Kalan and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

Kalan and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2019] AATA 787 (2 May 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2018/2449

Re:Birgun Kalan

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D. J. Morris

Date:2 May 2019

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision.

..............[sgd]..........................................................

Senior Member D. J. Morris

Catchwords

MIGRATION – application for prospective marriage visa – application refused under s 501(1) of Migration Act – sponsor of Applicant seeks review of refusal decision – consideration of character test and powers of discretion in Act – can Tribunal go behind conviction when applicant convicted in absentia – ministerial Direction – primary considerations – other considerations – serious nature of conviction – reviewable decision affirmed

Legislation

Extradition Act 1988 (Cth), s 55
Extradition (Turkey) Regulations 2003 – Sch 1
Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 338, 347, 501

Migration Regulations 2004 (Cth), reg 2.08E

Cases

HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1803
Jagroop and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Re [2015] AATA 751
Jagroop v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 241 FCR 461
Madafferi and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, Re [2000] AATA 450
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Ali [2000] FCA 1385

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SRT [1999] FCA 1197

Secondary Materials

Migration Act 1958 – Direction No. 79 – Direction under section 499 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s501CA (dated 20 December 2018; commenced 28 February 2019)
Treaty on Extradition between Australia and the Republic of Turkey, done at Canberra 3 March 1994.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D. J. Morris

2 May 2019

Background

  1. On 3 May 2018 Ms Birgun Kalan asked the Tribunal to review a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs (the Minister) on 12 April 2018 to refuse to grant her husband, Mr Tamer Talipoglu, a Prospective Marriage (Temporary)(Class TO) visa (the visa). The delegate was not satisfied that Mr Talipoglu passes the character test and decided to exercise her discretion under section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act) to refuse his application for a visa.

  2. Ms Kalan has standing to bring the application for review of the decision to the Tribunal because of section 347(2)(b) of the Act, which allows a sponsor or nominator of a person of a Part 5 reviewable decision under section 338 of the Act to seek review. The refusal of Mr Talipoglu’s visa is such a decision.

  3. The hearing was held on 15 and 17 January 2019.  Ms Kalan was represented by


    Mr Greg Hughan of counsel, instructed by Mr Attila Mete.  Ms Ashlee Briffa of the Australian Government Solicitor represented the Respondent.  Ms Kalan gave evidence and was cross-examined.  Mr Mert Kalan, her son, also gave evidence.  Mr Steve Wilson gave evidence by telephone.  Mr Talipoglu gave evidence by telephone from Turkey, as did Ms Meral Bingol, a lawyer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kalan and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 787
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse a prospective marriage visa to Mr Tamer Talipoglu, the sponsor of whom was Ms Kalan, an Australian citizen. The refusal was made under section 501(1) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) on character grounds, specifically relating to Mr Talipoglu's conviction in Turkey for his involvement in an illegal human tissue explanting ring, described in public opinion as the "Organ Mafia". The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) was required to consider the character test and the exercise of discretion under the Act, including whether it could look behind the conviction itself.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mr Talipoglu met the character requirements for the visa, and if not, whether there were sufficient compelling reasons to exercise discretion in his favour. This involved assessing the seriousness of his conviction, the risk of further offending, and balancing these against other considerations outlined in ministerial directions. The Tribunal had to determine the weight to be given to primary considerations, such as the protection of the Australian community from harm, and other considerations, including the impact on family members. A key aspect of the assessment was how to treat the conviction, particularly given the context provided by Ms Kalan regarding the nature of the criminal enterprise and her belief in Mr Talipoglu's lesser involvement.

