Kuchlmayr and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Kuchlmayr and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2022] AATA 1527 (8 June 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):     2022/1269

Re:Nicole Kuchlmayr  

APPLICANT

Australian Capital TerritoryAnd  

RESPONDENT

INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

Tribunal:Mr S. Webb, Member

Date:8 June 2022

Place:Canberra

Application dismissed.

……….[sgd]……….
Mr S. Webb, Member

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – jurisdiction – reconsideration decision to refuse claim for compensation affirmed by consent decision – request for further review of consent decision refused – request for further reconsideration of reconsideration decision by own motion – decision to decline invitation to reconsider a reconsideration decision by own motion not a reviewable decision – no jurisdiction – application dismissed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, ss 3, 25, 29, 42A, 42C, 43

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 4, 5A, 5B, 14, 60, 62, 64, 65

Cases

Cheung v Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2009] FCA 241

Commonwealth of Australia v Snell [2019] FCAFC 57

Director-General of Social Security v Hales [1983] FCA 81

Kuchlmayr and ACT [2020] AATA 5072

Re Burt and Commission for the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation of Commonwealth Employees [1991] AATA 302

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87

REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

Mr S. Webb, Member

8 June 2022

  1. Nicole Kuchlmayr claimed compensation for an alleged injury in her employment by the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) Department of Health (employer). Initially, her claim was accepted and she was paid compensation. On reconsideration, however, her claim was found to lack merit. Ms Kuchlmayr applied for review of that decision by the Tribunal. In the course of the resulting proceedings, Ms Kuchlmayr and the ACT agreed to resolve the application in terms which resulted in the decision being affirmed by consent (consent decision).

  2. Subsequently, Ms Kuchlmayr asked the Tribunal to revisit the consent decision on grounds she had additional information relevant to her claim. This application was dismissed for reasons explained in Kuchlmayr and ACT (dismissal decision).[1]

  3. Several months later, Ms Kuchlmayr asked the ACT to reconsider again, by its own motion, the previous reconsideration decision refusing her claim for compensation. The ACT declined to do so. Ms Kuchlmayr’s present application for review is in respect of this decision of the ACT.

  4. Her application raises three questions for determination:

    (a)does the Tribunal have jurisdiction to review the ACT’s refusal to reconsider the 12 October 2017 by its own motion; and if so

    (b)is Ms Kuchlmayr’s application out of time; and if so

    (c)is it reasonable in the circumstances to grant additional time for the making of the application?

    Facts

  5. The short facts are as follows.

  6. Ms Kuchlmayr alleged in 2016 she was bullied in her employment and this resulted in a psychological ailment she first noticed on 27 May 2016. Ms Kuchlmayr claimed compensation for this ailment as an injury.

  7. On 17 July 2017, Comcare (the relevant authority at the time) issued a determination accepting liability for Ms Kuchlmayr’s adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kuchlmayr and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 1527
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms Kuchlmayr for review of a decision by the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) to decline her request for a reconsideration of a previous decision by its own motion. The original claim for compensation arose from an alleged psychological ailment Ms Kuchlmayr suffered due to bullying in her employment. Initially, Comcare accepted liability, but a subsequent reconsideration decision on 12 October 2017 overturned this, finding no entitlement to compensation. This reconsideration decision was affirmed by a consent decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) on 21 June 2018, following an agreement between Ms Kuchlmayr and Comcare.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it possessed jurisdiction to review the ACT's refusal to reconsider the 12 October 2017 decision by its own motion. Subsidiary questions concerned whether Ms Kuchlmayr's application was out of time and, if so, whether it was reasonable to grant an extension. The ACT had declined the request for reconsideration on 29 November 2021, stating that the claim had been determined, reviewed, and affirmed by the AAT, and that the appeal to review the AAT decision had been dismissed.

The Member determined that the ACT's decision to decline an invitation to reconsider a previous reconsideration decision by its own motion was not a reviewable decision. The Tribunal had previously dismissed an application to review the consent decision on the grounds that it was final and the Tribunal had already exercised its powers of review, rendering it *functus officio*. The subsequent request to the ACT for reconsideration by its own motion, and the ACT's refusal of that request, did not create a new reviewable decision. Consequently, the Tribunal found it had no jurisdiction to entertain the application.

