LEGAL PROFESSION COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE and YOUNG

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: LEGAL PROFESSION ACT 2008 (WA)

CITATION:   LEGAL PROFESSION COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE and YOUNG [2020] WASAT 29

MEMBER:   JUDGE T SHARP, DEPUTY PRESIDENT

MS L EDDY, SENIOR MEMBER

MR J MANSVELD, MEMBER

HEARD:   12 SEPTEMBER 2019 AND 11 DECEMBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   9 MARCH 2020

FILE NO/S:   VR 230 of 2018

BETWEEN:   LEGAL PROFESSION COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE

Applicant

AND

NICOLE ANNE YOUNG

Respondent


Catchwords:

Legal practitioner - Professional misconduct - Unsatisfactory professional conduct - Penalty - Suspension - Reprimand - Costs

Legislation:

Legal Profession Act 2008 (WA), s 402, s 403, s 438, s 438(1), s 438(2), s 439(b), s 439(d)
Legal Profession Conduct Rules 2010 (WA), r 6(1)(b), r 6(2)(c)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 55, s 87(1), s 87(2)

Result:

Practitioner reprimanded
Practitioner disqualified from applying for registration for six months
Costs awarded

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr M Howard SC
Respondent : Mr SM Davies SC

Solicitors:

Applicant : Legal Profession Complaints Committee
Respondent : N/A

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Australian Iron & Steel Pty Ltd v Banovic [1989] HCA 56; (1989) 168 CLR 165

Herron v McGregor & Ors (1986) 6 NSWLR 246

Hewett v Medical Board of Western Australia [2003] WASC 128

Khosa v Legal Profession Complaints Committee [2017] WASCA 192

Legal Profession Complaints Committee v Detata [2012] WASCA 214

Legal Profession Complaints Committee v Love [2014] WASC 389

Legal Services Commissioner v Rallis (Legal Practice) [2009] VCAT 714

Medical Board of Western Australia and Roberman [2005] WASAT 81 (S)

Paridis v Settlement Agents Supervisory Board [2007] WASCA 97; (2007) 33 WAR 361

Quinn v Law Institute of Victoria Ltd [2007] VSCA 122

The New South Wales Bar Association v Evatt [1968] HCA 20; (1968) 117 CLR 177

Vogt v Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee [2009] WASCA 202

Western Australian Planning Commission v Questdale Holdings Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 32

Williams v Spautz [1992] HCA 34; (1992) 174 CLR 509

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction and background

Application

  1. By an application to the Tribunal made by the applicant (Committee) and lodged on 4 December 2018, the Committee sought from the Tribunal:

    a)orders to the effect that the Tribunal makes a finding that the respondent (Practitioner) had 'engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct and/or professional misconduct' under s 438(1) of the Legal Profession Act 2008 (WA) (LP Act);

    b)any other orders under s 438(2) of the LP Act; and

    c)an order that the Practitioner pays the Committee's costs pursuant to s 87(2) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) (SAT Act).

  2. The grounds upon which those orders were sought were,   in summary:

    a)that the Practitioner on 7 April 2016 sent an email to the email address CourtTranscriptDC@justice.wa.gov.au, with the salutation 'Dear Registrar', containing a representation which the Practitioner knew was misleading and deceptive; and

