Loadsman and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

Loadsman and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 1990 (29 June 2021)

Division:                NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s): 2020/5748

Re:Tascha Loadsman

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member W Frost

Date:29 June 2021

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and makes a decision in substitution for the decision so set aside that a Hercules PS Track stairclimber and associated modifications at Mrs Loadsman’s home be included in the statement of participant supports in her NDIS plan.

...............................[sgd].............................

Member W Frost

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – Motor Neuron Disease – whether support is reasonable and necessary – whether NDIA should fund a lift – whether NDIA should fund a stairclimber – whether cost of support is reasonable – whether funding for support is consistent with the Support for Participant Rules and Operational Guidelines – decision under review set aside and substituted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 43

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 ss 3-4, 33-35, 100, 103, 209

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Support for Participants) Rules 2013

Cases

Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

LZMX and NDIA [2021] AATA 378

Madelaine and NDIA [2019] AATA 4025

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

Secondary Materials

National Disability Insurance Scheme – Operational Guidelines – Planning

National Disability Insurance Scheme – Operational Guidelines – Including Specific Types of Support in Plans

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member W Frost

29 June 2021

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Mrs Tascha Loadsman, is 46 years old and was diagnosed with Motor Neuron Disease (MND) in January 2020. She lives in a two-storey house with her husband, three of their five children and her mother. In July 2020, Mrs Loadsman’s second National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) plan was approved, but it did not contain funding she requested for installation of an elevator in an external lift shaft at her home in order to independently access both levels.[1]

    [1] Exhibit R1, T6, pages 99-103; T12, pages 136-148.

  2. In September 2020, following Mrs Loadsman’s request for the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to conduct an internal review of its decision not to fund an elevator,[2] a delegate of the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the NDIA confirmed that original decision, under section 100 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (NDIS Act). An elevator was determined not to meet the value for money criterion under subsection 34(1)(c) of the NDIS Act.[3] Pursuant to section 103 of the NDIS Act, Mrs Loadsman applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) for merits review of the NDIA’s decision.[4]

    [2] Exhibit R1, T8, page 109; T9, pages 110-120.

    [3] Exhibit R1, T1A, pages 8-12.

    [4] Exhibit R1, T1, pages 1-7.

    ISSUE

  3. The Tribunal must decide whether the installation of an elevator (and associated building works) at Mrs Loadsman’s home is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Loadsman and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1990
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mrs Tascha Loadsman for review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse funding for the installation of an elevator and associated building works at her home. Mrs Loadsman, who has Motor Neuron Disease, sought this support to enable her to access all parts of her two-storey residence, as her mobility had significantly deteriorated, preventing her from safely using the stairs. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether the proposed elevator installation constituted a reasonable and necessary support under the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (NDIS Act).

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the requested elevator and associated building works met the criteria for "reasonable and necessary support" as defined by subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act. This involved assessing whether the support was cost-effective, would substantially improve Mrs Loadsman's life outcomes and provide long-term benefit, and whether it was the most appropriate and effective way to achieve her goals, considering alternative supports and the cost of relocation. The Tribunal also had regard to the NDIA's Operational Guidelines, which provide guidance on the application of the NDIS Act and the Support for Participant Rules, particularly concerning the "value for money" criterion.