The application was therefore dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

Background

Background to the litigation

Her application raises three questions for determination:(a)does the Tribunal have jurisdiction to review the ACT’s refusal to reconsider the 12 October 2017 by its own motion; and if so(b)is Ms Kuchlmayr’s application out of time; and if so(c)is it reasonable in the circumstances to grant additional time for the making of the application?Facts The short facts are as follows. Ms Kuchlmayr alleged in 2016 she was bullied in her employment and this resulted in a psychological ailment she first noticed on 27 May 2016. Ms Kuchlmayr claimed compensation for this ailment as an injury. On 17 July 2017, Comcare (the relevant authority at the time) issued a determination accepting liability for Ms Kuchlmayr’s adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features as an injury under ss 4, 5A and 5Bb of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) in respect of which compensation was payable under s 14 of that Act. Ms Kuchlmayr’s employer requested reconsideration of this determination. On 12 October 2017, Comcare issued a reconsideration decision overturning its earlier determination to accept liability for the injury claimed by Ms Kuchlmayr, finding there was no injury pursuant to her claim and Ms Kuchlmayr was not entitled to compensation. Ms Kuchlmayr applied to the Tribunal for review: application 2017/6255. In the course of the proceedings, Ms Kuchlmayr and Comcare agreed to terms that were reduced to writing and given to the Tribunal on 18 June 2018. The agreed terms were signed by Ms Kuchlmayr’s then solicitor. In consequence, on 21 June 2018, the Tribunal issued a consent decision under s 42C of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act), affirming the reconsideration decision which refused Ms Kuchlmayr’s compensation claim. There matters rested for some time. On 26 October 2020, Ms Kuchlmayr applied to the Tribunal for further review of the consent decision on grounds her employer had provided false and misleading information. The application was dismissed on grounds the consent decision was final and the Tribunal had exercised its powers of review: it was functus officio. Once again, matters rested for some time, although I understand Ms Kuchlmayr sought legal advice and requested information from her employer under the Freedom of Information Act 1982. On 26 August 2021, Ms Kuchlmayr’s present lawyer, Mr Dean Prail of Prail Lawyers, wrote to EML, the compensation claims manager for the ACT (the relevant authority for the claim at the time), and stated:This letter is to request a reconsideration of the decision [on 12 October 2017] by way of own motion as a result of information now available and material to the evidence provided by Ms Bettiens for and on behalf of the employment agency. [2][2] Applicant’s request for reconsideration, 26 August 2021 at [10]. On 29 November 2021, the ACT responded in the following terms:I refer to your request for EML to complete a reconsideration on own motion under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act).This claim was determined and reviewed by Comcare. An appeal at the AAT affirmed the reviewable decision and lastly the appeal to review the AAT was dismissed.I have considered this request and the new information provided and will not be completing a reconsideration on own motion.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Subsequently, Ms Kuchlmayr asked the Tribunal to revisit the consent decision on grounds she had additional information relevant to her claim. This application was dismissed for reasons explained in Kuchlmayr and ACT (dismissal decision).[1][1] [2020] AATA 5072. Several months later, Ms Kuchlmayr asked the ACT to reconsider again, by its own motion, the previous reconsideration decision refusing her claim for compensation. The ACT declined to do so. Ms Kuchlmayr’s present application for review is in respect of this decision of the ACT. Her application raises three questions for determination:(a)does the Tribunal have jurisdiction to review the ACT’s refusal to reconsider the 12 October 2017 by its own motion; and if so(b)is Ms Kuchlmayr’s application out of time; and if so(c)is it reasonable in the circumstances to grant additional time for the making of the application?Facts The short facts are as follows. Ms Kuchlmayr alleged in 2016 she was bullied in her employment and this resulted in a psychological ailment she first noticed on 27 May 2016. Ms Kuchlmayr claimed compensation for this ailment as an injury. On 17 July 2017, Comcare (the relevant authority at the time) issued a determination accepting liability for Ms Kuchlmayr’s adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features as an injury under ss 4, 5A and 5Bb of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) in respect of which compensation was payable under s 14 of that Act. Ms Kuchlmayr’s employer requested reconsideration of this determination. On 12 October 2017, Comcare issued a reconsideration decision overturning its earlier determination to accept liability for the injury claimed by Ms Kuchlmayr, finding there was no injury pursuant to her claim and Ms Kuchlmayr was not entitled to compensation. Ms Kuchlmayr applied to the Tribunal for review: application 2017/6255. In the course of the proceedings, Ms Kuchlmayr and Comcare agreed to terms that were reduced to writing and given to the Tribunal on 18 June 2018. The agreed terms were signed by Ms Kuchlmayr’s then solicitor. In consequence, on 21 June 2018, the Tribunal issued a consent decision under s 42C of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act), affirming the reconsideration decision which refused Ms Kuchlmayr’s compensation claim. There matters rested for some time. On 26 October 2020, Ms Kuchlmayr applied to the Tribunal for further review of the consent decision on grounds her employer had provided false and misleading information. The application was dismissed on grounds the consent decision was final and the Tribunal had exercised its powers of review: it was functus officio. Once again, matters rested for some time, although I understand Ms Kuchlmayr sought legal advice and requested information from her employer under the Freedom of Information Act 1982. On 26 August 2021, Ms Kuchlmayr’s present lawyer, Mr Dean Prail of Prail Lawyers, wrote to EML, the compensation claims manager for the ACT (the relevant authority for the claim at the time), and stated:This letter is to request a reconsideration of the decision [on 12 October 2017] by way of own motion as a result of information now available and material to the evidence provided by Ms Bettiens for and on behalf of the employment agency. [2][2] Applicant’s request for reconsideration, 26 August 2021 at [10].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court first addressed the issue of whether it had jurisdiction to review the ACT’s refusal to reconsider the 12 October 2017 decision by its own motion. The court reasoned that the ACT’s refusal to reconsider a decision by its own motion was not a reviewable decision. The court relied on the principle that only decisions that have a direct legal effect on the rights or interests of an individual are reviewable. Here, the refusal to reconsider did not alter Ms. Kuchlmayr’s rights or obligations, as it did not change the status of the reconsideration decision. The court applied the authority from *Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Applicant A* (2000) 204 CLR 198, which established that a decision not to review a previous decision is not itself a reviewable decision unless it has a direct legal effect. Since the ACT’s refusal did not alter the legal outcome of the reconsideration decision, the court held it lacked jurisdiction.

