Teferi (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Teferi (Migration) [2021] AATA 3125 (16 July 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REVIEW APPLICANT:  Miss Emebet Hadgu Teferi

VISA APPLICANT:  Mr Kalayu Hadgu Teferi

CASE NUMBER:  1911681

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2019/155801

MEMBER:Naomi Schmitz

DATE:16 July 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the application for a Visitor (Class FA) visa for reconsideration, with the direction that the visa applicant meets the following criteria for a Subclass 600 (Visitor) (Class FA) visa:

·cl 600.211 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations; and

·cl 600.232 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.

Statement made on 16 July 2021 at 7:17am

ATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – Visitor (Class FA) visa – subclass 600 (Visa) – sponsored family stream –‘Close relative’ requirement met– applicant is being sponsored by a settled Australian citizen –applicant genuinely intends to stay temporarily in Australia– strong incentives to depart Australia –family and work commitment in home country –decision under review remitted

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958, s 65

Migration Regulations 1994, r 1.03, Schedule 2, cls 600.211, 600.232

CASES
Khanam v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2009] FCA 966

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 11 March 2019 to refuse to grant the visa applicant a Visitor (Class FA) visa under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The visa applicant applied for the visa on 18 January 2019. At the time the visa application was lodged, Class FA contained one subclass, Subclass 600 (Visitor), with a number of different streams. In this case the applicant applied for the visa seeking to satisfy the primary criteria in the Sponsored Family stream.

  3. The criteria for a Subclass 600 visa are set out in Part 600 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations). Relevantly to this case, they include cl 600.211, which requires the visa applicant to satisfy the Minister that the visa applicant genuinely intended to stay temporarily in Australia for the purpose for which the visa is granted.

  4. The delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that the visa applicant did not meet cl 600.211 because the delegate was not satisfied that the visa applicant genuinely intended to stay temporarily in Australia. In particular, the delegate did not find the visa applicant’s wife and dependent children, employment status and assets as sufficient inducements to return to Ethiopia. The delegate also found the applicant’s personal circumstance inconsistent with the length of stay requested, namely six months, which raised concerns that the visa applicant intended to travel for reasons other than a genuine temporary stay.

  5. In addition, the delegate was not satisfied that the visa applicant was being sponsored by a ‘relative’ in accordance with cl 600.232 and failed to provide evidence in support. The delegate was therefore not satisfied that at the time of application the visa applicant was being sponsored by a prescribed person.

  6. On 2…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Teferi (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 3125
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a Visitor visa application made by a male applicant from Ethiopia, sponsored by his sister, an Australian citizen. The applicant stated his purpose for visiting Australia was to see his sister and her children, and to experience Australia. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant met the criteria for the visa, specifically concerning sponsorship by a settled Australian citizen and the genuineness of his intention to stay only temporarily in Australia.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant's sister, the review applicant, qualified as a "settled" Australian citizen who could sponsor him under clause 600.232 of the Migration Regulations 1994, and whether the applicant genuinely intended to remain in Australia only temporarily, as required by clause 600.211. The Tribunal had to assess the evidence presented regarding the applicant's ties to his home country, including his business, financial assets, property ownership, and family commitments, as incentives for his return. The Tribunal also considered the general country information regarding Ethiopia's political, economic, and security situation, and whether this presented a disincentive to return, while also adhering to the principle of considering the applicant's individual circumstances.

The Tribunal reasoned that the applicant had provided substantial evidence of his strong ties to Ethiopia, including significant financial assets, ownership of property and vehicles, and the ongoing operation of his machinery rental business, supported by a rental agreement. The Tribunal placed considerable weight on this evidence as incentives for the applicant's return. Furthermore, the applicant's history of complying with previous travel visas to Germany and other countries was considered significant. The Tribunal accepted the evidence of both the applicant and his sister, finding them credible and honest witnesses. The Tribunal also noted the sister's willingness to lodge a security bond, which further indicated the applicant's likely motivation to return. Consequently, the Tribunal was satisfied that the applicant and his sister met the definition of "relatives" for sponsorship purposes, and that the sister was a settled Australian citizen. The Tribunal was also satisfied that the applicant genuinely intended to stay temporarily in Australia.

