Le v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
50 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Le v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 51
MIGRATION – appeal from decision of single judge dismissing application for review – cancellation of visa under s 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – procedural fairness – where no written notice setting out reasons for the decision – whether Issues Paper and its annexures put the essential elements of the appellant’s case to the Minister – whether Issues Paper and its annexures contained an accurate summary of the matters put by the appellant to the Departmental Officer – whether Issues Paper and its annexures properly identified the issues raised by the appellant concerning the best interest of the appellant’s children – whether Minister failed to consider the best interest of the children as a primary consideration – whether there was no consideration ‘in truth’ of the best interests of the children – the Departmental Officer was not obliged to make further enquiries – the practical content of the obligation to provide procedural fairness was complied with – appeal dismissed
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Le v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigeno... and more:
The appellant, Le, appealed against the primary judge's decision to dismiss his application for judicial review of the Minister's decision to cancel his visa. The primary judge held that there was no jurisdictional error in the Minister's decision. The appellant's case was that the Minister had failed to take into account the best interests of his three children, and had failed to give him procedural fairness by not providing reasons for the decision. The appellant submitted that the Issues Paper and the record of interview were not before the Minister when he made the decision to cancel his visa. The appellant further submitted that the Issues Paper and its annexures did not contain an accurate summary of the matters which he had put to the Departmental Officer in his interview of 26 July 2000. The appellant also submitted that the Issues Paper and its annexures did not put the essential elements of his case to the Minister and did not identify the issues concerning the interests of the children.
The court held that the primary judge was correct in dismissing the appellant's application for judicial review. The court noted that the appellant had not identified any specific error in the Issues Paper or record of interview that would have affected the Minister's decision. The court held that the appellant had not demonstrated any jurisdictional error on the part of the Minister. The court noted that the Issues Paper and its annexures did respond to the considerations regarding the welfare of children listed in Direction 21, although there was no reference to paragraph 2.15 of Direction 21, which stated that in general terms, the child's best interests would be served if the child remained with their parents. However, the court held that this did not amount to jurisdictional error on the part of the Minister. The court held that the primary judge was correct in finding that there was no jurisdictional error in the Minister's decision. The court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the appellant pay the respondent's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be dismissed.
2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant claims that the primary judge erred in fact and in law in determining that the Minister had not failed to accord procedural fairness to himself and his three children. This is so, the appellant claims because, having accepted that a failure to take into account the best interests of the appellant’s children would have amounted to a breach of procedural fairness, his Honour should have found that:‘1.The Issues Paper and the documents attached even when taken together did not put the essential elements of the Appellant’s case to the Minister and did not identify the issues concerning the interests of the children and therefore it could be properly inferred that the Minister had failed to take the best interests of the children into account as a primary consideration. 2.The Issues Paper and its annexures did not contain an accurate summary of the substance of the matters which the Appellant had put to the Departmental Officer in his interview of 26 July 2000.3.It could be properly inferred from the Issues Paper and annexures that the consideration of the best interests of the children was so rudimentary so as to be mere lip service to the obligation to have regard to the best interests of the children as a primary consideration, namely there was no consideration in truth by the Minister.’The Facts Counsel for the appellant, Mr Christie, gives a detailed history of this matter in his submissions. The primary judge also sets out a detailed history of the matter in his judgment: Le v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 875. The relevant facts are as follows:(i) On 25 April 1959, the appellant was born in Vietnam. He is a national of Vietnam.(ii)In the 1980s, the appellant fled from Vietnam to a refugee camp in Hong Kong where he met his wife. They had a child at that camp.(iii)On 25 June 1990, the appellant, his wife and their child were admitted as refugees into Australia. The appellant and his wife have since had two more children. The children at the time of the decision to cancel his visa were aged 13, 8 and 7.