    b)that the Practitioner 'in a telephone call with Ms A and, or, in a text message she sent to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LEGAL PROFESSION COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE and YOUNG and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASAT 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves a legal practitioner, referred to as the practitioner, who has been found to have engaged in professional misconduct and unsatisfactory professional conduct. The practitioner, who was employed by HHG Legal Group and later by the Aboriginal Legal Service of Western Australia, was found to have sent an email to the District Court of Western Australia under false pretences and to have engaged in threatening and discourteous conduct with another individual, Ms A. The Legal Profession Complaints Committee brought these matters before the court for determination. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the practitioner's conduct constituted professional misconduct and unsatisfactory professional conduct under the Legal Profession Act 2008 (LP Act). The court found that the practitioner's actions in sending the email under false pretences and her conduct during the telephone conversation and text message to Ms A met the definitions of professional misconduct and unsatisfactory professional conduct respectively. The practitioner's actions fell significantly below the standards expected of a competent legal professional and had the potential to bring the legal profession into disrepute. The court accepted the agreed findings of fact and imposed a penalty of suspension and a reprimand. The practitioner was ordered to pay costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MR J
The Minute then sets out the two findings which the parties agree that the Tribunal should make. The proposed findings are as follows:1)the Practitioner on or around 7 April 2016 engaged in professional misconduct within the meaning of s 403 and s 438 of the LP Act, by preparing and sending from her work email address an email to the Registrar seeking access to 'decisions' made in the District Court of Western Australia in relation to an offender, Mr B, who was sentenced on 4 April 2016, as well as a copy of the sentencing decision (Decisions), which email represented that the Practitioner was making the request in the course of her practice of law in respect of matters concerning the admissibility of DNA evidence, where the Practitioner knew that the representation was misleading and deceptive but the Practitioner nonetheless intended the Registrar to rely on that representation; and2)the Practitioner engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct within the meaning of s 402 and s 438 of the LP Act in that her conduct in a telephone call with Ms A and, or, in a text message she sent to Ms A, fell short of the standard of professional conduct observed and approved by members of the legal profession of good repute and competence and was intemperate, threatening, intimidating and/or discourteous, and had the potential to bring the profession into disrepute. The Schedule attached to the Minute which sets out the agreed facts is in the following terms (the Practitioner being referred to in the Schedule as 'the practitioner'):SCHEDULE A1.At all material times, the practitioner:1.1.was an Australian legal practitioner within the meaning of the [LP Act];1.2.prior to 29 April 2016, practised in criminal and employment law at HHG Legal Group, Perth (firm);1.3.as at 5 May 2016, was not practising, but intended to practise, and in fact on 9 May 2016, commenced practice, at the Aboriginal Legal Service of Western Australia (Inc), in Perth, Western Australia.2.The practitioner's father and brother practised together as real estate agents in an area of Perth.3.Ms A (Ms A), who was also a real estate agent in the same area of Perth as the practitioner's family, competed for listings with the practitioner's family and lived next door to the practitioner's father and in the same street as the practitioner's brother.4.The practitioner had known Ms A and her husband (Mr B) since 2011, having herself previously lived next door to them (at her father's home) for a period of time at about that time.5.Sometime in or about April 2016, the practitioner's family and Ms A were engaged in a corrosive personal dispute, in which, relevantly, each family was alleging the other to be making defamatory remarks against them in the local community.6.Between 16 and 23 February 2016, Mr B stood trial before a jury in the District Court on an indictment alleging historic offences from 25 years prior, namely:6.1.one count of breaking and entering of a dwelling with intent to commit an offence;6.2.one count of deprivation of liberty; 6.3.one count of sexual penetration without consent; and 6.4.two counts of aggravated unlawful and indecent assault,which charges arose from a cold case investigation in which the DNA available from evidence obtained at the time of the offences in 1992 was later matched to Mr B (together, the criminal matters).7.During the course of the trial of the criminal matters, Ms A gave alibi evidence in defence of Mr B to the effect that she and Mr B were living in their home at a certain suburb at the time of the alleged offences and where the alleged offences were said to have been committed on a Thursday night, she and Mr B would have been shopping together as was their custom (Ms A's alibi evidence).8.Following the trial, Mr B was:8.1.acquitted of the offence of sexual penetration without consent; and8.2.convicted of:(a)one count of breaking and entering of a dwelling with intent