. Upstairs was converted into a residential premise to be occupied by the Applicant and his wife.

  5. A number of proposed renovation costs were in dispute at the start of the hearing. To the parties’ credit, all but one renovation cost was resolved. The remaining issue was whether a lift, installed in the premises to provide access to the first floor, was a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of sub-paragraphs 34(1)(a) – (f) of the Act.

    Background

  6. The Applicant is 65 years…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LZMX and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 378
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by LZMX (the Applicant) against the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding the NDIA's refusal to fund the installation of a lift in a residential property. The Applicant, a 65-year-old double leg amputee, sought funding for a lift to provide access to the first floor of a property purchased by his daughter, which was intended to accommodate both her psychology practice on the ground floor and the Applicant and his wife's residence on the first floor. The core dispute revolved around whether the proposed lift constituted a "reasonable and necessary" support under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the installation of the lift was a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of section 34(1) of the Act, considering factors such as whether the support was related to the Applicant's disability needs, whether it represented value for money, and whether it was consistent with the NDIS Supports for Participants Rules and Operational Guidelines. Specifically, the Tribunal had to assess if the cost of the lift was reasonable and if funding it aligned with the principles of providing supports that enable participants to achieve their goals and aspirations.

The Tribunal reasoned that while the Applicant had significant disability-related needs and the property's layout necessitated a solution for first-floor access, the decision to occupy the first floor and the subsequent installation of the lift were primarily driven by lifestyle choices made by the family. These choices included facilitating closer family connections and enabling the Applicant to live in a more convenient urban location. The Tribunal noted that the Applicant did not have a proprietary interest in the property, and the installation of a lift, a significant capital building addition, was generally not funded by the NDIS under its guidelines, particularly when it was linked to lifestyle decisions rather than being directly and solely related to the Applicant's disability goals.

Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that the cost of installing the lift was not a reasonable and necessary support in these circumstances. The Tribunal found that the decision to install the lift was part of broader lifestyle choices made by the family, and therefore, it did not represent value for money for the taxpayer. The Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision, finding that the installation of the lift, in this specific context, was an extravagance that the family could reasonably be expected to provide themselves.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

