Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) [2016] AATA 351 (30 May 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2013/3892

Re

Christopher William Lieschke

APPLICANT

And

Telstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President K Bean

Date 30 May 2016
Place Adelaide

The Tribunal:

1.Sets aside the reviewable decision of the respondent dated 16 July 2013;

2.In substitution for that decision determines that Mr Lieschke’s normal weekly earnings (NWE) amount, pursuant to section 8 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act), as at 15 October 2009, was $1,239.11;

3.Remits to the respondent the determination of Mr Lieschke’s subsequent NWE amounts, by reference to the Tribunal’s Reasons for Decision and on the basis that during the relevant period, Mr Lieschke was paid 100.71% of his ‘at risk’ remuneration amount;

4.Reserves liberty to apply within 14 days in relation to the costs of the proceedings; and

5.Orders that in the absence of any such application, the respondent is to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by Mr Lieschke pursuant to subsection 67(8) of the SRC Act.

......... [Sgd] ............................................

Deputy President K Bean

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Normal weekly earnings – Whether period of 2 weeks before date of injury fairly represents weekly rate of payment – Whether ‘at risk’ component of remuneration payable in addition to fixed remuneration – Whether ‘at risk’ component properly regarded as an allowance – Characterisation of payment makes no difference to calculation of normal weekly earnings – Decision under review set aside.

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 8, 9(1)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President K Bean

30 May 2016

  1. In October 2009 the applicant, Mr Lieschke, was employed by Telstra Corporation Limited (the respondent) as a sales consultant when he unfortunately suffered a brain haemorrhage whilst he was at work.  In due course he made a claim for compensation, and liability was ultimately accepted for “subarachnoid haemorrhage due to ruptured left middle cerebral aneurysm and fractured left ankle”.[1]

    [1]     Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, [2].

  2. Since then, the respondent has continued to pay compensation to Mr Lieschke.  However, during 2013, an issue arose as to the basis upon which Mr Lieschke’s weekly compensation payments for incapacity should be calculated.

  3. Following a request for reconsideration by Mr Lieschke, the respondent issued a reconsideration decision on 16 July 2013 varying a number of earlier determinations.[2]  In that reconsideration decision, the delegate determined that the ‘normal weekly earnings’ (NWE) figure used to determine Mr Lieschke’s incapacity entitlements should be determined by reference to the earnings he received in the 12 weeks prior to his compensable injury.[3]  This yielded the result that Mr Lieschke’s NWE as the date of injury were determined to be $971.27.[4]  However, on 9 August 2013, Mr Lieschke lodged an application for review of that decision by this Tribunal, contending that his NWE had not been correctly determined by the respondent and should be higher.

    [2]     Exhibit 1, T51/221.

    [3]     Exhibit 1, T51/225.

    [4]     Exhibit 1, T51/225.

  4. Accordingly,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 351
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Lieschke against a decision by Telstra Corporation Limited regarding the calculation of his normal weekly earnings (NWE) for compensation purposes. The dispute centred on how an "at risk" component of Mr Lieschke's remuneration should be treated in determining his NWE under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (SRC Act). The decision was made by Deputy K Bean P of the Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine whether the period of two weeks preceding the date of injury fairly represented Mr Lieschke's weekly rate of payment, and specifically, how the "at risk" component of his remuneration should be calculated and characterised for the purposes of section 8 of the SRC Act. This involved assessing whether this component should be regarded as an allowance and how its inclusion or exclusion impacted the calculation of his NWE.

The Tribunal reasoned that the characterisation of the "at risk" component as an allowance or otherwise did not alter its fundamental nature for the calculation of NWE. The Tribunal found that Mr Lieschke was paid 100.71% of his "at risk" remuneration during the relevant period. In substitution for Telstra's previous decision, the Tribunal determined that Mr Lieschke's NWE as at 15 October 2009 was $1,239.11. The matter was remitted to Telstra for the determination of subsequent NWE amounts based on this finding.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal:

1. Sets aside the reviewable decision of the respondent dated 16 July 2013;

2. In substitution for that decision determines that Mr Lieschke’s normal weekly earnings (NWE) amount, pursuant to section 8 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act), as at 15 October 2009, was $1,239.11;

3. Remits to the respondent the determination of Mr Lieschke’s subsequent NWE amounts, by reference to the Tribunal’s Reasons for Decision and on the basis that during the relevant period, Mr Lieschke was paid 100.71% of his ‘at risk’ remuneration amount;

4. Reserves liberty to apply within 14 days in relation to the costs of the proceedings; and

5. Orders that in the absence of any such application, the respondent is to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by Mr Lieschke pursuant to subsection 67(8) of the SRC Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over the calculation of Mr Lieschke's normal weekly earnings (NWE) under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) for the purposes of determining his entitlement to compensation. Mr Lieschke was employed by Telstra Corporation Limited and sustained a compensable injury on 15 October 2009. His remuneration included a fixed component and an 'at risk' component, which was contingent upon achieving sales targets. The 'at risk' component was a percentage of Mr Lieschke's fixed remuneration. The dispute arose over the appropriate period to be considered for calculating the NWE and whether the 'at risk' component should be included in its entirety or only a portion of it. Specifically, the issue centred on the two weeks immediately before the injury date and whether this period fairly represented Mr Lieschke's weekly earnings.

