Kailash Lawyers Pty Ltd v Patial

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kailash Lawyers Pty Ltd v Patial [2025] FCA 884  

File number(s): NSD 970 of 2025
NSD 1041 of 2025
NSD 1042 of 2025
NSD 1043 of 2025
NSD 1044 of 2025
Judgment of: GOODMAN J
Date of judgment: 4 August 2025
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – application to set aside creditors statutory demands served on four companies – whether the companies applied “to the Court for an order setting aside a statutory demand” within the meaning of s 459G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) in circumstances where, as co-plaintiffs, they filed one originating application to set aside the demands – whether individual proceedings are required – held individual proceedings not required

CORPORATIONS – application to set aside creditors statutory demands served on four companies – whether service of the originating application and affidavit in support was effected for the purposes of s 459G and whether personal service was required – held service was effected and personal service not required – unmeritorious position taken as to service despite receipt of documents having been acknowledged by recipient – application of the “effective informal service rule” – service electronically and in a physical form under s 110C and 110D of the Act 

CORPORATIONS – creditors statutory demands – whether genuine dispute established – where the legal foundation of the alleged debt not clear – where quantum of the alleged debts has changed several times – where the existence of debts in dispute in another proceeding – genuine dispute established

CORPORATIONS – creditors statutory demands – whether the demands should be set aside for another reason – held that the demands should be set aside as an abuse of process

COSTS – costs payable on an indemnity basis in circumstances where unmeritorious position taken with respect to service, where the existence of a genuine dispute was obvious and where the demands were not withdrawn, and the winding up proceedings were commenced and continued despite notice of fundamental problems

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 9, 105A, 110C, 110D, 110E, 459A, 459E, 459G, 459H, 459P, 467A, 470, 1322

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s 394

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 37N

Treasury Laws Amendment (Modernising Business Communications and Other Measures) Act 2023 (Cth)

Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth), r 1.3

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), rr 8.21, 9.02, Sch 1

Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules 2015 (NSW)

Cases cited:

A & M Short Pty Ltd v Prestige Residential Marketing Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 872; (2005) 54 ACSR 760

Bioaction Pty Ltd v Ogborne, in the matter of Bioaction Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 436; (2022) 402 ALR 542

Blatch v Archer (1774) 1 Cowp 63; 98 ER 969

CA Associates Pty Ltd v Fini Group Pty Ltd [2020] WASCA 31

Carter v Australian Securities Investments Commission [2019] FCAFC 229; (2019) 274 FCR 677

Clough v Frog (1974) 48 ALJR 481

Colgate Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd [1993] FCA 801; (1993) 46…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kailash Lawyers Pty Ltd v Patial and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 884
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kailash Lawyers Pty Ltd v Patial involved four companies seeking to set aside statutory demands served on them by Mr Patial. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the companies had complied with the procedural requirements under section 459G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and whether there was a genuine dispute regarding the debts claimed. Additionally, the Court had to decide if the statutory demands should be set aside for reasons beyond a genuine dispute, and if the companies should be wound up.

The primary legal issues revolved around whether the companies had correctly applied to the Court to set aside the statutory demands, including whether individual proceedings were required for each company, and if personal service was necessary for the application and affidavit. Furthermore, the Court had to determine whether a genuine dispute existed regarding the debts claimed, and if the statutory demands should be set aside for reasons such as abuse of process. Lastly, the Court needed to decide whether the companies should be wound up.

The Court found that individual proceedings were not required for each company, as they had collectively filed one originating application. Service of the originating application and affidavit was deemed effective under the "effective informal service rule," as the recipient acknowledged receipt of the documents. The Court concluded that a genuine dispute existed due to the unclear legal foundation of the alleged debts, the changing quantum of the debts, and the existence of the debts being disputed in another proceeding. Additionally, the demands were set aside as an abuse of process due to Mr Patial's unmeritorious position on service, the obvious existence of a genuine dispute, and the continuation of winding up proceedings despite fundamental issues. Consequently, the demands were set aside, the winding up proceedings dismissed, and an order was made preventing further statutory demands until the conclusion of another proceeding. Mr Patial was ordered to pay the companies' costs on an indemnity basis.

