Laing O'Rourke Australia Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Laing O’Rourke Australia Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2013] FCA 133

Citation: Laing O’Rourke Australia Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2013] FCA 133
Parties: LAING O'ROURKE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 111 023 431), LAING O'ROURKE AUSTRALIA CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD, EXPLORE INVESTMENTS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD, 825 ANN STREET PTY LTD (ACN 132 841 242) and 100 MCLACHLAN STREET PTY LTD (ACN 137 358 475) v CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION, AUSTRALIAN BUILDING CONSTRUCTION EMPLOYEES AND BUILDERS' LABOURERS' FEDERATION (QUEENSLAND BRANCH) UNION OF EMPLOYEES (AS A TRANSITIONALLY REGISTERED ORGANISATION), COMMUNICATIONS, ELECTRICAL, ELECTRONIC, ENERGY, INFORMATION, POSTAL, PLUMBING AND ALLIED SERVICES UNION OF AUSTRALIA (AS A TRANSITIONALLY REGISTERED ORGANISATION), MICHAEL RAVBAR, ANDREW SUTHERLAND, KEVIN GRIFFIN, SCOTT VINK, TIM JARVIS and MARK BATEMAN
File number: QUD 86 of 2013
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 25 February 2013
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – urgent interlocutory application – allegations of breaches of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) by unions and union organisers – allegations of coercion and intimidation of applicants and subcontractors – whether serious questions to be tried – balance of convenience

INDUSTRIAL LAW – workplace rights – adverse action – whether workplace rights identified by applicants – role of Health and Safety Committee at work site – right of unions to communicate their position to subcontractors – whether intimidation – whether union consent required for out of hours work – right of entry of union officials

Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 45D, 45E
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) Pt 3-4 of Ch 3, ss 19, 19(2), 340, 341, 342, 343, 347(c), 347(d), 347(f), 348, 362, 363, 408, 417, 545(1), 545(2), 550, 793
Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld) ss 85, 117
Cases cited: Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57 applied
James v The Commonwealth (1939) 62 CLR 339 cited
Short v FW Hercus Pty Ltd (1993) 40 FCR 511 cited
Date of hearing: 22 February 2013
Place: Brisbane
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 43
Counsel for the First, Second, Third, Fourth and Fifth Applicants: Mr JE Murdoch SC
Solicitor for the First, Second, Third, Fourth and Fifth Applicants: Minter Ellison Lawyers
Counsel for the First, Second, Third, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Seventh, Eighth and Ninth Respondents: Mr WL Friend SC
Solicitor for the First, Second, Third, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Seventh, Eighth and Ninth Respondents: Hall Payne Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

QUD 86 of 2013

BETWEEN:

LAING O'ROURKE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 111 023 431)
First Applicant

LAING O'ROURKE AUSTRALIA CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD
Second Applicant

EXPLORE INVESTMENTS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
Third Applicant

825 ANN STREET PTY LTD (ACN 132 841 242)
Fourth Applicant

100 MCLACHLAN STREET PTY LTD (ACN 137 358 475)
Fifth Applicant

AND:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION
First Respondent

AUSTRALIAN BUILDING CONSTRUCTION EMPLOYEES AND BUILDERS' LABOURERS' FEDERATION (QUEENSLAND BRANCH) UNION OF EMPLOYEES…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Laing O'Rourke Australia Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, M... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 133
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Laing O'Rourke Australia Pty Ltd and Laing O'Rourke Australia Construction Pty Ltd filed an urgent interlocutory application against the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union and others, alleging breaches of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) by unions and union organisers. The applicants claimed that the unions and union organisers had engaged in coercion and intimidation of the applicants and their subcontractors, which led to alleged breaches of workplace rights and adverse action against the applicants. The case was heard by the Australian Federal Court.

The court was required to decide whether there were serious questions to be tried, whether damages would be an inadequate remedy for the applicants, and whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of the orders sought by the applicants. The court considered the evidence presented by both parties and found that the evidence strongly supported findings that there were serious questions to be tried, that damages would be an inadequate remedy for the applicants, and that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of orders sought by the applicants.

The court held that the applicants had made out a prima facie case for relief, as they had shown a sufficient likelihood of success, which depended on the nature of the rights asserted and the practical consequences likely to flow from the interlocutory order sought. The court also considered that the grant or refusal of an interlocutory injunction would not dispose of the action finally in favour of whichever party succeeded on that application.