to commit an offence;(b)one count of deprivation of liberty; and(c)two counts of unlawful and indecent assault (absent any circumstances of aggravation).9.On 4 April 2016, following sentencing submissions made that day, Mr B was sentenced to imprisonment for a period of five years and six months with eligibility for parole after having served a period of three years and six months' imprisonment.10.On around 5 April 2016 following being informed by her father that he had heard on the radio that a person of the same name as Mr B had been convicted of a 1992 "rape" and sentenced to imprisonment, the practitioner then had regard to an online news article about the sexual assault conviction, following which the practitioner, at all material times, suspected that the alleged offender was in fact Mr B. 11.On 7 April 2016 the practitioner prepared and sent from her work email address "Nicole.Young@hhg.com.au", using the signing clause of "Nicole Young Associate", and the HHG Legal Group corporate logo, an email to the email address "CourtTranscriptDC@justice.wa.gov.au" addressed to "Registrar" in which she stated:"I am interested in obtaining access to the decisions made in relation to [name of offender] who was sentenced on 4 April 2016.I am only aware of the decision due to this news article [ … ] I am interested to research any argument and subsequent ruling about the admissibility of the DNA evidence that seems to have been key to the conviction. I do not know which hearing would be most relevant to the inquiry.I would be very grateful if you could indicate which hearing would be most relevant.I would also like a copy of the sentencing decision delivered on 4 April 2016.Can you please indicate what the costs of obtaining these transcripts will be?Lastly, I do have access to the PLEAS database at the Supreme Court library however I do not think that this decision is likely to be put into that database. If I am incorrect about this please let me know as I can wait if the information will eventually be available."(the transcript application email)12.Non-parties may apply to the Court for leave to inspect or obtain a copy of the record or certified transcript of any proceedings in a case pursuant to Rule 51 of the Criminal Procedure Rules 2005, which relevantly at:12.1.subrule (2A) provides that (in the practitioner's circumstances as a non media organisation) the application must be made in writing to the court and must set out the grounds of the application;12.2.subrule (4A) provides that a judge or a registrar may deal with a written application; and12.3.subrule (5) provides that a judge or registrar dealing with a written application, if satisfied the applicant has sufficient cause to be granted leave, may grant the application.13.The transcript application email represented that the practitioner was making the request in the course of her practice of law in respect of matters concerning the admissibility of DNA evidence (Representation), which Representation was made in part by the practitioner's use of her work email address ("Nicole.Young@hhg.com.au"); her work signing clause "Nicole Young Associate"; the presence of the HHG Legal Group corporate logo; and her reference to having access to the PLEAS database when making the request.14.The Representation was misleading and deceptive in that the practitioner was not motivated to seek the Decisions for the stated purpose but was motivated to seek them for the purpose of confirming that the identity of the offender was in fact Mr B, the husband of Ms A, which the practitioner failed to disclose in her email.15.The practitioner knew that the Representation was misleading and deceptive.16.By sending the transcript application email, the practitioner intended the Registrar to rely on the Representation.17.The practitioner was recklessly indifferent as to whether the Registrar would be misled or deceived by the Representation.18.Further, the practitioner did nothing to correct the Representation to the Registrar.19.In making the Representation in the circumstances set out in paragraphs 14 to 18 above, the practitioner's conduct: 19.1.fell short, by a substantial degree, of the standard of professional conduct observed and approved by members of the legal profession of good repute and competence; 19.2.would be reasonably regarded as disgraceful or dishonourable to practitioners of good repute and competence;such that her conduct is professional misconduct within the meaning of sections 403 and 438 of the LP Act.20.Sometime after 21 April 2016 but on or before 5 May 2016, the practitioner read and considered the transcript, from which she was able to inform herself about the criminal matter, including:20.1.the identity of the offender, being Mr B;20.2.the charges for which Mr B was tried;20.3.the charges of which Mr B was convicted; 20.4.the charge of which Mr B was acquitted;20.5.the evidence that Ms A gave during the course of the trial; and20.6.the factual basis upon which Mr B was sentenced.21.A copy of the transcript, redacted to remove references that would disclose the identity of Mr B or Ms A has been provided to the Tribunal.22.The transcript recorded that, in the course of making his sentencing remarks on 4 April 2016, the sentencing judge:22.1.re-stated the jury's verdicts following the trial of the criminal matter, including that "the jury acquitted you of count 5 on the indictment, being the offence of aggravated sexual penetration without consent".22.2.summarised Mr B's evidence that he denied that he knew the victim and denied committing any of the offences charged by way of the Indictment;22.3.summarised Ms A's alibi evidence as outlined in