A number of proposed renovation costs were in dispute at the start of the hearing. To the parties’ credit, all but one renovation cost was resolved. The remaining issue was whether a lift, installed in the premises to provide access to the first floor, was a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of sub-paragraphs 34(1)(a) – (f) of the Act.Background The Applicant is 65 years of age and a double leg amputee. In March 2016, the Applicant’s left leg was amputated below the knee. In August 2016, his right leg was amputated below the knee. In late 2016 the Applicant’s daughter was looking for new premises from which to run her psychology practice. In early 2017 the Applicant and his wife asked their daughter to consider the purchase of a dual-purpose property in Adelaide that would accommodate the business and provide a separate residence for them. The Applicant and his wife believed a residence in the city had a number of benefits including that;(a)it enabled the Applicant and his wife to spend more time with their daughter and daughter-in-law who worked in the practice, and see their grandchild who they could babysit for their daughter-in-law when she was at work;(b)it enabled the Applicant to be close to the Royal Adelaide Hospital and reduce travel time to the hospital for treatment; and(c)it was more conveniently situated to permit the Applicant a wider range of social and community activities with better disability infrastructure.The Applicant’s daughter agreed with that proposal. In June 2017 the Applicant suffered a fall from his wheelchair due to poor footpath infrastructure at local shops and suffered significant injury to his left stump. In July 2017 the Applicant’s daughter purchased a two-storey property in Adelaide. The settlement date was 15 September 2017. An architect was immediately engaged to design the building renovations to accommodate the business needs of the daughter on the ground floor, and the residential requirements of the Applicant and his wife on the first floor, taking into account the Applicant’s disability needs. On 12 December 2017 the Department of Health (SA) provided a letter of support for the Applicant’s participation in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). An architectural floorplan for the Adelaide premises dated 25 January 2018 included a lift for the Applicant’s access to the first floor,[1] and on 1 February 2018 the Applicant’s daughter received a proposal for the installation of an Austand CH-3000 Machine Room Less Home Lift. [1] Exhibit C. On 5 February 2018 the Applicant became a participant in the NDIS. On 14 March 2018 Austand elevators confirmed the order of the Austand CH-3000 Machine Room Less Home Lift with invoice number 06181574. On 15 March 2018 the Architect provided a lift plan and, in order to meet the deadline for the Applicant’s planned move-in date in November 2018, a 20% deposit was paid on a revised amount of $65,406.00 (including GST) for the manufacture of the lift.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A lift was considered most suitable for the Applicant to access the first floor because:(a)there was direct access between the home and the garage. The garage was undercover with level flooring, adequate lighting and was the safest location for the Applicant to transfer in and out of his motor vehicle, whether he was walking with prosthetics or mobilising in his wheelchair;(b)the lift enabled the Applicant to use any method of mobility, including his powered wheelchair and manual wheelchair using prosthetics with walking sticks. There was no requirement to transfer on and off a platform or seat;(c)the Applicant would be able to use a lift independently without the need for support to participate in community activities and events, which would assist in achieving his goals.The Applicant’s EvidenceStatement dated 14 June 2020 and oral evidence The Applicant detailed in his statement his family’s experience with NDIS as difficult, including staff turnover causing confusion, plans and advice being inconsistent, poor communication and decision-making. He was critical of delays which he said contributed to his subsequent left leg amputation. He detailed difficulties in addressing replacement prosthetics which he said required replacement when needed, rather than when NDIA got around to it. The Applicant referred to a complaint made to the Ombudsman which they withdrew following assurance from a staff member that outstanding issues would be progressed, but to no avail. The Applicant said that his current house was unsuitable. He and his family looked for an alternate residence but were unsuccessful. The Applicant explained, when using his wheelchair, some of the difficulties he had living at his current home which is located in a new suburb. Those difficulties included, from time to time, an absence of foot- paths or ramps. There was no footpath outside his home and he currently had to go down the road to get to a footpath which he can use, provided it is not a rubbish bin day, as rubbish bins on footpaths make navigating difficult. A light pole also may suddenly appear in the middle of a footpath which made manoeuvring difficult. He can walk 20 metres at best with the aid of prosthetic limbs, after which he feels like he is bruising the bone in his stump. Living in his current home is challenging. He cannot get out unless somebody collects him. This can put a strain on his marital relationship. In the city, he should be able to get out of the home and have more freedom. The Applicant and his wife have been wanting to move from their current home for some years and, more recently, they have been researching other premises but have found nothing. The new Adelaide premises will enable them to see their grandson, who was about to turn three years of age, more often while their daughter-in-law is at work in the practice downstairs. It is easier to see him if they are in the same building. The Applicant retains his driver’s licence and continues to drive. He wishes to continue to do so in the future. He uses a slide board to assist him in manoeuvring into and out of the motor vehicle from his wheelchair.