The court granted the interlocutory orders sought by the applicants, restraining various combinations of the respondents from taking certain actions, including placing bans or restrictions on work at the construction project, advising or encouraging employees not to carry out work when required, and taking actions that would cause detriment to the commercial interests of subcontractors. The orders also restrained the respondents from engaging in conduct that would hinder or prevent subcontractors from carrying out work on the project, and from advising, encouraging, or procuring industrial action by employees.

The court held that the orders did not apply to the organising or taking of protected industrial action in accordance with the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) or activity which was not industrial action because of the operation of section 19(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The court also ordered that the affidavit of Murray Middleton be provided only to lawyers acting for any respondent and that the affidavit or its contents not be otherwise disclosed. The matter was listed for a further hearing on a date to be fixed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In this Order:

“M&A Project” means the construction project located at the corner of McLachlan and Ann Streets, Fortitude Valley, Brisbane.

“M&A Project Employee” means an employee of the second applicant or any M&A Subcontractor employed to carry out work on the M&A Project.

“M&A Subcontractor” means any company or organisation carrying out work on the M&A Project as a subcontractor to the second applicant and includes:

(a) Lindores Construction Logistics Pty Ltd;

(b) QPI Pty Ltd;

(c) Freshmore (QLD) Pty Ltd trading as Advanced Precast (Aust);

(d) North West Commercial Industries (QLD) Pty Ltd;

(e) Saba Bros Tiling (QLD) Pty Ltd;

(f) Blue Star Pacific Pty Ltd;

(g) G James Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited;

(h) Active Platforms Pty Ltd;

(i) Dig It Landscapes Pty Ltd.

2. Until the final determination of these proceedings or earlier order the first and second respondents (whether by their officers, delegates or employees, or howsoever otherwise) and the fourth and fifth respondents be restrained from:

(a) taking any action or initiating or being involved in any communication (whether oral or in writing) likely to or intended to have the effect that any M&A Project Employee places a ban, limitation or restriction on the performance of work on the M&A Project;

(b) advising, encouraging or inducing or attempting to advise, encourage or induce any M&A Project Employee not to carry out work on the M&A Project at any time when required or requested to do so by the second applicant or by his or her employer.

3. Until the final determination of these proceedings or earlier order the first and second respondents (whether by their officers, delegates or employees, or howsoever otherwise) and the fourth and fifth respondents be restrained from:

(a) advising any M&A Subcontractor, whether orally or in writing, that they should not carry out work on the M&A Project at any time when required or requested to do so by the second applicant;

(b) advising any M&A Subcontractor, whether orally or in writing, that if they do carry out work on the M&A Project, there will or may be an adverse consequence of any kind for the M&A Subcontractor;

(c) taking any action in respect of any M&A Subcontractor in any circumstances if that action has the purpose or the likely effect of inducing the M&A Subcontractor to refuse to carry out work for the M&A Project when required or requested by the second applicant; or

(d) taking any action with the purpose or likely effect of causing detriment to the commercial interests of any M&A Subcontractor in any circumstances because the M&A Subcontractor has carried out or proposes to carry out work on the M&A Project.

4. Until the final determination of these proceedings or earlier the first and second respondents (whether by their officers, delegates or employees or howsoever otherwise) and the fourth and fifth respondents be restrained from engaging or attempting to engage in conduct in concert with any other person which has the purpose or the likely effect of hindering or preventing an M&A Subcontractor from carrying out construction work on the M&A Project including:

(a) advising any M&A Subcontractor, whether orally or in writing, that they should not carry out work on the M&A Project at any time when required or requested to do so by the second applicant;

(b) advising any M&A Subcontractor, whether orally or in writing, that if they do carry out work on the M&A Project, there will or may be an adverse consequence of any kind for the M&A Subcontractor;

(c) taking any action in respect of any M&A Subcontractor in any circumstances if that action has the purpose or the likely effect of inducing the M&A Subcontractor to refuse to carry out work for the M&A Project when required or requested by the second applicant; or

(d) taking any action with the purpose or likely effect of causing detriment to the commercial interests of any M&A Subcontractor in any circumstances because the M&A Subcontractor has carried out or proposes to carry out work on the M&A Project.

5. Until the final determination of these proceedings or earlier order the first and second respondents (whether by their officers, delegates or employees or howsoever otherwise) and the fourth and fifth respondents be restrained from reaching an agreement or arriving at an understanding or attempting to reach an agreement or understanding with any M&A Subcontractor which is entered into or reached or attempted to be entered into or reached for the purpose of preventing or hindering the M&A Subcontractor from carrying out work on the M&A Project as required or requested from time to time by the second applicant.

