Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v A PRACTITIONER

[2017] SASC 81

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

6 June 2017

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - PRACTISING CERTIFICATES - CANCELLATION AND SUSPENSION

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

The Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner has commenced disciplinary proceedings against the practitioner in the Legal Practitioners Conduct Tribunal.  The Commissioner also applied to this Court for an order suspending the practitioner's practising certificate on an interim basis, that is, pending the outcome of the disciplinary proceedings.

Held:

1.  The Commissioner's application for an order suspending the practitioner's practising certificate on an interim basis is dismissed.

2.  Until further order, the practitioner's practising certificate will be subject to and endorsed with the conditions identified in paragraph [58] of the judgment.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) s 77L, s 82, s 89A, Sch 4, referred to.
Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Viscariello [2012] SASC 92; Law Society of South Australia v Nicholson [2004] SASC 2, considered.

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v A PRACTITIONER
[2017] SASC 81

Civil: Application

NICHOLSON J.

Introduction

  1. The Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner has applied for an order suspending the practising certificate of the defendant practitioner on an interim basis. The application is brought pursuant to the power conferred on a single Judge of this Court by both section 89A of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) (the Act) and pursuant to the inherent jurisdiction of the Court.[1] 

    [1]    See generally Blue J in Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Viscariello [2012] SASC 92 at [37] and the cases there cited.

  2. The application is opposed.  The proceedings were conducted over a number of short hearings and the following affidavits were received in support of and in opposition, respectively, to the application. 

    (i)Two affidavits sworn by Kathryn Anne Caird on 16 March and 18 April 2017, read on behalf of the Commissioner;

    (ii)Four affidavits sworn by the practitioner on 31 March, 13 April, 13 April and 26 April 2017, read on behalf of the practitioner; and

    (iii)One affidavit sworn by Margaret Graham-King on 13 April 2017, read on behalf of the practitioner. 

    In addition, at the hearing on 28 April 2017, the practitioner tendered a copy of a letter from the practitioner’s solicitor to the Commissioner dated 27 April 2017, together with a document recording details of the practitioner’s attendance at various continuing professional development (CPD) courses which had been referred to in the letter. 

  3. The Commissioner has recently commenced disciplinary proceedings against the practitioner in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal).  The present proceedings are in the nature of interlocutory proceedings.  Any findings of fact I may make will be made for this purpose only and are to be understood as potentially having been based on incomplete material.  They may be the subject of review at any later substantive hearing. 

    Factual background 

  4. The practitioner is 54 years of age and was admitted to practice…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v A Practitioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASC 81
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commissioner brought proceedings against a legal practitioner in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, alleging 10 counts of professional misconduct. The Tribunal has not yet held a substantive hearing on the charge, but the Commissioner applied for an interim suspension of the practitioner’s practising certificate pending the hearing. The practitioner opposed the application. The court was required to decide whether the public interest warranted the interim suspension of the practitioner’s practising certificate and, if so, what conditions should be imposed. The court considered the principles relevant to determining whether an interim suspension should be ordered, including the public interest, the need for public protection, and the interests of the practitioner. The court found that a prima facie case of professional misconduct had been established, and the practitioner had failed to comply with notices issued by the Commissioner. The court held that the public interest warranted the interim suspension of the practitioner’s practising certificate, but that the interests of the practitioner should be taken into account. The court imposed conditions on the practitioner’s practising certificate, including that the practitioner must not accept instructions from new clients until further order. The court dismissed the Commissioner’s application for an order suspending the practitioner’s practising certificate on an interim basis, but ordered that the practitioner’s practising certificate be subject to certain conditions until further order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Commissioner has recently commenced disciplinary proceedings against the practitioner in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal). The present proceedings are in the nature of interlocutory proceedings. Any findings of fact I may make will be made for this purpose only and are to be understood as potentially having been based on incomplete material. They may be the subject of review at any later substantive hearing. Factual background The practitioner is 54 years of age and was admitted to practice on 15 December 1986. He holds a current practising certificate which is due for renewal on 1 July 2017. The practitioner conducts a sole practice from his residence in an inner northern suburb of Adelaide. The practice can be described as a commercial and litigation advising practice. The practitioner does not operate a trust account. On 23 February 2017, the Commissioner commenced disciplinary proceedings against the practitioner by way of laying a charge of professional misconduct in the Tribunal, pursuant to section 82(2) of the Act. There have been two directions hearings before the Tribunal but, as yet, no substantive hearing of the charge. The charge alleges 10 counts of professional misconduct in relation to five ongoing investigations into the practitioner’s conduct. Five counts relate to the practitioner’s failure to co-operate with the Commissioner’s office with reference to the investigations and five counts relate to the practitioner’s failure to comply with five Notices issued to him by the Commissioner pursuant to clause 4(1) of Schedule 4 to the Act. The five investigations each relate to conduct on the part of the practitioner that occurred some time ago. Further, the consequences of any substantive unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct (as those terms are defined in the Act) that may, in time, be established have by and large been redressed. The primary concerns would now appear to centre on the reasons why the practitioner failed in his obligations to the extent that he did, the practitioner’s past dilatoriness in redressing the consequences of any substantive unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct and his failures and continuing dilatoriness in responding to the Commissioner’s investigatory processes. These are matters that ultimately will need to be ruled on by the Tribunal.The first investigation The first investigation by the Commissioner concerns admitted conduct by the practitioner in practising without a practising certificate during the period 1 July 2013 to 16 December 2013 and in continuing to do so after the practitioner became aware on 29 August 2013 of the non-renewal of the practising certificate. The practising certificate was renewed for the period after 16 December 2013 and, thereafter, the practitioner has continued to practise under the authority of a current practising certificate. The Commissioner commenced an investigation into this conduct on 26 August 2014.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
Upon the making of the orders I have indicated, the practitioner is to be released from his undertaking given to the Court during the hearing of this matter, and being to the effect that he would not accept instructions from new clients until further order.Conclusion I make the following orders.1.The Commissioner’s application for an order suspending the practitioner’s practising certificate on an interim basis is dismissed.2.Until further order, the practitioner’s practising certificate will be subject to and endorsed with the conditions identified in paragraph [58] above.3.Liberty to either party and Margaret Graham-King to apply.I will hear the parties on the question of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J