The matter was brought before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for review of a decision made by Telstra Corporation Limited (the respondent) on 16 July 2013. The Tribunal was tasked with determining Mr Lieschke's NWE as at 15 October 2009 and subsequently reviewing the respondent's decision. Mr Lieschke, represented by counsel, argued that the Tribunal should consider a different period for calculating his NWE and that the 'at risk' component of his remuneration should be fully accounted for. The Tribunal heard submissions from both parties and considered relevant documentary evidence before making its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I note that at the hearing, Mr Wallace foreshadowed a possible application by the respondent in respect of costs. However, he accepted that it would be appropriate for the Tribunal to make the usual order as to costs, reserving liberty to the respondent to apply for any different order to be made. I will therefore make an order in those terms.DECISION The Tribunal:(1)Sets aside the reviewable decision of the respondent dated 16 July 2013;(2)In substitution for that decision determines that Mr Lieschke’s NWE amount, pursuant to s 8 of the SRC Act, as at 15 October 2009, was $1,239.11;(3)Remits to the respondent the determination of Mr Lieschke’s subsequent NWE amounts, by reference to the Tribunal’s Reasons for Decision and on the basis that during the relevant period, Mr Lieschke was paid 100.71% of his ‘at risk’ remuneration amount;(4)Reserves liberty to apply within 14 days in relation to the costs of the proceedings; and(5)Orders that in the absence of any such application, the respondent is to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by Mr Lieschke pursuant to subs 67(8) of the SRC Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I will first address the question of how much of the ‘at risk’ component of his salary was payable to Mr Lieschke with respect to the relevant period, before turning to how this should be characterised for the purposes of s 8.How much of the ‘at risk’ component of his remuneration was payable to Mr Lieschke with respect to the relevant period?Applicant’s contentions Mr Cole, who appeared as counsel for Mr Lieschke at the hearing, urged me to conclude that Mr Lieschke was paid an amount of approximately $453.00 of the ‘at risk’ component of his remuneration during the first 2 weeks of October 2009. Mr Cole explained the steps taken to arrive at that amount as follows. Mr Cole noted that Mr Lieschke’s overall remuneration amount was inclusive of superannuation.[6] Taking the amount of $4,885.40, which is the actual amount of superannuation paid to Mr Lieschke[7] from the fixed remuneration amount gave a figure of $54,281.60.[8] Accordingly, for compensation purposes, the ‘at risk’ component of Mr Lieschke’s remuneration was 20% of that fixed remuneration figure, which was $10,856.32.[6] Exhibit 1, T52/230.[7] See Exhibit 1, T51/226 and Exhibit 2, ST4/314. Mr Lieschke’s payslip indicates he was paid $187.90 per fortnight, which equates to $4,885.40 over the year.[8] See Chun v Comcare (2013) 209 FCR 39. As to the amount, see Exhibit 1, T51/226 – in his oral submissions, Mr Cole rounded up these amounts. Mr Cole also contended that Mr Lieschke would have been paid 100% of the ‘at risk’ component if he had achieved or had been deemed to achieve his sales targets for October 2009. Mr Cole submitted that dividing $10,856.32 by 12 gave a monthly ‘at risk’ remuneration amount of $904.69, being 1/12th of 20% of $54,281.60. Mr Cole further relied upon a payslip apparently recording a payment to Mr Lieschke for the pay period ending 25 November 2009 of $907.44 in respect of sales ‘commission’ paid for October 2009.[9] Mr Cole further contended that based upon the oral and documentary evidence, Mr Lieschke was paid 100% of his ‘at risk’ component for the last 2 weeks of October, when he was absent from work due to his compensable injury, presumably on sick leave.[10][9] Exhibit 1, T49/215.[10] Compensation liability was not accepted until 28 January 2010. Mr Cole reasoned that as the overall monthly figure paid to Mr Lieschke was higher than that which would have been paid if Mr Lieschke had achieved 100% of his sales targets, or been deemed to have achieved 100% for the month, it followed that Mr Lieschke must have exceeded his sales targets for the first half of October when he was at work. Mr Cole also noted that Mr Lieschke was in fact absent on carer’s leave for 1 day of the first 2 weeks of October, namely 13 October, for which he was also deemed to have met 100% of his sales targets.[11] Therefore, in order to be paid more than 100% of his ‘at risk’ remuneration for October 2009, it followed that he must have exceeded his sales targets whilst he was at work, otherwise he would not have been paid more than 100% of his ‘at risk’ remuneration for October.[11] Exhibit 5, Annexure 1.