| [2016] FWCFB 4218 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.604 - Appeal of decisions
v
Peter Norman
(C2016/2805)
VICE PRESIDENT WATSON |
|
Appeal against decision [2016] FWC 840 of Deputy President Bartel at Adelaide on 10 February 2016 in matter number U2015/7090 – Whether valid reason relating to capacity – Test for determining whether a valid reason – Relevance of subsequent assessments – Role of Commission in determining valid reason – Fair Work Act 2009, s.387.
Decision of Vice President Watson and Commissioner Wilson
Introduction
[1] On 24 March 2016 this Full Bench granted Lion Dairy and Drinks Milk Limited (Lion Dairy) permission to appeal against the decision of Deputy President Bartel of 10 February 2016 in an unfair dismissal application made by Peter Norman under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act). 1
[2] The Deputy President held that Mr Norman had been unfairly dismissed as his dismissal was found to be unjust and unreasonable. The Deputy President ordered that Mr Norman be reinstated to his former position and be paid for remuneration lost by him as a result of his dismissal.
[3] At the hearing of the appeal on 22 June 2016, Ms R. Preston of counsel, with Ms D. Katris, appeared on behalf of Lion Dairy and Mr R. Manuel of counsel, with Mr T. Hardie, appeared on behalf of Mr Norman.
[4] A chronology of relevant events is conveniently recorded in the Deputy President’s decision:
“23 February 2014: Applicant’s accident.
19 February 2015: Employer requests that Dr Graham undertake a medical assessment of the applicant and provide recommendations on his capacity to perform his role.
5 March 2015: Dr Graham examines the applicant.
11 March 2015: Dr Graham’s report (“the initial report”) provided to the employer.
25 March 2015: Meeting with the applicant Mr Draper and Ms Liston. Initial report provided to the applicant. This was to be a show cause meeting, but was adjourned after the applicant presented a certificate from Professor Jaarsma clearing him to return to work on 30 March 2015.
27 March 2015: Employer requests a further report from Dr Graham in light of Professor Jaarsma’s clearance.
30 March 2015: Dr Graham provides a further medical report (“the supplementary report”) to the employer.
1 April 2015: ‘Show cause’ meeting with the applicant, Mr Draper and Ms Pool. The applicant is given a copy of the supplementary report. A ‘show cause’ letter is provided to the applicant, giving him until 7 April 2015 to provide further information.
7 April 2015: Applicant responds to show cause letter.
9 April 2015: Employer requests that the applicant provide permission to speak with Professor Jaarsma.
10 April 2015: Applicant responds to employer request.
15 April 2015: Further meeting attended by the applicant, Mr Gordon, Mr Draper, Ms Liston. Ms Pool attends via telephone conference call. The applicant’s employment is terminated.”
[5] The show cause letter included the following passages:
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lion Dairy and Drinks Milk Limited v Norman and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] FWCFB 4218
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide several legal issues, including whether the dismissal was justified, the appropriate test for determining whether a valid reason existed, the relevance of subsequent assessments in this context, and the role of the Commission in assessing the validity of the reason provided for the dismissal. These issues were critical in determining whether the dismissal was fair and whether it complied with the Fair Work Act 2009.
The court found that the dismissal was not based on a valid reason relating to the appellant's capacity. The reasoning focused on the application of the statutory test outlined in the Fair Work Act, considering the evidence and the subsequent assessments. The court concluded that the dismissal was not justified, as the evidence did not support the reason given for the termination. The appeal was therefore upheld, and the original dismissal was found to be unfair.
In its final orders, the court set aside the decision of the Deputy President, and remitted the matter back to the Fair Work Commission for further consideration in accordance with the court's findings.