Lontav Pty ltd v Pineross Custodial Services Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

No. 4124 of 2011

LONTAV PTY LTD (ACN 112 630 190) Plaintiff
v
PINEROSS CUSTODIAL SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 097 434 145) Defendant

---

JUDGE:

DIXON J

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

8, 9, 12, 20 SEPTEMBER 2011

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

28 SEPTEMBER 2011

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

LONTAV PTY LTD v PINEROSS CUSTODIAL SERVICES PTY LTD (NO 2)

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2011] VSC 485

---

Landlord and Tenant – Lease of hotel premises – Lessee parted with licence of leased premises – Whether licence transferred by wilful breach or mistake – Whether mistake made by lessee or licensing authority – Continuing breach of an essential term which has not been remedied – Lease term about to expire – Option to renew exercised when in breach of essential term – Whether lessee entitled to further term – Lessee previously relieved from forfeiture on conditions including application for re-transfer of licence – Whether relief from forfeiture futile – Whether landlord unconscionably enforcing forfeiture rights – Whether lessee should have relief against forfeiture – Property Law Act1958 (Vic) s 146(2) – Liquor Control Reform Act 1998 (Vic) ss 32, 90(1), 93, 96B, 106, 107.

Retail Leases – Lease of hotel to subsidiary of public company – Whether a retail lease – Whether option to renew governed by statutory provisions – Jurisdiction of VCAT – Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) ss 3, 4, 11, 27, 28, 89.

Estoppel – Issue estoppel – Previous application for relief from forfeiture – Condition of relief in first proceeding was remedy of a breach not the subject of a default notice – Whether findings fundamental to decision to grant relief – Principles applying.

Practice and Procedure – Leave to re-open after judgment reserved – principles applying.

---

Appearances:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr A Klotz Lewenberg & Lewenberg
For the Defendant Mr M Robins Nathan Kuperholz

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Parties and issues............................................................................................................................... 1

General principles.............................................................................................................................. 4

Developments since the decision in the first proceeding........................................................... 6

Lontav re-opens its case after judgment is reserved.................................................................. 11

Was there breach of clause 17 of the lease and has breach been remedied?........................ 15

The Liquor Control Reform Act..................................................................................................... 15
Lontav remains in breach of clause 17..................................................................................... 16

In circumstances of continuing breach of an essential term, should equity intervene?..... 20

Was Lontav’s breach of clause 17 of the lease deliberate or does it arise out of a mistake or accident which Pineross is exploiting unconscionably?........................................................................... 22

Is there an issue estoppel arising from the first proceeding?.............................................. 23
There are not exceptional circumstances warranting equitable intervention.................... 28
Was there conduct disentitling Lontav to equity?................................................................. 33

Is relief from forfeiture futile in any event?................................................................................ 34

Is the lease a retail premises lease?.......................................................................................... 36
Is Lontav entitled to relief from ‘forfeiture’ of an option to renew the lease?................... 39

Conclusion......................................................................................................................................... 44

HIS HONOUR:

Parties and issues

  1. On 23 June 2011, Hargrave J granted the plaintiff, Lontav…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lontav Pty ltd v Pineross Custodial Services Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] VSC 485
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lontav Pty Ltd, the owner of a hotel in Melbourne, brought a claim against Pineross Custodial Services Pty Ltd, the lessee of the hotel premises, to terminate the lease and forfeit the lease due to alleged breaches by the lessee. The dispute reached the Supreme Court of Victoria, which was tasked with determining the validity of the forfeiture and the applicability of estoppel in the context of the previous relief from forfeiture granted to the lessee. The court also needed to decide whether the lease was a retail lease subject to the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) and whether it was within the jurisdiction of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT).

The primary legal issues involved whether the lessee's licence to operate the hotel had been transferred to a new entity by a wilful breach or a mistake, and whether the mistake was made by the lessee or the licensing authority. The court also needed to determine if the continuing breach of an essential term, which had not been remedied, warranted forfeiture of the lease, especially given that the lease was about to expire and the option to renew was exercised while in breach. Additionally, the court had to assess whether the previous relief from forfeiture was rendered futile and whether the landlord was unconscionably enforcing the forfeiture rights. The court further needed to consider the applicability of estoppel principles in light of the previous application for relief from forfeiture, and whether the findings from that proceeding were fundamental to the decision at hand.

The court held that the lessee had indeed parted with the licence by a mistake, but this was not due to the lessee but rather the licensing authority. Despite the breach of an essential term of the lease, the court found that the lessee was not entitled to a further term as the breach had not been remedied. The court also concluded that the previous relief from forfeiture was not rendered futile and that the landlord was not unconscionably enforcing the forfeiture rights. The court applied estoppel principles and found that the findings from the previous proceeding were not fundamental to the decision. The court found that the lease was not a retail lease, and thus the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) did not apply. The court also held that it had jurisdiction over the matter.

The Supreme Court of Victoria ordered that the lease be terminated, and the lessee be evicted from the premises. The court also granted leave to the landlord to re-open the case after judgment was reserved, allowing for the consideration of additional evidence and arguments.