Lui and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2009] AATA 626

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

TAXATION APPEALS DIVISION  )          No 3524 of 2009
  )          No 3629 of 2009

Re KEVIN LUI

Applicant

And

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Justice Buchanan (Presidential Member)

Date21 August 2009

PlaceSydney

Decision The Tribunal affirms the decisions of the Commissioner of Taxation made     on 28 July 2009 and 31 July 2009.

.....................[signed]..................

Justice R J Buchanan

(Presidential Member)

3.Subject to a reservation to be identified shortly, it was accepted by the Commissioner that there are humanitarian grounds which could justify the grant of a departure authorisation certificate if other conditions for the grant of the certificate are satisfied.  It was also accepted that a departure authorisation certificate should be granted on humanitarian grounds in the present case if the other conditions are satisfied.  That circumstance makes it unnecessary to attempt to evaluate the medical and other circumstances said to constitute the humanitarian grounds on which Mr Lui relied.  The Commissioner contended, however, that no occasion arose to act upon humanitarian grounds.  I shall return to that issue shortly. 

4.The short summary which follows is extracted from the reasons given for refusing the two applications.  On 9 August 2007 Mr Lui was advised that his income tax affairs and the affairs of his associates would be audited.  Taxation assessments and amended assessments totalling $16,479,846.54 were issued on 24 October 2008 in respect of the years 30 June 1994 to 30 June 2007 (inclusive).  A departure prohibition order was served on the same day.  On 28 November 2008 the Commissioner commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales seeking payment of $18,714,422.23.  An amended statement of claim was served on 20 March 2009.  On 23 February 2009 a summons was filed in the Supreme Court seeking orders that the departure prohibition order be set aside.  Those proceedings have not yet been resolved.  A statement of claim was filed in the proceedings on 4 August 2009.

5.Meanwhile, on 12 May 2009 Mr Dunstan advised by telephone that Mr Lui would apply for a departure authorisation certificate.  He was advised on 13 May 2009 by email that a submission would be required setting out the grounds on which Mr Lui relied, together with supporting documentation.  An exchange of letters ensued between Mr Dunstan and the Australian Taxation Office.  Letters were written by Mr Dunstan on 4 June 2009 (requesting the issue of a departure authorisation certificate), 25 June 2009, 17 July 2009 and 23 July 2009.  The relevant officers of the Australian Taxation Office took the view that inadequate responses were provided to questions put to Mr Lui, inadequate documentation was supplied and inadequate security was suggested with respect to the amounts claimed by the Commissioner.  The first application for a departure authorisation certificate was therefore rejected.  The second application for a departure authorisation certificate was made necessary as the first application covered only the June/July period.  The second application asked permission for Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lui and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] AATA 626
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lui v Commissioner of Taxation, the dispute centred around a departure prohibition order issued by the Commissioner under section 14R of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth). This order prevented the taxpayer from leaving Australia without the Commissioner's written consent. The taxpayer, Mr. Lui, sought review of this order in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, challenging the basis on which the Commissioner concluded that he was unable to give security as required by section 14U of the Act. The Tribunal was tasked with interpreting the phrase "unable to give security" in the context of the statutory provisions and determining whether the Commissioner's decision was legally sound.

The key legal issue was the interpretation of the term "unable to give security" within the context of section 14U of the Taxation Administration Act. The Tribunal considered whether this term should be narrowly construed, as argued by Mr. Lui, or if it should encompass broader circumstances where the individual could potentially provide security but does not. The Tribunal examined relevant legislative history and previous cases to determine the appropriate scope of this term, including references to the Explanatory Memorandum of the Taxation Laws Amendment Bill 1984 and the Second Reading Speech of 13 September 1984. The Tribunal also reviewed prior judicial decisions, such as IRG Technical Services Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation, Puglisi v Administrative Decisions Tribunal of NSW, and Troughton v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, which provided insights into the interpretation of similar statutory language.

The Tribunal concluded that the term "unable to give security" should be interpreted broadly, to include situations where the individual has the capacity to provide security but chooses not to. This interpretation was supported by the legislative history and the reasoning in prior cases. The Tribunal found that the Commissioner's decision was based on a reasonable interpretation of the statutory provisions and was therefore affirmed. The Tribunal also noted that the Commissioner's decision was supported by substantial evidence and adhered to the principles of natural justice.

The Tribunal affirmed the decisions of the Commissioner of Taxation made on 28 July 2009 and 31 July 2009. This outcome upheld the departure prohibition order and confirmed that Mr. Lui was unable to leave Australia without the Commissioner's consent. The Tribunal's decision clarified the scope of the term "unable to give security" and reinforced the Commissioner's authority to issue such orders under the relevant provisions of the Taxation Administration Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal affirms the decisions of the Commissioner of Taxation made on 28 July 2009 and 31 July 2009.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established