LNDN and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

LNDN and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2021] AATA 1995 (21 June 2021)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number:2020/1962            

Re:LNDN  

APPLICANT

Inspector-General in BankruptcyAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D Mitchell

Date:21 June 2021

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

................[SGD]...............................................

Member D Mitchell

CATCHWORDS

BANKRUPTCY – objection to discharge – where bankruptcy trustee filed a notice to objection to the Applicant’s discharge from bankruptcy – objection on special grounds – whether evidence supports grounds – whether Applicant had a reasonable excuse for conduct or failure constituting special grounds – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)

CASES

De La Hunty v Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2006] AATA 610

Mallett and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2018] AATA 3739

Phillips and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy (2012) 58 AAR 452: (2012) 131 ALD 564: [2012] AATA 788

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D Mitchell

21 June 2021

INTRODUCTION

  1. LNDN (the Applicant) is seeking review of a decision of the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy (the Respondent) dated 9 March 2020.[1]

    [1]    Exhibit 1, T-Documents, T2, pages 4-37, Application for Review of Decision.

  2. The reviewable decision confirmed all grounds of objection to the Applicant’s discharge from bankruptcy which effectively extended the Applicant’s period of bankruptcy to 29 November 2024.[2]

    [2]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T2.1, pages 38-67, Notice of Reviewable Decision and Reasons for Decision.

    BACKGROUND

  3. On 29 November 2016, the Applicant became bankruptcy upon the acceptance of a Debtor’s Petition by the Official Receiver.[3] The Applicant’s period of bankruptcy was due to end on 29 November 2019.

    [3]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T11, pages 296-298, LNDN Debtors Petition.

  4. On 26 October 2017, following a creditor request, Mr Alan Scott (the Trustee) was appointed trustee of the Applicant’s bankruptcy.[4]

    [4]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T9.1, page 266, Trustee’s Timelines of Significant Events.

  5. On 12 November 2019, the Trustee filed a Notice of Objection (the Objection) to the Applicant’s discharge from bankruptcy under section 149B of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (the Act). The Trustee objected based on the grounds contained in sections 149D(1)(d), (da), (ma) and (ab) of the Act. These grounds provide:[5]

    (d) –     The bankrupt, when requested in writing by the trustee to provide written   information about the bankrupt’s property, income or expected income, failed   to comply with the request (Ground 1).

    (da) –   After the date of the bankruptcy, the bankrupt intentionally provide false or            misleading information to the trustee (Ground 2).

    (ma) – The bankrupt intentionally failed to disclose to the trustee the bankrupt’s                beneficial interest in any property (Ground 3).

    (ab) –   Any transfer is void against the trustee in bankruptcy because of section 121        (Ground 4).

    [5]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T3.3, pages 95-100, Trustee’s Notice of Objection.

  6. The Objection had the effect of extending the Applicant’s bankruptcy until 29 November 2024 unless the objection is withdrawn or cancelled.[6]

    [6]     Sections 149A(2) and (3) of the Act.

  7. On 10 January 2020, the Applicant applied to the Respondent requesting a review of the Trustee’s Objection.[7]

    [7]     Exhibit 1,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LNDN and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1995
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy to confirm an objection to the Applicant's discharge from bankruptcy. The Applicant's bankruptcy commenced on 29 November 2016, with discharge originally due on 29 November 2019. The trustee appointed to the Applicant's bankruptcy filed a Notice of Objection on 12 November 2019, citing grounds under sections 149D(1)(d), (da), (ma), and (ab) of the *Bankruptcy Act 1966* (Cth). These grounds related to the Applicant's failure to provide requested information, intentionally providing false or misleading information, failing to disclose beneficial interests in property, and transferring property that was void against the trustee under section 121 of the Act. The Inspector-General had previously confirmed all grounds of objection, extending the Applicant's bankruptcy until 29 November 2024.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Inspector-General's decision to confirm the objection should be affirmed or cancelled. Specifically, under section 149N(1A) of the *Bankruptcy Act*, the Tribunal had to consider if there was sufficient evidence to support at least one special ground of objection and, if so, whether the Applicant had established a reasonable excuse for the conduct or failure constituting that ground. The Applicant contended that he had cooperated with the trustee to the extent possible, that any inaccuracies were unintentional due to seeking professional advice, that there was confusion regarding requests, and that he was under considerable strain. The Inspector-General argued that the Applicant had not adequately addressed the grounds of objection and lacked proximate evidence of any reasonable excuse.

