Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v A PRACTITIONER (No 2)

[2017] SASC 93

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

23 June 2017

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS

PROCEDURE - COURTS AND JUDGES GENERALLY - COURTS - PROCEEDINGS IN OPEN COURT OR IN CAMERA

This Court refused an application by the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner for an interim order suspending the practitioner’s practising certificate pending the outcome of disciplinary proceedings. The judgment was published to the parties in open court with an unredacted title.

The practitioner made an oral application for an order that any electronic publication of the judgment refer to him as ‘A Practitioner’ rather than by name.

Whether there is any practice or custom to redact the name of a practitioner in a judgment where legal practitioner disciplinary proceedings are involved – Whether the Court should exercise the discretion to redact the name of the practitioner where the proceedings are of an interlocutory nature.

HELD: Allowing the application

1.  It is within the discretion of a judge of this Court to publish a judgment, in a matter in which a legal practitioner is a party, with the name of a practitioner redacted. However there is no practice or custom to the effect that in matters involving legal practitioner disciplinary proceedings the name of the practitioner will be redacted.

2.  When considering whether or not to redact the name of a practitioner, relevant considerations will include: whether the publication of a judgment in unredacted form might unfairly and unnecessarily cause prejudice, whether the proceedings are for interlocutory or final relief and the desirability of clients of the practitioner and the public to be informed of matters relevant to the disciplinary proceedings.

3.  Where there are as yet no findings of unprofessional conduct nor an adverse final determination made against the practitioner, and there is no evidence of any ongoing risk of harm to clients of the practitioner or the public, it is appropriate that the Court exercise its discretion to redact the name of the practitioner.

Evidence Act 1929 s 69A; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 r 9, r 236; Legal Practitioners Act 1989 s 89C; Supreme Court Act 1935 s 131, referred to.
Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner [2017] SASC 81; J v D Pty Ltd & Ors [2010] SASC 318; Re Legal Practitioners Ordinance 1970; Ex parte Law Society of the Australian Capital Territory; Re Giles (1985) 61 ACTR 1, considered.

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v A PRACTITIONER (No 2)
[2017] SASC 93

Civil: Application

NICHOLSON J.

Introduction

  1. In my principal judgment in this matter,[1] I refused an application by the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner for an order suspending the respondent practitioner’s practising certificate on an interim basis and pending the outcome of disciplinary proceedings that have been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner (No 2... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASC 93
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a legal practitioner who was subject to disciplinary proceedings by the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner. The practitioner sought to have the judgment published with their name redacted and replaced with the term "A Practitioner." The Commissioner did not object to the judgment being electronically published but sought to challenge the practitioner’s proposition that, in cases like this, the name is customarily replaced with "A Practitioner." The Supreme Court of South Australia was tasked with determining whether the practitioner's name should be redacted from the published judgment and if the term "A Practitioner" should be used instead.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the name of the practitioner should be redacted from the published judgment and if the term "A Practitioner" should be used in place of the practitioner's name. The court had to consider the discretion under Rule 236 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 regarding the publication of reasons for judgment and whether there was a custom or practice to use "A Practitioner" in legal practitioner disciplinary proceedings.

The court found that while it was within the judge's discretion to redact the practitioner's name, there was no practice or custom of employing the term "A Practitioner" in such cases. The court noted that the naming of matters and the form in which judgments are published would be decided on a case-by-case basis, considering different considerations at various stages of the proceedings. The court concluded that publishing the judgment naming the practitioner might be unfairly prejudicial at that stage, given considerations such as the practitioner’s health and practice. Therefore, it was appropriate to redact the practitioner's name from the judgment.

The court ordered that the practitioner's name be redacted from the published judgment, and the term "A Practitioner" would not be used. The judgment would be published in a form that sufficiently served its purpose as a legal authority and precedent without identifying the practitioner.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

