Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v A PRACTITIONER

[2019] SASC 136

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

8 August 2019

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - PRACTISING CERTIFICATES

The Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner previously applied to the Court for an order suspending the practising certificate of the defendant practitioner on an interim basis. The application was refused, but the Court ordered that the practitioner’s right to practise be subject to and his practising certificate endorsed with conditions (i)-(v) (set out in paragraph [2]) until further order. Conditions (i) and (ii) have since been revoked by consent.

By interlocutory application filed in this Court, the practitioner now seeks to have conditions (iii)-(v) removed from his practising certificate.

Held:

1. The practitioner is invited to make the undertakings to the Court identified in paragraph [24] of the judgment. If the undertakings are made, conditions (iii) and (iv) currently endorsed on the practitioner’s practising certificate are to be revoked. If the practitioner is not prepared to give the undertakings, the practitioner’s practising certificate is to be endorsed with conditions which reflect the terms of the proposed undertakings in paragraph [24].

2.       The order imposing condition (v) is vacated and condition (v) on the practitioner’s practising certificate is revoked.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) s 89A, Sch 4, referred to.
Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner [2017] SASC 81; Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner (No 2) [2017] SASC 93, considered.

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v A PRACTITIONER
[2019] SASC 136

Civil: Application

NICHOLSON J.

Introduction

  1. In March 2017, the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner applied for an order suspending the practising certificate of the defendant practitioner on an interim basis. The application was brought pursuant to the power conferred on this Court by section 89A and section 5(7) of Schedule 4 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) and pursuant to the inherent jurisdiction of the Court. On 6 June 2017, I refused the application but did order that until further order the practitioner’s right to practise was to be subject to and his practising certificate endorsed with certain conditions. On 30 January 2018, I made an order amending condition (iv). The background to the matter is to be found in my earlier reasons for judgment, Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner[1] and Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner (No 2).[2]

  2. The conditions, as amended on 30 January 2018, were as follows.

    (i)Until further order the practitioner is to have fortnightly meetings with Margaret Graham-King a legal practitioner.  Those meetings are to canvass the following:

    (a)     The current state of the practice.

    (b)     The practitioner’s state of health and the extent to which he is or is not coping with his work load.

    (c)     The practitioner’s compliance with legal practice obligations including CPD and other…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASC 136
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner brought proceedings against a practitioner in the South Australian Supreme Court, seeking to have certain conditions removed from the practitioner’s practising certificate. The practitioner sought to have conditions removed from his practising certificate, including those requiring him to consult with his general practitioner and psychiatrist regularly, and to provide reports on his mental health to the Commissioner. The Commissioner opposed the application in part.

The court was required to decide whether the conditions on the practitioner's practising certificate should be removed. This involved balancing the practitioner's right to practice law against the Commissioner's interest in ensuring the practitioner's mental health was managed appropriately. The court needed to consider the evidence about the practitioner's mental health and whether the conditions were still necessary.

The court found that the conditions on the practitioner's practising certificate should remain in place. The court accepted that the Commissioner had a legitimate interest in ensuring the practitioner's mental health was managed appropriately. The court invited the practitioner to provide undertakings to the court in stronger terms, including regular consultations with his medical practitioners and provision of reports on his mental health to the Commissioner. The court considered that these undertakings would provide sufficient assurance to the Commissioner and that the conditions could be revoked if the practitioner complied with the undertakings.

