Khanam v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Khanam v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 966

MIGRATION – application to review decision of Migration Review Tribunal – Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 499 – Subclass UL Sponsored Family Visitor Visa – whether jurisdictional error in decision of Tribunal to refuse grant of Visitor Visa – appellant mother of visa applicant previously granted asylum in Australia – Tribunal’s treatment of question of whether visa applicant’s intention to only to visit Australia genuine – Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) cl 679.224 – Court may but has no obligation to identify other grounds of appeal – principles going to “satisfaction of the Minister” with respect to a condition – whether Tribunal failed to take into account a relevant consideration being the specific circumstances of the visa applicant – whether Tribunal gave genuine consideration to reasons of visa applicant and appellant for the visa applicant’s proposed visit Australia when assessing genuineness of proposed visit under cl 679.224 – whether Tribunal considered the situation of all Ahmadi Muslims in Pakistan instead of the situation of the visa applicant – whether the Tribunal asked itself the wrong question

Held: appeal allowed – jurisdictional error due to failure of Tribunal to ask itself correct question and failure to take into account a relevant consideration – the decision of the Federal Magistrate be set aside – the decision of the Migration Review Tribunal be quashed – the decision be remitted back to a differently constituted Tribunal to be heard and decided again according to law

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 65, s 499
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) Pt 679 of Sch 2

Avon Downs Pty Ltd v FCT (1949) 78 CLR 353 followed
Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic (1993) 43 FCR 280 cited
Craig v South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163 followed
Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 197 ALR 389 followed
Khanam v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2009] FMCA 285 cited
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323 followed
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Maltsin [2005] FCAFC 118 followed
NAIS v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 1 followed
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; ex parte Applicant S20/2002 (2003) 198 ALR 59 followed
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; ex parte Durairajasingham (2000) 168 ALR 407 cited
SZCOQ v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2007] FCAFC 9 cited
SZEJF v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) FCA 724 followed
SZFNK v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2006] FCA 1601 cited
SZLSA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 23 cited

BUSHRA KHANAM v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and MIGRATION REVIEW TRIBUNAL

QUD 105 of 2009

COLLIER J
27 AUGUST 2009
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 105 of 2009

ON APPEAL…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Khanam v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 966
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Khanam v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship involved the appellant, who is the mother of the visa applicant, challenging the decision of the Migration Review Tribunal. The Tribunal had affirmed the decision of the delegate that the visa applicant did not satisfy the requirement under cl 679.224 of Sch 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994, which necessitates the visa applicant satisfying the Minister that the expressed intention to only visit Australia is genuine. The visa applicant, a Pakistani national, had applied for a subclass 679 visa to visit his mother in Australia. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal correctly determined that the visa applicant's intention to only visit Australia was not genuine.

The court found that the Tribunal's approach was appropriate and that it had correctly identified and applied the relevant legislative requirements. The Tribunal had weighed the evidence presented by the visa applicant and the appellant, including the personal circumstances and potential risks the visa applicant faced in Pakistan due to his Ahmadi religious beliefs. Despite the visa applicant's claims of having a successful business and family ties in Pakistan, the Tribunal was not convinced of the genuineness of his intention to return, given the risks he faced. The court further held that the Tribunal's credibility finding, which was a matter of fact, was open to it and was properly made.

The final orders of the court were to allow the appeal, set aside the decision of the Federal Magistrate, quash the decision of the Migration Review Tribunal, and remit the matter back to a differently constituted Tribunal for reconsideration according to law. This decision underscores the importance of the genuineness of intent in visa applications and the Tribunal's role in assessing such intent based on the evidence and relevant considerations.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The decision of Wilson FM be set aside.