6. Until the final determination of these proceedings or earlier order the first, second and third respondents (whether by their officers, delegates or employees, or howsoever otherwise) and the fourth to the ninth respondents be restrained from:

(a) advising, encouraging, inciting, aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring any industrial action by any M&A Project Employee;

(b) advising, encouraging, inciting, aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring any M&A Project Employee not to attend for work as required by his or her employer;

(c) Impeding, hindering, preventing or discouraging the entry or exit of persons or vehicles to and from the M&A Project;

(d) organising, encouraging, assisting or participating in a picket line at the entry or exit point of any M&A Project which has the effect of impeding, hindering, preventing or discouraging the entry or exit of persons or vehicles to and from the M&A Project;

(e) placing or leaving any vehicle, trailer or other thing within 100 metres of any entrance or exit to the M&A Project.

7. The orders in paragraph 2, 3 and 6 do not apply to the organising or taking by any person of protected industrial action in accordance with s 408 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) or activity which is not industrial action because of the operation of s 19(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

8. Subject to further Order, the affidavit of Murray Middleton, filed in these proceedings, be provided only to lawyers acting for any respondent (other than any persons employed by respondents) and that the affidavit or its contents not be otherwise disclosed.

9. The matter be listed for further hearing on a date to be fixed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have considered submissions of Counsel, and have formed the view that interlocutory orders should be made in the terms submitted by the applicants, including an undertaking as to damages given by Mr Murdoch SC on behalf of the applicants. I have formed this view for the following reasons.Background to the present hearing The applicants are corporations involved in a major construction project for residential and commercial towers in Fortitude Valley, adjacent to the central business district of Brisbane. The project is located at the corner of McLachlan and Ann Streets, Fortitude Valley, and is known as the “M&A Project”. Employees at the site are employed by the second applicant, Laing O’Rourke Australia Construction Pty Ltd (“LORAC”) which is the head contractor and project manager of the M&A Project, and subcontractors engaged to supply labour and services to the site (“subcontractors”). Those subcontractors include:·Lindores Construction Logistics Pty Ltd (“Lindores”);·QPI Pty Ltd;·Freshmore (QLD) Pty Ltd trading as Advanced Precast (Aust);·Northwest Commercial Industries (QLD) Pty Ltd;·Blue Star Pacific Pty Ltd;·G James Glass & Aluminium Pty Ltd;·Active Platforms Pty Ltd;·Dig It Landscapes Pty Ltd. The orders made by Greenwood J on 15 February 2013 were extensive and detailed. At the ex parte hearing his Honour had before him substantial affidavits sworn on 15 February 2013 by:·Mr Lindsay McGibbon, General Manager – Building Group North. Mr McGibbon is employed by the second applicant;·Mr Pawel Zielinski, a solicitor with carriage of the matter on behalf of the applicants; and·Mr Murray Middleton, Queensland General Manager – Development. Mr Middleton is employed by the Laing O’Rourke group in Queensland. In substance, his Honour’s orders restrained various combinations of the respondents from:·Taking any action or initiating or being involved in any communication likely to have the effect that any employee of LORAC or the subcontractors (“M&A Project Employee”) places a ban or restriction on work at the M&A Project (order 2(a)).·Advising or encouraging any M&A Project Employee not to carry out work on the M&A Project at any time when required to by the employer (order 2(b)).·Advising any M&A Subcontractor that they should not carry out work on the M&A Project when requested by LORAC or taking any action detrimental to the commercial interests of any M&A Subcontractor because they carry out or propose to carry out work on the M&A Project (order 3).·Engaging or attempting to engage in conduct in concert with any other person which has the purpose or likely effect of preventing an M&A Subcontractor from carrying out construction work on the M&A Project (order 4).·Reaching an agreement with any M&A Subcontractor for the purpose of preventing that subcontractor from carrying out work on the M&A Project (order 5).·Advising, encouraging, or procuring industrial action by M&A Project Employees, impeding entry or exit of persons or vehicles to and from the M&A Project, organising a picket line at the M&A Project or placing or leaving any vehicle or other thing within 100 metres of any entrance or exit to the M&A Project (order 6).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I note that the applicants have also asked me to take into consideration in the present proceeding their written submissions before Greenwood J.Evidence before the Court on 22 February 2013 Between the ex parte hearing on 15 February 2013 and the hearing on 22 February 2013 extensive additional affidavit material was filed by both parties. Supplementary affidavits sworn by Mr McGibbon have been filed on behalf of the applicants, in addition to affidavits by Mr Payten. On behalf of the respondents affidavits have been sworn by Messrs Ravbar, Bateman, Close, Ramsay, Griffin and Sutherland.Affidavit of Mr Ravbar In his affidavit sworn 21 February 2013 Mr Ravbar deposed, in summary, as follows:·Mr Ravbar is the Divisional Branch Secretary of the CFMEU in Queensland.