The court made orders that the application be dismissed and that there be no order as to costs. The court did not remove the conditions from the practitioner's practising certificate but invited the practitioner to provide undertakings to the court to manage his mental health appropriately.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The practitioner now seeks to have those conditions removed from his practising certificate. By interlocutory application filed 5 June 2019, the practitioner seeks the following orders or directions:1.That this application be made specially returnable before the Honourable Justice Nicholson pursuant to the liberty to apply granted by the orders made herein on 6 June 2017.2.That the orders of this Honourable Court made on 6 June 2017 and 30 January 2018 endorsed upon the respondent practitioner’s practising certificate be dissolved.3.That the respondent practitioner’s practising certificate be re-issued without restriction.4.That the action herein be dismissed.5.That there be no order as to costs.The Commissioner opposes the application in part. At the hearing of the application, I received the following affidavit evidence.1.Ninth affidavit of the practitioner sworn 5 June 2019, filed on behalf of the practitioner.2.Second affidavit of Margaret Graham-King sworn 4 June 2019, filed on behalf of the practitioner.3.Fifth affidavit of Kathryn Anne Caird sworn 21 June 2019, filed on behalf of the Commissioner.4.Third affidavit of Peter Austin Whatson sworn 4 July 2019, filed on behalf of the practitioner.5.Sixth affidavit of Kathryn Anne Caird sworn on 30 July 2019, filed on behalf of the practitioner.[3][3] This affidavit was received on the basis that it may become relevant to any contested application for costs. Essential background On 23 February 2017, the Commissioner commenced disciplinary proceedings against the practitioner by way of laying charges of professional misconduct in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal pursuant to section 82(2) of the Legal Practitioners Act. A number of the counts of professional misconduct charged related to asserted failures by the practitioner to cooperate with the Commissioner’s office with respect to his investigations. It was essentially for this reason that the order for interim suspension of the practitioner’s practising certificate was sought. In my earlier reasons,[4] I summarised the position as it was at the time of the original hearing before me in the following terms.The charge alleges 10 counts of professional misconduct in relation to five ongoing investigations into the practitioner’s conduct. Five counts relate to the practitioner’s failure to co-operate with the Commissioner’s office with reference to the investigations and five counts relate to the practitioner’s failure to comply with five Notices issued to him by the Commissioner pursuant to clause 4(1) of Schedule 4 to the Act. The five investigations each relate to conduct on the part of the practitioner that occurred some time ago. Further, the consequences of any substantive unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct (as those terms are defined in the Act) that may, in time, be established have by and large been redressed. The primary concerns would now appear to centre on the reasons why the practitioner failed in his obligations to the extent that he did, the practitioner’s past dilatoriness in redressing the consequences of any substantive unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct and his failures and continuing dilatoriness in responding to the Commissioner’s investigatory processes. These are matters that ultimately will need to be ruled on by the Tribunal.[4] Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner [2017] SASC 81 at [6]-[7].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
In cross-examination by counsel for the Commissioner, Dr Moten explained that the reason she gave the more unqualified opinion in the May and July reports was because she saw no signs or symptoms of depression in the practitioner when she interviewed him on those two occasions. Dr Moten said that the typical signs of depression would be an increase in anxiety, diminished interest or pleasure and impact on social or work function but she saw none of those signs. Whilst Dr Moten was uncomfortable using the word “cured” in this context, she said that it was not appropriate to label someone with a mental health diagnosis for the rest of their life and that this practitioner had had an episode of major depression which had resolved. She would expect that resolution to continue whilst he maintained his medication regime. Dr Moten also indicated that in her view it was appropriate that she see and review the practitioner every six months rather than every two months given his present condition.Conclusion On my review of the additional material that has now been provided to the Court bearing on the practitioner’s state of mental health and its potential relevance to the proper conduct of his practice, I am satisfied that it remains important, perhaps essential, that the practitioner continue to be reviewed by Dr Moten as and when recommended by Dr Moten which presently is every six months and that he maintain such treatment regimes as may be prescribed from time to time. In this respect, I am conscious of the fact that the Tribunal proceedings presently on foot are still at an early stage although it is clear from the affidavit evidence before me that they have been and will continue to be hard fought on both sides. In these circumstances, the potential for further strain and stress on the practitioner to lead to a relapse in his mental state, in the event that he were not being adequately treated and medically supervised, is apparent. In the circumstances, I accept that the Commissioner has a legitimate interest in being assured that the practitioner is remaining compliant with his medical treatment for the foreseeable future. In this respect, the practitioner has offered to give undertakings to the Court. In my view, the undertakings proffered by the practitioner do not go quite far enough. I would invite the practitioner to give undertakings to the Court in slightly stronger terms in which case there would be no need, in my view, to have his practising certificate endorsed with conditions (iii) and (iv). As such, should undertakings in appropriate form be given, I would revoke those conditions. The undertakings I would invite the practitioner to give are as follows.The practitioner undertakes to the Court,(i)that the practitioner will consult with his general practitioner and/or his treating psychiatrist at regular intervals as recommended by those health professionals and will comply with such treatment including medication regimes as may be recommended from time to time by his medical practitioners relating to his mental health; and(ii)that the practitioner will procure his treating psychiatrist or general practitioner to provide to the Commissioner at intervals of no less than six months a report as to the practitioner’s medical state and progress which report is to include the then present diagnosis, the severity of any presenting symptoms, the current treatment plan and current prognosis, with the first report to be provided pursuant to this undertaking on or before 31 December 2019.These undertakings will remain in place unless and until the practitioner is released therefrom by the Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J

Full text does not contain this section.