(iv)In 1995, the appellant’s wife formed a relationship with the appellant’s ‘former best friend’ Mr Pham and the appellant and his wife separated. The appellant’s wife retained ordinary custody of their three children but the appellant remained involved in the children’s lives. The appellant’s counsel, Mr Christie, submitted that the appellant had often looked after the children ‘when the Appellant’s wife and Mr Pham went gambling for long periods at night’.(v)In 1998, the appellant visited his parents in Vietnam and was away from Australia for a total of 11 days.(vi)On 25 May 1999, the appellant was involved in an altercation with Mr Pham. The appellant struck Mr Pham ‘with a machete to the head causing an incision wound and further abrasions and also cut Mr Pham’s wife when she intervened’. The appellant was arrested. He pleaded guilty to unlawful wounding and was sentenced on 20 August 1999 to two years imprisonment. He served 10 months and was released in April 2000. At the time of sentencing, Mr Le had a short criminal history involving mainly offences for stealing for which he had been fined and a conviction for common assault in December 1995 for which he was fined. (vii)By letter dated 6 September 1999, the Minister’s officer advised that he might be liable for deportation. An officer of the Minister (“the officer”) invited the appellant to provide material to demonstrate why he should not be deported and informed the appellant that he would be interviewed before a decision to deport him was made.(viii)On 14 September 1999, the appellant responded by letter to the officer’s letter and gave his account of the altercation between himself and Mr Phan, and of the events leading up to the altercation (“the September letter”). (ix)In February 2000, the officer obtained a conduct report and other information from the Casuarina Prison (“the prison report”) and a transcript of the sentencing remarks from the Director of Public Prosecutions.(x)On 11 April 2000, the Minister’s translation service translated into English a letter from the appellant of 26 March 2000 (“the March letter”).(xi)On 19 July 2000, by an internal minute, the Criminal Deportation Branch of the Minister’s Department requested the Onshore Protection Branch (“Onshore Protection”) to undertake an assessment of Australia’s protection obligations to the appellant.(xii)On 26 July 2000, the appellant attended an interview with the officer. There is a signed record of that interview (“the record of interview”).(xiii)On 17 August 2000, a copy of the appellant’s signed statement was provided to Onshore Protection.(xiv)On 4 September 2000, Onshore Protection provided Criminal Deportations with an undated assessment wherein it was advised that the appellant was no longer a refugee under Article 1C(5) of the Refugees Convention, that Australia did not owe the appellant protection obligations and that he did not have claims under the Convention against Torture or under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.(xv)On 20 July 2001, the officer gave the appellant a notice of intention to consider cancelling his visa under s 501(2) of the Act. The material that was before the officer was not annexed to this notice. A copy of the Minister’s Direction No 17 made under s 499 of the Act was provided to the appellant. (xvi)On 6 August 2001, the appellant responded by letter to the notice of intention by way of a ‘general plea to remain in Australia’.(xvii)On 24 October 2001, the Department sent the appellant a Notice of Intention to consider cancelling his visa and enclosing Direction No 21 which had replaced Direction No 17. That letter was returned unclaimed to the Department from two separate addresses.(xviii)On 12 July 2002, the officer prepared a ‘Minute’ for the Minister (“the Issues Paper”) annexing documents including the sentencing remarks and the protection assessment paper referred to above, but not including the prison report. The appellant’s letter dated 6 August 2001 was annexed and described as the submissions from Mr Le however, the September letter, the April letter and the record of interview were not provided with the Issues Paper and were not referred to. (xx)On 26 August 2002, the Minister endorsed the option at the end of the Issues Paper to cancel the appellant’s visa and the appellant was notified accordingly, by letter dated 26 August 2002. It is accepted by both parties that the Minister did not provide reasons for his decision.(xxi)On 4 September 2002, Mr Le was sent a notice of visa cancellation under s 501(2) of the Act.(xxii)In September 2002, the appellant was taken into immigration detention.(xxiii)On 1 November 2002, the appellant lodged an application for review of the Minister’s decision cancelling his visa. The matter was listed for hearing on 30 April 2003 but the matter was adjourned to a date to be fixed after 13 June 2003.(xxiii)On 15 May 2003, the appellant filed a motion seeking his release from detention until the hearing of the application or further order. That application was refused on 18 June 2003.(xxiv)The substantive application was heard on 20 April 2004 and 15 June 2004.