The Tribunal reasoned that while the installation of an elevator was a significant expense, it was necessary to enable Mrs Loadsman to access all areas of her home, thereby promoting her independence and participation in family life. However, upon considering the evidence and the principles of value for money, the Tribunal determined that a Hercules PS Track stairclimber, along with necessary modifications to facilitate its use, represented a more appropriate and cost-effective solution than a full elevator installation. The Tribunal found that this alternative support would achieve the desired outcome of enabling Mrs Loadsman to access different levels of her home, aligning with the NDIS Act's requirements for reasonable and necessary supports.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's original decision. In substitution, the Tribunal ordered that funding for a Hercules PS Track stairclimber and the required home modifications be included in Mrs Loadsman's NDIS plan as a reasonable and necessary support.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal must decide whether the installation of an elevator (and associated building works) at Mrs Loadsman’s home is a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of subsection 33(2) of the NDIS Act. BACKGROUND In 2013, Mrs Loadsman and her husband bought a two-storey house, which is situated on the corner of two roads in a suburb of Queanbeyan in New South Wales. The two storeys are connected by a single straight staircase. Mrs Loadsman’s bedroom and bathroom (which she shares with her husband) are on the ground floor of the house. The NDIA has separately allocated funding to make them more accessible. The garage is also on the ground floor, which opens out onto one of the roads at the front of the property. Mrs Loadsman can access all areas on the lower level of the house and the immediate external areas on that lower level. The house originally had a kitchen and lounge room on each level. The Loadsman’s recent renovations of the house removed the kitchen on the ground floor and the adjoining room now has a billiard table. A swimming pool was also installed in the rear yard at the property, which is only accessible by external stairs or by entering from a side driveway. Mrs Loadsman received her MND diagnosis during the course of the renovations. One of her NDIS goals is to have access to all parts of the house; Mrs Loadsman wants to remain in her home and has sought supports to overcome the problems that its layout poses for her mobility and independence.[5][5] Exhibit R1, T11, page 128. Funding was requested from the NDIA for the installation of an elevator to allow Mrs Loadsman to access the upstairs kitchen, lounge room, dining room and balconies, because she will increasingly be unable to safely move up and down the stairs that connect the two storeys. The proposed elevator would be located on the outside wall at the rear of the house. It would require the removal of sections of the external wall on both levels of the house to create two entrances from inside the home to an external lift shaft. In September 2020, Mrs Loadsman applied to the Tribunal for review of the NDIA’s decision refusing the inclusion of funding for the installation of an elevator and the associated building works in her NDIS plan. On 8 January 2021, with the consent of the parties, the Tribunal made orders which remitted the reviewable decision to the NDIA, pursuant to section 42D of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act). On 15 January 2021, following the NDIA’s reconsideration of the reviewable decision in accordance with the Tribunal’s abovementioned order, it approved the commencement from that date of Mrs Loadsman's third NDIS plan, which continued her reasonable and necessary supports on a pro rata basis and stipulated a plan review date of 16 July 2021.[6] Mrs Loadsman’s current plan comprises total NDIS funding for six months of $126,145.51, made up of $68,419.90 for core supports, $48,944.61 for capacity building supports and $8,781 for capital supports.[7][6] Exhibit R1, Tab 6.[7] Exhibit R1, Tab 6.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mrs Loadsman submitted that the supply of an elevator and associated building works satisfies all of the ‘reasonable and necessary support’ limbs of subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act and the Tribunal should therefore approve the inclusion of that support in the statement of participant supports in her NDIS plan pursuant to subsection 33(2) of the NDIS Act. EVIDENCEMrs Tascha Loadsman The Tribunal has considered Mrs Loadsman’s ‘Life Experience Statement’ regarding her MND diagnosis and request for the provision of funding by the NDIA for the installation of an elevator at her home.[19] [19] Exhibit R1, Tab 4. Mrs Loadsman attended the Tribunal hearing in-person to give evidence in this proceeding. She informed the Tribunal that she has difficulty with her speech, including due to new medication, and wrote down some responses to questions, which were conveyed at the proceeding by a Tribunal assistant. These handwritten notes were taken into evidence to avoid any doubt as to Mrs Loadsman’s evidence to the Tribunal,[20] noting also that the parties had the benefit of the transcript of the hearing for the purposes of making their written closing submissions. In addition, Mrs Loadsman explained to the Tribunal that it was ‘part of’ MND that she could uncontrollably cry or laugh while speaking, but she was content to persist with her evidence despite occasional difficulty.