Lynch and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

Lynch and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2024] ARTA 452 (24 October 2024)

Applicant: Jacob Holden Michael Lynch

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2024/5629

Tribunal:Deputy President S Burford
General
Member J Papalia

Place:Perth

Date:24 October 2024

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.............................[Sgd]........................................

Deputy President / Member

  1. The Applicant is a 34-year-old male, who emigrated to Australia from New Zealand on 10 April 1997, at the age of 7. He was granted a Special Category Visa on arrival. [1]  

    [1] R1, G17, page 107. 

  2. The Applicant has criminal record as an adult in Western Australia spanning between January 2008 and June 2022.[2] 

    [2] R3, TB6, pages 86-91. 

  3. On 30 June 2009, following his conviction and sentencing in the Perth Magistrates Court on 9 March 2009 for a number of offences, the Applicant was notified of the then Minister for Immigration and Citizenship’s intention to consider cancellation of his Special Category Visa under s 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Migration Act). 

  4. On 30 July 2009, a delegate of the Minister decided not to cancel the Applicant’s visa.[3]  In the letter informing the Applicant of this decision, he was warned that ‘visa cancellation may be reconsidered if [he committed] further offences or otherwise breach[ed] the character test in the future.  Disregard of this warning w[ould] weigh heavily against [him] if [his] case is reconsidered’.[4]

    [3] R1, G24, page 153. 

    [4] R1, G24, page 153. 

  5. On 16 February 2023, the Applicant was convicted by a jury in the South Hedland District Court of one count of grievous bodily harm contrary to 297 of the Criminal Code (WA) (the Grievous Bodily Harm offence).[5] 

    [5] R3, TB8, page 1123. 

  6. On 6 April 2023, Flynn DCJ sentenced the Applicant to 4 years’ imprisonment for this offence, from 29 May 2022.[6]

    [6] R3, TB8, page 1123. 

  7. On 24 July 2023, the Applicant’s Special Category Visa was mandatorily cancelled by a delegate of the respondent (Minister) under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act due to the April 2023 sentence of imprisonment and the fact he was serving a sentence of imprisonment on a full-time basis at Albany Regional Prison (the cancellation decision).[7] 

    [7] R1, G18; G19, pages 110-117. 

  8. The Applicant was notified of the cancellation decision on the same day and invited to make representations to the Minister requesting revocation of this decision.[8] 

    [8] R1, G18, pages 110-115. 

  9. The Applicant requested revocation on 8 August 2023.[9] He submitted a personal circumstances form and evidence in support of this request using the Department’s template revocation request and personal circumstances forms.[10] On 31 July 2024, a delegate of the Minister refused to revoke the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act (the non-revocation decision).[11] The Applicant was notified of the non-revocation decision by hand on 1 August 2024.[12] This is the reviewable decision before the Tribunal.

    [9] R1, G12, pages 79-83. 

    [10] R1, G12,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lynch and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicul... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ARTA 452
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lynch and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs, the applicant, a New Zealand citizen, sought a review of the decision not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of his Special Category Visa. The visa was cancelled due to the applicant's conviction and subsequent imprisonment for grievous bodily harm, which led to the application of section 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether there were grounds to revoke the cancellation of the visa, taking into account various considerations outlined in Direction No. 110. The primary legal issue was whether the Tribunal was satisfied that there was "another reason" to revoke the visa cancellation decision, considering the competing factors as directed by the legislative framework.

The key considerations included the protection of the Australian community, family violence, the strength, nature, and duration of the applicant’s ties to Australia, the best interests of minor children, and other relevant factors such as the legal consequences of the decision and the extent of impediments if removal were to occur. The Tribunal carefully weighed these factors, finding that the primary considerations against revocation, such as the protection of the Australian community, family violence, and community expectations, outweighed those in favor of revocation, such as the strength of the applicant's ties to Australia and the best interests of his minor children. The Tribunal concluded that there was no sufficient basis to revoke the visa cancellation, affirming the Minister's decision.

