Roger Shahani and Child Support Registrar

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2014] AATA 312 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2014/1786

Re

Roger Shahani

APPLICANT

And

Child Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr Dean Letcher, QC, Senior Member

Date 19 May 2014  
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

............[sgd]............................................................

Mr Dean Letcher, QC, Senior Member

CHILD SUPPORT – Departure Prohibition Order – revocation –child support liability – no arrangement to wholly discharge liability – liability recoverable –discretion not enlivened – decision under review affirmed.

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988: ss 3, 72D, 72H, 72I, 72T, 112

Kevin Lui and Commissioner Taxation [2009] AATA 626

Re ONeill and Child Support Registrar [2010] AATA 545

Whittaker v Child Support Registrar 2010 264 ALR 473

-

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr Dean Letcher, QC, Senior Member
19 May 2014

  1. The Applicant is the subject of child support orders made under the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (“the Act”). On 28 March 2014 a Departure Prohibition Order (“DPO”) was issued under s 72D(1) of the Act, preventing the Applicant from travelling outside Australia.

  2. On 4 April 2014 a delegate of the Child Support Registrar refused his application to revoke the DPO. The Applicant seeks review of that decision by this Tribunal pursuant to s 72T of the Act.

    FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  3. The Applicant and his ex-wife have been engaged in long-running Family Court proceedings involving property and children. Child support orders have been made, appealed, varied and re-visited. Relevantly, the Full Court of the Family Court upheld in part the Applicant’s appeal against a single judge’s orders and the orders of the Full Court on 16 September 2013 concluded:

    “86. So that it is clear, it is the payment of periodic and non-periodic child support by the father commencing on 11 April 2012 that is the issue for the rehearing and not the effect of the orders on his obligation to pay child support prior to that date”.

  4. That order meant that the amount owing for the period before 11 April 2012 was fixed and not to be altered. No stay has been ordered on recovery of that amount, nor of the weekly amounts already ordered to be paid in respect of child support after 11 April 2012.

  5. The Full Court remitted to a different judge the rehearing of the question of what support should be payable for the period after 11 April 2014. No hearing date has been set for that rehearing but a date may be fixed at the next mention on 24 June 2014. The Court Varied Amount for each child is $272.19 per child per week, although the Applicant says he will seek to argue, because he has a very low income, that amount should be more like $20.00 per week. As the matter stands, unless and until the Family Court alters its present orders, the Applicant is the subject of child support orders of $2,367.08 per month from 11 April 2012 to date and continuing, as well as the arrears to 11 April 2012. In the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roger Shahani and Child Support Registrar and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 312
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Shahani v Registrar of the Child Support Agency, the Full Court remitted the matter to a different judge for a rehearing on the issue of child support payable from a certain date. The court was required to decide whether the departure prohibition order (DPO) should be revoked under s 72I of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth). The Applicant argued that he had no child support liability because he intended to challenge the amount claimed during forthcoming Family Court proceedings. The Applicant also argued that he would only pay a nominal amount of child support until his income increased, and that he had no liability because arrangements had not been made for the liability to be wholly discharged. The Applicant further argued that the liability was not completely irrecoverable, as he would be able to pay some amount of child support in the future.

The court found that the factors in s 72I(1)(a) and (b) did not exist, and that the liability was not completely irrecoverable under s 72I(1)(c). The court found that significant amounts of the liability were recoverable, and that this was likely to continue in the future. The court also found that the discretion available in s 72I(3) was not enlivened, as it had not been demonstrated that it was desirable to revoke the DPO. The court found that revoking the DPO would be contrary to the objects and purpose of the Act.

