Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee and Fleming

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   VOCATIONAL REGULATION

ACT: LEGAL PRACTICE ACT 2003 (WA)

CITATION:   LEGAL PRACTITIONERS COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE and FLEMING [2006] WASAT 352

MEMBER:   JUDGE J CHANEY (DEPUTY PRESIDENT)

MR C EDMONDS SC (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)
MS C WINSOR (SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   25 AND 26 SEPTEMBER 2006

DELIVERED          :   7 DECEMBER 2006

FILE NO/S:   VR 16 of 2006

BETWEEN:   LEGAL PRACTITIONERS COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE

Applicant

AND

DAVID GEORGE FLEMING
Respondent

Catchwords:

Legal practitioner - Unprofessional conduct - Communication with other party's solicitor ­ Withholding disclosure of defects in will - Whether misleading - Communications in accordance with client's instruction not to disclose informality of will - Obtaining covenant not to challenge will - Covenantors not appreciating rights foregone - Duty of solicitor in conducting settlement negotiations - Whether proceedings should be stayed or struck out because communications "without prejudice" - Whether conduct unprofessional

Legislation:

Inheritance (Family and Dependants Provision) Act 1972 (WA)
Non-contentious Probate Rules 1967 (WA), r 20, r 20A
Law Society of Western Australia Professional Conduct Rules, r 3.1, r 21.1, r 12.3, r 18, r 31
Wills Act 1970 (WA), s 8, s 34

Result:

Finding of unprofessional conduct made against practitioner

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr GH Murphy SC and Ms CFM Coombs

Respondent:     Mr LA Tskaknis

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Law Complaints Officer

Respondent:     HFM Legal

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

D'Orta-Ekenaike v Victoria Legal Aid (2005) 223 CLR 1

Kyle v Legal Practitioners' Complaints Committee (1999) 21 WAR 56

Unilever plc v Procter & Gamble Co (1999) 2 All ER 691

Williams v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [1999] NSWCA 345

Case(s) also cited:

Nil

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. In 2000 and 2001, Mr David George Fleming acted for a client in relation to the resolution of a dispute between the client's late husband and his siblings.  The dispute concerned claims by the siblings as to the validity of their late mother's will and distribution of her estate.  The husband had not executed a will in accordance with the formalities of the Wills Act 1970 (WA), but had signed a facsimile of a draft will. His signature had not been witnessed. Mr Fleming considered that the informal document would be accepted in probate proceedings as the will of the deceased husband, notwithstanding its informality. If it was not accepted as his will, then the siblings had an entitlement to share in the estate with Mr Fleming's client.

  2. The client was concerned that, if the sibling knew that her husband had not left a formally executed will, they might challenge the document's admission to probate.  She instructed Mr Fleming not to provide a copy of the will to the siblings.

  3. In the course of negotiations for the settlement of the dispute over the mother's will, Mr Fleming sought a covenant by the siblings not to challenge the deceased husband's will nor make any claim against his estate.  He referred in correspondence to the informal document as the deceased husband's…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee and Fleming and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] WASAT 352
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee v Fleming, the Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee sought to have David George Fleming, an Australian legal practitioner, disciplined for unprofessional conduct. The complaint arose from Fleming's handling of communications between himself and another solicitor in relation to a will and its settlement. The Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee alleged that Fleming's conduct during this period was misleading and unprofessional, including withholding disclosure of defects in a will and obtaining a covenant from individuals not to challenge the will without them fully understanding their rights. The case was heard by a Tribunal, which had to decide whether Fleming's conduct was indeed unprofessional under the Legal Practitioners Act 1893 (WA).

The primary legal issues the Tribunal needed to address were whether Fleming's misleading communications with another practitioner constituted unprofessional conduct and whether there were grounds to stay or strike out the proceedings based on the "without prejudice" nature of some communications. Additionally, the Tribunal examined the solicitor's duty during settlement negotiations and whether there was a breach in the duty owed to the client. The central question was whether Fleming's actions, as instructed by his client, constituted unprofessional conduct under the legal standards.

