Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Rowe

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Application)

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD v ROWE

[2012] SASCFC 144

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice White, The Honourable Justice Peek and The Honourable Justice Blue)

21 December 2012

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT - FALSIFICATION OF DOCUMENTS AND TRANSACTIONS

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - ORDERS

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - PRACTISING CERTIFICATES - CANCELLATION AND SUSPENSION

Application by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board for the name of the respondent to be struck off the roll of legal practitioners - the respondent had arranged for her client to sign blank pages so that his affidavit could be printed on to them without his having to attend to sign the document - the respondent accepted that she was, and the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal found the respondent, guilty of unprofessional conduct.

Whether the name of the respondent should be struck off the roll of legal practitioners - whether the respondent's immediate and frank disclosure of her unprofessional conduct and her previous professional history rendered a lesser sanction appropriate.

Held (per Peek and Blue JJ): Although this was a serious case of unprofessional conduct, the action was not taken for financial gain, the contents of the purported affidavit were complete and accurate in accordance with the client's instructions, the respondent made immediate and frank disclosure of her unprofessional conduct and the Court in the event was not misled. The respondent had voluntarily reliquished her practising certificate and there was impressive evidence as to her character. The respondent's non-opposition to an order striking her name off the roll of legal practitioners confirmed her contrition and her acceptance of the seriousness of her conduct. In all of the circumstances, the appropriate order is the respondent to be precluded from holding, or applying for, a practising certificate for a total of three years (at [65]-[85]).

Held (per White J dissenting): The conduct was dishonest and involved the client in that dishonesty. The conduct was intended to mislead the Court. The practitioner’s consent to an order striking her name from the roll makes it unnecessary to consider whether some other disciplinary order may have been sufficient. The name of the practitioner should be struck off the roll of legal practitioners (at [31]-[39]).

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) ss 5, 82(6), 89(2); Family Law Act 1975 (Cth); Federal Magistrates Act 1999 (Cth) s 59; Oaths Act 1936 (SA) s 30; Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001 (Cth) s 15.26, referred to.
Law Society of South Australia v Murphy (1999) 201 LSJS 456, applied.
Re Mirza [1991] SASC 3171 and [1996] SASC 5577, distinguished.
English v Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee (1986) 41 SASR 217; Re McLardie [1998] 3 LPDR 23; Law Society of New South Wales v McElvenny [2002] NSWADT 166; Legal Services Commissioner v Flynn [2007] NSWADT 186, discussed.
Legal Practitioners Conduct…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Rowe and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASCFC 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board applied to the Supreme Court of South Australia for an order striking the name of the respondent, a legal practitioner, from the roll of legal practitioners. The dispute arose from the respondent's actions in arranging for her client to sign blank pages of an affidavit, which were then later printed with the client's evidence and presented to the court as a duly sworn document. The respondent admitted to unprofessional conduct, and the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal found her guilty of the same.

The Court was required to determine whether the respondent's conduct constituted professional misconduct and, if so, what disciplinary action was appropriate. Specifically, the Court had to consider the nature and seriousness of the respondent's actions, including the falsification of documents, the deception of the court, and the involvement of her client in dishonest conduct. The Court also had to assess whether the respondent's conduct was a result of a momentary error in judgment or a deliberate course of action, and whether it was undertaken to further her own interests.

The Court reasoned that the respondent's conduct was undoubtedly unprofessional and of a serious kind. It involved an agreement with the client to prepare a document that was to be passed off as a properly executed affidavit, thereby involving the client in dishonest conduct. The respondent then carried out this agreement, falsely stating that she had witnessed the affidavit being sworn when she had not administered any oath. Furthermore, she presented this document to the Family Court of Western Australia with the intention that it be accepted as a properly sworn affidavit, thereby deceiving the court and the client's former wife. The Court found that this conduct was dishonest and involved a substantial failure to meet the standards of competent legal practitioners. Despite having an opportunity to reflect on her actions, the respondent persisted with the conduct, which the Court viewed as inconsistent with a momentary error of judgment and indicative of an effort to avoid criticism for the delay in filing the affidavit.

