Lisica v NRMA (Motor Accident Injuries)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

LISICA v NRMA (Motor Accident Injuries) [2022] ACAT 98

MAI 2/2022

Catchwords:  MOTOR ACCIDENT INJURIES – application for review of insurer’s decision pursuant to section 193 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2019 – calculation of applicant’s pre-injury weekly income (PIWI) – whether applicant was self-employed – whether common law principles of employment law apply to consideration of applicant’s employment status – onus of proof in procuring information about employment status – calculation of PIWI for self-employed persons – intent and application of “significant improvement in profitability of the business” in Guideline 5.2.4 of MAI (Income Replacement Benefit) Guidelines

Legislation cited:  Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 13, 14

Motor Accident Injuries Act 2019 ss 81, 82, 193

Subordinate

Legislation cited:  Motor Accident Injuries (Internal Review) Guidelines 2019

Motor Accident Injuries (Income Replacement Benefit) Guidelines 2021

Cases cited:Coco v R [1994] HCA15

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Barker [2014] HCA 32
Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1
Fair Work Ombudsman v Jooine (Investment) Pty Ltd [2013] FCCA 2144
Neish v Insurance Australia Limited Trading as NRMA [2022] ACAT 24
Potter v Minahan (1908) 7 CLR 277
Thompsonv Australian Capital Television Pty Ltd (1994) 54 FCR 513
WorkPac Pty Ltd v Rossato [2021] HCA 23

Tribunal:Acting Presidential Member T Kyprianou

Date of Orders:  23 November 2022

Date of Reasons for Decision:       23 November 2022

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          MAI 2/2022

BETWEEN:

BELMA LISICA

Applicant

AND:

INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED ACN 000 016 722 TRADING AS NRMA

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Acting Presidential Member T Kyprianou

DATE:23 November 2022

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The Reviewable Decision dated 6 April 2022 be set aside and the matter be remitted to the respondent for reconsideration in accordance with the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2019 (MAI Act), the relevant Motor Accident Injuries (Income Replacement Benefit) Guidelines (Guidelines) and the directions made in the reasons for decision.

  2. The same time periods for making the reconsideration decision apply as if order 1 was an application for internal review of the decision to reject liability received by the respondent received on the day after the date of these orders.

  3. The applicant is to lodge with the tribunal and give to the respondent any application she wishes to make in relation to costs along with an itemised list of costs she has incurred, in accordance with regulation 6(2) of the Motor Accident Injuries (ACAT Costs Orders) Regulation 2020 by 14 December 2022.

  4. The respondent is to lodge with the tribunal and give to the applicant any submissions it wishes to make, if any, in relation to any application by the applicant for costs and the applicant’s list of costs, or alternatively advise the tribunal and the applicant that it does not propose to make any submissions by 21 December 2022.

    ………………………………..

Acting Presidential Member T Kyprianou

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The application for review…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lisica v NRMA (Motor Accident Injuries) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ACAT 98
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lisica v NRMA (Motor Accident Injuries), the applicant sought a review of a decision made by the respondent, NRMA, regarding the calculation of the applicant’s pre-injury weekly income (PIWI). The dispute arose under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2019 and was heard by the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales (NCAT). The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant was self-employed or an employee at the time of the motor accident, which would significantly affect the calculation of her PIWI. The respondent had determined that the applicant was self-employed, a finding that the applicant contested. This determination hinged on the definition of employment status and whether the common law principles of employment law should be considered alongside the statutory definitions provided in the Motor Accident Injuries Act.

The Tribunal found that the respondent had erred in assuming that the statutory definitions of self-employed and employee were exclusive of common law principles. The respondent had also relied on a commissioned report that assumed the applicant was self-employed without sufficient evidence. The Tribunal held that the onus of proof did not lie with the applicant to establish her employment status, but rather the respondent had the responsibility to gather sufficient information. The Tribunal emphasised that the applicant had a duty to disclose relevant information, but the absence of pertinent information from the applicant's lawyer did not justify the respondent's decision. The Tribunal concluded that more information was necessary to accurately determine the applicant's employment status and the nature of her relationship with Waterblue, the entity from which she received payment.