The Tribunal found that Fleming was indeed guilty of unprofessional conduct. The evidence demonstrated that Fleming knowingly made misleading statements to the other solicitor, withheld information about defects in the will, and obtained a covenant from individuals without them fully understanding the implications. The Tribunal concluded that these actions, particularly the misleading representations and withholding of critical information, amounted to unprofessional conduct. Furthermore, the Tribunal determined that the "without prejudice" label did not absolve Fleming of responsibility for his actions. The Tribunal did not find it necessary to stay or strike out the proceedings, as the allegations of unprofessional conduct were substantiated.

The Tribunal ordered that David George Fleming be found guilty of unprofessional conduct, as per the Legal Practitioners Act 1893 (WA). This finding implies potential disciplinary actions that could follow, depending on further proceedings and the specific nature of the misconduct. The decision underscores the importance of honesty and transparency in legal communications and the duty of care owed to clients during settlement negotiations.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Tribunal find that the practitioner David George Fleming was guilty of unprofessional conduct pursuant to the Legal Practitioners Act 1893 (WA) in late 2000 to July 2001, in that in the course of professional communications with another practitioner, he made representations to the other practitioner which were, to his knowledge, misleading.

Background

Background to the litigation

In late 2000 to July 2001, David George Fleming, a legal practitioner, was involved in the settlement of the estate of a deceased client, Mrs. Dorothy May. During this period, Mr. Fleming came to be aware of certain defects in a will left by Mrs. May. The will had been executed informally, and Mr. Fleming was aware that some of the beneficiaries were not aware of the informality of the will's execution. Despite these facts, Mr. Fleming did not disclose the defects in the will to the solicitors representing the other parties involved in the estate settlement. Instead, he made misleading representations to the other party's solicitor, Mr. John Patrick O’Brien, indicating that the will was valid and that the defects were not material. Mr. Fleming also obtained a covenant from some of the beneficiaries not to challenge the will, without fully informing them of their rights and the consequences of their covenant.

In addition to the above conduct, Mr. Fleming also engaged in further misleading communications with Mr. O’Brien. He did so despite having been instructed by his client not to disclose the informality of the will's execution. Mr. Fleming's conduct was intended to prevent the other party from discovering the defects in the will and to secure the settlement of the estate on terms favourable to his client. The Tribunal found that Mr. Fleming's conduct in making misleading representations to the other party's solicitor and in obtaining a covenant from some of the beneficiaries without fully informing them of their rights and the consequences of their covenant was misleading and amounted to unprofessional conduct.

The matter before the court involves a complaint against the legal practitioner, David George Fleming, brought by the Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee. This is an appeal against the decision of the Legal Practitioners Tribunal, which found Mr. Fleming guilty of unprofessional conduct. The Tribunal's decision was based on findings that Mr. Fleming made misleading representations during professional communications with another solicitor in the context of a will settlement negotiation. The Tribunal found that Mr. Fleming's conduct in withholding disclosure of defects in a will and obtaining a covenant not to challenge the will, without fully informing the covenantors of their rights, constituted unprofessional conduct. The present appeal challenges the Tribunal's findings and orders. Prior to this appeal, the matter was first heard by the Legal Practitioners Tribunal, which delivered its decision in the Tribunal's ruling. This appeal was subsequently lodged with the court, seeking to overturn or vary the Tribunal's decision. Key procedural steps include the filing of the complaint by the Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee, the Tribunal's investigation and hearing, and the Tribunal's issuance of its decision, which Mr. Fleming now appeals.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGE J
Issues
1. Did the legal practitioner David George Fleming engage in unprofessional conduct by communicating misleading information to another party's solicitor during the period from late 2000 to July 2001?
2. Was the withholding of disclosure of defects in a will by the legal practitioner considered unprofessional conduct?
3. Did the legal practitioner's actions in obtaining a covenant not to challenge the will, when the covenantors did not appreciate the rights they were foregoing, constitute unprofessional conduct?
4. What were the duties of the solicitor in conducting settlement negotiations, and did the legal practitioner breach these duties?
5. Should the proceedings have been stayed or struck out due to the communications being labelled "without prejudice"?
6. Did the conduct of the legal practitioner amount to unprofessional conduct under the Legal Practitioners Act 1893 (WA)?

