LEON ZWIER and and AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

[2012] AATA 52

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2010/1053

2010/1265

Re

LEON ZWIER

APPLICANT

And

COMMONWEALTH DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

RESPONDENT

And

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

JOINED PARTY

File Number(s)

2010/1252

Re

LEON ZWIER

APPLICANT

And

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr John Handley, Senior Member

Date 1 February 2012
Place Melbourne

1.The decisions of the Respondents in each application opposing the applications to either waive or displace legal professional privilege (LPP) are affirmed.

2.The decisions under review in applications 2010/1252 and 2010/1053 are affirmed.

3.The following documents in application 2010/1265 are not privileged from production on the basis of LPP and the Applicant is entitled to have a copy of:

a)the email of Ms Thompson of 10 October 2008 and the attachment to it comprising document 32;

b)the list of documents dated 3 October 2008 attached to the email of 6 October 2008 found at document 63; and

c)          page 2 of the document found at document 99.

In all other respects, the decision in 2010/1265 is affirmed.

.............................[sgd]...............................

Mr John Handley, Senior Member

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION – civil proceedings between ACCC and another resolved by consent before the Federal Court – terms of settlement included an agreement of facts stated as not being an admission outside the context of the civil proceedings – terms read to the Court by counsel for the ACCC and read by the presiding Judge – terms recited in published reasons – CDPP later commenced criminal proceedings – the agreement was identified in the Prosecutor's Case Statement and filed with the brief of evidence in the Federal Court – decision by Federal Court that the agreement was not an admission for the purposes of the prosecution but cross-examination over it would be permitted – whether conduct of the Respondents constituted a) a breach of express or implied undertakings not to use the agreement b) improper purpose or illegal object c) contempt of the Federal Court – whether documents exempt and privileged from production on the ground of legal professional privilege (LPP) or irrelevance – whether LPP displaced by Respondents' conduct including displacement on grounds of public interest.

LEGISLATION

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 131, 191

Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) ss 22, 42(1)

CASES

Attorney-General for the Northern Territory v Maurice and Others (1986) 161 CLR 475

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pratt (N° 3) (2009) 175 FCR 558

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Visy Industries Holdings Pty Ltd and Others (N° 3) (2007) 244 ALR 673

AWB Ltd v Cole and Another (N° 5) (2006) 155 FCR 30

Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) v Pratt Holdings Pty Ltd and Another (2005) 225 ALR 266

Esso Australia Resources Limited v Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia   (1999) 201 CLR 49

Mann v Carnell (1999) 201 CLR 1

O’Reilly and Others v The Commissioners of the State Bank of Victoria and Others (1983) 153 CLR 1

Osland v Secretary, Department of Justice (2010) 241 CLR 320

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LEON ZWIER and and AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMI... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Leon Zwier sought documents held by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP) and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) (FOI Act). The CDPP and ACCC refused to release certain documents, claiming they were privileged and exempt under s 42(1) of the FOI Act or irrelevant and exempt under s 22 of the FOI Act. The case involved significant controversy regarding the actions of Visy and Amcor, who had engaged in a price fixing and market sharing arrangement in the corrugated fibreboard packaging market. The dispute centred on whether certain documents were exempt from disclosure under the FOI Act, specifically under s 42(1) and s 22.

The legal issues the court needed to decide included whether certain documents were privileged communications protected by legal professional privilege (LPP) and therefore exempt from disclosure under s 42(1) of the FOI Act, and whether other documents were irrelevant and exempt under s 22 of the FOI Act. The court also had to determine if any documents were exempt from disclosure due to reasons other than LPP or irrelevance.

The court found that some of the documents were protected by legal professional privilege and therefore exempt from disclosure under s 42(1) of the FOI Act. However, the court ruled that certain documents were not privileged and should be disclosed to the Applicant. Specifically, the court allowed the disclosure of an email from Ms Thompson dated 10 October 2008 and its attachment, a list of documents dated 3 October 2008, and page 2 of a particular document. The court affirmed the decisions of the Respondents in the other applications, maintaining that the documents were exempt from disclosure either under s 42(1) or s 22 of the FOI Act.