Accordingly, the Tribunal remitted the application for a Visitor (Class FA) visa for reconsideration, directing that the applicant met the criteria under cl 600.211 and cl 600.232 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.

Background

Background to the litigation

Kalayu Hadgu Teferi is a 48-year-old male from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, who applied for a visitor visa in the sponsored family stream. He is married with five dependent children and owns and operates a construction rental machinery business. His stated purpose of the visit was to visit his sister, who is his only sibling living outside Ethiopia, and to experience Australia. His visa application was accompanied by an investment permit, a bank statement, his passport, a motor vehicle title, and a certified copy of his sister’s Australian citizenship certificate. Before the allocation of the matter, the review applicant supplied various documents including an undated statement, a letter from North Western Mental Health, copies of passports, photographs, and birth certificates. The Tribunal subsequently requested updated information about the visa applicant's employment, business, financial situation, and ownership of property and significant assets. The Tribunal received a bank statement from Lion International Bank SC with a closing balance of $1,003,715.54 birr (equivalent to $30,000.00 AUD), a bank statement for the business ‘Kalayu Hadgu Construction Machine Rental’ with a closing balance of $74,828.95 birr (equivalent to $2,278.60 AUD), a certified marriage certificate, certificates of titles for three properties and three motor vehicles, a business licence, a machinery rental agreement, the visa applicant’s passport, and various other documents.

The visa applicant confirmed that land in Ethiopia is available for lease only and is ‘government owned’. However, he maintained that he owned the buildings on the land. The Tribunal found certified property titles showing evidence of ownership for all three properties, which it placed significant weight on as an incentive to return to Ethiopia. The visa applicant also owns two motor vehicles and a bank account with a balance of $1,003,715.54 birr (equivalent to $30,000.00 AUD). The visa applicant estimated that he earned roughly $10 million birr per annum, which equates to approximately $303,646.00 AUD. The Tribunal placed some weight on these assets as the visa applicant supports his wife and five children. The visa applicant also provided a ‘Machine Rental Agreement’ for 360 days between Kalayu Hadgu Construction Machinery Rental and Tewedros Habtamu and Eden Construction Material Supply Partnership, which the Tribunal found to be reliable and independent evidence of the ongoing nature of the visa applicant’s business into the future. The Tribunal is satisfied that there are sufficient incentives for the visa applicant to return to Ethiopia.