Blue J summarised the relevant principles as follows.1.In determining whether the circumstances are such as to justify invoking the provisions of section 89A and in exercising the discretion what order (if any) should be made, the public interest is a major consideration. 2.For this purpose, the extent to which an interim order is necessary or desirable for the protection of the public or to maintain public confidence in the profession is a relevant consideration.3.Ordinarily, there should be a prima facie case of unprofessional conduct established where it is that conduct which gives rise to the perceived need for public protection or maintenance of public confidence. 4.Ordinarily, a prima facie case will be established by virtue of the Tribunal having made findings of unprofessional conduct, albeit subject to appeal. If the Court were to assess that an appeal challenging the finding was bound to succeed, it may be (depending on the reason for the assessment) that no prima facie case would be established. 5.Hardship to the practitioner is a relevant consideration, particularly in exercising the discretion whether to make an order and to what effect. In this respect, it is relevant to take into account that there are no means for compensating the practitioner for loss suffered due to an order (especially of suspension) if the practitioner’s appeal is successful. 6.However, to the extent that the interests of the practitioner are to be weighed against the public interest, the public interest is ordinarily regarded as predominant.[footnotes omitted]Proposition 4 above does not directly apply given the absence of any findings to this point. Nevertheless, on the basis of the affidavit evidence relied on by the Commissioner without objection by the practitioner, I am satisfied that a prima facie case of professional misconduct has been established. Consideration – should an order for interim suspension be made The Commissioner contends that the power to order suspension has been enlivened and should be exercised at least until the Notices are complied with. Independently of section 89A and the inherent jurisdiction, clause 5(7) of Schedule 4 to the Act expressly confers a discretion to suspend a practising certificate whilst failure by a practitioner to comply with a notice properly issued pursuant to clause 4(1) subsists. Section 5(7) is in these terms.5—Provisions relating to requirements under this Part...(7)The Supreme Court may, on application by the Commissioner or the Society, or on its own initiative, suspend a legal practitioner's practising certificate while a failure by the practitioner to comply with the requirement continues. The Commissioner argues for this position, a fortiori, where a reason for the failure to comply, being the practitioner’s mental health difficulties, persists. In his written submission, the Commissioner has put it in this way:The failure to comply with the Notices itself enlivens a discretion to suspend the practitioner’s right to practise whilst that failure continues. The Commissioner submits that that discretion should ordinarily be exercised in favour of suspension at least until the notices are complied with. This should particularly be so where, as here, the reason for the failure to comply (the practitioner’s mental health) persists. Here the fact of the failure to comply with the notices, as well as the circumstances surrounding the failure to comply and the subject matter of the notices all speak of serial and chronic neglect and delay by the practitioner in attending to his practice.[footnote omitted]