The Tribunal reasoned that the conviction for mediating for kidney givers and buyers within a criminal enterprise involved in illegal human tissue explanting was a serious offence that weighed heavily against granting the visa. It noted that the criminal enterprise was international in scope and involved exploiting vulnerable individuals. While acknowledging the genuineness of the marriage and the potential impact on Ms Kalan, the Tribunal found that her adult sons were becoming independent, making it feasible for her to relocate to Turkey if she chose. The Tribunal also considered the expectations of the Australian community, concluding that a hypothetical member of the community, properly informed of the facts, would expect a visa not to be granted to someone convicted of such a serious offence who had no prior connection to Australia. The Tribunal found insufficient corroborative evidence to support the assertion that the conviction was solely due to discrimination against Mr Talipoglu's Alevi faith.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the visa, finding that the primary consideration of protection of the Australian community weighed against granting the visa, and that this consideration was not outweighed by other factors.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Paragraph 12(1) of the Direction sets out other considerations in relation to refusal of a visa (the Direction actually refers to ‘deciding whether to cancel a visa’ [sic] but this appears to be a printing error in the instrument as the relevant paragraph is headed ‘Other considerations – visa applicants’). They are: ‘International non-refoulement obligations; Impact on family members; Impact on victims; Impact on Australian business interests.’ The Direction states that primary considerations should generally be given more weight than the other considerations and that one or more primary considerations may outweigh other primary considerations (see paragraphs 8(4) and 8(5) of the Direction).Evidence of Ms Kalan Ms Kalan said she was born in Australia of a Turkish family. At the age of 6 she returned to Turkey with her parents. She later returned to Australia in 1998, aged 22. She married her first husband in Turkey and they had their older son there. She divorced her first husband in 2009. She told the Tribunal she and her father came from an Alevi community. The Tribunal is aware that Alevism is a syncretic, heterodox and local tradition of the Islamic Faith and adherents make up the largest religious minority group in Turkey, the majority of the population being Sunni Islam. Ms Kalan said she first met Mr Talipoglu in February 2014, having been introduced to him by friends and first interacting with him on ‘Skype’ (a telecommunications application). She said she had various exchanges with him over a period of seven months before she went to Turkey to meet him in person in September 2014, accompanied by her two sons. Ms Kalan said she spent about seven or eight weeks in Turkey on that occasion, with Mr Talipoglu and met his family and some of his friends. She said she went to Mr Talipoglu’s village for an engagement ceremony, and they were engaged in September 2014. Ms Kalan said she was aware of the offending history of Mr Talipoglu and told the Tribunal that, while she knew there was a decision made against him, she believed that the police had arrested him because he knew another person who was involved, but Ms Kalan did not believe that Mr Talipoglu had been involved in the ‘organ mafia’, because ‘their activities disgust both him and me.’ Ms Kalan returned to Australia in October 2014 and maintained contact with her now fiancé. In 2017 she and her sons returned to Turkey for about seven or eight weeks and she and Mr Talipoglu were married in Tarsus in March that year. She lived with Mr Talipoglu at his house during this visit while her sons lived at her family home village, which was nearby. Ms Kalan told the Tribunal that Mr Talipoglu was employed in forestry, which was also the trade of his father and grandfather and did other handyman-type work. He is also a gifted musician, playing the baglama (a traditional stringed instrument), and gave music lessons, specialising in Alevi music. Ms Kalan explained that she is a member of the Alevi Community in Dandenong.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal finds that this primary consideration weighs against granting the visa.Best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision (paragraph 11.2) Both of Ms Kalan’s children are over 18 years old. There were no other minor children in Australia brought to the Tribunal’s attention by parties who may be affected by the decision, so the Tribunal did not consider this consideration further.Expectations of the Australian community (paragraph 11.3) The Direction states that: ‘Visa refusal may be appropriate simply because of the nature of the character concerns or the offences are such that the Australian community would expect that the person should not be granted a visa.’ The Tribunal accepts the evidence of Ms Kalan and Mr Kalan that they have no concerns at all about the character of Mr Talipoglu and, to the contrary, have found him nothing other than kind and considerate in their dealings with him. The Tribunal found the evidence of Mr Mert Kalan in this respect honest and impressive. The Tribunal considers that the expectations of the Australian community must, self-evidently, involve the weighing up of what a hypothetical member of the Australian community, who is properly apprised of the relevant facts, would think. In this respect, the Tribunal concludes that such a hypothetical person would have an expectation that the visa not be granted to a person convicted of a serious offence who has never been to Australia, in spite of the fact that he has recently married an Australian citizen. He has not made any positive contribution to the Australian community and has, putting aside the illegal human tissue explanting conviction, a somewhat chequered history in terms of his family responsibilities to his own children. Ms Bingol in her statement recorded that Alevis have been subject to some discrimination and the Tribunal notes the UK Home Office report (Exhibit A6) states, at paragraph 6.153:Alevis were reviled as non-Muslims of dubious loyalty, and to avoid persecution they practised dissimulation, taqiyya. Until the 20th century, Alevis survived by living in remote areas, but with conscription and the drift to towns in search of work, Alevis, especially Kurds, have been increasingly exposed to Sunni prejudice and animosity. The Tribunal may accept this as factual, but there was insufficient corroborative evidence before me that the fact that he is Alevi was the sole reason Mr Talipoglu was convicted, and that he was wrongly convicted, of being a mediator for the illegal human tissue explanting ring.International non-refoulement obligations (paragraph 12.1) This consideration is not engaged; Australia does not owe any international protection obligations to Mr Talipoglu as he has not ever entered this country.Impact on family members (paragraph 12.2) The Direction requires the Tribunal to assess the impact of a visa refusal on immediate family members in Australia, where those family members are Australian citizens, as in this case. The Tribunal accepts the genuineness of the marriage between Ms Kalan and Mr Talipoglu. While Mr Talipoglu said he would be keen for Ms Kalan to join him to make a life in Turkey should his visa not be granted, Ms Kalan herself said she would be unlikely to take that course, because of her two sons here. However, the Tribunal notes that her sons are now adults aged 18 and 20. One is about to embark on a tertiary course and the other is looking to work in a trade. They are beginning to make their way in the world, so it would be possible for Ms Kalan to relocate to Turkey to join her husband, if that were her ultimate decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent conceded that the impact on family members if Mr Talipoglu is not granted a visa weighs in favour of setting aside the decision under review but noted that it was open for Ms Kalan to live with Mr Talipoglu in Turkey, should she choose to.CONSIDERATION As mentioned above, the Tribunal must consider Mr Talipoglu’s application for a visa against the considerations set out in Part B of the Direction.Protection of the Australian community (paragraph 11.1) Decision-makers must have regard to the principle that the Government is committed to protecting the Australian community from harm as a result of criminal activity or other serious conduct by non-citizens. Decision-makers are required to give consideration to the nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s conduct to date, and the risk should the non-citizen commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct.The nature and seriousness of the conduct (paragraph 11.1.1) In respect of the illegal human tissue explanting trial, the (translated) Court record was before the Tribunal (RD, p 37-50). The Court found that a criminal enterprise with international contacts was established in Turkey with the specific purpose of illegally smuggling kidneys. The enterprise included doctors and academics. The record relevantly said:It was determined that the buyers of kidney were from Israel, France, England and the kidney givers were from old USSR such as Romania, Bulgaria, Ukraine, Moldova, Belarus and Russia, the kidney givers, who were found by the members of criminal enterprise and whose economic conditions were not good, were persuaded by the mediators and the interviews were made with the defendant Yusuf Ercin Sonmez, the givers were supplied by this way the kidneys taken out from these people against very cheap costs were sold to buyers against excessive prices. The Court further recorded: ‘the defendant Tamer Talipoglu mediated for kidney givers and buyers for criminal enterprise.’ It went on to record:The defendant TAMER TALIPOGLU stated that he met with Kenan Sehit through Niyazi Sahin, he did not participate in criminal enterprise and he did not accept the previous statements which he had given related to this subject. Later in the Court record, Mr Talipoglu is named with seven other defendants as acting together:to find poor people to donate kidneys and persuade these people to sell kidneys against a minimum wage and thus this organization known as ‘Organ Mafia’ in the public opinion brought rich kidney patients both in Turkey and abroad, especially from Israel, to Turkey for transplantation of kidneys of poor people both in Turkey and from countries such as Moldova, Romania, Bulgaria, the provisions of the organ transplantation law were not complied with in these transplantations… The wicked nature of this criminal enterprise may be clear by the evidence one witness (RD, p 45) gave at the trial that she was told by a medical practitioner member of the ring that a poor friend could have both of her kidneys explanted, ‘because she could live for 45 days without kidney[s]’ and in the meantime could source some cheaper kidneys from Iraq to be implanted, bought with part of the money she was paid for her own.