The reasoning of the Tribunal hinged on the comprehensive evaluation of the competing considerations, as guided by Direction No. 110. The Tribunal found that the considerations against revocation were stronger, particularly the protection of the Australian community, which was deemed to outweigh the other factors. The Tribunal noted that the applicant's criminal history and the nature of his offense significantly impacted the decision, leading to the conclusion that the mandatory cancellation should stand. Consequently, the Tribunal decided to affirm the decision not to revoke the visa cancellation, reflecting the statutory obligations and the need to protect the community from individuals who pose a risk due to their criminal conduct.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the reasons below, the Tribunal has decided that the correct decision is that the decision not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s visa be affirmed. THE HEARING AND THE EVIDENCE The Applicant appeared before the Tribunal at a two-day hearing on 2 and 3 October 2024. The Applicant was incarcerated at Albany Regional Prison at the time of the hearing and the hearing was conducted in person at the Peter Durack Commonwealth Law Courts Building. He was self-represented. The respondent was represented by Ms Jones-Bolla of Sparke Helmore Lawyers, who also appeared in person. The Applicant gave evidence at the hearing, as did his mother (Ms BW) and older brother – Mr DM. The Applicant’s psychologist, Mr Webb gave evidence by telephone. The Tribunal admitted the following documents into evidence:·Applicant’s Bundle of Documents filed 24 September 2024 (Exhibit A1);·Extract from the Transcript of the Armadale Magistrates Court in Western Australia Police v Jacob Holden Michael Lynch (AR 4829-4832/2021 and 7032/2021) dated 29 November 2021, page 5 (Exhibit A2);[20] ·G-Documents filed 16 August 2024 (Exhibit R1);·Summons Bundle filed 11 September 2024 (Exhibit R2);·Supplementary Tender Bundle filed 13 September 2024 (Exhibit R3); and·Supplementary G-Documents filed 26 September 2024 (Exhibit R4). [20] The full transcript is contained within the Respondent’s Summons Bundle (R2) at page 19ff. The Respondent filed a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SOFIC) prior to the hearing, with revisions to accommodate material received under summons. The Applicant relied upon the material he had given to the delegate and a handwritten letter that accompanied his application for review. He also provided the Tribunal with a typed written statement, letters from his immediate family members (including supporting material from John Tonkin College regarding the younger siblings’ attendance at school) and a letter from Mr Webb dated 11 September 2024.[21] [21] These are contained within the Applicant’s Bundle of Documents (A1). Evidence of the Applicant The Tribunal was mindful of the Applicant’s lack of representation in the conduct of the proceedings. The Applicant was cross-examined extensively by Ms Jones-Bolla over the course of the hearing, including in respect of a series of uncharged acts and matters for which criminal charges had been dismissed or the Applicant acquitted. The Applicant was advised in simple terms of his right to invoke the privilege against self-incrimination prior to his giving evidence.[22] He was reminded of this right several times during cross-examination. [22] See Bainbridge v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCA 1080 at [64]-[65]. The Applicant was also provided an opportunity at the hearing to respond to matters put to him and to provide answers to questions asked by the Tribunal which were directed at relevant considerations under Direction no. 110.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal considers this consideration should be afforded neutral weight in the Applicant’s case.CONCLUSION The Tribunal is required to bring together the relevant considerations in this matter and consider, as part of a single evaluation, their relative significance in terms of whether the Tribunal is ultimately satisfied that there is “another reason” why the mandatory cancellation decision should be revoked. In determining the weight to be applied to each consideration, the Tribunal has considered all the primary and other relevant considerations and weighed them in light of the evidence and findings and according to the guidance provided by Direction no. 110. The Tribunal has gone on to compare and balance all of the considerations to determine whether there is another reason the cancellation should be revoked. The Tribunal has considered all of the primary considerations, including the protection of the Australian community which weighs strongly against revocation in the Applicant’s circumstances. The consideration of family violence weighs against revocation but only carries limited weight in the Applicant’s case. The strength, nature and duration of the Applicant’s ties to Australia carry heavy weight in favour of