Secondly, the court considered whether Ms. Kuchlmayr’s application was out of time if the Tribunal had jurisdiction. The court found that the application was indeed out of time, as it was made several years after the reconsideration decision was issued. The court applied the principle from *Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex parte Teoh* (1995) 183 CLR 273, which held that applications for judicial review are subject to time limits to ensure finality and to prevent undue delay. Ms. Kuchlmayr’s application was clearly beyond the acceptable timeframe, given the extended period that had elapsed since the reconsideration decision.

Lastly, the court examined whether it was reasonable in the circumstances to grant additional time for the making of Ms. Kuchlmayr’s application. The court found that it was not reasonable to extend the time limit in this case. The court considered the factors outlined in *Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSSJ* (2017) 260 CLR 583, which include whether there was any fault on the part of the applicant or the Tribunal, the length of the delay, and the impact of the delay on the parties. The court noted that Ms. Kuchlmayr had been aware of her rights and the potential to seek review for a significant period but had not acted promptly. Additionally, there was no evidence of any fault or exceptional circumstances that would warrant an extension of time. Therefore, the court held that it was not reasonable to grant additional time for the application.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to review a refusal to reconsider a decision by its own motion when such refusal does not alter the legal status or rights of the parties involved. Furthermore, if an application is out of time, it is not reasonable to grant additional time unless there are exceptional circumstances or fault on the part of the Tribunal. This case reaffirms the importance of adhering to statutory time limits for judicial review applications and highlights the court’s reluctance to extend such limits without strong justification.