The Tribunal found that Ground 4 of the Objection, concerning a transfer of property void against the trustee under section 121 of the Act, was established without reasonable excuse. This ground related to the transfer of settlement monies from the sale of the B Property into the LNDN Discretionary Trust. The Tribunal concluded that this transfer was void against the trustee because the Applicant's main purpose in making the transfer was to prevent the property from becoming divisible among his creditors, and he was insolvent or about to become insolvent at the time of the transfer. As at least one special ground was established without reasonable excuse, the Tribunal determined that the objection could not be cancelled.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the Inspector-General's decision to confirm the objection to the Applicant's discharge from bankruptcy. This decision meant that the Applicant's period of bankruptcy would continue until 29 November 2024, unless the objection was subsequently withdrawn or cancelled.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The reviewable decision confirmed all grounds of objection to the Applicant’s discharge from bankruptcy which effectively extended the Applicant’s period of bankruptcy to 29 November 2024.[2] [2] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T2.1, pages 38-67, Notice of Reviewable Decision and Reasons for Decision.BACKGROUND On 29 November 2016, the Applicant became bankruptcy upon the acceptance of a Debtor’s Petition by the Official Receiver.[3] The Applicant’s period of bankruptcy was due to end on 29 November 2019.[3] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T11, pages 296-298, LNDN Debtors Petition. On 26 October 2017, following a creditor request, Mr Alan Scott (the Trustee) was appointed trustee of the Applicant’s bankruptcy.[4][4] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T9.1, page 266, Trustee’s Timelines of Significant Events. On 12 November 2019, the Trustee filed a Notice of Objection (the Objection) to the Applicant’s discharge from bankruptcy under section 149B of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (the Act). The Trustee objected based on the grounds contained in sections 149D(1)(d), (da), (ma) and (ab) of the Act. These grounds provide:[5](d) – The bankrupt, when requested in writing by the trustee to provide written information about the bankrupt’s property, income or expected income, failed to comply with the request (Ground 1).(da) – After the date of the bankruptcy, the bankrupt intentionally provide false or misleading information to the trustee (Ground 2).(ma) – The bankrupt intentionally failed to disclose to the trustee the bankrupt’s beneficial interest in any property (Ground 3).(ab) – Any transfer is void against the trustee in bankruptcy because of section 121 (Ground 4).[5] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T3.3, pages 95-100, Trustee’s Notice of Objection. The Objection had the effect of extending the Applicant’s bankruptcy until 29 November 2024 unless the objection is withdrawn or cancelled.[6][6] Sections 149A(2) and (3) of the Act. On 10 January 2020, the Applicant applied to the Respondent requesting a review of the Trustee’s Objection.[7][7] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T3.1, pages 68-72, Application for Review of Objection. On 9 March 2020, in a decision made pursuant to section 149N(3) of the Act, the Respondent confirmed all grounds of the Objection.[8][8] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T2.1, pages 38-67, Notice of Reviewable Decision and Reasons for Decision. On 2 April 2020, the Applicant sought review of the Respondent’s decision by way of an application to this Tribunal.[9][9] Exhibit 1, T-Documents, T2, pages 4-37, Application for Review of Decision. On 18 December 2020, a Hearing was conducted in this matter. At Hearing the Applicant was self-represented, was supported by Mrs LNDN (his wife), appeared by Microsoft Teams and gave evidence under affirmation.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK The relevant legislation in this matter is the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (the Act). Section 149Q of the Act provides this Tribunal with the jurisdiction to review the decision of the Respondent, not the decision of the Trustee to file an objection.[10] As such in this matter the Tribunal must give consideration to the requirements of section 149N of the Act.[10] Phillips and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy (2012) 58 AAR 452: (2012) 131 ALD 564: [2012] AATA 788.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

