Lowe v AMP Capital Investors Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

[2011] QDC 267

DISTRICT COURT

CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE ROBIN QC

No 418 of 2010

EVE LOWE Plaintiff

and

AMP CAPITAL INVESTORS LIMITED AND OTHERS Defendants

BRISBANE

..DATE 28/10/2011

JUDGMENT

CATCHWORDS

Negligence - fall on slippery floor in shopping centre - whether cleaning contractor liable - damages for minor back injury assessed
HIS HONOUR:  Whatever the outcome of this claim, the court is obliged to assess the plaintiff's damages.  The great issue between the parties is whether the back pain which the


36-year-old plaintiff suffers and continues to suffer on her evidence, which the court accepts is attributable to a fall at the first and second defendants’ premises at Pacific Fair Shopping Centre on the 9th of May 2007, or attributable to a hip complaint which appears to run in her family and has blighted her life since the age of about eight.

Dr Steadman, the defendant's orthopaedic expert is of the view that after six weeks or so the plaintiff's injuries from the accident in which she slipped on liquid on the floor, landing on her knee and then on her coccyx would have been spent. 

Dr Wallace, the plaintiff's expert orthopaedic practitioner brought in for medico-legal purposes, is of the contrary view that the accident was the probable cause of her complaint which he described as coxodynia or a painful tail bone.  After learning of the plaintiff's history of regular attendances on chiropractic practitioners by his re-examination, he appeared to have become somewhat less certain.

It is embarrassing to the plaintiff's case that she did not disclose to Dr Wallace who saw her in 2008 or to Dr Steadman, who saw her the following year, her extensive resort to chiropractic treatments or services which, in respect of her last chiropractor, Dr Josie Barnes began in December 2006 when the previous chiropractor she'd attended became unavailable.
There were six or seven attendances in the second half of December, 10 or more in January.  These tapered off in February, March and April 2007.  There was only one in May preceding the accident and, ironically, on the very day of it, presumably earlier.

The chiropractor's services were invoked again on the 14th of May when the accident was reported.  There were four attendances in the next 12 days and three in June, three in July, four in each of August and September and smaller numbers in the following months of 2007.

The plaintiff cannot, justly, be charged with trying to conceal the chiropractic aspect of her history.  It is clearly disclosed in the part 1 notice of claim produced under the PIPA, as it's called, The Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 and, indeed, shortly after the incident the plaintiff, as any of us might in such circumstances, made a statement to the effect that she already had a problem with her back and didn't know how much damage had been done to it after she slipped at Pacific Fair.  I think it's human nature to be concerned that an existing problem hasn't…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lowe v AMP Capital Investors Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] QDC 267
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lowe v AMP Capital Investors Ltd, the plaintiff, Eve Lowe, initiated proceedings against the defendants, AMP Capital Investors Limited and others, for damages resulting from a fall at the Pacific Fair Shopping Centre on May 9, 2007. The primary dispute centered on whether the back pain experienced by Lowe, which she claimed arose from the fall, was attributable to the accident or to a pre-existing hip condition. The defendants argued that the cleaning contractor was not liable, and the case hinged on the adequacy of the cleaning schedule and the presence of a slippery substance on the floor.

The court had to determine if the cleaning system was sufficient to prevent such accidents and if the defendants were negligent in failing to maintain a safe environment. The evidence showed that the cleaning schedule required inspections every 26 minutes, but discrepancies in the records and testimonies raised doubts about the reliability of the system. The plaintiff's reliance on chiropractic treatments prior to the accident also complicated the assessment of her injuries.

The court concluded that the defendants were negligent due to the inadequate cleaning system, which failed to address the foreseeable risk of spillages effectively. The evidence suggested that the cleaning round preceding the accident was not conducted as required, leading to the presence of a slippery substance on the floor. The court found that the system was insufficient, as it relied too heavily on staff observation rather than regular, systematic inspections. This negligence resulted in Lowe's fall and subsequent injuries.

In terms of damages, the court assessed general damages at $6,200, past economic loss at $2,715.80, and future economic loss at $40,000. The court also awarded special damages for past expenses and future medical expenses. The total damages awarded reflected the plaintiff's long-term consequences from the accident, despite the pre-existing hip condition. The court ordered the defendants to pay the awarded damages to the plaintiff.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.