The decision under review was affirmed, and the DPO remained in place. The court found that the Registrar had not erred in deciding that the DPO should not be revoked. The Applicant was still subject to the child support orders of $2,367.08 per month from 11 April 2012 to date and continuing, as well as the arrears to 11 April 2012. The Applicant had paid $1,846 voluntarily and other amounts by enforced collection methods totalling some $20,108.90 in the last calendar year.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Full Court remitted to a different judge the rehearing of the question of what support should be payable for the period after 11 April 2014. No hearing date has been set for that rehearing but a date may be fixed at the next mention on 24 June 2014. The Court Varied Amount for each child is $272.19 per child per week, although the Applicant says he will seek to argue, because he has a very low income, that amount should be more like $20.00 per week. As the matter stands, unless and until the Family Court alters its present orders, the Applicant is the subject of child support orders of $2,367.08 per month from 11 April 2012 to date and continuing, as well as the arrears to 11 April 2012. In the last calendar year the Applicant has paid $1,846 voluntarily and other amounts by enforced collection methods totalling some $20,108.90.LEGAL BACKGROUND Under s 72H of the Act, a DPO continues in force until it is revoked or until it is set aside by a court. Section 72I provides that:72I Revocation and variation of departure prohibition orders(1) The Registrar must revoke a departure prohibition order in respect of a person if:(a)the person no longer has a child support liability; or(b)the person has a child support liability, but arrangements satisfactory to the Registrar have been made for the liability to be wholly discharged; or(c)the person has a child support liability, but the Registrar is satisfied that the liability is completely irrecoverable.(2)However, if the Registrar considers that the person may later become subject to a child support liability in respect of, or arising out of, matters that have occurred, the Registrar must not revoke a departure prohibition order under subsection (1) unless the Registrar is satisfied:(a)that the liability will be wholly discharged; or(b)that arrangements satisfactory to the Registrar will be made for the liability to be wholly discharged; or(c)that the liability will be completely irrecoverable.(3)The Registrar may also, at the Registrar’s discretion, revoke or vary a departure prohibition order in respect of a person if the Registrar considers it desirable to do so.(4)The Registrar may revoke or vary a departure prohibition order under subsection (1) or (3):(a) on application by the person in the approved form; or(b) on the Registrar’s own motion.EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL Section 72I(1) directs a DPO must be revoked if (a), (b) or (c) are established and, if not, discretion may be applied if it is determined desirable to do so. The Applicant gave evidence that he believed he had no ‘child support liability’ because he intended to challenge the amount claimed during forthcoming Family Court proceedings - he regarded the amount claimed as speculative and not definite. Further, he believed that ‘arrangements’ depended on the outcome of those proceedings, and that reliance on the outcome was the appropriate arrangement. He also stated that he regarded the liability as recoverable but only when it was judicially decided and he had appropriate income.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 72I provides that:72I Revocation and variation of departure prohibition orders(1) The Registrar must revoke a departure prohibition order in respect of a person if:(a)the person no longer has a child support liability; or(b)the person has a child support liability, but arrangements satisfactory to the Registrar have been made for the liability to be wholly discharged; or(c)the person has a child support liability, but the Registrar is satisfied that the liability is completely irrecoverable.(2)However, if the Registrar considers that the person may later become subject to a child support liability in respect of, or arising out of, matters that have occurred, the Registrar must not revoke a departure prohibition order under subsection (1) unless the Registrar is satisfied:(a)that the liability will be wholly discharged; or(b)that arrangements satisfactory to the Registrar will be made for the liability to be wholly discharged; or(c)that the liability will be completely irrecoverable.(3)The Registrar may also, at the Registrar’s discretion, revoke or vary a departure prohibition order in respect of a person if the Registrar considers it desirable to do so.(4)The Registrar may revoke or vary a departure prohibition order under subsection (1) or (3):(a) on application by the person in the approved form; or(b) on the Registrar’s own motion.EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL Section 72I(1) directs a DPO must be revoked if (a), (b) or (c) are established and, if not, discretion may be applied if it is determined desirable to do so. The Applicant gave evidence that he believed he had no ‘child support liability’ because he intended to challenge the amount claimed during forthcoming Family Court proceedings - he regarded the amount claimed as speculative and not definite. Further, he believed that ‘arrangements’ depended on the outcome of those proceedings, and that reliance on the outcome was the appropriate arrangement. He also stated that he regarded the liability as recoverable but only when it was judicially decided and he had appropriate income. As to s 72 (1)(a) of the Act, the evidence was that the Applicant had a ‘child support liability’, as defined in s 72E of the Act, because he had a ‘registrable maintenance liability’ certified as at 7 May 2014 to be $49,452.71. Under s 116(2) of the Act, that certificate is prima facie evidence of the amount and the liability. As to s 72(1)(b) of the Act, in respect of that liability, there was no arrangement made to discharge it wholly, and indeed in a telephone conversation between the Applicant and a Child Support Agency officer on 26 March 2014, the most that the Applicant was prepared to offer was $26.00 per week (probably for each of the two children). There was no evidence to suggest that another or better offer has been made since. The Applicant said that his view was that he would await a decision by the Family Court judge whenever that occurred. As to s 72(1)(c) of the Act, in his evidence the Applicant rejected the idea that the liability was completely irrecoverable, saying in his evidence in chief:“It’s not irrecoverable, it is recoverable”.He went on to say that he would be happy to enter into an agreement to pay $2,000.00 a year until his income increased. In any event, even the smallest recovery would mean that the liability was not ‘completely irrecoverable’, and the evidence was that sums had been recovered by garnishee, taxation refund interception and employer withholdings, while caveats had been lodged against properties in which he had interests.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It has not been demonstrated that the factors in s72I(1)(a) or (b) exist. Further, it has not been demonstrated that the liability is completely irrecoverable, as per s72I(1)(c). I find that significant amounts of the liability are recoverable, and this is also likely to be the case in the future. On that basis, there should be no revocation of the DPO pursuant to s 72I(1). With respect to the discretion available in s72I(3), which can be enlivened if s72I(1)(a), (b) or (c) can’t be met, it has not been demonstrated that it is desirable to revoke the DPO. To do so would, in my view, be contrary to the objects and purpose of the Act. DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.