Beamer Pty Ltd v Star Lodge Supported Residential Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

F**f

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION

No. 8145 of 1998

Beamer Pty Ltd Plaintiff
v
Star Lodge Supported Residential Services Pty Ltd & Ors Defendants

No. 6604 of 1999

Najjar Special Accommodation Services Pty Ltd & Ors Plaintiffs
v
Kimis Pty Ltd & Ors Defendants

---

JUDGE:

Hollingworth J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

21-23, 26-30 July, 3-6, 9-13, 16, 17, 23, 24, 31 August, 1-3, 6-10 September 2004

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

1 July 2005

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2005] VSC 236

1st revision 4 July 2005

---

LANDLORD AND TENANT –  whether landlord properly determined lease pursuant to Property Law Act 1958 ss. 146, 198 – application for relief against forfeiture – relevant discretionary principles – effluxion of lease – failure of tenant to purport to exercise option to renew – tenant’s demonstrated incapacity to respond to serious breaches of municipal fire standards – grant of relief not appropriate in the circumstances.

TRUSTS – whether trustee breached duty of care owed to beneficiaries – failure to seek relief against forfeiture  - no breach of duty in circumstances where trustee could not afford to carry out the works required to retain the business and comply with obligations under the lease – whether failure to ensure statutory registration in name of trust company a breach of duty – trustee lodged transfer form with statutory body – nothing more required in the circumstances.

CORPORATIONS  - whether director of trustee company breached duty of care to beneficiaries – failure to seek relief against forfeiture -  duties ceased upon appointment of new trustees – failure to ensure DHS certificate registered in company name – no breach of duty in the circumstances.

TRADE PRACTICES -  vendor sold half-interest in business to purchaser – whether representations made by vendor were misleading and deceptive Trade Practices Act 1974 s.52 – purchaser’s decision not made in reliance on vendor’s misrepresentations.

EVIDENCE  - whether Jones v Dunkel (1958) 101 CLR 298 inference available – applicable principles – effect of inference where witness in both camps – adverse inference not relevant to facts in issue – inference not appropriate where witness is party’s solicitor and evidence would be subject of privilege .

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors

For Beamer Pty Ltd, Kimis & Co Pty Ltd, George Moutidis & Louis Moutidis

Mr G Hevey

Dr A Ciro

Anthony Peterson & Co

For Hidek International Pty Ltd

Mr R McGarvie

McDonald Slater & Lay
For Zenn Nominees Pty Ltd, Western Lodge Supported Residential Services Pty Ltd, Manuel Jiminez Mr P W Collinson
Mr M Ravech
Brygel Lawyers

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction........................................................................................................................................ 1

The parties........................................................................................................................................... 2

The Moutidis parties..................................................................................................................... 2

Star Lodge...................................................................................................................................... 2

The Najjar parties.......................................................................................................................... 3

The Jiminez parties....................................................................................................................... 3

Hidek............................................................................................................................................... 4

Mitsios............................................................................................................................................. 4

Summary of the Beamer proceeding.............................................................................................. 5

Summary of the Najjar proceeding................................................................................................ 6

The witnesses...................................................................................................................................... 7

The Moutidis family..................................................................................................................... 8

Witnesses for the Najjar defendants........................................................................................... 9

Hidek witnesses.......................................................................................................................... 12

Council witnesses........................................................................................................................ 13

DHS witnesses............................................................................................................................. 13

Fire witnesses............................................................................................................................... 14

Other…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Beamer Pty Ltd v Star Lodge Supported Residential Services P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] VSC 236
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Beamer Pty Ltd, the landlord, brought an action against Star Lodge Supported Residential Services Pty Ltd, the tenant, to determine whether the landlord properly terminated the lease in accordance with the Property Law Act 1958. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The tenant applied for relief against forfeiture, claiming that the landlord had wrongly terminated the lease and that the tenant had been unable to remedy serious breaches of municipal fire standards. The landlord argued that the tenant had failed to exercise an option to renew the lease and that the tenant had demonstrated an incapacity to respond to the breaches.

The court had to determine several legal issues, including whether the landlord correctly terminated the lease and if the tenant was entitled to relief against forfeiture. The court also considered whether the trustee of the tenant had breached their duty of care owed to the beneficiaries, particularly in relation to the failure to seek relief against forfeiture and ensuring the statutory registration of the property in the trust company's name. Additionally, the court assessed whether the director of the trustee company had breached their duty of care to the beneficiaries and if there had been any misleading or deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act 1974. Finally, the court examined the applicability of the Jones v Dunkel inference in the context of the evidence presented.

The court found that the landlord had properly terminated the lease and that relief against forfeiture was not appropriate in the circumstances. The court held that the trustee of the tenant had not breached their duty of care as they could not afford to carry out the required works to retain the business and comply with the lease obligations. The trustee's failure to ensure statutory registration in the trust company's name was not considered a breach of duty as the transfer form had already been lodged with the relevant statutory body. The director of the trustee company was also found not to have breached their duty of care as their duties had ceased upon the appointment of new trustees. Regarding the trade practices claim, the court concluded that the purchaser's decision was not made in reliance on any misleading or deceptive conduct by the vendor. Lastly, the court determined that the Jones v Dunkel inference was not applicable to the evidence presented as the witness in question was a party's solicitor and their evidence would be subject to privilege.