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the circumstances of this matter, it is not value for money to install a lift at significant cost to the taxpayer in circumstances where the Applicant has no proprietary interest in the property. However well-intentioned the family members were in granting a life tenancy in the property to the Applicant, when balanced with the risk of termination of the Granny Flat Agreement, the installation of the lift does not represent value for money for the purposes of s 34(1)(c) of the Act. CONCLUSION The decisions that underpinned the purchase of the particular city property, the joint occupancy with the Applicant occupying the first floor, the reconfiguration of the property and the installation of the lift were lifestyle decisions. Those lifestyle decisions were made by a close and loving family who had undergone much difficulty in navigating the NDIS system and who were determined to achieve what they genuinely believed was best for the Applicant given his significant disability. Once the decision was made that the Applicant would occupy the first floor, the purchased property, in the absence of major modification, could not be regarded as one that provided, in the words of Dr Cafaro, safe and appropriate housing that enabled the Applicant to conduct his normal life in an environment which was accessible to a heavily disabled person requiring full time wheelchair use. The installation of a lift was not in and of itself, directly relevant to the Applicant’s goals and aspirations, but was relevant to the lifestyle choices that the family then made to enable the Applicant to occupy and use the first-floor accommodation. As the Respondent submitted, this was an extravagance that was, pursuant to s 34(1)(e), in the circumstances of this matter, reasonable to expect the family to provide. The Tribunal does not criticise the Applicant and his family for that decision. They were fortunate to be able to make the lifestyle choices that they did, and to their credit. Nor does this mean that, in all circumstances, the funding of a lift will never be a reasonable and necessary support. The Applicant provided the Tribunal with an example where such funding had been granted. Each matter will turn on its own facts. However, in this matter those lifestyle decisions to which the Tribunal has referred, including the installation of a lift, guided the Applicant and his family and accordingly the cost of installing a lift at the new premises was not a reasonable and necessary support. The Guidelines provide that the NDIS will generally not fund capital building additions such as lifts or inclinators to allow access to multiple levels of a home. The Guidelines are not mandatory and there may be occasions when, in the factual circumstances of a matter, such funding will be a reasonable and necessary support. However, entering into a Granny Flat Agreement to occupy the first floor of a property, purchased by a company in which the participant’s daughter and partner are directors, and in which property capital building works (including a lift) were undertaken and based on lifestyle considerations, means that the cost of the lift, in the circumstances of this matters, is not properly regarded as a reasonable and necessary support to be met by the NDIS.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant said in response to the possible impact of COVID-19 and any possible economic recession, that she works in the health industry and, in periods of recession, health care workers continue to do well and are not impacted upon to the same extent as other professions. It would only be the change in Medicare funding for mental health consultations that would have any real impact on her business, which she said was performing very well.CONSIDERATION The Tribunal received written statements from the Applicant’s wife LH and daughter SH which detailed the Applicant’s health difficulties and the impact his disability had upon both he and LH. The Tribunal accepts their evidence. The Tribunal also received a written statement from the Applicant together with his oral evidence. The Applicant was an impressive witness and the Tribunal accepts his evidence. The reports and opinions of Dr Cafaro were unchallenged. The reports and opinions expressed were prepared referable to a time when the Applicant was residing in his original home, which was unsuited to the Applicant’s disability needs. Dr Cafaro supported the Applicant’s change in residence to meet his disability requirements, which in turn, would support his rehabilitation. The Tribunal accepts the opinion of Dr Cafaro that the Applicant would benefit from safe and appropriate housing that accommodated his wheelchair requirements, that would not be a hinderance on his recovery, and that would enable him, as much as possible, to conduct his life and achieve his desired goals. The Tribunal accepts that the facilities at his original home did not achieve that outcome and was having a detrimental effect on the Applicant and LH. However, that opinion does not assist the Tribunal in determining whether the purchased lift was a reasonable and necessary support, in the circumstances of this matter. The Applicant underwent bilateral below knee amputations in 2016 well before he engaged with the NDIS. The Tribunal accepts that his home was not suited to a person who had mobility issues requiring the use of Assistive Technology including an electric wheelchair. The Tribunal received photographs of the Applicant’s home depicting damage to walls and doorways caused by the Applicant’s wheelchair and walker. The Tribunal also accepts that the suburb in which the Applicant lived was not suited to his disability, and he had difficulty navigating around the suburban streets in his wheelchair due to changes in terrain, positioning of lampposts and rubbish bins placed on the footpath. The Tribunal received photographs which corroborated that evidence. The Tribunal also accepts that the Applicant’s fall from his wheelchair on a roadway in June 2016 and the injury to his stump, resulting in two weeks’ hospitalisation and 6 months’ confinement to a wheelchair, had a significant impact upon his confidence, independence and quality of life. He would not leave the house without assistance from another.