Destro and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) [2018] AATA 4278 (16 November 2018)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s): 2015/4073
Re:John Destro
APPLICANT
AndTelstra Corporation Limited
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President P Britten-Jones
Date:16 November 2018
Place:Adelaide
The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision dated 20 July 2015.
The matter is remitted to the respondent to quantify the applicant’s entitlements to weekly payments for the period 3 May 2010 to 30 June 2013 in accordance with and in light of these reasons for decision.
The Tribunal further orders the respondent to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by Mr Destro pursuant to section 67(9) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.
................................[SGD]........................................
Deputy President P Britten-Jones
CATCHWORDS
WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – NWE and AE amounts – Whether AE amount should be actual weekly earnings or average earnings per week – Whether AE amount should deduct GST or expenses – Whether applicant failed to seek suitable employment – Decision under review set aside and remitted.
LEGISLATION
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 4, 8, 9, 14, 19, 21
CASES
Watson and Comcare
Jagtenberg and Australian Postal Corporation
Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Ltd
KCZH and Comcare [2009] AATA 861
Fleming and Comcare [2011] AATA 939
Comcare v Wuth [2018] FCAFC 13
Comcare v Davies [2008] FCA 393
Comcare v Line [2002] FCA 553
Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (NT)
Cooper Brookes (Wollongong) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1981) 147 CLR 297
Brennan v Comcare(1994) 50 FCR 555
Comcare v Pires[2005] FCA 747; (2005) 143 FCR 104
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President P Britten-Jones
16 November 2018
The primary issue in dispute in this matter is one of statutory construction. Specifically, the issue is whether, when calculating an applicant’s entitlement to weekly incapacity payments, an applicant’s AE amount (AE) under s 19(2)(a) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) should be:
-the actual amount earned by the applicant in that week; or
-an average of what the applicant has earned per week over a relevant period.
This discrete issue (the Averaging Issue) arises in the following circumstances.
BACKGROUND
Mr John Destro, the applicant, was employed by the respondent on 5 July 1976. On 25 January 2001, the applicant sustained an injury described as a “right knee strain”. On 5 February 2001, the respondent accepted liability under s 14 of the SRC Act.
On 1 October 2003, the respondent terminated the applicant’s employment. As a result of that termination, the applicant received a lump sum benefit under a superannuation scheme. The applicant has since been self-employed, working irregular hours.
The applicant has over the years applied for weekly incapacity payments pursuant to the SRC Act.
On 2 September 2013, a delegate of the respondent determined that it was not presently liable to pay compensation for incapacity for work…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Destro and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] AATA 4278
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the "AE" (actual earnings) amount should be calculated by reference to actual weekly earnings or an averaging process, and whether this amount should be reduced by Goods and Services Tax (GST) and other expenses. Additionally, the Tribunal was required to consider whether Mr Destro had failed to seek suitable alternative employment.
The Tribunal determined that, as a matter of law, the AE amount should be actual earnings less GST and expenses. However, the parties agreed that due to practical difficulties in proving expenses, the AE should be calculated based on the amounts specified in invoices, excluding GST, effectively assuming expenses were nil. The Tribunal also noted that the reconsideration officer had used inaccurate normal weekly earnings (NWE) figures and that there was insufficient evidence to determine the number of hours worked or to calculate the relevant adjustment percentage under s 19(3) of the SRC Act, or to determine certain components required for calculation under s 21 of the SRC Act.
Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the reviewable decision and remitted the matter to the respondent for reconsideration. This reconsideration is to include the quantification of Mr Destro's entitlements to weekly payments for the specified period, taking into account the agreed approach to AE calculations and the determination of various statutory components. The respondent was also ordered to pay Mr Destro's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In calculating Mr Destro’s AE, the primary delegate did not deduct GST or expenses from Mr Destro’s actual earnings. On reconsideration, GST was deducted but as the available evidence could not quantify any expenses incurred, Mr Destro’s expenses were assumed to be nil. The parties are in agreement and I am satisfied that as a matter of law, AE should be actual earnings less GST and less expenses. However, the applicant conceded that due to the practical difficulties with proving expenses, the Tribunal should find that Mr Destro’s actual earnings were the amounts specified in the invoices, not including GST. In essence, the applicant asked the Tribunal to assume that expenses were nil. The respondent agreed with that approach and I accordingly adopt the approach urged by the parties.Matters to be remitted for reconsideration The parties are also in agreement that ultimately the decision under review should be set aside and remitted to the respondent for reconsideration for a number of reasons, namely:-the reconsideration officer used inaccurate NWE figures;-there is insufficient evidence for the Tribunal to determine the number of hours worked by Mr Destro in a particular week, and therefore it is impossible to calculate the relevant adjustment percentage under s 19(3) of the SRC Act, which is a necessary component in the calculation of Mr Destro’s entitlements; and-there is insufficient evidence for the Tribunal to determine the lump sum, the weekly interest rate and the “SC” amount for the purposes of s 21 of the SRC Act.ISSUES IN DISPUTE The parties are, however, not in agreement as to all of the issues that need to be remitted. In addition to the Averaging Issue, the parties are not in agreement as to whether the applicant’s AE figure should incorporate a determination of what the applicant was able to earn in other suitable employment (the Suitable Employment issue). I will first address the Averaging Issue.The Averaging Issue: should the “AE” figure under s 19 of the SRC Act be calculated by reference to actual weekly earnings or by an averaging process? Both parties acknowledged that there were no or very few case authorities directly on the Averaging Issue. By and large, the submissions of both parties came down to first principles of statutory interpretation. Counsel for the applicant, Mr Warren, referred to the use of the phrase “during that week” in s 19 as support that the calculation of AE under s 19 does not contemplate the use of any averaging process. This is in contrast to other provisions in the SRC Act that clearly contemplate the use of an averaging process. For instance, Mr Warren referred me to the definition of normal weekly hours in s 4: "normal weekly hours" , in relation to an employee, means the average number of hours (including hours of overtime) worked in each week by the employee in his or her employment during the relevant period as calculated for the purpose of applying the formula in subsection 8(1) or (2).