In summary, the Court dismissed the winding up proceedings, set aside the statutory demands, and ordered Mr Patial to pay the companies' costs on an indemnity basis. The Court also made an order preventing Mr Patial from serving further statutory demands on the companies until the conclusion of another proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be dismissed.

2. The plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs on an indemnity basis, as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

A. INTRODUCTION

[1]

B. BACKGROUND

[4]

B.1 The Agreement and events during the Agreement period

[5]

B.2 The 31 August 2020 invoices and a dispute raised

[12]

B.3 The Commission proceeding

[18]

B.4 Proceeding NSD1016/2021 and the initial statement of claim

[21]

B.5 The second iteration of the statement of claim

[27]

B.6 The Supreme Court and District Court proceedings

[34]

B.7 The bankruptcy notice

[38]

B.8 The prior demands

[39]

B.9 The 20 May 2025 invoices

[41]

B.10 Withdrawal of the prior demands and service of the demands

[46]

B.11 The third iteration of the statement of claim

[57]

B.12 Commencement of the proceeding NSD970/2025 to set aside the demands

[61]

B.13 Service of the originating application and affidavit in support

[68]

B.14 Commencement of the winding up proceedings

[73]

C. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

[81]

D. THE AMENDMENT APPLICATION

[82]

E. HAVE THE REQUIREMENTS OF S 459G OF THE ACT BEEN MET FOR EACH DEMAND?

[91]

E.1 Has the company made an application to the Court (s 459G(1))?

[100]

E.2 Were the application and the supporting affidavit filed and served within 21 days after service of the demands (s 459G(2) and (3))?

[110]

E.2.1 Is personal service required?

[121]

E.2.2 Has service occurred?

[124]

E.2.2.1 Service by electronic communication

[128]

E.2.2.2 Physical service

[143]

E.3 Does the application seek an order setting aside the demand (s 459G(1))?

[147]

E.4 Is the affidavit filed with the application in truth an affidavit “supporting” the application to set aside the particular demand (s 459G(3)(a))?

[149]

E.5 Conclusion as to compliance with s 459G of the Act

[151]

F. SHOULD THE DEMANDS BE SET ASIDE?

[152]

F.1 Is there a genuine dispute?

[153]

F.2 Is there an abuse of process?

[173]

G. SHOULD THE COMPANIES BE WOUND UP?

[177]

H. OTHER ORDERS SOUGHT BY THE COMPANIES

[178]

I. MISCELLANEOUS ISSUES

[182]

J. COSTS

[185]

K. CONCLUSION

[189]

SCHEDULE TO [2025] FCA 884 - 20 MAY 2025 INVOICES AND AMOUNTS SAID TO HAVE BEEN PAID, AND AMOUNT SAID TO BE OWING AS PER THE 29 MAY 2025 DEMANDS

