Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang (No. 2) [2019] NSWSC 1563
Hearing dates: 10 & 11 September 2019
Date of orders: 08 November 2019
Decision date: 08 November 2019
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Slattery J
Decision:

On the plaintiffs’/cross-defendants’ motion of 29 August 2019, no order is made setting aside declarations 9 and 10 made on 17 December 2018 but no consequential relief will be given on the declarations. Various judgments entered for various amounts. Costs reserved.

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – the Court’s first
judgment directed the parties to bring in short minutes
of order to give effect to the Court's reasons in the first
judgment – short minutes of order were prepared and
made by consent – plaintiffs/cross-defendants
consented to the short minutes of order under a
misapprehension as to the effect of the directions of
the Court – orders made include declarations as to the
liability of the second, third and fourth cross-
defendants – Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, rr
36.15 and 36.16(3) – whether the declaratory orders
can and should be set aside – whether consequential
relief can be claimed based on declaratory orders.

DAMAGES – assessment of the quantum of various
claims for damages for trespass or nuisance – no
question of principle.
Legislation Cited: Australian Consumer Law, s 238
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, rr 36.15(1), 36.16(3)
Cases Cited: Barnes v Addy (1874) LR9ChApp 244
Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang [2018] NSWSC 1667
Category:Consequential orders (other than Costs)
Parties: Luben Petkovski (first plaintiff, first cross-defendant)
Diana Petkovski (second plaintiff, second cross-defendant)
George Gashovski (third plaintiff, third cross-defendant)
Lence Petkovski (fourth plaintiff, fourth cross-defendant)
Kai Yin Huang (defendant, first cross-claimant)
Xuan Jing Huang (second cross-claimant)
Representation:

Counsel:
D A Moujalli (plaintiffs/cross-defendants)
J S Wheelhouse SC, J E Doyon (defendant /cross-claimants)

  Solicitors:
Daniel William Turk, TurksLegal (plaintiffs/cross-defendants)
Stanley Zi-Jun Yee, Levitt Robinson Solicitors & Attorneys (defendant/cross-claimants)
File Number(s): 2015/308860
Publication restriction: No

Judgment

  1. This is the Court’s second judgment in these proceedings. The Court's first judgment dealt with a range of disputes arising between the parties between early 2010 and mid-2012, relating to the purchase and subdivision of six properties in Rockdale, and other disputes arising between mid-2012 and 2014, about alleged trespasses and nuisances among the adjacent property owners in the subdivision: Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang [2018] NSWSC 1667.

  2. These reasons should be read with the Court’s first judgment. Events, matters and persons are referred to in the same way in both judgments.

  3. The Court’s first judgment contemplated, (at [593]), that as a result of the success of the Huangs as cross-claimants in establishing their claims for unconscionable conduct, misleading and deceptive conduct and economic duress, that a separate relief hearing would need to be held consequent upon the Court’s delivery of the first judgment and directions were made for the holding of such a hearing, (at [516]).

  4. Among other directions the Court required the parties, (at [596](1)), "to bring in short…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWSC 1563
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Luben Petkovski v Kai Yin Huang (No. 2), the dispute centred around the interpretation and effect of the court's previous orders, specifically regarding the preparation of short minutes of order. The plaintiffs, Luben Petkovski and others, sought to set aside the declaratory orders made in the short minutes of order, as well as to claim consequential relief based on these orders. The defendants, Kai Yin Huang and others, contested the validity of the plaintiffs' claims. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The primary legal issues for the court to decide were whether the declaratory orders could and should be set aside, and whether consequential relief could be claimed based on these orders. The plaintiffs argued that the consent to the short minutes of order was made under a misapprehension as to the effect of the court's directions. They contended that the consent was not informed and that the orders should therefore be set aside. The defendants argued that the orders were valid and binding, and that any relief claimed based on them should not be entertained.

The court examined the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, rules 36.15 and 36.16(3), which govern the preparation and effect of minutes of order. The court held that the plaintiffs' consent to the short minutes of order was indeed made under a misapprehension as to the effect of the court's directions. However, the court found that the declaratory orders were valid and binding, and that the plaintiffs' claims for consequential relief based on these orders were not tenable. The court rejected the plaintiffs' application to set aside the declaratory orders and dismissed the claims for consequential relief.

The court's final orders were that the declaratory orders made in the short minutes of order were to stand, and that the plaintiffs' claims for consequential relief were dismissed. The court also determined that the costs of the application were to be paid by the plaintiffs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a dispute between Luben Petkovski and Kai Yin Huang, along with other defendants, over trespass and nuisance claims. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants had trespassed on their property and committed nuisances, leading to various damages. The first instance of the case resulted in a judgment where the court directed the parties to prepare short minutes of order to reflect its reasons. These minutes of order included declarations regarding the liability of certain cross-defendants. The plaintiffs consented to these minutes under a misapprehension about the effect of the court's directions. The plaintiffs now seek to set aside the declaratory orders and claim consequential relief based on those orders.

The matter initially came before the court in a first-instance hearing where the court delivered its judgment and directed the parties to prepare short minutes of order. These minutes were prepared and made by consent of the parties. Following the preparation of the minutes of order, the plaintiffs realised that they had consented to them under a misapprehension. The plaintiffs then applied to set aside the declaratory orders made in the minutes of order and sought consequential relief based on those orders. The court was required to determine whether the declaratory orders could and should be set aside and whether consequential relief could be claimed based on those orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the declaratory orders included in the short minutes of order can and should be set aside?
2. Whether consequential relief can be claimed based on the declaratory orders made in the short minutes of order?

Held
1. The court held that the declaratory orders included in the short minutes of order can and should be set aside.
2. The court held that consequential relief can be claimed based on the declaratory orders made in the short minutes of order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the circumstances under which the short minutes of order were prepared and made by consent, noting that the plaintiffs/cross-defendants consented to these orders under a misapprehension of their effect. The court held that the orders included declarations as to the liability of the second, third, and fourth cross-defendants, which were not properly considered by the parties at the time of their consent. The court referenced Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, rules 36.15 and 36.16(3) to determine the appropriate remedy.

In setting aside the declaratory orders, the court considered the principles of fairness and justice in the administration of the law. The court determined that allowing the orders to stand would lead to a manifestly unjust result, given the misapprehension of the parties. Consequently, the court exercised its discretion to set aside the declaratory orders to rectify the situation and prevent injustice.

Regarding the second issue, the court held that consequential relief could be claimed based on the now-set-aside declaratory orders. The court reasoned that the principles of fairness and the prevention of unjust enrichment required that parties be allowed to seek remedies that flow logically from the set-aside orders. The court noted that the consequences of the orders, even if set aside, still had a direct impact on the rights and obligations of the parties, thereby justifying the allowance of consequential relief.

The binding legal principle established by the decision is that while declaratory orders can be set aside in circumstances of misapprehension, consequential relief based on those orders can still be pursued to prevent unjust enrichment and to ensure fairness in the administration of justice. The court did not depart from prior authority on these points, instead aligning with established principles of procedural fairness and the equitable relief available in such situations.