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The Assessment refers to country information and concludes that the appellant is no longer is a refugee according to Article 1C(5) of the Refugees Convention due to the significant changes which Vietnam has experienced since he fled and that he is not owed protection obligations by Australia.Further evidence On 23 April 2003, the appellant’s wife, Tran Thi Lan, swore an affidavit in which she gave details of her relationship with the appellant, of his contact with the children and of his care of them, both emotionally and domestically. She also gave evidence as to the lack of likelihood of the children being able to visit the appellant in Vietnam because of the cost of the airfares. On 19 May 2004, the appellant swore an affidavit as to the effect on his parents of his evasion of military service and flight from Vietnam in 1987. He also described the fact that, when he returned to Vietnam in 1998, his brother told him that the local public security were looking for him. He returned to Australia ‘much sooner than [he] had intended to’. He states in the affidavit that it is likely that he will be put in gaol if he returns to Vietnam and that he will be persecuted and unable to get a job once released.The material not before the MinisterThe record of interview In the record of interview, the following answer was given by the appellant to an officer of the Department:‘Yes, I still look after my children. Every day I go to the house and play with them. Sometimes I take them to school and pick them up. On the weekends we go shopping together.’ In answer to the question ‘Degree of contact with spouse and children prior to sentencing’, the appellant replies ‘between 1987 and 1994 we lived together as a family. Between 1994 and 1999 I would visit my wife and children 3 or 4 times a week after work, but I did not live with them. Since about three weeks ago, I have lived with my wife and children. Whether my wife wants it or not, my intention is to go back to my wife’. The appellant describes the circumstances of his attack on Mr Pham and his concern that his wife would go gambling with Mr Pham and leave the children at home with no-one to look after them. Reference was also made to his concern that he must look after and provide for his children because of his wife’s gambling. The appellant refers to his trip to Vietnam in 1998 and states that:-“they knew me and recognised me so I had to get away. I am not wanted on any criminal matters. I was gaoled only because I had previously tried to escape Vietnam. That was before I actually got away to Hong Kong and eventually came to Australia.” The appellant comments on the difficulties his children would face if they were forced to leave Australia and that ‘they would suffer because I would be either thrown in gaol or I would have to hide’. The appellant also states that the children depended on him, that he is ‘the only stable thing’ in their lives and that since he was released from gaol he has been living with his wife and children.The September letter
Decision
Reasons for decision
The appellant refers to the fact that the Viet-Cong have, since he fled the country, kept his parents and siblings’ families ‘under control’.The decision of the primary judge The grounds of the application before the primary judge were, in substance, that there was jurisdictional error in the following ways:(a)Having regard to the sparse information before the Minister in relation to the effect of Mr Le’s removal from Australia upon his children and having regard to the content of the Issues Paper and Record of Decision it may be inferred that the Minister failed to give any or any proper consideration to the best interests of the children in making his decision and thereby: (i)failed to take into account a relevant consideration which he was obliged to take into account in the exercise of his discretion under s 501; (ii)failed to accord natural justice to Mr Le having regard to the legitimate expectation that he would not fail to observe Australia’s obligations under Art 3.1 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child;(iii)acted upon information so deficient that no reasonable decision could be made as to the best interests of the children as a primary consideration in determining whether Mr Le’s visa should be cancelled; (iv)acted upon information so deficient that there was a constructive failure on the part of the Minister to consider the best interests of the children as a primary consideration and to properly exercise jurisdiction.(b)The Minister failed to afford natural justice to Mr Le in failing to give him an opportunity to comment upon adverse information from departmental officers: (i) relating to his contact with his children; (ii)relating to whether Australia owed him any obligations under any relevant United Nations Convention.’ The primary judge gave comprehensive reasons for his decision not to allow the appellant’s application for review of the Minister’s decision. It was accepted before the primary judge and on appeal that no reasons for decision were given by the Minister. That of itself does not invalidate the decision nor amount to jurisdictional error (Djalic v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 206 ALR 488 (‘Djalic’)).Interests of the children The primary judge recognised that, if the visa cancellation stands, the appellant will be deported and removed from all practical hope of any real ongoing contact with his children. His Honour observed that ‘this is a case where there is a question mark about the adequacy of the materials put before the Minister and the merits of the decision-making process based upon them’ but that the Court is not empowered to review administrative or ministerial decisions simply on that basis. His Honour was not satisfied that there was any jurisdictional error upon which the Minister’s decision to cancel the visa could be set aside. The primary judge considered the Issues Paper and Direction 21 in detail. His Honour noted that the Issues Paper responded to the considerations regarding the welfare of children listed in Direction 21. However, his Honour also noted:‘there was no reference to par 2.15 of the Direction which states, inter alia, that ‘In general terms the child’s best interests will be served if the child remains with its…parents’.’