ORDERS:
The court affirmed the decisions under review in applications 2010/1252 and 2010/1053. In application 2010/1265, the court allowed the disclosure of specific documents identified in the judgment. In all other respects, the decision in application 2010/1265 was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Reason

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant sought to obtain documents held by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP) and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) (the FOI Act). The CDPP and ACCC, the Respondents, prepared a schedule of the documents sought in each application which is reproduced later. Some documents have been released. However, the Respondents have refused to release other documents on the basis that they are privileged and therefore exempt pursuant to s 42(1) of the FOI Act or irrelevant and exempt under s 22 of the FOI Act. In order to comprehend the parties' position, a brief overview of the proceedings against Mr Pratt is necessary. BACKGROUND The proceedings instituted against Mr Pratt were the subject of considerable publicity between 2007 and 2009. The summary which follows is taken from the history recorded by Ryan J in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pratt (N° 3) (2009) 175 FCR 558; Heerey J in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Visy Industries Holdings Pty Ltd and Others (N° 3) (2007) 244 ALR 673; the submissions of Mr Hanks QC who appeared with Mr Gray at the hearing of these applications and the Applicant who initially appeared alone but was represented later by Mr Clelland SC. Between January 2000 and October 2004 a number of officers within the Visy group of companies (Visy Board Pty Ltd, Visy Industries Holdings Pty Ltd and Visy Industries Australia Pty Ltd) (Visy) and officers of Amcor Limited (Amcor) were engaged in a price fixing and market sharing arrangement with respect to the supply of corrugated fibreboard packaging products in Australia. Visy and Amcor supplied over 90 per cent of that market. In November 2004, Russell Jones, the former Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer of Amcor approached the ACCC for immunity from prosecution for his involvement in the price fixing cartel which had operated between Visy and Amcor. The ACCC then had a policy of leniency where it would grant immunity from prosecution provided that there was full disclosure of known cartel arrangements and cooperation with the ACCC in its investigations and any subsequent prosecution of other parties. As a result of its investigation, the ACCC learnt that from early 2000, Visy and Amcor mutually agreed to increase their prices for their respective customers and also had mutual agreements concerning the prices to be charged for particular customers. Significantly, Visy and Amcor agreed that they would not deal with each other's customers but in the event that one customer decided to change supplier, the company benefiting would agree to compensate the other by a type of customer swapping arrangement. The process was described by Heerey J at [7] in the following terms:...If, say, Amcor customer X decided to switch to Visy, Amcor and Visy would get together and decide on a Visy customer, say Y, who would be provided to Amcor as "compensation" for the loss of X. When Y's contract came up for renegotiation, Visy and Amcor would exchange details of proposed prices and other terms so as to ensure that the deal offered to Y by Visy was much less attractive than Amcor's. Y would then, as Visy and Amcor intended, accept Amcor's offer.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Paragraph 77 of the Affidavit of Mr Pedley identifies the annotations as having been made by counsel retained by the CDPP on the instructions of the ACCC. The annotations must be regarded as notes or thoughts or comments made by counsel for the purposes of the prosecution and/or the giving of advice to the client. The annotations on pages 1 and 3 must be regarded as professional and confidential communications which exempts those pages from release pursuant to s 42. However, there are no annotations made on page 2 of the document and it could not be the subject of s 42 or any other prohibition against release. However, it is a document which has been prepared by the defendant’s solicitors and no doubt it retains a copy of it. DECISION For the reasons given earlier, the decisions of the Respondents in each application opposing the applications to either waive or displace LPP are affirmed. Having inspected the documents identified by each schedule, I am satisfied, save for the documents recorded below, that all are exempt from production in these proceedings on the ground of LPP pursuant to s 42 or irrelevance pursuant to s 22. The decisions under review in applications 2010/1252 and 2010/1053 are affirmed. The following documents in application 2010/1265 are not privileged from production on the basis of LPP and the Applicant is entitled to have a copy of: (i)the email of Ms Thompson of 10 October 2008 and the attachment to it comprising document 32;(ii)the list of documents dated 3 October 2008 attached to the email of 6 October 2008 found at document 63; and(iii)page 2 of the document found at document 99.In all other respects, the decision in 2010/1265 is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established