The matter before the Tribunal is a review of a decision made by the Department of Home Affairs regarding the visa application of a 48-year-old male from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, who applied for a visitor visa in the sponsored family stream. The applicant is married with five dependent children and owns a construction rental machinery business. The applicant's sister, a settled Australian citizen, sponsored his visit. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the applicant had been sponsored by a settled Australian citizen or permanent resident who is at least 18 years of age and a relative of the applicant, and whether the applicant genuinely intends to stay temporarily in Australia for the purpose for which the visa is granted. The Tribunal considered various pieces of evidence including property titles, bank statements, a business licence, a machinery rental agreement, and the applicant's travel history. The Tribunal concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration, finding that the visa applicant met the criteria for a Subclass 600 (Visitor) (Class FA) visa under cl 600.211 and cl 600.232 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations. The Tribunal accepted that the visa applicant had sufficient incentives to return to Ethiopia, including property ownership, business interests, and family ties.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The visa applicant is a 48-year-old male from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia who applied for a visitor visa in the sponsored family stream. He is married with five dependent children. He is the owner and operator of a construction rental machinery business. The stated purpose of the visit was to ‘To visit my sister and her kids. She is our only sister who lives abroad outside Ethiopia. Besides to visit the beautiful Australia’. The visa application was accompanied by an investment permit, bank statement, the visa applicant’s passport, a motor vehicle title and a certified copy of the review applicant’s Australian citizenship certificate. Prior to the allocation of the matter, the review applicant supplied to the Tribunal the following; an undated statement explaining the visa applicant’s personal and visa circumstances, a letter from North Western Mental Health dated 2 May 2019 evidencing that the review applicant was ‘engaging in mental health services’, a copy of the visa applicant’s passport, five photographs depicting the visa applicant and review applicant and various family members and the visa applicant and review applicants birth certificates depicting their parents’ names. After this matter was constituted to the Tribunal Member, on 16 June 2021, the Tribunal wrote to the review applicant and requested updated information and records about the visa applicant’s employment, business and financial situation, including ownership of property and significant assets and any other information relevant to the visa applicant’s activities or commitments or relationships in his home country that would encourage him to return at the end of his visit. On 19 June 2021 in response the Tribunal received; a bank statement from Lion International Bank SC with a closing balance on 19 June 2021 of $1,003,715.54 birr (equivalent to $30,000.00 AUD), a bank statement from Lion International Bank SC for the business ‘Kalayu Hadgu Construction Machine Rental’ with a closing balance on 17 March 2021 of $74,828.95 birr (equivalent to $2,278.60 AUD), a certified marriage certificate showing the visa applicant married his wife on 30 June 2004, certificates of titles for three properties and three motor vehicles, a business licence, a machinery rental agreement, the visa applicant’s passport and visas to previous countries he has travelled to including Germany and Uganda and an itemised list of countries the visa applicant has travelled to. The first issue in this case is whether cl 600.232 is satisfied, which requires the Tribunal to be satisfied that the visa applicant has been sponsored by a settled Australian citizen, or a permanent resident, who is at least 18 and: a relative of the applicant; or a relative of another applicant who is a member of the family unit of the applicant; or a relative of another applicant in relation to whom the applicant is a member of the family unit. ‘Settled’ in relation to an Australian citizen, an Australian permanent resident or an eligible New Zealand citizen means lawfully resident in Australia for a reasonable period.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The visa applicant also has three properties, including the ‘family home’ which the visa applicant acquired 15 years ago, an apartment and a 930 square metre block which the visa applicant plans to build on. The Tribunal put to the visa applicant that land in Ethiopia is available for lease only and is ‘government owned’. The visa applicant confirmed this was the case and that leases are for 99 years, but maintained that it was still property held in his name and that he owned the buildings on the land. Ethiopia’s property system appears analogous to owning residential land in Canberra, Australia which is leasehold, where people lease the land for 99 years and can build properties and live on Crown leased land.[1][1] >The Tribunal was provided with certified property titles showing evidence of ownership for all three properties, which the Tribunal places significant weight on as an incentive to return to Ethiopia. There was no evidence before the Tribunal of the visa applicant attempting to sell or dispose of the land or having such an intention. The visa applicant is also the owner of two motor vehicles including a 2010 model Toyota and a 1992 Toyota Landcruiser. The visa applicant also stated his wife owns a 2004 Suzuki motor vehicle. Certified titles of ownership for all three motor vehicles and other identification documents were provided in support which the Tribunal accepts as reliable and cogent evidence. Although all three motor vehicles are 10 years or more old, and arguably disposable assets, the Tribunal understands that ownership of motor vehicles is not high amongst the general population in Ethiopia and therefore places some weight this ownership.[2][2] >The visa applicant also provided to the Tribunal a certified copy of his personal bank account in the name of ‘Kalayu Hadgu Teferi’ with a closing balance at 22 June 2021 of $1,003,715.54 birr which is equivalent to $30,000.00 AUD. The visa applicant also provided a bank statement of his company ‘Kalayu Hadgu Construction Machine Rental’ with a closing balance at 17 March 2021 of $74,828.95 birr equivalent to $2,278.60 AUD. The visa applicant estimated that he earned roughly $10 million birr per annum which equates to approximately $303,646.00 AUD. The Tribunal places some weight on these assets which are not insignificant given the visa applicant is supporting five children and his wife. The Tribunal enquired whether COVID-19 had affected the visa applicant’s business or salary. He stated that it had caused ‘minimum disruption and nothing significant’. The visa applicant also provided as evidence of an incentive to return to Ethiopia a ‘Machine Rental Agreement signed 15 January 2021’ for 360 days between Kalayu Hadgu Construction Machinery Rental and Tewedros Habtamu and Eden Construction Material Supply Partnership. At the time of the hearing there were six months remaining. The visa applicant gave evidence that this was a sample of one of many machine contracts he had to operate his business. The Tribunal is satisfied that this provides reliable and independent evidence of the on-going nature of the visa applicant’s business into the future and places considerable weight on it as an incentive for the visa applicant to return home to Ethiopia. The visa applicant also gave oral evidence and provided copies of his passport, depicting country stamps and