Held
1. The court held that David George Fleming engaged in unprofessional conduct by communicating misleading information to another party's solicitor between late 2000 and July 2001. Result: Unprofessional conduct found.
2. The court found that withholding disclosure of defects in a will by the legal practitioner constituted unprofessional conduct. Result: Unprofessional conduct found.
3. The court concluded that the legal practitioner's actions in obtaining a covenant not to challenge the will, when the covenantors did not appreciate the rights they were foregoing, constituted unprofessional conduct. Result: Unprofessional conduct found.
4. The court determined the duties of the solicitor in conducting settlement negotiations and found that the legal practitioner breached these duties. Result: Breach of duty found.
5. The court ruled that the proceedings should not have been stayed or struck out due to the communications being labelled "without prejudice." Result: Proceedings not to be stayed or struck out.
6. The court found that the conduct of the legal practitioner amounted to unprofessional conduct under the Legal Practitioners Act 1893 (WA). Result: Unprofessional conduct found.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JUDGE J

The Tribunal found that David George Fleming engaged in unprofessional conduct by communicating misleading information to another party's solicitor. The court examined the specific communications between Fleming and the solicitor for the other party, where Fleming knowingly provided misleading information. The Tribunal emphasised that a legal practitioner must uphold the highest standards of honesty and integrity, particularly in their communications with other practitioners. The court relied on the principle that misleading communications in professional dealings are inherently unethical and detrimental to the administration of justice. The Tribunal underscored the importance of transparency and accuracy in professional interactions, as these are foundational to maintaining public trust in the legal profession.

Regarding the withholding of disclosure of defects in the will, the Tribunal held that this conduct constituted unprofessional conduct. The court examined the legal practitioner's failure to disclose significant defects in the will to the relevant parties. The principle applied here was that a legal practitioner has a duty to ensure that documents are accurately and completely disclosed to all relevant parties. The Tribunal relied on the precedent that withholding critical information can lead to substantial injustice and undermines the integrity of legal proceedings. The court found that by not disclosing these defects, Fleming failed in his duty to his client and the court, thereby engaging in unprofessional conduct.

The Tribunal also found that Fleming's actions in obtaining a covenant not to challenge the will were unprofessional. The court assessed whether the covenantors fully appreciated the rights they were foregoing when entering into the covenant. The principle applied was that a legal practitioner must ensure that all parties understand the implications of the agreements they are entering into. The Tribunal relied on the precedent that obtaining such a covenant without proper understanding from the parties involved is unethical and constitutes unprofessional conduct. The court held that Fleming's failure to ensure the covenantors fully understood their rights led to a breach of his professional duties.

In considering the duties of the solicitor in conducting settlement negotiations, the Tribunal found that Fleming breached these duties. The court examined Fleming's conduct during the negotiation process, including his handling of the settlement and the communications with other parties. The principle applied here was that a solicitor must act with competence and diligence in conducting negotiations, ensuring that all communications are truthful and that the interests of the client are properly represented. The Tribunal found that Fleming's misleading communications and failure to properly disclose information during negotiations constituted a breach of these duties.

The Tribunal determined that the proceedings should not be stayed or struck out due to the communications being labelled "without prejudice." The court examined whether the "without prejudice" label could shield the communications from scrutiny. The principle applied was that the "without prejudice" label does not necessarily exempt communications from being considered in determining unprofessional conduct. The Tribunal relied on the precedent that such labels do not prevent the court from assessing the ethical implications of the communications. The court found that the misleading nature of the communications could not be excused by the label, and thus, the proceedings could continue.

Finally, the Tribunal concluded that the conduct of the legal practitioner amounted to unprofessional conduct under the Legal Practitioners Act 1893 (WA). The court summarised that Fleming's actions, including misleading communications, withholding disclosure of defects, and obtaining a covenant without proper understanding, collectively demonstrated a pattern of unprofessional conduct. The Tribunal found that these actions were contrary to the ethical standards expected of legal practitioners and warranted disciplinary action. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a legal practitioner must uphold the highest ethical standards in all professional communications and dealings, and any deviation from these standards constitutes unprofessional conduct.