L Pearse & Co v Eli-Ann Nominees Pty Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   L PEARSE & CO -v- ELI-ANN NOMINEES PTY LTD [No 2] [2023] WADC 94

CORAM:   REGISTRAR JEYAMOHAN

HEARD:   14 AUGUST 2023

DELIVERED          :   17 AUGUST 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIV 3835 of 2018

BETWEEN:   L PEARSE & CO

Plaintiff

AND

ELI-ANN NOMINEES PTY LTD

Defendant (Applicant)

CNH INDUSTRIAL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

Third Party (Respondent)


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Application for leave to discontinue - Costs upon discontinuance - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 23 r 2

Result:

Defendant granted leave to discontinue
Defendant to pay the third party's costs

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : No appearance
Defendant (Applicant) : Mr J T Schombee
Third Party (Respondent) : Mr S M Davies & Mr M A MacLennan

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Not applicable
Defendant (Applicant) : McCabes
Third Party (Respondent) : Bennett & Co

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

ACN 116 149 092 Pty Ltd v Coopers Brewery Ltd [2006] FCA 1119

Alpine Holdings Pty Ltd v Warwick Entertainment Centre Pty Ltd [2003] WASC 53 (S)

Hall v Hall (No 2) [2019] VSC 60

IBN Corporation Pty Ltd v Banjyma Aboriginal Corporation [2009] WASC 279

Kelliher v Commissioner for Main Roads [2013] WASC 437

L Pearse & Co v Eli-Ann Nominees Pty Ltd [2023] WADC 62

Lafferty v Waterton [2016] WASCA 183

McClure v The Mayor and Councillors of the City of Stirling [No 3] [2009] WASC 247; (2009) 170 LGERA 138

Miller v Evans [2010] WASC 127 (S)

One.Tel Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2000] FCA 270; (2000) 101 FCR 548

Peet Ltd v Richmond [2010] VSCA 71

Re The Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs of the Commonwealth of Australia; Ex parte Lai Qin [1997] HCA 6; (1997) 186 CLR 622

Rodgers v De Mol Investments Pty Ltd [No 2] [2016] WASC 151

Walter v Buckeridge [No 4] [2011] WASC 313

REGISTRAR JEYAMOHAN:

Introduction and summary

  1. By chamber summons dated 15 November 2022 the defendant seeks the following orders (Application):[1] 

    1.The defendant have leave to discontinue the third party proceedings.

    2.There be no order as to costs in the third party proceedings.

    [1] The defendant sought leave on 30 May 2023 to amend the Application to an application for leave to discontinue the third party proceedings with no order as to costs under O 23 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) (RSC). Leave to amend the Application in the terms sought was granted on 31 May 2023.

  2. At the hearing of the Application on 8 March 2023, the defendant took issue with the admissibility of evidence sought to be relied upon by the third party in response to the Application, specifically the affidavits of Mark Alan MacLennan sworn 21 February 2023 (MacLennan Affidavit) and Colin Timothy Bignell affirmed 19 March 2021 (Bignell Affidavit) (Preliminary Issue).  In my reasons for decision of the Preliminary Issue delivered 16 June 2023, I determined that it is not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read L Pearse & Co v Eli-Ann Nominees Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WADC 94
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of L Pearse & Co v Eli-Ann Nominees Pty Ltd [No 2] concerned an application for leave to discontinue proceedings and the associated issue of costs upon discontinuance. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The applicant, L Pearse & Co, sought leave to discontinue the proceedings, and the respondent, Eli-Ann Nominees Pty Ltd, opposed the application on the grounds of costs.

The legal issues before the court were whether the applicant had acted reasonably in bringing the proceedings and in discontinuing them, and whether the court should exercise its discretion to award costs to either party. The court needed to determine the appropriate costs order in light of the discontinuance of the proceedings, considering the circumstances surrounding the discontinuance and the conduct of both parties.