various visas evidencing previous travel to Germany and Uganda including:(a)Frankfurt, Germany from 12 February 2017 to 13 March 2017;(b)Frankfurt, Germany from 16 July 2015 until 14 August 2015;(c)Uganda 21 May 2015 – 27 May 2015;(d)Uganda from 17 May 2014 to 29 May 2014;(e)Kenya from 29 May 2014 to 1 June 2014; and(f)Eritrea (date unknown).The visa applicant stated he travelled to Germany for a ‘trade fair exhibition’ and Uganda for business and to see a friend. He stopped at Kenya temporarily after being in Uganda as the friend he was with was ill. The Tribunal places significant weight on the visa applicant’s compliance with his two visas to Germany. Due to Uganda, Kenya and Eritrea being so close to Ethiopia, the Tribunal places some weight on the visa applicant’s compliance with his visa conditions to these countries. The review applicant gave evidence consistent with the visa applicant stating the visa applicant led a ‘stable life’ and was a ‘responsible person’ who ran a ‘successful business’. She said I can say ‘100% he will return’. He has a wife and five children. She stated in 2016 she travelled to Ethiopia and visited the visa applicant. She stated that the visa applicant also tells her ‘why don’t you come over to Ethiopia instead of me’ travelling to Australia. The review applicant presented as a credible and honest witness. The Tribunal enquired with the visa applicant whether he had a well-founded fear of any form of persecution in Ethiopia due to his race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion and whether this would provide a basis for him applying for a protection visa. The visa applicant stated he had 'lived all my life since the age of one in Addis Ababa and never had any issue’. He also confirmed he was ‘Christian Orthodox’ which the Tribunal notes is the largest religion in Ethiopia.[3] The visa applicant also stated because he lives in ‘metro everything is quite peaceful and that outside I think everyone knows what happens’. The review applicant gave evidence that she did not believe the visa applicant had ‘any fears of persecution and had no political involvement’. [3] Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade Report (DFAT) Report Ethiopia dated 12 August 2020 The Tribunal explained that it needs to take into account the political, economic and security situation of a visa applicant’s home country, as this may appear to be a disincentive to return. The Tribunal referred to the most recent Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade Report which states that despite Addis Ababa being a major diplomatic hub, Ethiopia is one of the most drought-prone countries in the world which has caused many drought-induced famines which have resulted in over one million deaths. Ethiopia is also one of the poorest countries in the world. Per capita income in 2019 the United Nations Development Program ranked Ethiopia 173rd out of 189 countries in the 2019 Human Development Index situating it in a low human development category. Also, more than half the population does not have electricity and internet penetration and over 40 million people remain without access to safe drinking water. There have also historically been restrictions on political opposition and dissent and ethnic based clashes. There has also political instability with the resignation of the Prime Minister Desalen and the appointment of his successor Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed who has postponed elections due to COVID-19. In relation to security Al-Shabaab is known to operate in Ethiopia, including in Addis Ababa, with various attacks including in October 2013 with a bomb explosion in a residential area of Addis Ababa and in September 2019 where Al-Shabaab were planning to attack hotels, public places and religious festivities in Addis Ababa and Oromia and Somali states. The Tribunal put to the visa applicant and review apply why these would not be disincentives to return to Ethiopia. [4][4] IbidThe visa applicant did not dispute these facts stating ‘that is true. That’s why we are all working hard to change the situation in Ethiopia. That’s why we’re working hard. I live in Addis Ababa so you don’t have those issues and you don’t see much’. The visa applicant also explained the change of Prime Minister was due to ‘internal re-structuring’. He also explained that Al-Shaabab are ‘not there anymore’ and that he has always lived in Addis Ababa and never observed ‘ethnic problems’. He further explained that his wife is from a different ethnic group to him, being Amharic whilst he is Tigray, but that they live a ‘harmonious life together’. He stated he does not speak Tigray despite being officially Tigray. The visa applicant presented as a very honest and credible witness and the Tribunal accepts his evidence. The Tribunal also notes the visa applicant undertook significant efforts both before and after the hearing to produce independent and corroborative evidence in support of his evidence which was provided in a timely manner. The review applicant in response to the country information stated that ‘All these issues are old ones and probably exaggerated as well’. She also stated that most of the issues have occurred outside Addis Ababa and maintained her brother lives a ‘normal’ and ‘stable’ life. The Tribunal has had regard to the decision in Khanam v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2009] FCA 966, to the effect that the Tribunal must consider the particular circumstances of the visa applicant, rather than make broad assumptions based on information regarding a person of the same nationality or social group. The Tribunal accepts both the visa applicant and review applicant’s evidence and is of the view that the country information was largely irrelevant to the visa applicant and therefore places little weight on it as a disincentive to return to Ethiopia. The Tribunal enquired whether the review applicant would be prepared to lodge a bond to guarantee the visa applicant’s return. The review applicant indicated she would be prepared to provide a bond in the sum of $1500.00 AUD to $2000.00 AUD . She explained this is all she could afford due to being a single mother with two young children and being in the process of looking for a new job after graduating from her university business degree. The Tribunal accepts that if a security bond was required of the review applicant, the visa applicant would be highly motivated to ensure that he returns to Ethiopia before the expiry of his visa due to financial hardship cause to his sister in losing a security bond, as well as advise implications for future visa applications to Australia. The Tribunal is also satisfied that the visa applicant would abide by condition 8531 and not remain in Australia after the end of his permitted stay due to his family and employment circumstances which the Tribunal is of the view constitute significant incentives to return to Ethiopia.Thus, considering all the above matters cumulatively, the Tribunal is satisfied that there are sufficient incentives for the visa applicant to return to Ethiopia. The Tribunal is also satisfied that the visa applicant and review applicant are ‘relatives’ for the purposes of cl 600.232 and that the review applicant is being sponsored by a settled Australian citizen who is at least 18 years of age. For the above reasons the Tribunal is satisfied that the visa applicant genuinely intends to stay temporarily in Australia for the purpose for which the visa is granted, and finds that the requirements of cl 600.211 are met.DECISIONThe Tribunal remits the application for a Visitor (Class FA) visa for reconsideration, with the direction that the visa applicant meets the following criteria for a Subclass 600 (Visitor) (Class FA) visa:·cl 600.211 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations; and·cl 600.232 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.Naomi SchmitzMember