paragraph 7, above;22.4.stated that the jury was instructed that if they accept Mr B's evidence or thought as a reasonable possibility that it might be true then they should acquit; but22.5.did not make any findings as to the credibility of Ms A or her evidence; and22.6.did not comment any further in relation to Ms A's evidence given during the course of the trial of the criminal matter.23.On 5 May 2016, the practitioner received a telephone call from her father, who reported to the practitioner that an exchange had taken place between him and Ms A by telephone earlier that day along the lines that:Ms A: "I know what you have been doing - telling everyone my husband is a rapist."Practitioner's father: "Well he is [Ms A] - he is"Ms A: "No he isn't and you will be getting a letter from my lawyer. You want war - you've got war!"Practitioner's father: "Is that a threat [Ms A]?"Ms A: "Yes it is."Practitioner's father: "Well what does it even mean?"Ms A: "You'll find out."24.On 5 May 2016, the practitioner telephoned Ms A, but did not reach her, and left a message requesting that Ms A return her call.25.Later on 5 May 2016, in circumstances where Ms A had not returned her call, the practitioner again telephoned Ms A and had a brief conversation with her (the telephone conversation), during which the practitioner made the serious allegation that: Mr B was "a rapist".26.In the telephone conversation, the practitioner conducted herself in a manner that was rude, offensive, insulting, intemperate, provocative, and discourteous to Ms A by communication with her using words in effect as follows:.Practitioner: "Hello is that [Ms A] ?"Ms A: " Yes"Practitioner "Hi [Ms A], my name is [Practitioner]. I am actually [practitioner's father]'s daughterMs A: "Oh yes?"Practitioner: "[Ms A], my father has called me this morning very distressed after receiving a call from you in which you apparently made some threats?"Ms A "Yes, that's right."Practitioner: "O.K. Well what's this all about [Ms A]?"Ms A: "He has been defaming me - going around saying despicable things about my husband that are just not true, trying to ruin my business and cost me money."Practitioner: "Well, hang on as I understand it [Ms A], all my father has been saying is that your husband is a rapist and is in jail."Ms A: "Yes - and he is not!"Practitioner: "Wait are you saying he is not a rapist or not in jail?"Ms A: "Both. You should get your facts straight. I know you [Practitioner]. I know you are a lawyer and you are just as foul and stinking as your father and brother. Your whole family is vile. You'll hear from my lawyer."Practitioner: "OK - you have a lawyer do you? What is his name?"Call truncated by Ms A27.Following the telephone conversation, on 5 May 2016 (at approximately 3.05pm) the practitioner sent a text message to Ms A as follows:"Further to our conversation a moment ago I repeat that I am concerned that you are making verbal threats to my father and have made harassing and offensive remarks by calling my brother and myself "foul and stinking". Further you have threatened "war" - whatever that means and outright lied by stating that your husband is not a rapist and not in jail. You are a liar [Ms A] and your husband is a rapist. You are a very poor judge of character. We are aware you have attempted to discredit my father and brother publicly notwithstanding your criminal associations. A normal person would hang their head in shame not lie on the stand to protect a rapist. We look forward to your letter from an unknown lawyer and suggest you ensure you do NOT make any further threats lest we are forced to seek the protection of the Courts. Luckily your rapiat (sic) husband IS locked up [Ms A]. But you are not (yet). Seek some legal advice and in yhe (sic) mean time any further telephone contact with my father or brother should immediately cease. I represent them. Have your lawyers call me. Oh and think about a divorce. He raped a woman [Ms A]. While he was married to YOU. Horrific that you continue to deny that and slander MY family" (the text message).28.In the text message, the practitioner stated that:28.1.Mr B was "a rapist",28.2.Ms A was "a liar" in asserting that Mr B was not "a rapist";28.3.Ms A had lied on oath at the hearing of Mr B;when the practitioner was recklessly indifferent as to whether or not there were reasonable grounds to make those allegations.29.In the text message, the practitioner conducted herself in a manner that was rude, offensive, insulting, intemperate, provocative, and discourteous to Ms A.30.In both the telephone call and the text message, on 5 May 2016, the practitioner purported to act, and held herself out as acting, for her father and brother.31.The practitioner, in the telephone call and the text message, engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct within the meaning of sections 402 and 438 of the LP Act in that her conduct fell short of the standard of professional conduct observed and approved by members of the legal profession of good repute and competence and was intemperate, threatening, intimidating and/or discourteous, and had the potential to bring the profession into disrepute.32.Further, the content and tone of the telephone call and the text message to Ms A was offensive, intemperate, provocative, intimidating and discourteous and in breach of the practitioner's obligations under rule 6(1)(b) of the Legal Profession Conduct Rules 2010 (Conduct Rules).33.Further, the practitioner's conduct in the telephone call and the text message was such that it may bring the profession into disrepute in breach of Conduct Rule 6(2)(c).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MR J