During submissions, the Commissioner indicated that he did not object to the judgment being electronically published in the manner sought by the practitioner. However, he wished to be heard on the matter generally so as to assist the Court as to the relevant considerations and also in order to challenge a proposition initially put by the practitioner that, in cases such as the present one, ‘customarily the name is replaced in the citation by the designation A Practitioner’. Background The proceedings in this matter were conducted in open court[2] and the judgment, with an unredacted title, was published to the parties in open court. There has been no application for a suppression order pursuant to section 69A of the Evidence Act 1929 or the Court’s inherent jurisdiction.[2] No application was made pursuant to rule 9(2)(b) of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 for a private hearing. Typically, a copy of a judgment of this Court, including an interlocutory judgment, once delivered in open court and published to the parties will be placed on the Court file. As such, its availability to any member of the public will be in accordance with the regime provided for by section 131 of the Supreme Court Act 1935. Furthermore, and again typically, such a judgment will be further published or disseminated to a wider audience by email. The practice of the Judges is to instruct their chambers’ staff to “publish” the judgment relatively soon after its delivery. The process, as I understand it, requires a staff member to use a computer program which, through an automated process, distributes the judgment by email to a standard list of recipients.Those recipients include, for example, all judicial officers in the State, the South Australian Bar Association, the South Australian Law Society, the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, the Legal Services Commission, other government departments or entities and various external private publishers of legal materials. Importantly, as soon as a judgment is further published by way of dissemination from chambers in this way, it becomes available to external publishers for uploading on the internet. Typically, by way of example, very soon after such dissemination a judgment will appear on the publically available internet site. [3] Australasian Legal Information Institute. Leaving aside any contractual or other arrangements between the Courts Administration Authority and any of the recipients and leaving aside the requirements of section 131 of the Supreme Court Act, there is no legal obligation on a Judge to further disseminate a judgment that has been published and delivered to the parties in open court. In the past, all court judgments unrestricted as to publication[4] were available to the public, although ready access might have proven difficult unless the judgment found its way into a published series of law reports. However, for quite some years now the vast majority of this Court’s judgments have been made available to the public on any number of internet sites including, of course, Having said that, not all judgments are dealt with in this way; many ex tempore reasons and interlocutory judgments and even some final determinations, thought to contain nothing of general interest, are not disseminated in this way. [4] Such as, for example, being judgments with respect to which no suppression order has been made.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
Rule 236 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 in its present form came into effect on 1 October 2010. It is in these terms.236—Publication of reasons for judgment(1)The reasons for a judgment, order or direction may be published in an appropriate case both in the form of a summary and in a more extended form.(2)After publication of reasons for a judgment, the Registrar will include a copy of the reasons in the Court’s records relating to the proceedings.A former Master of this Court had occasion to consider this rule and the question of further publication or dissemination of reasons for judgment in J v D Pty Ltd & Ors.[5] His Honour made the following observations.[6][Rule 236, unlike] its predecessor ... no longer requires publication of reasons on the Court’s website. However, there is still a general practice that most reasons will be published on the website. This is particularly so where they involve interpretations of laws and rules, and precedents of interest to the legal profession. These reasons fall into that category. The Court has an inherent jurisdiction to edit its reasons to limit the availability of sensitive material. Here to avoid embarrassment to the defendants, it is appropriate to edit these reasons so that they do not name the parties or the deceased, or otherwise identify them. What is contained in these reasons is sufficient for their subsequent use as legal authorities and precedents. The order for hearing in private will also apply to the hearing at which these reasons are published.In my view, this is, with respect, a correct statement of the position. [5] [2010] SASC 318.[6] At [22].The present case In the present case, I have always been of the view that my principal reasons are of such a nature as warrant being further published and made available to the public generally on the internet. As far as the discretion to redact the name of the practitioner is concerned, I am satisfied that it would be within my discretion to do so in this case. However, there is no practice or custom of which I am aware to the effect that where legal practitioner disciplinary proceedings are involved, the term A Practitioner will be employed; quite the contrary. There may be a practice in this State that this terminology is employed in the cause list for the Legal Practitioners Conduct Tribunal at the directions hearing stage of matters before the Tribunal but, if so, the practice goes no further. Whether a matter is in the Tribunal or this Court, the naming of the matter and the form in which any judgment is published will be decided upon on a case by case basis. Different considerations may well apply at various stages whilst a matter is ongoing and as compared with the publication of a judgment that serves to conclude a matter whether at an interlocutory or final relief level. In the present case, there are considerations which support a conclusion that the dissemination at large of a judgment naming the practitioner might be unfairly and unnecessarily prejudicial to the practitioner, including as to his health and his practice such that such dissemination would be premature at this stage.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J

Full text does not contain this section.