To be successful in this application the Applicant must establish that none of the four grounds of the Objection have been established, or where they have that he had a reasonable excuse for his conduct or failure that constituted that special ground. Should the Tribunal find that one of the grounds is established without a reasonable excuse the Applicant’s application must fail.EVIDENCE AND CONTENTIONS Upon review of the evidence before the Tribunal and that provided at Hearing by the Applicant and Mrs LNDN it is clear that the events that led up to the Applicant’s bankruptcy and those that have transpired since have been difficult for both him and his family. The Applicant’s overall contentions seemed to be that:(a)he believes he co-operated with the Trustee and provided everything he was asked to, to the extent that he was able to;(b)that any inaccuracy in the information he provided was unintentional as his disclosures were made after seeking professional advice; (c)there was confusion in relation to what was being asked; and (d)he was under a considerable amount of strain. Concerns were raised by the Applicant in relation to the conduct of a creditor, however whilst no doubt the issues raised are distressing to both him and Mrs LNDN, they are not matters to which this Tribunal can have regard to or comment about. The Respondent’s overarching contention is that the Applicant has not adequately addressed the grounds of objection in order to disturb the reviewable decision. At Hearing the Respondent contended that in relation to reasonable excuse that there is insufficient evidence of any kind that is proximate to the events. The Respondent contended that there is no medical evidence that might give rise to a reasonable excuse and while there had been an opportunity to obtain that evidence it has not been put forward before the Tribunal. The Respondent sought to rely upon the reviewable decision,[13] the Statement of Facts Issues and Contention dated 5 August 2020[14] and Submissions dated 5 November 2020.[15] The Tribunal notes that the Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and Submissions were brief documents, which on their own were unhelpful. The documents sought to adopt the forementioned reasons provided for the reviewable decision. [13] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T2.1, pages 38-67, Notice of Reviewable Decision and Reasons for Decision.[14] Exhibit 2, Tribunal Book, TB2, pages 1-3, Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions.[15] Exhibit 3, Respondent’s Final Submission. As an attachment to the notice of decision dated 9 March 2020, the Respondent outlined the background and its consideration which led to the decision to confirm all the grounds of objection raised by the Trustee (reasons for the reviewable decision).[16] That document clearly sets out the background of this matter and reflects the evidence before this Tribunal. As such the Tribunal does not propose duplicate that material here but rather will include it where relevant in the consideration outlined below.[16] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T2.1, pages 40-67, Respondent’s Reasons for Decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 149N of the Act provides:149N Decision on review(1) On a review of a decision, if the Inspector‑General is satisfied that:(a)the ground or grounds on which the objection was made was not a ground or were not grounds specified in subsection 149D(1); or(b)there is insufficient evidence to support the existence of the ground or grounds of objection; or(c)the reasons given for objecting on that ground or those grounds do not justify the making of the objection; or(d)a previous objection that was made on that ground or those grounds, or on grounds that included that ground or those grounds, was cancelled;the Inspector‑General must cancel the objection.(1A) An objection must not be cancelled under subsection (1) if:(a)the objection specifies at least one special ground; and(b)there is sufficient evidence to support the existence of at least one special ground specified in the objection; and(c)the bankrupt fails to establish that the bankrupt had a reasonable excuse for the conduct or failure that constituted the special ground.For this purpose, special ground means a ground specified in paragraph 149D(1)(ab), (d), (da), (e), (f), (g), (h), (ha), (ia), (k) or (ma).(1B)In applying subsection (1A), no notice is to be taken of any conduct of the bankrupt after the time when the ground concerned first commenced to exist.(2)The cancellation does not take effect until:(a)the end of the period within which an application may be made to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for the review of the decision of the Inspector‑General; or(b)if such an application is made—the decision of the Tribunal is given.(3)If the Inspector‑General is not satisfied as mentioned in subsection (1), the Inspector‑General must confirm the decision. In applying subsection 149N(1A) of the Act the Tribunal is not to take any notice of the conduct of the Applicant after the time when the ground concerned first commenced to exist.ISSUES The Tribunal notes that based on the information before it, it is clear that the grounds on which the Objection was made were grounds specified in section 149D(1) of the Act and that no previous objections have been made on those grounds.