The court considered the principles established in previous cases, including Lai Qin and Walter v Buckeridge, which emphasised that if both parties have acted reasonably, the court should generally make no order as to costs. However, the court also noted that even if a party acts reasonably in commencing proceedings, it does not necessarily mean that there should be no order for costs if the proceedings are discontinued. The court must consider the reason for the discontinuance and whether there has been a supervening event that removes or modifies the subject of the dispute. In this case, the court found that both parties had acted reasonably and that there was no clear reason why one party should bear the costs. Consequently, the court exercised its discretion and made no order as to the costs of the proceedings.

The court ordered that leave to discontinue be granted to L Pearse & Co and that there be no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

If both parties have acted reasonably in commencing and defending the proceedings and continued to act reasonably until the discontinuance of the proceedings, the proper exercise of the discretion as to costs will usually mean that the court makes no order as to costs. As was stated by McHugh J in Re The Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs of the Commonwealth of Australia; Ex parte Lai Qin, where there has been no hearing on the merits of the case:[8]The court cannot try a hypothetical action between the parties. To do so would burden the parties with the costs of a litigated action which by settlement or extra-curial action they had avoided. … …If it appears that both parties have acted reasonably in commencing and defending the proceedings and the conduct of the parties continued to be reasonable until the litigation was settled or its further prosecution became futile, the proper exercise of the cost discretion will usually mean that the court will make no order as to the cost of the proceedings.(citations omitted)[8] Re The Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs of the Commonwealth of Australia; Ex parte Lai Qin [1997] HCA 6; (1997) 186 CLR 622, 624 - 625 (Lai Qin). However, even if a party acts reasonably in commencing proceedings, it does not follow there should be no order for costs in the event the proceedings are discontinued. The question must be looked at from the perspective of both the plaintiff and the defendant.[9][9] Walter v Buckeridge[No 4] [2011] WASC 313 [13] - [14], [19]. In considering the appropriate costs order, it is necessary to consider the reason for the discontinuance of the proceedings. As was noted by Burchett J in One.Tel Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation:[10]In my opinion, it is important to draw a distinction between cases in which one party, after litigating for some time, effectively surrenders to the other, and cases where some supervening event or settlement so removes or modifies the subject of the dispute that, although it could not be said that one side has simply won, no issue remains between the parties except that of costs. In the former type of case, there will commonly be lacking any basis for an exercise of the Court's discretion otherwise than by an award of costs to the successful party. It is the latter type of case which more often creates problems, since there may be difficulty in discerning a clear reason why one party, rather than the other, should bear the costs. …[10] One.Tel Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2000] FCA 270; (2000) 101 FCR 548 [6]. In ACN 116 149 092 Pty Ltd v Coopers Brewery Ltd,[11] Finn J granted leave to the plaintiff to discontinue the proceedings but ordered it to pay the defendant's costs. Finn J stated:[12]As I foreshadowed, I am satisfied that an order for costs is appropriate. While it cannot be said that the institution of this proceeding was in any way unreasonable - it was one of a complex of legal manoeuvres in a hostile takeover bid - it was done in the full knowledge that, consequent upon the decision of Perry ACJ, Coopers would act to alter its constitution to remove Lion Nathan Australia's pre-emptive rights and exemptions unless either that decision was reversed on appeal or the holding of the necessary extraordinary general meeting could be prevented. Neither of these contingencies eventuated. From its inception this matter contained the seeds of its own futility, yet ACN was prepared to proceed and to put Coopers to its defence. In so doing ACN assumed the risk of the proceedings becoming futile. It cannot escape the consequences of that by the assertion that it nonetheless conducted itself reasonably. It gambled and it lost. It is entirely appropriate that it pay Coopers' costs occasioned by the discontinued claim including reserved costs and its costs of this motion.[11] ACN 116 149 092 Pty Ltd v Coopers Brewery Ltd [2006] FCA 1119.[12] ACN 116 149 092 Pty Ltd v Coopers Brewery Ltd [22].