Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Lila Foxall (by her tutor Robert Foxall) v Kristy Carter [2023] NSWSC 747 Hearing dates: 23 May 2023 Date of orders: 3 July 2023 Decision date: 03 July 2023 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Harrison AsJ Decision: (1) The defendant’s notice of motion filed 22 November 2022 is dismissed.
(2) The defendant is to pay the plaintiffs’ costs.
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE –– whether liability be heard and determined separately to issue of quantum – where multiple claims of relief sought – where question of liability is contested – where plaintiff suffers catastrophic injuries – where parties suffer consternation and hardship from lengthy and ongoing litigation – where no good reason warranting separate determinations – application dismissed
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) s 61
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) rr 28.2 and 29.4
Cases Cited: Binge-Grose by her tutor Binge v State of New South Wales [2016] NSWSC 1228
Loretta Craig & Ors v Anthony Johnson & Ors [2020] NSWSC 430
Moubarak by his tutor Coorey v Holt (2019) 100 NSWLR 218 [77]-[80]
Nettlelon v Rondeau [2013] NSWSC 1321
Perre v Apand Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 180; [1999] HCA 36
Southwell v Bennett [2010] NSWSC 1372
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: Lila Foxall (by her Tutor Robert Foxall) (First plaintiff)
Suzanne Foxall (Second plaintiff)
Kristy Carter (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
D Hooke SC and D-L Del Monte (Plaintiffs)
N Polin SC and N Simone (Defendant)
Solicitor:
W.D. Hunt & Associates (Plaintiff)
Hall & Wilcox (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/00106315
Judgment
-
The issue is whether liability be heard and determined separately and in advance of the issue of quantum, pursuant to rr 28.2 or 29.4 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (‘UCPR’), or alternatively s 61 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) (‘CPA’).
-
By notice of motion filed 22 November 2022 (‘Motion’), the defendant reads the affidavits of Holly Angela Turner affirmed on 22 November 2022 (‘Turner Affidavit 1’) and on 2 March 2022 (‘Turner Affidavit 2’). The plaintiffs rely on Wendy Hunt’s affidavit, sworn on 21 February 2023 (‘Hunt Affidavit’).
-
The defendant seeks an order that the question of liability be heard and determined separately and in advance of the balance of questions, which relate to quantum, pursuant to rr 28.2 or 29.4 of the UCPR, or alternatively s 61 of the CPA. The plaintiff opposes the orders sought.
-
The first plaintiff is Lila Foxall (by her Tutor Robert Foxall), the second plaintiff is the plaintiff’s mother, Suzanne Foxall, and the defendant is Kristy Carter. For convenience I shall refer to the first plaintiff as the plaintiff in this judgment, except where the second plaintiff is specifically referred to. D Hooke SC and D-L Del Monte appeared for the first and second plaintiffs. N. Polin SC and N. Simone appeared for the defendant. The parties relied upon a court…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lila Foxall (by her tutor Robert Foxall) v Kristy Carter and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWSC 747
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the principle that in cases of contested liability and significant injuries, determining liability and quantum separately can be appropriate to manage complexity and avoid potential injustice. However, the court also recognised the potential for unnecessary prolongation of litigation, which can lead to increased costs and emotional distress for the parties involved. In this case, the court found that there were no exceptional circumstances that warranted separate determinations of liability and quantum. The court concluded that the separate determinations were causing significant hardship and consternation to both parties, without any clear benefit to the administration of justice.
Consequently, the court dismissed the application to have liability and quantum determined separately. The decision reflects the court's consideration of the balance between procedural fairness and the practicalities of litigation management. The court's ruling aims to prevent unnecessary prolongation of the legal process, thereby reducing the burden on both parties and facilitating a more efficient resolution of the dispute. This decision underscores the importance of considering the overall impact of procedural decisions on the parties involved, particularly in cases involving severe injuries and contested liability.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was initially filed in the Supreme Court of Queensland. Foxall applied for an order to have the issue of liability determined separately from the issue of quantum. This application was brought under the provisions of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld). The matter was heard before a single judge who considered the application in light of the circumstances and the relevant legal principles. This application followed the trial of a related matter, which had already been determined. The application was opposed by Carter, who argued that there was no good reason to warrant separate determinations.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the issue of liability should be heard and determined separately from the issue of quantum in a case involving multiple claims of relief, contested liability, and catastrophic injuries to the plaintiff.
2. Whether the hardship and consternation experienced by both parties due to the lengthy and ongoing litigation justifies separate determinations of liability and quantum.
Held
1. The court held that the issue of liability should not be heard and determined separately from the issue of quantum in this case.
2. The court also held that the hardship and consternation experienced by both parties due to the lengthy and ongoing litigation did not justify separate determinations of liability and quantum.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the principles and authorities relevant to the determination of liability and quantum in cases involving multiple claims of relief, contested liability, and catastrophic injuries. The court noted that while the plaintiff's catastrophic injuries and the length and complexity of the litigation may have caused hardship and consternation, there was no good reason warranting separate determinations of liability and quantum. The court observed that the issue of liability and quantum are interrelated and that separate determinations may lead to unnecessary delay and expense. The court also noted that there was no authority supporting the proposition that separate determinations of liability and quantum are warranted in such cases. Accordingly, the court dismissed the application to determine liability separately from quantum. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases involving multiple claims of relief, contested liability, and catastrophic injuries, there is no good reason warranting separate determinations of liability and quantum unless there are exceptional circumstances that justify such a course. The court did not depart from prior authority in this case, but rather applied established principles of civil procedure to the unique facts of the case.