Knight Frank Australia Pty Ltd v Paley Properties Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

KNIGHT FRANK AUSTRALIA PTY LTD & ANOR v PALEY PROPERTIES PTY LTD & ORS

[2014] SASCFC 103

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Sulan, The Honourable Justice Blue and The Honourable Justice Parker)

22 September 2014

PROCEDURE - COSTS - GENERAL RULE - COSTS FOLLOW THE EVENT - THIRD PARTIES

PROCEDURE - COSTS - DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE - CONDUCT OF PARTIES - MISCONDUCT, ETC - GENERALLY

PROCEDURE - COSTS - DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE - ORDER FOR COSTS ON INDEMNITY BASIS

The plaintiff, Paley Properties, retained Mr Gambranis, an employee of the land agent Knight Frank Australia, to sell a commercial property. Mr De Chellis made an offer to purchase the property in the name of De Chellis Homes. Ultimately the sale did not proceed. Paley Properties sued De Chellis Homes (first defendant), Mr De Chellis (second defendant), Knight Frank Australia (third defendant) and Mr Gambranis (fourth defendant). De Chellis Homes Pty Ltd also brought a third party claim against the land agents, Knight Frank Australia and Mr Gambranis. The trial judge dismissed the action and consequentially the third party action.

The trial Judge made orders that, despite their being successful, Knight Frank Australia and Mr Gambranis pay the costs of action of Paley Properties against Mr De Chellis, and Mr De Chellis' costs on a solicitor and client basis. This was on the basis of Mr Gambranis' misconduct. Paley Properties was to pay De Chellis Homes' costs of action. No order as to costs of the third party action was made.

Neither party on appeal seeks to disturb the costs orders in so far as they were made in favour of De Chellis Homes or Mr De Chellis. The land agents appeal to this Court against the other cost orders of the trial Judge, and Paley Properties cross-appeals the other costs orders.

Held by Blue J (Sulan and Parker JJ agreeing) allowing the appeal:

1. The general rule is that costs follow the event. However, this is subject to exceptions such as when the costs of litigation have been incurred or inceased by a party's misconduct (at [5]).

2.  The first step is to determine whether the conduct of a party constitutes misconduct within the meaning of established authorities. The second step, if there is misconduct, is to analyse whether, and if so, the extent to which, the misconduct caused the litigation, its continuation or extent. The third step, if there is causation, is to determine the appropriate costs order (at [57]-[59]).

3. The trial Judge's discretion miscarried because she did not clearly identify the precise conduct of Mr Gambranis said to amount to misconduct, why this caused costs to be incurred in the  litigation and finally whether the land agents should be deprived of their own costs, pay their opponents' costs on a party and party basis or pay their costs on a solicitor and client basis (at [60]-[65]).

4. There was an inherant inconsistency in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Knight Frank Australia Pty Ltd v Paley Properties Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASCFC 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned a costs appeal before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia, involving Knight Frank Australia Pty Ltd (Knight Frank) and Paley Properties Pty Ltd (Paley Properties). The underlying dispute, which had been the subject of a trial, involved the sale of a commercial property. While the primary dispute between the parties was not the focus of this appeal, the court was required to determine the appropriate costs orders arising from that trial, particularly concerning the liabilities between Knight Frank and Paley Properties in relation to costs ordered in favour of third parties, De Chellis Homes and Richard De Chellis.

The central legal issues before the Full Court were whether the trial judge had erred in her costs orders, specifically in relation to Paley Properties' application for its costs against Knight Frank, and whether the court should depart from the usual rule that costs follow the event. The parties sought "Bullock orders" against each other, which are orders where a defendant who has incurred costs in defending a claim brought by a third party, and who is entitled to costs against the plaintiff, can recover those costs from the plaintiff. In this context, the appeal focused on the allocation of liability for costs between Knight Frank and Paley Properties, particularly in light of their respective conduct and the orders made in favour of the De Chellis parties.

