LEVET and LEVET & DALLA (Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

LEVET AND LEVET & DALLA (Appeal) [2013] ACAT 52

AA 13/16

Catchwords:             APPEAL -  unit title property – principles of appeal – whether appeal tribunal should disturb findings of fact of the member hearing the matter – consideration of comments from the Supreme Court – unit title holders in dispute – whether damages payable in actions under the Unit Titles Act 2001 limited by part 4 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 –whether damage should be apportioned over a period of time - admission of further evidence after hearing appealed against – whether there was reasonable apprehension of bias in appeal tribunal members

List of Legislation:     ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, ss 16, 17, 18, 82 and 86, and part 4

Civil Law (Sale of Residential Property) Act 2003, s 9

Unit Titles Act 2001, ss 18, 123 and 125

List of Cases:            Amanda Levet and Bruce Levet v. Moira Dalla  [2012] ACTSC 23

Belgrove v. Eldridge [1954] HCA 36

Farah Constructions Pty Ltd v. Say-Dee Pty Ltd
 
[2007] HCA 22

Garry O'Donnell v. Environment Protection Authority [2012] ACTSC140

Levet and Levet & Dalla and the owners Corporation of units plan 2165 [2011] ACAT 20

Maloney v. New South Wales National Coursing Association Ltd [1978] 1 NSWLR 161

Stollery v. The Greyhound Racing Control Board [1972] 128 CLR 509

Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v. Bowen InvestmentsPty Ltd [2009] HCA 8

Yared v. Glenhurst Gardens [2012] NSWSC 11

List of Texts/Papers: JRS Forbes, Justice in Tribunals, The Federation Press, 3rd edition 2010

Appeal Tribunal:                 Mr W.G Stefaniak – Appeal President
  Mr C. G Chenoweth – Senior Member

Date of Orders:  1 August 2013

Date of Reasons for Decision:         1 August 2013

Amended Reasons for Decision:     6 August 2013

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          

BETWEEN:

AMANDA LEVET AND

BRUCE LEVET

Appellant

AND:

MOIRA DALLA

Respondent

APPEAL TRIBUNAL:        Mr W.G Stefaniak – Appeal President
  Mr C.G Chenoweth – Senior Member

DATE:  1 August 2013

ORDER

The decision of the tribunal of 22 February 2013 is confirmed.

………………………………..

W.G Stefaniak – Appeal President

For and on behalf of the Appeal Tribunal

AMENDED REASONS FOR DECISION

Background.

  1. This is an appeal against the order of Senior Member Anforth in proceedings number XT 915 of 2010. The order was dated 22 February 2013. The order was that the appellants were to pay to the respondent the sum of $12,287 within 28 days of the date of the order. There were no other or residual obligations on the appellants as a result of the order, other than the payment of money.

  2. The matter has had an extensive history in the tribunal and before the Master of the Supreme Court. The appellants commenced proceedings against the respondent on 29 June 2010. The respondent filed a cross-claim on 23 August 2010. On 21 September 2010, the appellants filed an amended application that joined the owners corporation as second respondent.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LEVET and LEVET & DALLA (Appeal) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ACAT 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants, Amanda Levet and Bruce Levet, sought leave to appeal from the decision of the appeal tribunal, which had dismissed their appeal from an order made by a senior member of the tribunal. The matter was heard by Master Harper, who dismissed the application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court and ordered that the appellants pay the respondent's costs. The appellants now sought to appeal to the Supreme Court from the Master's decision, which is reported as Amanda Levet and Bruce Levet v. Moira Dalla [2012] ACTSC 23. The appeal tribunal had considered two issues that had not been raised at first instance, but the Master dismissed them as not warranting leave to appeal.