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons developed below, each demand should be set aside, and each of the applications by Mr Patial for the winding up of the companies should be dismissed. Further, an order preventing Mr Patial from serving further statutory demands upon the companies before the conclusion of proceeding NSD1016/2021 should be made.B. BACKGROUND Before addressing the questions for determination, it is necessary to set out in some detail some of the history of the dispute between Mr Patial on the one hand and Mr Pall and his companies on the other. The background set out below is taken from the evidence relied upon at the hearing, namely:(1)for Mr Patial, (a) an affidavit affirmed by him on 15 July 2025 in proceeding NSD970/2025; (b) three affidavits affirmed by him on 15 July 2025 in each of the winding up proceedings; and (c) an affidavit affirmed by him on 25 June 2025 in each of the winding up proceedings; (2)for the companies, (a) affidavits of Mr Pall affirmed on 17 June 2025 and 16 July 2025 in proceeding NSD970/2025; (b) an affidavit of Mr Gaurav Sareen, the solicitor for the companies, sworn on 28 July 2025 in proceeding NSD970/2025; (c) an affidavit of Ms Paulene Hill, a process server, affirmed on 23 June 2025 in proceeding NSD970/2025; and (d) an affidavit of Mr Pall affirmed on 28 June 2025 in each of the winding up proceedings;(3)various exhibits to the above affidavits; and(4)an extract from an affidavit made by Mr Pall in proceeding SYG2899/2024 in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2).B.1 The Agreement and events during the Agreement period Mr Pall is the sole director of the companies, namely:(1)Kailash Lawyers Pty Ltd, a company which trades as Kailash Lawyers;(2)Koala Investments Property Pty Ltd; (3)Kuber Investment Group Pty Ltd; and(4)Kailasam Holdings Pty Ltd. On 17 April 2019, Mr Patial and Kailash executed a document titled “Agreement for General Use”. Mr Patial is described as “Prateek” in the Agreement. Clauses 2, 4 and 5 of the Agreement provide (as written):2. Operative provisions (a)It is expressly understood and agreed between Prateek and Kailash that:i)Prateek is going to undertake his supervised legal training with Kailash for 12 months (or any other time agreed between the parties) of the date of this agreement;ii)Kailash has agreed to provide the supervised training in the legal areas the practice undertakes legal work;iii)Kailash shall provide with essential infrastructure considered necessary at its discretion for this purpose;iv)Prateek shall undertake all the work diligently, keeping utmost confidentiality of the clients and the work being undertaken;v)Prateek shall work on the client files to gain diverse experiences;vi)It is expressly understood and stated that the parties do not form an employer-employee relationship. Kailash do not owe any employer obligations towards Prateek including but not limited to remuneration, salary, superannuation etc. The pure and simple objective of this agreement for the parties is conduct and receive supervised training with certain benefits to both the parties arising out of this relationship.vii)To provide training, infrastructure and related resources, Kailash shall charge 60% of the gross professional fee (excluding disbursements) generated by Prateek up to the total income of $100,000 per annum. Should the fee grow above $100,000.00 per annum in the increments of $10,000, the Kailash percentage shall decrease to 50% of the gross professional fee (excluding disbursements) on anything above $100,000, in the increments of $10,000;viii)The term of this agreement is for one year from the date of this agreement. To provide certainty to the agreement, this is an essential term;ix)Prateek will conducts itself in a proper, prudent, and professional manner that is required form a duly registered legal practitioner to operate in the circumstances. He will ensure that he fulfils the licencing and qualification requirements to legally perform his duties, including registration with law society, undergoing annual CPD points and strictly adhere to Solicitors Conduct Rules and code of ethics.x)Both parties shall use their best endeavours to promote the business of the law practice; andxi)Kailash reserves its right at its sole discretion and assessment of the factual circumstances to offer partnership in the legal practice on the terms decided at the end of the term.…4. Entire agreementThis agreement is the entire agreement and understanding between the parties on everything connected with the subject matter of this agreement, and supersedes any prior understanding, arrangement, representation or agreements between the parties as to the subject matter contained in this agreement.5. AmendmentAn amendment or variation to this agreement is not effective unless it is in writing and signed by all the parties.(bold emphasis in original; italic emphasis added)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am satisfied that indemnity costs orders are appropriate in each of the present proceedings because:(1)the existence of a genuine dispute was pellucid;(2)Mr Patial was put on notice that his position that the NSD970/2025 originating application was non-compliant was contrary to authority and that the service of the demands was an abuse of process ( [40], [55] and [75] above);(3)Mr Patial’s position that service had not been effected despite his own evidence that he had received the originating documents within the statutory period was, as noted above, devoid of merit;(4)as noted above, Mr Patial’s service of the demands and his commencement of the winding up proceedings in the face of his knowledge of the existence of a genuine dispute was an abuse of process; and(5)by dint of the above positions, and steps, that were taken by Mr Patial, the companies were subjected to costs of litigation that ought never have been necessary to commence (in the case of proceeding NSD970/2025) or to defend (in the case of the winding up proceedings).K. CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, the demands should be set aside and the winding up originating processes should be dismissed. The ancillary order discussed at [179] to [180] above should also be made. In each proceeding Mr Patial should pay the costs of the opposing party or parties on an indemnity basis. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.