Lennard v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  No.  1813 of 1992
[Lennard v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) P/L]

BETWEEN:

KEVIN FRANCIS LENNARD
  Plaintiff

AND:

ANSETT TRANSPORT INDUSTRIES (OPERATIONS) PTY LTD
  Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  -  THOMAS J.

Delivered:28 August 1997

CATCHWORDS:     NEGLIGENCE - Occupier’s liability - Plaintiff pushed off left-hand side of jetty - Jetty only had railing on right-hand side - - Quantum - 20%-25% disability of right lower leg.

Counsel:Mr J. Griffin QC, with him Mr G. Thompson for the Plaintiff

Mr D. North SC for the Defendant

Solicitors:Bennett & Philp for the Plaintiff

Drake Walker & Leahy for the Defendant

Hearing date:               18-19 August 1997

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  No.  1813 of 1992
[Lennard v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) P/L]

BETWEEN:

KEVIN FRANCIS LENNARD
  Plaintiff

AND:

ANSETT TRANSPORT INDUSTRIES (OPERATIONS) PTY LTD
  Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  -  THOMAS J

Judgment delivered 28 August 1997

On 5 January 1990 the plaintiff, then a 23 year old telecommunications rigger in the air force, was holidaying in the Airlie Beach area.  He took an evening excursion to South Molle Island with his companion, Mr Sharp.  Such an excursion entailed leaving the mainland by ferry from Shute Harbour on the vessel Capricorn, disembarking on the jetty at South Molle Island between 6.30 p.m. and 7 p.m., walking to the resort, having dinner and drinks, and attending a function which on this particular occasion was called a Polynesian Floor-dance.  At 11.10 p.m. the excursion visitors were warned that the vessel would be leaving at 11.30 p.m. from the jetty.  In the ordinary course such a visitor would walk back to the jetty, walk along it to the head of the jetty, reembark upon the Capricorn and return to the mainland.

The jetty in question is quite long, probably about 170 metres.  As one proceeds from its abutment to the land towards the sea, there is a fence along the right-hand edge but not along the left.  I shall refer to the side of the jetty which contains the handrail as the right-hand side of the jetty.  The right-hand handrail is about 4'10" high and of solid timber construction apparently designed to withstand a force in the vicinity of 110 kg.  The head of the jetty is quite wide, giving the jetty a T-shape. The fence terminates where the head of the jetty commences.  The head, which is the area where passengers embark and disembark from vessels, is unfenced.

The head of the jetty is in relatively deep water, but the sea bed rises fairly quickly, and for a considerable distance over the mid-section of the jetty the water is quite shallow, and for a considerable distance from the abutment there is no water at all.  The surface beneath the jetty for many metres from the abutment consists mainly of rocks.  If one proceeded from the abutment the drop from the surface of the jetty to the ground below increases.  By the time one reached the third…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lennard v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QSC 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lennard v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) P/L involved a dispute between Kevin Francis Lennard, the plaintiff, and Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) P/L, the defendant. The plaintiff alleged that he was injured while disembarking from a ferry on a jetty operated by the defendant. The central issue in the case was whether the defendant was negligent in failing to provide adequate safety measures on the jetty, which led to the plaintiff's injuries. Specifically, the court had to determine if the absence of a fence on the left-hand side of the jetty, where the plaintiff fell, constituted negligence on the part of the defendant.

The court held that the defendant was indeed negligent in not providing a fence on the left-hand side of the jetty. The reasoning was that it was reasonably foreseeable that patrons would be using the jetty late at night, potentially under the influence of alcohol, and that such circumstances could lead to falls from the unfenced side of the jetty. The court emphasized that the installation of a fence would not have been difficult or particularly expensive, and it would have significantly reduced the risk of injury. The court also noted that while the exact manner of the plaintiff's fall was not foreseeable, the general risk of falling from an unprotected jetty was.