3. The decision of the Migration Review Tribunal be quashed.

4. The decision be remitted back to a differently constituted Tribunal to be heard and decided again according to law.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant in these proceedings is the mother of the visa applicant. In summary the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the delegate as it was not satisfied that the express intention of the applicant to only visit Australia was genuine; accordingly the applicant failed to satisfy cl 679.224 of Sch 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (“the Regulations”).Background The visa applicant is a male national of Pakistan born 23 March 1989. He applied for a Sponsored (Visitor) Class UL (subclass 679 (Sponsored Family Visitor)) visa (“subclass 679 visa”) on 25 March 2008. The subclass 679 visa provides for an application by a person seeking to enter Australia for the purposes of visiting an Australian citizen or Australian permanent resident who is, inter alia, a parent of the visa applicant, for a purpose other than related to business or medical treatment. This visa subclass allows a relative (as defined in reg 1.03 of the Regulations) to formally sponsor a visa applicant. In this matter the appellant is one of the sponsors of the visa applicant. It is not in dispute that the appellant is entitled to sponsor the visa applicant as required by the Regulations. The appellant came to Australia in 2005 on a visitor’s visa and was granted a protection visa in 2006 due to the risk of persecution. The visa applicant’s father subsequently came to Australia on a spouse visa. The appellant has a daughter living in Brisbane, and two sons – including the visa applicant – and a daughter still living in Pakistan. The visa applicant has been married since 19 May 2005 and lives with his wife and brother in Rabwah in Pakistan. On his visa application the visa applicant indicated he wants to visit his mother, the appellant, in Australia for 13 days. The visa applicant stated he owns a business, the Nabeel Karyana General Store in Rabwah, and has done so for 3 years and 2 months. He stated that he has sufficient funds in his bank account to visit Australia for a short time.Relevant Legislation The criteria for a subclass 679 visa are found in Pt 679 of Sch 2 to the Regulations. So far as is relevant the criteria are as follows:679.21 Criteria to be satisfied at time of application679.211 The applicant seeks to visit Australia:(a)for the purpose of visiting an Australian citizen, or Australian permanent resident, who is a parent, spouse, de facto partner, child, brother or sister of the applicant; or(b)for a purpose other than a purpose related to business or medical treatment.679.212The applicant has adequate funds, or access to adequate funds, for personal support during the period of the proposed visit to Australia.679.213The period of stay in Australia proposed in the application does not exceed 12 months.679.214 The applicant is sponsored by:(a)a settled Australian citizen, or a settled Australian permanent resident, who:(i)is:(A) a relative of the applicant; or(B) a relative of a person who:(I)is a member of the family unit of the applicant; and(II)is also an applicant for a Subclass 679 visa; and(ii)has turned 18; or(b)a settled Australian citizen, or a settled Australian permanent resident, who:(i)is a member of the Commonwealth Parliament or a State Parliament; or(ii)is a member of the Legislative Assembly of the Australian Capital Territory or the Northern Territory; or(iii)holds the office of mayor; or(c)a Commonwealth government agency or instrumentality or a State or Territory government agency or instrumentality.679.22 Criteria to be satisfied at time of decision679.221The applicant continues to satisfy the criteria in clauses 679.211 to 679.214.679.222The sponsorship referred to in clause 679.214 has been approved by the Minister and is still in force.679.223 If:(a)the applicant’s sponsor is a settled Australian citizen or a settled Australian permanent resident; and(b)the applicant is not a relative of the sponsor, but is included in the sponsorship on the basis that the applicant is a member of the family unit of a person who:(i)is an applicant for a Subclass 679 visa; and(ii)is sponsored by the sponsor; and(iii)is a relative of the sponsor —the person has been granted a Subclass 679 visa.679.224The applicant satisfies the Minister that the expressed intention of the applicant only to visit Australia is genuine.

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J
During the hearing the Tribunal spoke with the appellant and her husband, through an interpreter. The Tribunal also spoke at length with the visa applicant by telephone, through an interpreter.Decision of the Tribunal The Tribunal was not satisfied that the visa applicant’s visit to Australia was genuine as required by cl 679.224 of the Regulations. Satisfaction by the visa applicant of other criteria prescribed by the Regulations was not an issue in the proceedings before the Tribunal. In summary, the Tribunal found as follows:1.In relation to para 8(a) of the Ministerial direction and consideration of personal circumstances which may encourage the visa applicant to return to his home country, the Tribunal accepted that:a.the visa applicant has a wife in Pakistan as well as other family;b.the visa applicant owned a business which the Tribunal accepted was successful and making a profit; andc.the visa applicant owned property.The Tribunal noted that the visa applicant was a member of the Ahmadi religion and that there were many Ahmadis in the region in which the visa applicant lived. The Tribunal accepted that these factors could encourage the visa applicant to return to Pakistan.2.In relation to para 8(b) of the Ministerial direction and consideration of circumstances which may encourage the visa applicant to remain in Australia, the Tribunal found that:a.the visa applicant has significant family ties in Australia in that his parents reside in Australia, as do his sister and her family;b.the visa applicant is a follower of the Ahmadi religion, and based on independent country information the Tribunal is of the view that Ahmadis are currently persecuted in Pakistan. The Tribunal observed:Even though the visa applicant lives in Rabwah, a town originally established by Ahmadis, based on the independent country information the Tribunal believes that he is still at risk of serious harm there. (at [74])Notwithstanding evidence given by the visa applicant and the appellant, the Tribunal did not accept the claims of the visa applicant and the appellant that the visa applicant is somehow safe and not at risk of serious harm in Rabwah, because:Based on the independent country information, the Tribunal considers that being an Ahmadi is sufficient to invite persecution in Rabwah or anywhere in Pakistan. This is a significant factor which may encourage the visa applicant to remain in Australia. (at [78])3.In relation to para 8(c) of the Ministerial direction, although the visa applicant gave evidence that he travelled to India each year for religious reasons, and returned to Pakistan, the Tribunal put “little weight on this return travel as it is to India for religious purposes only; it is not to a free developed country where his parents reside. There has been no previous travel to Australia”. (at [79])4.In relation to para 8(d) of the Ministerial direction and the credibility of the visa applicant in terms of his character and conduct, the Tribunal was not aware of any false or misleading information or documentation presented in relation to the visa application or any other visa application.5.In relation to para 8(e) of the Ministerial direction and the claimed purpose of the applicant’s visit, including the duration of his proposed stay, the Tribunal found:… the stated purpose of the visa applicant’s travel to Australia is to visit his mother and father for 2 to 3 months. The Tribunal accepts that as he runs his own store, he does not need to obtain approved leave. As such, the visa applicant’s plans are reasonable and consistent with the purpose of a visitor visa. (at [81])6.In relation to para 8(f) of the Ministerial Direction the Tribunal noted that there was independent country information available as to the persecution of Ahmadis in Rabwah and Pakistan, that the Tribunal was not aware of any reports as to the numbers of Ahmadis seeking protection in Australia, but was aware that significant numbers of Pakistanis sought protection here.7.In relation to para 8(g) of the Ministerial Direction the Tribunal was not aware of any such profile information or analysis.8.In relation to circumstances of the appellant, who was a proposed sponsor of the visa applicant, the Tribunal noted that she had sought protection in Australia after arriving on a visitor visa in 2005. The Tribunal continued:85. The review applicant has claimed in her oral evidence that it was not her intention to seek protection on first arriving here in Australia, but the circumstances changed so that her husband was at risk of serious harm. It was only because of the change of circumstances that she applied for a protection visa. Her husband supported this claim. However she later agreed that she had sought protection here in 2006 because of the FIR issued in March 2005 against her husband.86. As noted earlier, based on the independent country information, the Tribunal finds that Ahmadis are constantly at risk of serious harm. Thus, the Tribunal does not accept the claim of the review applicant. Rather, the Tribunal finds that it was the review applicant’s intention to seek protection in Australia when she obtained her visitor visa.9.In reviewing other considerations, the Tribunal found that:a.the undertaking of the appellant’s husband that he could be deported if the visa applicant sought protection in Australia was hollow, as it would not happen under Australian law;b.although the Tribunal accepted that the fact of the visa applicant seeking protection in Australia would probably disentitle his siblings obtaining visitor visas in future, this would not prevent the visa applicant seeking protection;c.the claim of the appellant that she could have brought the visa applicant to Australia with her in 2006, because he was a minor of only 16 or 17 at the time, but that he did not wish to come to Australia, lacks substance because at the time the appellant sought asylum the visa applicant, while under 18, was married and no longer a member of the appellant’s “family unit” for the purposes of the relevant legislation;d.although the visa applicant has significant family, business and religious reasons to return to Rabwah, these reasons can be overcome by the visa applicant because he could bring his wife to Australia, sell his business and continue to practise his religion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J