The court was required to decide whether the appellants were entitled to leave to appeal to the Supreme Court from the Master's decision. The appeal tribunal had already considered two issues that had been raised on appeal, but not at first instance. One related to the effect of section 18 (2) of the Unit Titles Act. The appeal tribunal had rejected that submission and it was not pursued in the draft notice of appeal to the Supreme Court being considered by the Master. The other issue was as to the jurisdiction of the tribunal where the amount at issue exceeded $10,000. The Master noted that the appeal tribunal had correctly rejected the argument and it was not pursued in the proposed appeal to the Supreme Court. The Master had dismissed the application for leave to appeal on the basis that it was not a case in which leave to appeal to the Supreme Court should be granted.

The court considered the Master's decision and the arguments put forward by the appellants. The court found that the Master had given sufficient reasons for rejecting the appeal and that the appellants had not demonstrated that there were any grounds for the Supreme Court to grant leave to appeal. The court confirmed the decision of the tribunal of 22 February 2013, dismissing the appellants' appeal and ordering that they pay the respondent's costs.

The court dismissed the appeal and confirmed the decision of the tribunal of 22 February 2013. The appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs. The appeal tribunal had correctly rejected the arguments put forward by the appellants, and the Master had given sufficient reasons for dismissing the application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. The court found no grounds for the Supreme Court to grant leave to appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision of the tribunal of 22 February 2013 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellants applied for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court from the appeal tribunal's decision. Section 86 of the ACAT Act provides that a party to an application may appeal to the Supreme Court on a question of fact or law from a decision of the appeal tribunal. However, the appeal may only be brought with the Court’s leave. The leave application was heard before Master Harper. On 10 February 2012, he made an order dismissing the application for leave and ordering that the applicants pay the respondent’s costs. The decision of the Master is reported as Amanda Levet and Bruce Levet v. Moira Dalla [2012] ACTSC 23. It is referred to in these reasons as "the Master’s decision." It is not necessary to set out in detail the reasons that the Master gave for rejecting the appeal, but he noted that Senior Member Anforth in reaching the decision in Anforth one had found as a fact that damage to the garage walls had been caused by water seepage from a buildup of soil abutting the exterior side of the wall, and made the same finding in relation to the log retaining wall on the boundary between the properties. Senior Member Anforth noted that the use of the garage wall as a retaining wall was entirely for the benefit of the appellants with no corresponding benefit to the respondent[4].[4] Master’s decision – paragraphs 12 and 13 The Master determined that this was not a case in which leave to appeal to the Supreme Court should be granted for the reasons set out in the decision[5]. The matter then returned to Senior Member Anforth for determination of the compensation and the timing for compliance in accordance with the original order made by him as varied by the appeal tribunal.[5] Master’s decision – paragraphs 47 and 48 In the proceedings on this appeal to the Master no transcript of the application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was available to the appeal tribunal, nor was a copy of the application itself filed with the tribunal. In this appeal hearing, Mr Levet indicated that he had not been present at the application for leave proceedings, and was therefore unable to advise the tribunal on the arguments that counsel had raised[6]. Accordingly, this tribunal is left with only the reasoning of the Master for rejecting the application.[6] Transcript dated 15 May 2013 – page 24, line 40; paragraph 27 line 3 The Master noted that the appeal tribunal had dealt in its reasons with two other issues which had been raised on appeal, but apparently not at first instance. One related to the effect of section 18 (2) of the Unit Titles Act. The appeal tribunal had rejected that submission and it was not pursued in the draft notice of appeal to the Supreme Court being considered by the Master[7].[7] Master’s decision – paragraph 25 The other issue was as to the jurisdiction of the tribunal where the amount at issue exceeded $10,000. In relation to that the Master in paragraph 26 said as follows:"The other issue was as to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal where the amount at issue exceeded $10,000. The jurisdiction of the Tribunal in relation to civil disputes under part 4 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act is limited to that figure. Effectively what was the small claims jurisdiction of the Magistrates Court has been removed from the court and conferred on the Tribunal. Part 4 has no application to applications to the Tribunal in the exercise of jurisdiction conferred by other legislation, such as, in the present case, the Unit Titles Act. The appeals tribunal correctly rejected the argument and it is not pursued in the proposed appeal to this court.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.