·Agreements to which the CFMEU is a party in the building and construction industry in Queensland contain a clause setting the hours of work, generally providing that the ordinary hours of work are between either 5.00 am or 6.00 am and 6.00 pm, and that the maximum number of hours per week per employee is 58 (being 10 hours per day Monday to Friday and 8 hours on Saturday). The standard clause is in the following terms:25. HOURS OF WORK25.1 Except as provided elsewhere in this agreement, the ordinary working hours will be 36 per week (7.2 hours per day) worked between 6.00am and 6.00pm Monday to Friday.25.2 The maximum number of hours worked on site by any employee will be not more than 58 hours per week, which shall be taken to mean no more than 10 hours per day Monday to Friday and 8 hours Saturday. In certain circumstances, hours may be extended to perform works which are critical to the ongoing productivity of other workers on the project or where a critical work task is delayed due to unforeseen circumstances. However, it is agreed that Sunday work and hours in excess of the aforementioned will not be worked unless written agreement is reached between the parties. Whilst such agreement will not be unreasonably withheld, an appropriate consultative process must be implemented prior to agreement being sought.25.3. If an employer is found to have breached the previous sub clause on more than 2 instances in any 28 day period, each employee required to work in excess of the maximum hours shall be paid double time for all hours worked on that day.·This standard clause has been in existence for approximately 6-8 rounds of enterprise bargaining, and has been a feature of the industrial landscape in the commercial construction industry in Queensland for approximately 20 years.·The spread of hours clauses and the lack of provision for shift work reflect the established practice with all of the major subcontractors and most of the major builders that work is not performed outside of the hours of 5.00 am or 6.00 am to 6.00 pm without the agreement of the CFMEU. This practice has existed for approximately 20 years and was developed to reduce the risks associated with employees on construction sites working long hours, at night, or without proper supervision.·He was not aware of any circumstances of a subcontractor electing to perform work outside of these hours without first obtaining the union’s agreement, and further was not aware of any subcontractor engaged by the applicants expressing any dissatisfaction with these arrangements to the CFMEU.·All enterprise bargaining agreements negotiated by the CFMEU in respect of commercial construction contain a clause requiring the employer to consult with employees over major workplace change, which includes changes to employees’ hours of work.·Mr Ravbar was aware of industrial issues on the M&A Project site, in particular:§the manner in which Mr Sutherland was gaining access to the site;§whether Laing O’Rourke management were refusing to accept the proper role of the HSC to direct employees not to perform work that the HSC believed to be unsafe;§the proposal that employees work on RDOs and the lack of notification to the CFMEU of that proposal.·Mr Ravbar attended a meeting with union officials and LORAC employees including Mr McGibbon on 7 January 2013, and at that meeting objected to M&A Project Employees working on RDOs (as this was an important entitlement to be taken) and outside of the 6.00 am to 6.00 pm span of hours (for fatigue and safety reasons). After discussion Mr Ravbar informed Mr McGibbon that the union would not oppose the night work proposed. There was, however, no discussion that night landscaping work might occur that night, and he understood that that it took place.·At a meeting on 14 January 2013 Mr Ravbar attended another meeting with union officials and LORAC employees including Mr McGibbon where night work was discussed. During that meeting:§Mr Ravbar expressed his view that the subcontractors could not perform work outside of 6.00 am to 6.00 pm without union agreement, and that this was a well-established custom and practice for major building contractors;§Mr Ravbar informed Mr McGibbon that the CFMEU would not unreasonably withhold agreement to night works if it was consulted by the applicants, however Mr McGibbon was unwilling to accept that the subcontractors needed the CFMEU’s agreement to perform work outside of core work hours. In relation to this issue, Mr Ravbar deposed at [36] in his affidavit:The CFMEU is unaware of whether Laing O’Rourke want to extend the hours of employees who work during the day to work through the night or whether Laing O’Rourke is preposing (sic) to roster separate crews to work the period outside of 6am to 6pm. Further, the CFMEU is unaware of what arrangements Laing O’Rourke or the subcontractors propose to put in place to regulate the performance of night work so as to ensure that those workers performing night work have a proper break before they resume day work.§Mr McGibbon stated his view that the HSC did not have a right to direct workers not to perform work if the HSC thought it was unsafe, a view Mr Ravbar considered inconsistent with s 85 of the WHS Act;§Mr Ravbar informed Mr McGibbon that Mr McGibbon’s attitude concerning rights of the union in respect of work outside of core hours would lead to further disputes at the M&A Project site, and the CFMEU would not be prepared to authorise any work outside normal hours until the LORAC changed its attitude.·On 15 January 2013 it was clear to Mr Ravbar that Mr McGibbon had been misleading in respect of the amount of night work LORAC had planned, and Mr Ravbar immediately rang Mr McGibbon to raise concerns.·At a meeting on 30 January 2013 Mr Ravbar informed Mr McGibbon that the CFMEU had no overtime ban in place in respect of the M&A Project, but the CFMEU would not authorise the subcontractors that had agreements to work outside of the ordinary hours until LORAC was prepared to properly consult with the union about the risks of working those hours. Mr Ravbar also informed Mr McGibbon that he did not agree with LORAC’s position in relation to right of entry by union officials.·In summary, the CFMEU position is that:§there is no ban on the performance of overtime at the M&A Project;§the union does not oppose the performance of overtime by employees working at the M&A Project;§the CFMEU considers that the subcontractors working at the M&A Project, who have an agreement with the CFMEU, cannot perform work outside of 6.00 am to 6.00 pm without the agreement of the CFMEU;§none of the subcontractors engaged at the M&A Project have sought to consult with the CFMEU or their employees in respect of a change to working hours;§the CFMEU is not presently prepared to authorise the performance of work outside of 6.00 am to 6.00 pm, and will not be prepared to do so until the applicants properly consult with the union and outline a thorough and detailed fatigue management plan and schedule for the performance of that work, and recognise the important role that the WHS Act confers upon the HSC.Affidavit of Mr Bateman