In summary, the Minister further submitted:·The requirements in subclass 679 are cumulative, all of them must be satisfied before the visa can be granted. Determination by the Tribunal that the visa applicant had failed to satisfy requirements of subcl 679.224 was sufficient to resolve the matter against the visa applicant. In light of this finding it was not relevant that the visa applicant may have satisfied the requirements of subcll 679.211-214.·The finding by the Federal Magistrate that the approach of the Tribunal was correct, that it had identified the relevant legislative requirements and that it did not misconstrue or misapply the prescribed visa criteria was correct and did not support a finding of jurisdictional error.·The third ground of appeal was not properly particularised. In any event, as the Federal Magistrate noted the Tribunal member carefully considered the evidence before him and made a decision after weighing that evidence.·The appellant has not contested or raised any alleged jurisdictional error with respect to the consideration of subcl 679.224.·The Tribunal considered the evidence of the visa applicant and the appellant and made a credibility finding in relation to whether the expressed intention only to visit Australia was genuine. A credibility finding is a finding of fact, and a matter for the Tribunal. The Tribunal did not accept the visa or review applicants’ evidence and found the expressed intention was not genuine. This finding was open to the Tribunal.·The Tribunal asked itself the right questions and properly considered the material before it. Wilson FM considered these matters and correctly held that the Tribunal applied the correct test. No error of the Federal Magistrate or jurisdictional error of the Tribunal has been established.Consideration The articulation of the grounds of appeal in this case reflect the difficulties faced by self-represented litigants in pleading grounds of jurisdictional defect, which provide the sole basis for review of decisions of the Tribunal. I consider that the submissions of the Minister with respect to the appellant’s pleaded grounds of appeal have merit. The pleaded grounds of appeal are unparticularised, they do not plead any identifiable ground of jurisdictional error, and they are vague and difficult to follow. In my view the case of the appellant as articulated in her grounds of appeal is not sustainable. However while there is no obligation on the Court, in cases particularly involving a self-represented litigant it is open to the Court to identify other grounds of appeal which the litigant may have missed, but which present an arguable case. This practice is particularly apparent in migration matters where litigants are commonly not only self-represented, but frequently lack English language skills in attempting to address the Court in respect of an area of law of considerable difficulty. The position can be placed no higher – I agree with the observations of Madgwick J in SZFNK v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2006] FCA 1601 at [4]-[5] that no obligation is imposed on the Court to investigate alternative grounds to advance the case of the self-represented litigant.“Satisfaction” of Minister