Regarding damages, the court assessed the plaintiff's disability at between 20% and 25% of the use of his right lower limb, resulting in significant long-term impacts on his physical capabilities and employment opportunities. The court awarded compensation for pain, suffering, and loss of amenities, past and future economic loss, and special damages. The total awarded was $202,127.41. This comprehensive sum took into account the plaintiff's diminished earning capacity, the impact on his lifestyle, and the medical expenses incurred as a result of the accident.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 5 January 1990, the plaintiff, a 23-year-old telecommunications rigger in the Air Force, was holidaying in the Airlie Beach area. He took an evening excursion to South Molle Island with his companion, Mr Sharp. The excursion involved leaving the mainland by ferry from Shute Harbour on the vessel Capricorn, disembarking on the jetty at South Molle Island, walking to the resort, having dinner and drinks, and attending a function. At 11.10 p.m., the excursion visitors were warned that the vessel would be leaving at 11.30 p.m. from the jetty. The jetty in question is approximately 170 metres long, with a fence along the right-hand edge but not along the left. The right-hand handrail is about 4'10" high and of solid timber construction, designed to withstand a force in the vicinity of 110 kg. The head of the jetty, where passengers embark and disembark from vessels, is unfenced. The plaintiff and his companion were walking back to the vessel when a group of four young men approached them. Two other young men brushed shoulders with one of the men in the front group, leading to an exchange of abuse. The short-haired man aimed a karate kick at the plaintiff's head, which the plaintiff blocked. However, the short-haired man then took hold of the plaintiff from behind and pushed him off the side of the jetty. The plaintiff fell onto the ground and rocks below, taking the main impact on his right leg. He also suffered a laceration to the chest and a nick to the head.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Queensland for a final hearing on 18-19 August 1997. The plaintiff, Kevin Francis Lennard, sought damages against the defendant, Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd, for injuries sustained as a result of being pushed off the jetty. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant was negligent in failing to erect a fence on the left-hand side of the jetty, which would have prevented the accident. The defendant denied the allegations of negligence and argued that the plaintiff's injuries were caused by the intentional act of a third party, which broke the chain of causation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendant was negligent in failing to erect a fence on the left-hand side of the jetty.
2. If the defendant was found to be negligent, whether the plaintiff's injuries were a direct result of that negligence or if the intentional act of a third party broke the chain of causation.

Held
1. The court held that the defendant was negligent in failing to erect a fence on the left-hand side of the jetty, as it was reasonably foreseeable that patrons would be leaving the island late at night and there was a strong possibility that such people might be intoxicated. The court found that the erection of a fence would have been a simple precaution that could have been taken without significant expense.
2. The court held that the plaintiff's injuries were a direct result of the defendant's negligence, as the intentional act of the third party did not break the chain of causation. The court found that had a fence similar to that on the other side of the wharf been provided, the accident probably would not have happened.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the foreseeability of risks associated with the jetty, such as the potential for large groups of people hurrying to catch the boat back to the mainland, the prospect of jostling, and even of relatively bizarre conduct by persons present. The court held that the duty owed by an occupier to an entrant is to take reasonable care to prevent injury to entrants from risks that are reasonably foreseeable. The court found that the defendant's failure to erect a fence along the left-hand side of the jetty, similar to that on the right-hand side, constituted a breach of this duty.

In considering whether the intentional act of the third party broke the chain of causation, the court noted that if a fall from an unprotected and much-used structure is foreseeable, the fact that the precise way in which the fall happened might not be reasonably foreseeable does not matter. The court found that had a fence been provided, the plaintiff's falling from the jetty to the rocks thirteen feet below probably would not have happened. The court concluded that the existence of a fence would have substantially eliminated the risk to which the plaintiff was subjected.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an occupier has a duty to take reasonable care to prevent injury to entrants from risks that are reasonably foreseeable, and that the intentional act of a third party does not necessarily break the chain of causation if the risk of injury was foreseeable. The court found that the defendant was negligent in failing to erect a fence on the left-hand side of the jetty, and that this negligence was a cause of the plaintiff's injury.