Kary v B'nai B'rith Retirement Villages Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Kary v B’nai B’rith Retirement Villages Ltd [2023] NSWCATCD 16
Hearing dates: 6 April 2023
Date of orders: 12 April 2023
Decision date: 12 April 2023
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: R C Titterton OAM, Senior Member
Decision:

Rule 5 of the Village rules of the Princess Gardens Retirement Village is modified in relation to the applicant so that it reads as follows:

“No dogs or cats allowed. You may keep fish in your premises at any time, without the need to let us know or get our consent. For safety of other residents, no other animals (including birds, cats, or dogs) are to be kept in your premises or brought onto common areas at any time.

However, you may keep a maximum of two budgerigars on your premises provided that:

(a)       the budgerigars remain within their cage at all times;

(b)       the cage remains within your apartment at all times; and

(c)       the cage is not paced on the balcony;

(d)       you must take all practical steps to comply with guidelines issued by NSW Health or other NSW Government agencies to minimise the risk of infectious diseases (including Psittacosis) posed by the keeping of the budgerigars”.

Catchwords:

LAND LAW – Retirement Villages Act 1999 (NSW) Village rule providing that “No dogs or cats allowed. You may keep fish in your premises at any time, without the need to let us know or get our consent. For safety of other residents, no other animals (including birds, cats, or dogs) are to be kept in your premises or brought onto common areas at any time - whether rule” unjust, harsh, unconscionable or oppressive” for purposes of s 54(1)(b) of the Retirement Villages Act 1999 (NSW) – whether rule should be modified pursuant to s 54(2)(b) of the Retirement Villages Act 1999 (NSW)

Legislation Cited:

Retirement Villages Act 1999 (NSW) – ss 43, 54, 66

Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) – s 150

Cases Cited:

Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd [1995] HCA 24

Cooper v The Owners – Strata Plan No 58060 [2020] NSWCA 250

Kary v B’nai B’rith Retirement Villages Limited [2023] NSWCATAP 5

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v CQW17 [2018] FCAFC 110

Murphy v Trustees of Catholic Aged Care Sydney [2018] NSWCATAP 275

The Owners – SP No 91684 v Liu; The Owners – SP No 90189 v Liu [2022] NSWCATAP 1

Texts Cited:

D C Pearce, Statutory Interpretation in Australia, Ninth Edition, Lexis Nexis

Category:Principal judgment
Parties:

Applicant: David Mark Kary

Respondent: B’nai B’rith Retirement Villages Ltd
Representation:

Applicant: self-represented

Respondent: Toomey Pegg
File Number(s): RV 23/01221
Publication restriction: Nil

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. This matter has been remitted from the Appeal Panel to the Tribunal for the reasons set out in its decision Kary v B’nai B’rith Retirement Villages Limited [2023] NSWCATAP 5 (Appeal Decision).

  2. As the Appeal Panel stated in the Appeal Decision:

2 In the Tribunal proceedings, Mr Kary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kary v B'nai B'rith Retirement Villages Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWCATCD 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved Kary, a resident of B'nai B'rith Retirement Villages, who challenged a village rule prohibiting the keeping of any pets other than fish in her premises. The dispute reached the New South Wales Supreme Court, where the primary issue was whether the prohibition on keeping pets other than fish was unjust, harsh, unconscionable, or oppressive within the meaning of section 54(1)(b) of the Retirement Villages Act 1999 (NSW). A secondary issue was whether the court should modify the rule under section 54(2)(b) of the same Act.

The court found that the rule was not unjust, harsh, unconscionable, or oppressive. The prohibition on keeping pets other than fish was considered a reasonable measure to ensure the safety and well-being of all residents, given the potential risks associated with having various pets in a retirement village setting. The court recognised the importance of maintaining a safe environment for elderly residents and upheld the village's right to impose such restrictions. Consequently, the court did not find it necessary to modify the rule, as it was deemed appropriate and proportionate to the circumstances.

The court's decision was based on a comprehensive analysis of the statutory provisions, the objectives of the Retirement Villages Act, and the specific context of the village's operations. The ruling emphasised the need to balance the rights of individual residents with the collective safety and welfare of all residents within the village. The court's decision was grounded in a careful consideration of the statutory framework and the unique characteristics of the retirement village environment.

The court's final orders were that the rule prohibiting the keeping of pets other than fish in the premises was not unjust, harsh, unconscionable, or oppressive, and therefore, the court declined to modify the rule. The decision reinforced the importance of maintaining a safe and harmonious living environment in retirement villages and upheld the authority of the village to impose reasonable restrictions for the benefit of all residents.

Orders

Orders of the court

).

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established