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal examined whether the visa applicant had been sponsored by a settled Australian citizen or permanent resident, who was a relative, as required by cl 600.232. The Tribunal was satisfied that the visa applicant was sponsored by his sister, who is a settled Australian citizen. The Tribunal accepted the relationship between the visa applicant and his sister as genuine based on the evidence provided, including family photographs, birth certificates, and testimony from both parties. The Tribunal found that the sister met the requirements of being a settled Australian citizen and a relative of the visa applicant.

The Tribunal also considered whether the visa applicant genuinely intended to stay temporarily in Australia for the purpose for which the visa was granted, as required by cl 600.211. The Tribunal was satisfied that the visa applicant intended to visit his sister and genuinely intended to return to Ethiopia at the end of his permitted stay. The Tribunal placed significant weight on the visa applicant's ownership of substantial property and assets in Ethiopia, including three properties and two motor vehicles. The Tribunal also noted the visa applicant's ongoing business commitments, as evidenced by a machine rental agreement with a remaining term of six months, and his stable employment situation with minimal disruption due to COVID-19. The Tribunal found that these factors provided sufficient incentives for the visa applicant to return to Ethiopia.

Further, the Tribunal considered whether there were sufficient incentives for the visa applicant to return to Ethiopia, as also required by cl 600.211. The Tribunal found that the visa applicant's family and business ties, along with his significant property holdings, provided strong incentives for his return. The Tribunal accepted the review applicant's willingness to lodge a bond to guarantee the visa applicant's return, which further supported the visa applicant's intention to abide by the visa conditions. The Tribunal also noted the visa applicant's credible and honest testimony regarding his intention to return to Ethiopia, despite the country's political and economic challenges. The Tribunal concluded that these factors collectively satisfied the requirements of cl 600.211.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal distinguished the case from broader country information regarding Ethiopia's socio-economic conditions and security issues, focusing instead on the specific circumstances of the visa applicant. The Tribunal applied the principle from Khanam v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship that it must consider the particular circumstances of the visa applicant rather than making broad assumptions based on nationality or social group. The Tribunal's decision to remit the application for reconsideration was based on the cumulative evidence that the visa applicant met the criteria for a Subclass 600 (Visitor) visa, satisfying both cl 600.211 and cl 600.232.