[20] Exhibit A3. Mrs Loadsman confirmed to the Tribunal that she has lived at her current house since 2013. She lives with her husband, Mr Matthew Loadsman, and four of their children, only one of which is still of school age, and her 78-year-old mother. Her husband subsequently told the Tribunal that three of their children now reside with them at the property. Mrs Loadsman told the Tribunal that her stated goals covered in her NDIS plan included being close to family, accessing the community and all parts of her home and the property. Mrs Loadsman also said that she had exercise and social needs. In this regard, Mrs Loadsman said it was ‘absolutely’ important for her to have independence in her home and the community. Mrs Loadsman was asked about her difficulties getting up the internal stairs from the ground floor of the house to the upstairs section. She replied that she ‘cannot’ get upstairs because her ‘legs don’t work’. She currently mobilises in the home with a wheelchair, but until recently was using a walker and an Ankle Foot Orthosis (AFO) on her left leg. Mrs Loadsman said she was waiting for provision of an approved powered wheelchair and AFO for her right leg. However, Mrs Loadsman told the Tribunal that she cannot currently get any wheelchair upstairs and nobody can assist her to do so or get her upstairs. Because she cannot access the upstairs section of the house, Mrs Loadsman said she was unable to participate in family activities undertaken on that level. Additionally, Mrs Loadsman said that she cannot currently undertake any social activities in the courtyard area at the rear of the property, which includes the pool. To access this area, Mrs Loadsman must go out the front of the property and onto the road, because there is no footpath, and down the side of the house and in a side roller door. Mrs Loadsman told the Tribunal that she felt ‘frustrated’, ‘upset’, ‘unimportant’ and ‘like I am already dead’ as a result of not being able to engage in the family’s social activities.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, as discussed in these reasons, the Tribunal is satisfied that the provision of a Hercules PS Track stairclimber meets the criteria set out in subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act. The decision under review should therefore be set aside and a decision made in substitution for the NDIA to fund this reasonable and necessary support by way of inclusion in the statement of participant supports in Mrs Loadsman’s NDIS plan under subsection 33(2) of the NDIS Act. DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and makes a decision in substitution for the decision so set aside that a Hercules PS Track stairclimber and required modifications at Mrs Loadsman’s home be included in the statement of participant supports in her NDIS plan.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clause 3.1 of the Rules relates to the ‘value for money’ criterion in subsection 34(1)(c) of the NDIS Act and provides that:In deciding whether the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support, the CEO is to consider the following matters: (a) whether there are comparable supports which would achieve the same outcome at a substantially lower cost; (b) whether there is evidence that the support will substantially improve the life stage outcomes for, and be of long-term benefit to, the participant; (c) whether funding or provision of the support is likely to reduce the cost of the funding of supports for the participant in the long term (for example, some early intervention supports may be value for money given their potential to avoid or delay reliance on more costly supports); (d) for supports that involve the provision of equipment or modifications: (i) the comparative cost of purchasing or leasing the equipment or modifications; and (ii) whether there are any expected changes in technology or the participant’s circumstances in the short term that would make it inappropriate to fund the equipment or modifications; (e) whether the cost of the support is comparable to the cost of supports of the same kind that are provided in the area in which the participant resides;(f) whether the support will increase the participant’s independence and reduce the participant’s need for other kinds of supports (for example, some home modifications may reduce a participant’s need for home care).Operational Guidelines The NDIA has made operational guidelines to provide guidance on the application of the NDIS Act and the Rules. Relevantly, the NDIS Operational Guidelines – Planning (Planning Guideline)[9] provides that:[10] Before any support is added to a participant’s plan, the NDIA must also be satisfied that the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable as compared to the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support (section 345(1)(c)).…The NDIA will consider value for money both in the context of the relative expense of different supports available to achieve the same goal, and in the context of whether investments in supports will represent value for money over time.For example, where an investment in early intervention supports is likely to reduce a participant's overall support needs over time, the NDIA may consider that the support represents value for money as an early investment (even where that value may be realised over the period of several plans).In applying the value for money criteria in the NDIS Act and Supports for Participants Rules, the NDIA will, to the extent is permissible under the NDIS Act and Rules, consider the cost of any available in-kind supports and the impact on the sustainability of the NDIS if supports which are already available in-kind are instead purchased by paying cash.The NDIA is considerate of the fact that funding supports that do not represent value for money has the potential to undermine the financial sustainability of the NDIS (section 3(3)(b)).For example, where assistive technologies and certain types of aids and equipment are being considered, it is expected the NDIA will generally only fund the minimum necessary or standard level of support required (i.e. a wheelchair with standard specifications and features, as opposed to funding additional items such as bespoke wheels or other luxury finishes).Home modifications, as a further example, would generally only be considered where the home to be modified is the participant's principal place of residence and the participant intends to remain living at the premises. Other value for money considerations in this instance would relate to the length of a tenancy agreement for participant's [sic] who are renting, whether the outcomes expected to be achieved by home modifications could be achieved using less costly alternatives or whether supporting a participant with the cost of relocating to more accessible premises would be a more cost effective solution.[9] Exhibit R1, T15, pages 167-240. [10] ibid., pages 183-184.