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to whether the applicant has shown that there is a serious question to be tried:·it is sufficient that the applicant show a sufficient likelihood of success to justify the preservation of the status quo pending the trial;·the applicant need not demonstrate more than a 50% chance of ultimate success;·in that light the issue may be understood as whether the applicant has made out a prima facie case for relief;·whether the applicant shows a sufficient likelihood of success depends on the:onature of the rights asserted; andopractical consequences likely to flow from the interlocutory order sought. Particular considerations arise where the grant or refusal of an interlocutory injunction in effect would dispose of the action finally in favour of whichever party succeeded on that application.(Gleeson CJ and Crennan J at [19], Gummow and Hayne JJ at [65]-[72])Consideration Extensive evidence has been filed both in support of and opposing the interlocutory application before me. In my view however, the evidence strongly supports findings that there are serious questions to be tried, that damages would be an inadequate remedy for the applicants, and that the balance of convenience favours the grant of orders sought by the applicants. I take this view for the following reasons.Serious questions to be tried This is not a case where the grant or refusal of an interlocutory injunction in effect would dispose of the action finally in favour of whichever party succeeded on that application. Practical Completion of the residential building in the M&A Project is now scheduled to be achieved by 18 October 2013, some eight months away. The issues between the parties agitated in the originating application for relief will remain alive at least until that date.Workplace rights and adverse action The applicants broadly frame their claim for interlocutory relief in terms of paragraphs 2, 3 and 6 of the originating application filed 15 February 2013. They rely, in summary, on ss 340, 343, 348, 362, 363, 417, 545(1), 545(2), 550, and 793 of the Fair Work Act. In summary:·section 340 provides that a person must not take adverse action against another person because the other person (inter alia) has a work place right, or has or has not exercised or proposed to exercise a workplace right;·section 343 provides that a person must not organise or take or threaten to organise or take any action against another person with intent to coerce the other person, or a third person, to exercise or not exercise a workplace right (including in a particular way);·section 348 provides that a person must not knowingly or recklessly make a false or misleading representation about another person’s obligation to engage in industrial activity;·section 362 provides that, subject to s 550, a person must not advise, encourage or incite a second person to take action if that action would contravene a provision of Pt 3-1 of the Fair Work Act;·section 363 defines actions of industrial associations, to include actions of officers of the associations;·section 417 prohibits employers, employees, employee organisations or officers of employee organisations from organising or engaging in industrial action before the nominal expiry date of an enterprise agreement;·section 545 grants wide powers to the Court, including the power to grant injunctions, in respect of the contravention or proposed contravention of civil penalty provisions;·section 550 provides that involvement in a contravention of the Fair Work Act shall be treated in the same way as an actual contravention;·section 793 provides (inter alia) that conduct engaged in on behalf of a body corporate by an officer or agent of the body within the scope of that person’s actual or apparent authority is taken to have been engaged in also by the body.