Kuchlmayr and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2023] AATA 2305 (1 August 2023)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s): 2022/6558
Re:Nicole Maree Kuchlmayr
APPLICANT
Australian Capital TerritoryAnd
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Mr S. Webb, Member
Date:1 August 2023
Place:Canberra
Objections upheld.
...............[SGD]..............................
Mr S. Webb, Member
Catchwords
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – review of decision refusing compensation claim in respect of alleged injury – summons – objection to production – scope of summons – relevance – objections upheld
Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 40A
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 5A, 5B, 14
Cases
BrisConnections Finance Pty Ltd (Receiver and Manager Appointed) v Arup Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 906
Comcare v Maganga [2008] FCA 285
Hamilton v Oades [1989] HCA 21
Hunt v Wark (1985) 40 SASR 489
Kuchlmayr and Australian Capital Territory [2020] AATA 5072
Kuchlmayr and Australian Capital Territory [2022] AATA 1527
Lakatoi Universal Pty Limited and Ors v Walker and Ors [1998] NSWSC 470
Re Trade Practices Commission v Arnotts Pty Ltd & Ors [1989] FCA 248
Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 42) [2023] FCA 750
Wong v Sklavos [2014] FCAFC 120
REASONS FOR DECISIONMr S. Webb, Member
1 August 2023
Nicole Kuchlmayr claimed compensation in respect of an alleged injury in her employment by the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) Department of Health (ACT Health). Employers Mutual Limited (EML), the ACT’s compensation claims manager, decided to refuse her claim. This decision was affirmed on reconsideration. Ms Kuchlmayr lodged an application for review of the decision by the Tribunal.
In the course of the resulting proceedings, Ms Kuchlmayr’s legal representative, Mr Dean Prail of Prail Lawyers, applied to summons records of the ACT Integrity Commission (Commission). A summons was sealed and issued. The Commission partially complied with the summons and objected to production of internal documentation. Mr Prail opposed the objection and pressed for full production by the Commission.
It is the Commission’s objection which is the subject of this interlocutory decision.
Facts
On 1 July 2017, Ms Kuchlmayr lodged a claim for compensation (1st claim).[1] The claim included the following terms:
[2]
[1] T4.
[2] Ibid folio 16.
On 17 July 2017, Comcare (then responsible for determining compensation claims against the ACT) decided to accept the claim (initial determination).[3] Comcare was satisfied Ms Kuchlmayr suffered a ‘disease’ for the purposes of s 5B of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act), namely an adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features ailment to which her employment contributed to a significant degree.[4] Comcare accepted liability for the ‘injury’ under s 14 of the SRC Act and approved compensation in respect of reasonable medical treatment expenses and for time off work from 31 March 2017 to 18 May 2017.
[3] T13.
[4] Ibid folio 266.
The ACT requested reconsideration of the initial determination.
On 12 October 2017, Comcare issued a reconsideration decision revoking the initial determination…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kuchlmayr and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] AATA 2305
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it should exercise its discretion under s 40A(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 to issue a summons compelling the Commission to produce documents requested by Ms Kuchlmayr. The Tribunal was required to determine if the requested documents were relevant and necessary for the proper determination of the compensation claim.
The Tribunal reasoned that the applicant, through their representative Mr Prail, had not provided sufficient justification to warrant the exercise of its discretion to issue the summons. While Mr Prail asserted the documents were relevant, necessary, and reasonable, the Tribunal found this assertion to be insufficient. The Tribunal applied the principle that a party seeking a summons must demonstrate a clear need for the documents and their relevance to the issues in dispute, rather than merely making a general assertion. Consequently, the Tribunal directed Ms Kuchlmayr to provide further and better reasons for the summons request.
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
On 12 October 2017, Comcare issued a reconsideration decision revoking the initial determination (1st reconsideration decision).[5] The reconsideration decision maker decided Ms Kuchlmayr’s ‘disease’ was excluded as an ‘injury’ under s 5A of the SRC Act because it resulted from reasonable administrative action undertaken in a reasonable manner in respect of her employment.[5] T19. Ms Kuchlmayr lodged an application for review of the reconsideration decision by the Tribunal. In the result, on 21 June 2018, following written agreement of the parties, the Tribunal issued a consent decision (consent decision) affirming the reconsideration decision.[6][6] T21. I understand Ms Kuchlmayr obtained further information she considered relevant to her 1st claim under the Freedom of Information Act 1981 (FOI Act).[7][7] See T31, folios 431-432 for example. On 26 October 2020, without legal representation, Ms Kuchlmayr lodged an application for review of the consent decision on grounds ACT Health had provided false and misleading information to Comcare when requesting reconsideration of the initial determination. The Tribunal decided it was functus and dismissed her application for want of jurisdiction under s 42A(4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act).[8][8] Kuchlmayr and Australian Capital Territory [2020] AATA 5072. On 26 August 2021, Mr Prail wrote to EML inviting the ACT to undertake an own motion reconsideration of the 1st reconsideration decision. The ACT declined the invitation and provided written reasons. On 14 February 2022, acting for Ms Kuchlmayr, Mr Prail lodged an application for review on grounds that the ACT’s refusal to undertake an own-motion reconsideration was a reconsideration decision capable of review by the Tribunal. The Tribunal did not agree and dismissed the application for want of jurisdiction.[9][9] Kuchlmayr and Australian Capital Territory [2022] AATA 1527; T29. On 3 May 2022, Ms Kuchlmayr lodged a further compensation claim (2nd claim).[10] The 2nd claim was substantially similar to the 1st claim,[11] although additional supporting materials were provided. It sets out the following information of present relevance:[10] T22.[11] Ibid, folio 382.…18. What is/are the injury(ies) you are claiming for? Psychological injury19. What parts of your body are affected? All20. What happened, and how were you injured?Reprisals from management after raising fraud21. What task(s) were you doing when you were injured?Administration…23. When did the injury occur?Date: 27/05/2016 …24. When did you first notice your injury?27/05/2016… On 1 July 2022, EML decided the claim was in respect of the same alleged injury as the 1st claim. EML determined the claim was not made out and ACT was not liable to pay Ms Kuchlmayr compensation.[12][12] T30. Mr Prail was instructed to request reconsideration of EML’s determination. On 10 August 2022, EML affirmed the determination refusing Ms Kuchlmayr’s 2nd claim. On 15 August 2022, Mr Prail lodged an application for review of EML’s reconsideration decision on 10 August 2022.