The Court ordered that the name of the respondent be struck off the roll of legal practitioners.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal recommended the commencement of proceedings in this Court against the practitioner. She consents to the striking off order.Background The practitioner is very experienced, having been admitted to practice in 1971. Generally she has practised in the family law jurisdiction. In late 2006, the practitioner accepted instructions to act for a client in the FMC in relation to a disputed property division. After unsuccessful attempts at a conciliated resolution to the dispute, the matter was listed for hearing on 31 May 2007 at Broken Hill. Each party was directed to file and serve in advance of the hearing an affidavit containing the substance of their evidence-in-chief. The practitioner experienced some difficulties in obtaining instructions from the client, in part because he resided in Broken Hill and she practised in Adelaide. This meant that the client was not always readily available to the practitioner to provide instructions. On some occasions the practitioner saw him personally and on other occasions took instructions by telephone. In order to prepare the client’s affidavit for the hearing on Thursday 31 May 2007, the practitioner had a consultation with him at her Prospect office on Sunday 27 May. The Tribunal accepted that in May the practitioner was under considerable pressure as a sole practitioner. Her practice had become disorganised and, whether by oversight or otherwise, she had not had the client make his affidavit by the date required by the FMC. The consultation on 27 May was lengthy, occupying most of the day. The practitioner had prepared a draft affidavit in advance of the meeting based on the instructions she had received to that time. However, it soon became apparent that it was incomplete in some respects and in other respects did not accord with the client’s further instructions. The practitioner took detailed instructions to complete the draft. Because it was a Sunday, the practitioner did not have staff available to type the amended draft affidavit then and there. She asked the client to return on the following day to sign the typed document. He was unable to do so as he needed to return to Broken Hill to meet employment commitments. The practitioner was concerned by the prospect of still further delay in filing and serving the affidavit in time for the hearing to take place on the following Thursday. Towards the end of the consultation, the client signed more than 30 blank pieces of paper at the foot of each page. There was some discussion in the Tribunal as to whether it was the practitioner or the client who first suggested that the practitioner use the signed blank pages in the preparation of the client’s affidavit. The client claimed that it was the practitioner. Counsel for the practitioner, on the other hand, maintained that it was the client who had suggested this course of action and that the practitioner, in the pressure of the circumstances, had gone along with it. Counsel for the Board took the view that it was not necessary for the Tribunal to resolve that issue but acknowledged that the “preponderance of evidence” favoured that of the practitioner.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WHITE J BLUE JJ

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WHITE J, BLUE JJ

The document prepared by the practitioner and provided for filing in the FMC was positively misleading and deceptive. Contrary to the statement attributed to the client at the commencement of the document, he did not “make oath and say” the matters in the document. He had not signed each page to indicate the authenticity of that page as his affidavit. The practitioner had not administered any oath at all and falsely stated that she was the person before whom the affidavit had been made. Further still, the practitioner engaged in the preparation of a document purporting to be an affidavit knowing that it would deceive the FMC and her client’s former wife into thinking that it contained statements to which the client had, by his oath, committed his conscience.Consideration The practitioner’s conduct was undoubtedly unprofessional conduct of a serious kind. It comprised several elements:(a)an agreement with the client to participate in the preparation of a document which was to be passed off as a properly executed affidavit and therefore involved the client in dishonest conduct;(b)the carrying out of that agreement;(c)entering her own signature on the affidavit so as to indicate that it had been properly sworn when she had not witnessed the affidavit at all; and(d)the presentation of the document to the FMC through counsel with the intention that that Court should, without enquiry, accept that it was a properly sworn affidavit. Plainly this was conduct involving a “substantial … failure to meet the standard of conduct observed by competent legal practitioners of good repute”.[5] The conduct was dishonest and, even though at the client’s instigation, involved the client in that dishonesty. The practitioner intended that the FMC should be misled into proceeding on the basis that the affidavit had been made in the manner required by its Rules.[5] Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA), s 5(1) (Definition of unprofessional conduct). I note, however, that the practitioner did not intend that the affidavit should misstate the client’s evidence-in-chief. Counsel for the Board accepted that the practitioner had believed at relevant times that the “affidavit” did record accurately the evidence which the client would give. The practitioner had an opportunity to reflect on the wrongfulness of her conduct between Sunday 27 May and the time when, on the next day or so, she printed the body of the client’s affidavit onto the pre‑signed pages and purported to execute it as a witness. Despite that opportunity, the practitioner persisted with the conduct. This seems inconsistent with the conduct resulting from a momentary error of judgment. It also seems that the practitioner engaged in the conduct for the purpose of furthering her own interests, ie, in an effort to avoid the criticism which she foreshadowed would be made by the FMC because of the delay in providing the affidavit. The deception which the practitioner sought to work on the FMC and the client’s former spouse had the potential both to abort the FMC proceedings on 31 May 2007 and to undermine her own client’s credibility in those proceedings.