Sewell and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

Sewell and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 2783 (31 August 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2021/5932

Re:Christopher Lee Sewell

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member P Smith

Date:31 August 2023

Place:Sydney

Pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Chief Executive Officer of the National Disability Insurance Agency with a direction that the following reasonable and necessary supports be included in the Applicant’s Plan over a 12-month period:

1.    Funding in the amount of $16,900.00 for the construction and installation of a pathway to be included in the Applicant’s Plan as recommended by Deborah Hammond, Occupational Therapist in her Functional Capacity Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022 and by Peter Nasr, Building Consultant in his Feasibility Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022.

2.    Funding in the amount of $12,300.00 for minor modifications to the Applicant’s ensuite bathroom as recommended by Deborah Hammond, Occupational Therapist in her Functional Capacity Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022 and by Peter Nasr, Building Consultant in his Feasibility Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022.

3.    Funding in the amount of $14,780.00 to modify the Applicant’s home for minor modifications as recommended by Deborah Hammond, Occupational Therapist in her Functional Capacity Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022 and by Peter Nasr, Building Consultant in his Feasibility Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022:

(a)Changing the door hardware on internal and external doors;

(b)Changing light switches and power points to large format switches;

(c)Installing a sensor light for night time bathroom use; and

(d)Using wireless charging for electronic devices.

4.    As agreed between the parties, funding to the Applicant’s Capacity Building Supports Budget for nine x 30-minute podiatry visits per year (4.5 hours per year), plus the amount of $120.00 for an annual biomedical assessment and the amount of $160.00 for an annual podiatrist report.

5.    Funding to the Applicant’s Capacity Building Supports Budget for one hour of physiotherapy per month (12 hours per year), plus three hours for report writing and consultation with other health professionals (15 hours in total).

...............................[SGD].........................................

Member P Smith

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION – Application to the Tribunal to review a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency to approve a statement of participant supports under subsection 33(2) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) – whether the Applicant’s request for approval to install three external ramps or pathways with handrails to three outside areas to the Applicant’s home meets the reasonable and necessary criterion test – whether the Applicant’s request for approval to tile the outside area of his swimming pool with either travertine or porcelain tiles meets the reasonable and necessary criterion test – whether the Applicant’s request for approval to modify his main bathroom and toilet meets the reasonable and necessary criterion test – whether the Applicant’s request for approval for a Thermomix meets the reasonable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sewell and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2783
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) to review a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Agency) regarding the approval of a statement of participant supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). The applicant, Mr. Sewell, sought approval for various supports, including home modifications, assistive technology such as a Thermomix and a home automation system, and increased allied health and personal support services. A key point of contention was whether these requested supports met the "reasonable and necessary" criteria, particularly in light of the applicant's decision to purchase a home without prior consultation with the Agency.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant's requests for specific supports, such as external ramps, tiling around a swimming pool, bathroom modifications, a Thermomix, a home automation system, additional physiotherapy and exercise physiology, and increased 1:1 support for daily living and community access, were reasonable and necessary. The Tribunal also had to consider the weight to be given to differing expert opinions, particularly concerning home modifications, and whether the applicant's decision to purchase a home without Agency involvement impacted the assessment of value for money for public funds. The applicant's underlying condition, Charcot Marie Tooth Disease, and its contribution to reported pain were also relevant considerations.

The Tribunal's reasoning involved a detailed assessment of each requested support against the legislative framework, including the "reasonable and necessary" criteria outlined in section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). The Tribunal considered the evidence presented, including various occupational therapy reports, physiotherapy and exercise physiology reports, and participant impact statements. While some supports were deemed not sufficiently evidenced as reasonable and necessary, the Tribunal ultimately set aside the Agency's decision.

