King and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

King and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation) [2024] AATA 244 (20 February 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2022/1713; 2022/2152

Re:Deakon King

APPLICANT

AndK&S Freighters Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

Date:20 February 2024

Place:Perth

On 7 and 9 February 2024 I made the following order:

The Tribunal refuses to grant a confidentiality order under s 35(4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1974 (Cth) over surveillance footage and associated materials obtained by the Respondent and supplementary medical opinion in relation to the events depicted in the surveillance footage, as described and/ or annexed to the affidavit of Mr Snell dated 6 February 2024.

On 9 February 2024, I made the following order:

The Tribunal refuses to give leave to the Respondent to rely upon surveillance footage and associated materials obtained by the Respondent and supplementary medical opinion in relation to the events depicted in the surveillance footage, as described and/ or annexed to the affidavit of Mr Snell dated 6 February 2024.

These are my written reasons for the above orders.

.....................[Sgd]...................................................

Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interlocutory orders – workers’ compensation

CONFIDENTIALITY ORDER – Respondent applied for confidentiality order under s 35(4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) over video surveillance and associated materials (surveillance evidence) – ex-parte hearing in the absence of the Applicant to determine whether confidentiality order should be granted – procedural fairness – application for confidentiality order made by Respondent six business days before substantive hearing listed to commence – confidentiality order refused – Applicant previously unaware of existence of surveillance evidence and has not seen the evidence – Hayes and Bessey distinguished – trend in the case law towards a “cards on the table” approach

LEAVE TO RELY ON SURVEILLANCE EVIDENCE – further interlocutory hearing to determine whether Respondent should be given leave to rely on surveillance evidence – Respondent sought to rely on surveillance evidence less than 28 days before substantive hearing listed to commence – leave for Respondent to rely on surveillance evidence refused – unnecessary to decide whether surveillance evidence attracts legal professional privilege because leave refused

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 2A, 35(4)

Safety, Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) s 14

CASES

Australian Postal Commission and Hayes (1989) 23 FCR 320

Australian Postal Corporation v Bessey [2001] FCA 266

Boyes v Colins [2000] WASCA 344

Buttigieg and Comcare [2017] AATA 1002

Comcare v Maganga [2008] FCA 285

Digby v Essex County Council [1994] PIQR P53

Esso Australia Resources v Commissioner of Taxation [1999] HCA 67

Khan v Armaguard Ltd [1994) 3 All ER 545

Morton v Colonial Life Assurance Society Limited [2013] FCA 681

Re Stoiche and Telstra Corporation Ltd (1995) 40 ALD 369

Re Taxation Appeals NT 94/281-291 (1995) 30 ATR 1279

Tuimaseve v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 396

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Administrative Appeals Tribunal General Practice Direction

Administrative Appeals Tribunal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read King and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerned an application by the Respondent, K & S Freighters Pty Limited, for a confidentiality order under s 35(4) of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975* (Cth) regarding video surveillance and associated materials. The Applicant, King, was not present at the ex-parte hearing where this application was considered, having been unaware of the existence of the surveillance evidence. The Respondent sought to withhold this evidence until after the Applicant's cross-examination, arguing it was necessary to prevent the Applicant from tailoring his evidence dishonestly.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether to grant the confidentiality order, considering principles of procedural fairness and the Respondent's stated need to conduct effective cross-examination. Additionally, the Tribunal had to consider whether to grant the Respondent leave to rely on this surveillance evidence, given that it was lodged less than 28 days before the substantive hearing, contrary to the Tribunal's practice directions.