The Full Court found that the trial judge had failed to address Paley Properties' application for its costs against Knight Frank. The court noted that both Knight Frank and Paley Properties were seeking Bullock orders against each other concerning their respective liabilities to the De Chellis parties. The court applied the general principle that costs follow the event, but also considered the conduct of the parties in determining whether to depart from this rule or to order costs on an indemnity basis. The court ultimately remitted the matter back to the trial judge to determine the outstanding costs issues, including Paley Properties' application for its costs against Knight Frank and the appropriate basis for any such orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Neither party on appeal seeks to disturb the costs orders insofar as they were made in favour of De Chellis Homes or Richard De Chellis under the first order part (b) or the second order, but rather seek Bullock orders against each other in relation to their respective liabilities to the De Chellis parties under those orders. Accordingly, De Chellis Homes and Richard De Chellis took no part on the costs appeal.BackgroundEvents on 18–20 August 2009 Paley Properties was the owner of a commercial property at 245 Greenhill Road Dulwich. David Paley was its sole director and shareholder. Single storey retail premises were constructed on the land. Paley Properties had in June 2009 obtained development plan consent, but not development approval, for the demolition of the premises and the construction of a two storey retail/office building. De Chellis Homes was a commercial property developer. It had two directors and shareholders: Richard De Chellis and his father Mario De Chellis. Clause 128 of De Chellis Homes’ Constitution addressed the manner of execution of documents by or on behalf of the company. Richard and Mario De Chellis were also directors and shareholders of De Chellis Constructions Pty Ltd, a residential builder. Knight Frank Australia was a registered commercial land agent. Peter Gambranis was a registered sales representative employed by Knight Frank Australia. On 18 August 2009, Paley Properties appointed Knight Frank Australia as its agent to sell the property for $1.6 million (plus GST).[10] That same day, Mr Gambranis met with a prospective buyer, Richard De Chellis (Mr De Chellis), at the De Chellis Constructions office. Mr Gambranis told Mr De Chellis about the property and the proposal that it be redeveloped as two storey retail/office premises. At that stage, Mr De Chellis had not seen the property, nor was he given any plans or other documentation relating to the redevelopment proposal. Mr De Chellis made a verbal offer to purchase the property in his own name (and/or nominee) for $1.5 million with a deposit of $50,000 and settlement within 60 days.[10] All figures are exclusive of GST, unless otherwise stated. On 19 August 2009, Mr Gambranis returned to the De Chellis Constructions office with two copies of a contract for the sale of the property to Mr De Chellis and/or nominee for $1.5 million. Mr De Chellis had still not seen the property. He was not given a form 1 vendor’s statement[11] or plans or other documentation relating to the redevelopment proposal.[12] [11] Land and Business (Sale and Conveyancing) Act 1994 (SA) section 7; Land and Business (Sale and Conveyancing) Regulations 1995 (SA) regulation 7. It was not mandatory to provide a vendor statement to a purchaser before execution of a contract. Section 7 only required that it be served at least 10 days before settlement. However, if a vendor’s statement were not provided before execution of a contract, there was a greater risk that the purchaser would seek to avoid the contract, or alternatively claim damages, for non-disclosure or misrepresentation in relation to a matter which would have been disclosed in the vendor statement. Accordingly, it may be expected that generally agents would serve a vendor statement on a purchaser before execution of a contract.[12] There was a contest at trial between Mr Gambranis and Mr De Chellis as to what was said on the topic of development approval, but the trial Judge did not make findings on that issue and neither party on appeal invites this Court to do so.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 1 November 2013, the trial Judge delivered reasons for judgment on costs. Paley Properties observed that the trial Judge did not address in her reasons its application that the land agents pay its costs of action as against them. The trial Judge subsequently heard argument from the parties whether such an order should be made and declined to make such an order. Reasons for trial judge’s judgment on costs At all stages throughout the action, Mr Gambranis and Knight Frank Australia were jointly represented and no distinction was drawn between the liabilities or entitlements of Mr Gambranis and Knight Frank Australia in the action or for costs. The same applies in the costs appeal. For convenience, from this point onwards, I refer only to Mr Gambranis on the basis it is understood that Knight Frank Australia is jointly liable and has joint entitlements with him. On the costs argument, Paley Properties did not oppose an order that it pay the costs of action of De Chellis Homes and Mr De Chellis on a party and party basis. It sought an order that Mr Gambranis pay its costs of the entire proceedings and indemnify it for any adverse costs orders to be made against it in favour of the De Chellis parties. The De Chellis parties sought costs against Paley Properties on an indemnity basis or in the alternative on a solicitor and client basis after 9 July 2011, following their filing of a formal offer to settle the action under rule 187 of the District Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) (the Rules). The De Chellis parties sought costs on a party and party basis for the period before 9 July 2011. Mr Gambranis sought orders that Paley Properties pay his costs of action on an indemnity basis from April 2012, and that De Chellis Homes pay his costs of the third party action on an indemnity basis. The trial Judge in her reasons for judgment addressed the issues in the following sequence:1.Should Mr Gambranis be deprived of orders for costs of action in his favour against Paley Properties because of misconduct alleged against him by Paley Properties and the De Chellis parties?2.Should Mr Gambranis be ordered to pay the costs of action of De Chellis Homes and Paley Properties’ costs of action against De Chellis Homes because of misconduct alleged against him by Paley Properties and the De Chellis parties?3.Should Mr Gambranis be ordered to pay the costs of action of Mr De Chellis and Paley Properties’ costs of action against Mr De Chellis because of misconduct alleged against him by Paley Properties and the De Chellis parties?4.If yes to questions 2 or 3 above, should Mr Gambranis be ordered to pay those costs on a solicitor and client basis because of his misconduct?5.Should Paley Properties be ordered to pay the costs of De Chellis Homes on a party and party or solicitor and client basis?6.What costs orders (if any) should be made in respect of the third party action? The trial Judge did not address the issue arising from the application by Paley Properties against Mr Gambranis for its costs of the action against Mr Gambranis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.