The Tribunal remitted the matter to the Chief Executive Officer of the Agency with a direction to include specific reasonable and necessary supports in the applicant's plan over a 12-month period. These included funding for pathway construction, minor ensuite bathroom modifications, other minor home modifications, podiatry visits, and physiotherapy. The decision reflected a balance between the applicant's needs and the prudent expenditure of public funds, acknowledging the importance of appropriate assessments and expert advice in determining the suitability of supports.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant is seeking additional funding to his Core Supports Budget for four hours per week of 1:1 support to access the community because he has finished full time employment[75] and is now working for himself. It was submitted by the Applicant that due to this change in circumstance he is more isolated than ever. It was further submitted by the Applicant that additional funding for four hours per week of 1:1 support will enable him to participate in community and social activities[76].[75] The Tribunal understands that the Applicant ceased fulltime employment in November of 2021.[76] See the Applicant’s Participant Impact Statement at A13 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.Evidence relied upon by the Applicant The Applicant relied upon the following evidence in support of his request for the approval of the supports identified and discussed above:(a)The Occupational Therapy Report of Ms Wright dated 23 August 2022[77];[77] See A2 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(b)The Occupational Therapy Report of Ms Wright dated 16 November 2021[78];[78] See A13 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(c)The Occupational Therapy Home Modification Specification Report of Ms Wright dated 16 and 23 August 2021[79]; [79] See T1D of the T-documents and A17 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(d)The Thermomix Functional Assessment Report of Ms Wright dated 10 August 2021[80];[80] See T1C of the T-documents and A13 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(e)The IOH Functional Assessment Report of Ms Wright dated 5 August 2021[81];[81] See T1B of the T-documents and A16 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle. (f)The Plan Review Supplementary Support Report of Ms Wright dated 25 May 2021[82];[82] See T23 of the T-documents.(g)The Thermomix Letter of Support Report of Ms Wright dated 19 April 2021[83];[83] See T18 of the T-documents.(h)The Chris Sewell Home System Support Report of Ms Wright dated 25 February 2021[84]; [84] See T15 of the T-documents.(i)The Chris Sewell Thermomix Supplementary Report of Ms Wright dated 17 December 2020[85];[85] See T12 of the T-documents.(j)The National Disability Insurance Scheme Complex Home Modification Assessment Template Form completed by Ms Wright on 18 August 2021[86];[86] See T1G of the T-documents and A16 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(k)The National Disability Insurance Scheme Complex Home Modification Assessment Template Form completed by Ms Wright on 24 May 2021[87]; [87] See T22 of the T-documents.(l)The National Disability Insurance Scheme Complex Home Modification Assessment Template Form completed by Mr Sagenes on 22 February 2022[88]; [88] See A9 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(m)The Physiotherapy Report of Mr Morrissy dated 16 August 2021[89];[89] See T1E of the T-documents and A20 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(n)The Physiotherapy Report of Mr Morrissy dated 18 May 2021[90]; [90] See T20 of the T-documents.(o)The Exercise Physiology Report of Laura Olliver (Ms Olliver), Accredited Exercise Physiologist, (undated)[91]; [91] See A11 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(p)The Exercise Physiology Report of Ms Olliver dated 11 November 2021[92];[92] See A13 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(q)The Occupational Assessment Summary Report of Janine P dated 23 November 2020[93];[93] See T9 of the T-documents and A12 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(r)The letter of Prof Nicholson dated 15 March 2022[94];[94] See A6 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(s)The Applicant’s first Participant Impact Statement (PIS) (undated) lodged with the Tribunal on 25 August 2021[95]; [95] See T1I of the T-documents also pages 15 and 80 of the Respondent’s Tender Bundle.(t)The Applicant’s second PIS (undated) lodged with the Tribunal on 25 November 2021[96]; [96] See A13 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle. (u)The Applicant’s third PIS (undated) lodged with the Tribunal on 13 January 2022[97]; and [97] See A10 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(v)The Applicant’s fourth PIS (undated) lodged with the Tribunal on 5 September 2022[98]; and[98] See A5 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.(w)The Applicant’s statutory declaration made on 28 June 2022[99].[99] See A7 of the Applicant’s Tender Bundle.THE RESPONDENT’S CASE