The Tribunal refused to grant the confidentiality order. It noted that the Respondent's application was made only six business days before the substantive hearing, and the Applicant had no prior knowledge of the evidence. The Tribunal distinguished this case from precedents where confidentiality orders had been granted, indicating a trend towards a "cards on the table" approach in proceedings. Furthermore, the Tribunal refused to grant the Respondent leave to rely on the surveillance evidence due to its lateness, noting that the Respondent had obtained the material significantly earlier, including reports from mid-2022 and May 2023, yet only sought to rely on it shortly before the hearing. The Tribunal considered the timeline of events, including further surveillance arranged after a direction for the Respondent to file evidence by August 2023, as relevant to the refusal of leave.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The details of that evidence were set out in an affidavit of Mr Snell. At 8:55am AWST on the morning of the ex-parte hearing, the Respondent lodged with the Tribunal an unsigned affidavit of Mr Snell with Annexures. Before the hearing commenced, a signed and witnessed version was filed. The affidavit included the timeline for the surveillance and outlined the Surveillance Evidence that had been obtained. Consequently, when drafting refusal to grant the confidentiality order, I referred to the Surveillance Evidence by reference to Mr Snell’s affidavit as “surveillance footage and associated materials obtained by the Respondent and supplementary medical opinion in relation to the events depicted in the surveillance footage, as described and/ or annexed to the affidavit of Mr Snell dated 6 February 2024”. For clarity, this is what I referred to above as the Surveillance Evidence. The confidentiality order was sought so that the Respondent would not be required to disclose the existence or content of the Surveillance Evidence to the Applicant prior to his cross-examination, at which time the Respondent could elect to put that material to the Applicant. This was the first time the Tribunal was alerted to the existence of the Surveillance Evidence. As I stated above, Friday 2 February 2024 was the sixth business day before the commencement of the substantive hearing, listed to commence on Monday 12 February 2024. An Associate from the Tribunal emailed Mr Snell on the afternoon of Friday 2 February 2024 to advise my availability for the ex-parte hearing subsequently scheduled for Tuesday 6 February 2024. I conducted that hearing at 11.30am AWST on Tuesday 6th February 2024. Mr Seymour of counsel appeared for the Respondent, instructed by Mr Snell. There was precedent for hearing an ex-parte application in cases concerning surveillance footage and associated materials such as Re Stoiche and Telstra Corporation Ltd (1995) 40 ALD 369 and Buttigieg and Comcare [2017] AATA 1002. Immediately prior to that interlocutory hearing, the Respondent filed a document titled, “Respondent’s submissions on s 35(4) application” (s 35 Submissions) comprising [35] paragraphs. The first two paragraphs of the s 35 Submissions succinctly summarise the Respondent’s submissions:The Respondent’s Application under s 35 (4)1. The Respondent, for reasons set out further below, seeks an order that it be permitted to withhold, until the Applicant has been cross-examined by it, certain material obtained by it in circumstances attracting legal professional privilege.2. It makes that application in order that it be permitted to properly conduct its case, and in particular that it might undertake effective cross-examination of the Applicant, in circumstances where the Respondent says:• the evidence suggests the Applicant has not been candid about matters concerning his health and capacity• his disputed conditions are both conditions as to the existence, consequences and severity of which the Tribunal is largely dependent upon an assessment of his credit and the truthfulness of his account to experts,• it apprehends that if aware of the material when giving evidence in chief he will likely tailor his evidence dishonestly to accommodate it.

Decision

Reasons for decision

So do the last three paragraphs of the Respondent’s s 35 Submissions:Conclusion34. The Respondent submits that by reason of the large number of instances identified above in which, when given the opportunity to give a candid account of his history, he has given plainly misleading or frankly untruthful answers, the likelihood is that if the Applicant is made aware of the surveillance material and medical reports based upon them, he will similarly give untruthful evidence to the Tribunal in an effort to accommodate it.35. For that reason, the Respondent contends that the orders sought are:-• necessary for it to properly conduct its case;• unlikely to cause substantial prejudice to the Applicant or undue disruption to the conduct of the case;• may shorten other aspects of the case and• to the extent any such disruption or prejudice might be unavoidable, the balance of convenience favours the making of orders that are conducive to it receiving an accurate appreciation of the facts in issue, rather than one likely to be untruthful or misleading.36. Accordingly, the Tribunal ought therefore make the orders sought by the Respondent under s 35 (4). Mr Seymour’s submissions for the Respondent at the ex-parte hearing expanded upon and reiterated these written submissions. In summary, Mr Seymour argued that the Respondent would be denied procedural fairness if they were not granted the confidentiality order because:·The case was dependent on the evidence of the Applicant. Whether he suffered from the claimed injuries could not be established by independent, objective evidence. Therefore, the Applicant’s account, and his credibility, is “critical” to the outcome of the applications.·The opinions of the medical experts were dependent of the Applicant’s self-reporting of his symptoms. For example, the Respondent submitted that the claimed psychological injury could only be based on what the Applicant self-reported to the medical practitioners assessing him. I will refer to this as the Self-reporting Submission which I will return to in a moment. ·The Applicant has a history of giving untrue answers regarding his prior claims, for example in his pre-employment questionnaire (T5). Consequently, if the Applicant was aware of the existence of the surveillance footage before cross-examination, he would tailor his evidence accordingly. At the ex-parte hearing I raised the issue that the Respondent was required to seek leave from the Tribunal to rely on the Surveillance Material because it was not provided to the Tribunal and the Applicant at least 28 days before the day on which the hearing was listed to commence: see [9.4] and [9.5] of Practice Direction: Lodgement of Documents under s 37 and s 38AA of the AAT Act (Lodgement of Documents Practice Direction) and [4.45] of the General Practice Direction. I expressed concern about the lateness of the material. That concern was, in part, based on the timeline of events set out in Mr Snell’s affidavit, in particular that the Respondent had arranged surveillance from mid-2022, received a report from the private investigation firm in September 2022, received a supplementary report from Dr Ghoshal who had reviewed the footage dated 25 May 2023, and had arranged further surveillance approximately a week after a direction requiring that the Respondent file any further evidence upon which they intended to rely at the hearing by 1 August 2023. I will provide more details about this timeline below because it is relevant to the issue of leave.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.