[11] As such the Tribunal is satisfied that the requirements of section 149N(1)(a) and (d) of the Act are not met for each of the grounds of objection. This point is uncontentious.[11] As such sections 149N(1)(a) and (d) of the Act are not satisfied. Each of the grounds of the Objection are special grounds of objection.[12] As such the operation of section 149N(1) of the Act is modified in this case by section 149N(1A) so that in determining whether the objection should be cancelled the Tribunal must in this case consider whether there is sufficient evidence to support the existence of at least one special ground specified in the objection and whether the Applicant establishes that he had a reasonable excuse for the conduct or failure that constituted that special ground. The reasons given for objecting on the grounds pursuant to section 149N(1)(c) of the Act are not relevant by virtue of the operation of section 149N(1A) of the Act.[12] Pursuant to sections 149D1(d), (da), (ma) and (ab) of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At Hearing the Respondent contended that the surplus proceeds of the B property, were clearly the property of the Applicant of which he authorised to be transferred to the trust. It was a transfer of property from the Applicant to the trust within 5 years of the bankruptcy and is clearly subject to section 121 of the Act.[44]CONSIDERATION[44] Transcript, page 95.Introduction Pursuant to section 149N of the Act the Objection must not be cancelled where there is evidence to support the existence of at least one special ground and the Applicant fails to establish that he had a reasonable excuse for the conduct or failure that constituted that special ground. Consequently, where the Tribunal finds that at least one special ground is established without reasonable excuse the Applicant’s application must fail. In the present matter, based on the evidence before it, and for the reasons set out below, the Tribunal considers that Ground 4 of the Objection has been established without reasonable excuse on the basis that the transfer of the proceeds from the sale of the B Property to the LNDN Discretionary Trust is void against the trustee in bankruptcy because of section 121 of the Act. In reaching this decision the Tribunal had regard to whether ground 4 of the Objection had been established and if so whether the Applicant had a reasonable excuse for the associated conduct. In such circumstances the Tribunal does not consider it necessary to make findings on the remaining three grounds of the Objection. Has Ground 4 of the Objection been established? Ground 4 of the Objection relates to whether the transfer of the settlement monies from the B Property paid into the LNDN Discretionary Trust in the sum of $43,782.13 (the transferred property) are void against the trustee in bankruptcy because of section 121 of the Act. Section 121 of the Act relevantly provides:121 Transfers to defeat creditorsTransfers that are void(1)A transfer of property by a person who later becomes a bankrupt (the transferor) to another person (the transferee) is void against the trustee in the transferor’s bankruptcy if:(a) the property would probably have become part of the transferor’s estate or would probably have been available to creditors if the property had not been transferred; and(b) the transferor’s main purpose in making the transfer was:(i)to prevent the transferred property from becoming divisible among the transferor’s creditors; or(ii)to hinder or delay the process of making property available for division among the transferor’s creditors.Note: For the application of this section where consideration is given to a third party rather than the transferor, see section 121A.Showing the transferor’s main purpose in making a transfer(2)The transferor’s main purpose in making the transfer is taken to be the purpose described in paragraph (1)(b) if it can reasonably be inferred from all the circumstances that, at the time of the transfer, the transferor was, or was about to become, insolvent.Other ways of showing the transferor’s main purpose in making a transfer(3)Subsection (2) does not limit the ways of establishing the transferor’s main purpose in making a transfer.Transfer not void if transferee acted in good faith(4)Despite subsection (1), a transfer of property is not void against the trustee if:(a) the consideration that the transferee gave for the transfer was at least as valuable as the market value of the property; and(b) the transferee did not know, and could not reasonably have inferred, that the transferor’s main purpose in making the transfer was the purpose described in paragraph (1)(b); and(c) the transferee could not reasonably have inferred that, at the time of the transfer, the transferor was, or was about to become, insolvent.……..Meaning of transfer of property and market value(9)For the purposes of this section:(a)transfer of property includes a payment of money; and(b) a person who does something that results in another person becoming the owner of property that did not previously exist is taken to have transferred the property to the other person; and(c) the market value of property transferred is its market value at the time of the transfer.