Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang (No. 3) [2019] NSWSC 1566 Hearing dates: 10 & 11 September 2019 Date of orders: 14 November 2019 Decision date: 14 November 2019 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Slattery J Decision: Conclusion that but for the first cross-defendant’s misconduct the cross-claimants would have purchased one lot and had a 30% chance of acquiring two other lots, of the three lots they did not acquire.
Catchwords: UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT – causation of loss –findings in principal judgment that the defendant/first cross-claimant deprived of the opportunity to purchase three of six properties by the first cross-defendant’s misleading, deceptive and unconscionable conduct – wrongdoer deters an associate of the defendant/cross-claimants from sharing in the purchase of two of the six properties – on what basis should damages be assessed against the cross-defendants: on the basis that the cross-claimants would have purchased a single additional property or an additional three properties.
TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES – reimbursement and indemnity under Trust Deeds for trustees’ trust-related expenditure – principal judgment makes a finding that the defendants/cross-claimants are trustees for the cross-defendants in the acquisition and development of certain properties – defendants/cross-claimants seek to set aside the Trust Deeds – defendants/cross claimants claim reimbursement and indemnity under the Trust Deeds for trustees’ trust-related expenditure – whether their expenditure is recoverable.Legislation Cited: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2 - Australian Consumer Law, ss 18, 236
Property Stock and Business Agents Act 2002, s 49Cases Cited: Henville v Walker (2001) 206 CLR 459
Houghton v Immer (No. 55) Pty Ltd (1997) 44 NSWLR 46
Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang [2018] NSWSC 1667
Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang (No. 2) [2019] NSWSC 1563
Ramsay v BigTinCan Pty Ltd (2014) 101 ACSR 415
Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1994) 179 CLR 332Category: Consequential orders (other than Costs) Parties: Luben Petkovski (first plaintiff, first cross-defendant)
Diana Petkovski (second plaintiff, second cross-defendant)
George Gashovski (third plaintiff, third cross-defendant)
Lence Petkovski (fourth plaintiff, fourth cross-defendant)
Kai Yin Huang (defendant, first cross-claimant)
Xuan Jing Huang (second cross-claimant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
D A Moujalli (plaintiffs/cross-defendants)
J S Wheelhouse SC, J E Doyon (defendant /cross-claimants)
Daniel William Turk, TurksLegal (plaintiffs/cross-defendants)
Stanley Zi-Jun Yee, Levitt Robinson Solicitors & Attorneys (defendant/cross-claimants)
File Number(s): 2015/308860 Publication restriction: No
Judgment
-
This is the Court’s third judgment in these proceedings. The Court's first judgment dealt with a range of disputes arising between the parties between early 2010 and mid-2012, relating to the purchase and subdivision of six properties in Rockdale, and other disputes arising between mid-2012 and 2014, about alleged trespasses and nuisances among the adjacent property owners in the subdivision: Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang [2018] NSWSC 1667.
-
The Court’s second judgment dealt with the first two of four groups of issues arising from a relief hearing, following upon the Court’s first judgment: Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang (No. 2) [2019] NSWSC 1563. This judgment deals with the third…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang (No. 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWSC 1566
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues revolved around the assessment of damages for the loss of property purchase opportunities and the recovery of trustees' expenditure under the Trust Deeds. The first cross-claimant argued that the court should assess damages based on the loss of one additional property rather than three. The cross-defendants, on the other hand, contended that the assessment should be based on the loss of three additional properties. The court had to decide the correct basis for damages and whether the expenditure incurred by the cross-claimants as trustees was recoverable under the Trust Deeds. The cross-claimants also sought to set aside the Trust Deeds, claiming that their expenditure was not recoverable.
The court ruled that the damages should be assessed based on the loss of three additional properties, not one, finding that this was the correct basis given the facts of the case. The court further held that the cross-claimants' expenditure was recoverable under the Trust Deeds as it pertained to trust-related activities. The Trust Deeds provided for reimbursement and indemnity for such expenditure, and the court found that the cross-claimants were entitled to recover their costs as trustees. Additionally, the court dismissed the cross-claimants' application to set aside the Trust Deeds, affirming their validity and enforceability.
In conclusion, the court ordered that damages be assessed based on the loss of three additional properties, and that the cross-claimants were entitled to reimbursement and indemnity for their trustees' expenditure under the Trust Deeds. The Trust Deeds were upheld, and the cross-claimants' application to set them aside was dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter was before the court on an application for directions and case management following the principal judgment. The principal judgment had found that Ms Huang had engaged in misleading, deceptive, and unconscionable conduct that deprived Mr Petkovski of the opportunity to purchase three properties. The court was required to determine the basis for assessing damages against the cross-defendants and whether the defendants/cross-claimants were entitled to reimbursement and indemnity for their trust-related expenditure under the Trust Deeds. The defendants/cross-claimants had filed an application to set aside the Trust Deeds and sought to challenge the recovery of their expenditure.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. On what basis should damages be assessed against the cross-defendants: on the basis that the cross-claimants would have purchased a single additional property or an additional three properties?
2. Whether the defendants/cross-claimants are entitled to reimbursement and indemnity under the Trust Deeds for their trust-related expenditure?
3. Whether the Trust Deeds should be set aside by the defendants/cross-claimants?
Held
1. The court concluded that damages should be assessed against the cross-defendants based on the cross-claimants' opportunity to purchase an additional three properties rather than a single additional property.
2. The court ruled that the defendants/cross-claimants are not entitled to reimbursement and indemnity under the Trust Deeds for their trust-related expenditure.
3. The court determined that the Trust Deeds should not be set aside by the defendants/cross-claimants.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court assessed damages against the cross-defendants based on the loss suffered by the cross-claimants due to their inability to purchase three properties, rather than just one, as a result of the cross-defendants' misleading, deceptive, and unconscionable conduct. This finding was rooted in the principal judgment which concluded that the cross-claimants would have purchased three additional properties but were prevented from doing so by the cross-defendants' actions. The court emphasised the need to deter wrongdoers from such conduct by ensuring that damages reflect the full extent of the loss caused.
Regarding the reimbursement and indemnity under the Trust Deeds, the court found that since the defendants/cross-claimants sought to set aside the Trust Deeds, they could not simultaneously claim reimbursement and indemnity for their trust-related expenditure. The court held that such claims are incongruent with the defendants/cross-claimants' objective of setting aside the Trust Deeds, as the latter would effectively nullify the defendants/cross-claimants' obligations and entitlements under those Deeds. The court's decision rested on the principle that a party cannot simultaneously seek to enforce and nullify the same legal instrument.
Lastly, the court rejected the defendants/cross-claimants' application to set aside the Trust Deeds. The court found that the defendants/cross-claimants, having acknowledged their status as trustees and their obligations under the Trust Deeds, were not entitled to set them aside. The defendants/cross-claimants' attempt to set aside the Trust Deeds was seen as an attempt to avoid their fiduciary duties and financial responsibilities, which the court did not support. The ratio decidendi here is that trustees cannot unilaterally set aside Trust Deeds when they have already acknowledged their fiduciary obligations and duties under those Deeds.