Given these findings, the Tribunal set aside the Reviewable Decision and ordered the matter to be remitted to the respondent for reconsideration. The reconsideration was to be conducted in accordance with the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2019, the Motor Accident Injuries (Income Replacement Benefit) Guidelines, and the directions provided in the Tribunal's reasons for decision. The Tribunal also specified timeframes for the reconsideration and outlined the procedures for any applications for costs, requiring the applicant and the respondent to lodge their respective applications and submissions by specific dates.

The Tribunal's decision underscores the importance of accurately determining an applicant's employment status in the context of motor accident injuries, highlighting the need for insurers to gather sufficient evidence and consider both statutory and common law principles. The outcome ensures that the applicant's claim will be reassessed with the appropriate legal framework in mind, facilitating a fair and accurate calculation of her PIWI.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The Reviewable Decision dated 6 April 2022 be set aside and the matter be remitted to the respondent for reconsideration in accordance with the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2019 (MAI Act), the relevant Motor Accident Injuries (Income Replacement Benefit) Guidelines (Guidelines) and the directions made in the reasons for decision.

2.

The same time periods for making the reconsideration decision apply as if order 1 was an application for internal review of the decision to reject liability received by the respondent received on the day after the date of these orders.

3.

The applicant is to lodge with the tribunal and give to the respondent any application she wishes to make in relation to costs along with an itemised list of costs she has incurred, in accordance with regulation 6(2) of the Motor Accident Injuries (ACAT Costs Orders) Regulation 2020 by 14 December 2022.

4.

The respondent is to lodge with the tribunal and give to the applicant any submissions it wishes to make, if any, in relation to any application by the applicant for costs and the applicant’s list of costs, or alternatively advise the tribunal and the applicant that it does not propose to make any submissions by 21 December 2022.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further information needs to be obtained from the applicant and Waterblue about the agreement between them which led to the applicant providing cleaning services to Waterblue and its clients and receiving payment from Waterblue for those services. This is a necessary prerequisite to a determination of the applicant’s PIWI.Does the applicant’s failure to provide information establishing her employment status mean the reviewable decision is correct? In my view, the short answer to the above question is no. The respondent has submitted that the applicant had the opportunity to submit information through her solicitor supporting the proposition that she was either an employee or fixed term contractor but did not do so. She also did not provide any information that she had an ongoing contract with Waterblue. Neither the applicant nor her solicitor provided such information to the respondent before the reviewable decision was made. However, this does not mean that the respondent’s decision is correct in fact and law. The role of the Tribunal is to determine whether the decision is correct on the facts and the law.[30] As stated earlier, in my view, the respondent was in error in assuming that the definitions of self-employed and employee as they appear in the MAI Act are exclusive of the common law principles defining those terms.[30] See section 193 of the MAI Act and [2022] ACAT 24 at [17]-[20] Further, the respondent relied on the PKF report the respondent commissioned which proceeded on the assumption that the applicant was self-employed. The information the applicant was asked to produce was insufficient to establish her employment status and the kind of relationship she had with Waterblue through which she derived income from personal exertion at the time of the motor accident. The MAI Act does not impose an onus of proof on either party. The applicant has a duty under section 20 of the Act to disclose all relevant information in relation to her claim and to provide information reasonably requested by an insurer. There is no suggestion that the applicant has failed to provide any of the information she was asked to provide by the respondent. The lawyer who represented the applicant at the time should have been aware of the significance of providing more information about her employment status, especially when an internal review of the decision was sought. However, the MAI legislative scheme envisages that injured people will lodge their claims without the need for legal representation and that the relevant insurer will guide the procurement of whatever information is necessary to assess a claim. Applicants for defined benefits cannot recover legal fees incurred in obtaining legal advice and representation in relation to their claims prior to the external review stage. Under these circumstances, I am not prepared to dismiss the applicant’s application on the basis that her lawyer did not provide any pertinent information to challenge the respondent’s finding that the applicant was self-employed at the internal review stage.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.