revocation. The best interests of the Applicant’s brother, sister and niece carry moderate weigh in favour of revocation. The expectations of the Australian community would be that the visa would remain cancelled and this consideration weighs heavily against revocation. In relation to the relevant ‘other considerations’ identified in Direction no. 110, the Tribunal finds that the legal consequences of the decision carries slight weight in favour of revocation the Applicant’s case. The impact on Australian businesses weighs neutrally in the Applicant’s circumstances. The extent of impediments if removed weigh slightly in favour of revocation in the Applicant’s case. Paragraph 7(2) of Direction no. 110 states that primary considerations should generally be given greater weight than the other considerations. Further it states that primary consideration 8.1 (protection of the Australian community) is generally to be given greater weight than other primary considerations. Having weighed the considerations in favour of the revocation of the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa and the considerations against revocation, the Tribunal finds that the considerations weighing against revocation being the primary considerations of the protection of the Australian community, family violence and the expectations of the Australian community, outweigh those weighing in favour of revocation, being the primary considerations of the strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia and the best interests of minor children and the other consideration of the legal consequences of the decision and the extent of impediments if removed. In summary, having regard to all of the primary considerations, and the relevant other considerations in Direction no. 110, the Tribunal is not satisfied that there is ‘another reason’ why the cancellation decision should be revoked.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 30 June 2009, following his conviction and sentencing in the Perth Magistrates Court on 9 March 2009 for a number of offences, the Applicant was notified of the then Minister for Immigration and Citizenship’s intention to consider cancellation of his Special Category Visa under s 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Migration Act). On 30 July 2009, a delegate of the Minister decided not to cancel the Applicant’s visa.[3] In the letter informing the Applicant of this decision, he was warned that ‘visa cancellation may be reconsidered if [he committed] further offences or otherwise breach[ed] the character test in the future. Disregard of this warning w[ould] weigh heavily against [him] if [his] case is reconsidered’.[4][3] R1, G24, page 153. [4] R1, G24, page 153. On 16 February 2023, the Applicant was convicted by a jury in the South Hedland District Court of one count of grievous bodily harm contrary to 297 of the Criminal Code (WA) (the Grievous Bodily Harm offence).[5] [5] R3, TB8, page 1123. On 6 April 2023, Flynn DCJ sentenced the Applicant to 4 years’ imprisonment for this offence, from 29 May 2022.[6][6] R3, TB8, page 1123. On 24 July 2023, the Applicant’s Special Category Visa was mandatorily cancelled by a delegate of the respondent (Minister) under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act due to the April 2023 sentence of imprisonment and the fact he was serving a sentence of imprisonment on a full-time basis at Albany Regional Prison (the cancellation decision).[7] [7] R1, G18; G19, pages 110-117. The Applicant was notified of the cancellation decision on the same day and invited to make representations to the Minister requesting revocation of this decision.[8] [8] R1, G18, pages 110-115. The Applicant requested revocation on 8 August 2023.[9] He submitted a personal circumstances form and evidence in support of this request using the Department’s template revocation request and personal circumstances forms.[10] On 31 July 2024, a delegate of the Minister refused to revoke the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act (the non-revocation decision).[11] The Applicant was notified of the non-revocation decision by hand on 1 August 2024.[12] This is the reviewable decision before the Tribunal.[9] R1, G12, pages 79-83. [10] R1, G12, pages 84-106. [11] R1, G3, page 14. [12] R1, G3, pages 9-13; G32, page 204. On 7 August 2024, the Applicant lodged an application to the Tribunal for review of the non-revocation decision in accordance with s 500(1)(ba) of the Migration Act.[13] As the application was made within nine days after notification, it complied with the time limit set by s 500(6B) of the Migration Act. The Applicant is in the custody of the State of Western Australia at Albany Regional Prison. Accordingly, the review relates to a person in the “migration zone”.[14] [13] R1, G1, pages 1-8. [14] As defined in s 5(1) of the Migration Act. The Tribunal is required by s 500(6L) of the Migration Act to make a decision in relation to this application by no later than 24 October 2024. LEGAL FRAMEWORK