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons outlined above, the Tribunal finds on the evidence that it cannot be satisfied that this support is reasonable and necessary.DECISION512.Pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Chief Executive Officer of the National Disability Insurance Agency with a direction that the following reasonable and necessary supports be included in the Applicant’s Plan over a 12-month period: 1.Funding in the amount of $16,900.00 for the construction and installation of a pathway to be included in the Applicant’s Plan as recommended by Deborah Hammond, Occupational Therapist in her Functional Capacity Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022 and by Peter Nasr, Building Consultant in his Feasibility Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022.2.Funding in the amount of $12,300.00 for minor modifications to the Applicant’s ensuite bathroom as recommended by Deborah Hammond, Occupational Therapist in her Functional Capacity Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022 and by Peter Nasr, Building Consultant in his Feasibility Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022.3.Funding in the amount of $14,780.00 to modify the Applicant’s home for minor modifications as recommended by Deborah Hammond, Occupational Therapist in her Functional Capacity Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022 and by Peter Nasr, Building Consultant in his Feasibility Assessment Report dated 28 July 2022:(a) Changing the door hardware on internal and external doors;(b) Changing light switches and power points to large format switches;(c) Installing a sensor light for night-time bathroom use; and(d) Using wireless charging for electronic devices.4.As agreed between the parties, funding to the Applicant’s Capacity Building Supports Budget for nine x 30-minute podiatry visits per year (4.5 hours per year), plus the amount of $120.00 for an annual biomedical assessment and the amount of $160.00 for an annual podiatrist report.5.Funding to the Applicant’s Capacity Building Supports Budget for one hour of physiotherapy per month (12 hours per year), plus three hours for report writing and consultation with other health professionals (15 hours in total).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

After a person becomes a participant of the NDIS, they develop a plan with the Agency in two parts. The first part to the development of a participant’s plan includes the preparation of a statement (the statement of goals and aspirations) that is prepared by the participant that specifies their goals, objectives and aspirations, the environmental and personal context of the participant’s living, including the participant’s living arrangements and informal community supports and other community supports and their social and economic participation[115].[115] See section 33 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). The second part to the development of a participant’s plan includes the preparation of another statement (the statement of participant supports) that must be included in the participant’s plan as required under subsection 33(2) of the NDIS Act. This statement must be prepared with the participant and approved by the CEO, that specifies a number of matters, including the general supports (if any) that will be provided to, or in relation to, the participant, and the reasonable and necessary supports (if any) that will be funded under the NDIS, the date by which, or the circumstances in which, the Agency must reassess the plan under Division 4, and the management of the funding for supports under the plan[116] and the management of other aspects of the plan[117].[116] See Division 3 of Part 2 to Chapter 3 to the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).[117] See subsection 33(2) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). Subsection 33(3) of the NDIS Act provides that the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded or provided under the NDIS may at the discretion of the CEO be identified in a participant’s plan specifically or generally, whether by reference to a specified purpose or otherwise. Subsection 33(4) of the NDIS Act provides that the CEO must decide whether or not to approve the statement of participant supports either within the period worked out in accordance with the NDIS Rules prescribed for the purposes of this paragraph (which may take account of section 36 (information and reports))[118] or if there are no such Rule(s) – as soon as reasonably practicable, including what is reasonably practicable having regard to section 36 (information and reports)[119]. [118] See subsection 33(4)(a) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).[119] See subsection 33(4)(b) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). Subsection 33(5) of the NDIS Act sets out several matters that the CEO must have regard to when deciding whether to approve a statement of participant supports. These include the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations as mentioned earlier[120], whether the supports are reasonable and necessary supports as required by section 34 of the NDIS Act[121], whether any relevant assessments have been conducted in relation to the participant[122], whether any methods or criteria are specified in the NDIS Rules for deciding the manner in which, and by whom, the reasonable and necessary supports will be funded or provided[123], the principle that it is desirable for a participant to manage their plan to the extent that they wish to do so[124], and the operation and effectiveness of any previous plans of the participant[125].[120] See subsection 33(5)(a) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).[121] See subsection 33(5)(c) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).[122] See subsection 33(5)(b) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).[123] See subsection 33(5)(d) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).[124] See subsection 33(5)(e) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).[125] See subsection 33(5)(f) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).