Kadam v MiiResorts Group 1 Pty Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kadam v MiiResorts Group 1 Pty Ltd (No 5) [2018] FCA 1086

File number(s): QUD 528 of 2016
QUD 147 of 2017
Judge: LEE J
Date of judgment: 20 July 2018
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – representative proceeding – Part IVA class action and related proceeding by Indian regulator seeking relief on behalf of investors in large ‘Ponzi’ scheme operated in the Republic of India – questions as to appropriate declaratory and other relief

EQUITY – tracing of pooled funds of investors in an Indian “collective investment scheme” being funds transferred from India to Australia and then applied in breach of trust to acquire Australian assets – consideration of recovery of allowance out of trust fund for costs and expenses incurred in getting in trust assets  

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 440D, 564

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), Part IVA, ss 33ZB, 33ZF

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), Div 14.3

Legal Profession Act 2007 (QLD)

Probate and Administration Act 1898 (NSW), s 86

Securities and Exchange Board of India Act 1992 (Ind), s 11AA

Cases cited:

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v GDK Financial Solutions Pty Ltd (in liq) [2008] FCA 448; (2008) 246 ALR 580

Coad v Wellness Pursuit Pty Ltd (in liq) [2009] WASCA 68; (2009) 40 WAR 53

Campden Hill Ltd v Chakrani [2005] All ER (D) 238

Cristovao v Tan & Tan Lawyers Pty Ltd [2018] FCAFC 41

Darwalla Milling Co Pty Ltd (ACN 009 698 631) v F Hoffman-La Roche Ltd (No 2) [2006] FCA 1388; (2006) 236 ALR 322

Dillon v RBS Group (Australia) Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 896; (2017) 252 FCR 150

Dovuro Pty Ltd v Wilkins (2003) 215 CLR 317

El Ajou v Dollar Land Holdings plc (No 1) [1993] 3 All ER 717

El Ajou v Dollar Land Holdings Plc (No 2) [1995] 2 All ER 213

Evans v European Bank Ltd [2004] NSWCA 82; (2004) 61 NSWLR 75

Ford v Earl of Chesterfield (No 3) (1856) 21 Beav 426

Foskett v McKeown [2001] 1 AC 102

Graham Barclay Oysters Pty Ltd v Ryan [2002] HCA 54; (2002) 211 CLR 540

Ide v Ide [2004] NSWSC 751; (2004) 184 FLR 44

IMF (Australia) Ltd v Meadow Springs Fairway Resort Ltd (in liq) [2009] FCAFC 9; (2009) 253 ALR 240

In Re Universal Distributing Company Limited (in liq) (1933) 48 CLR 171

International General Electric Company of New York Ltd v Commissioners of Customs and Excise [1962] Ch 784

Kadam v MiiResorts Group 1 Pty Ltd (No 2) [2016] FCA 1343; (2016) 118 ACSR 1

Kadam v MiiResorts Group 1 Pty Ltd (No 3) [2017] FCA 1138)

Kadam v MiiResorts Group 1 Pty Ltd (No 4) [2017] FCA 1139; (2017) 252 FCR 298

Latham v Hubbard; Estate of Ross [2014] NSWSC 805

Money Max Int Pty Ltd (Trustee) v QBE Insurance Group Limited [2016] FCAFC…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kadam v MiiResorts Group 1 Pty Ltd (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1086
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Kadam v MiiResorts Group 1 Pty Ltd (No 5), the Federal Court of Australia was required to determine questions relating to the appropriate relief for investors in a Ponzi scheme. The investors, including Mrs Kadam, had invested funds in the scheme which were subsequently transferred to Australia and used to acquire assets there. The court was tasked with determining whether the investors could trace their funds to the assets and whether they were entitled to certain declaratory reliefs.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the investors could trace their pooled funds to the assets acquired in Australia and whether they were entitled to declaratory reliefs vindicating their claims. The court needed to consider the principles of tracing in equity and the requirements for claiming under proprietary relief.

The court held that there was a causal connection between the investors' funds and the assets in Australia, and that the transfers were in breach of trust. Consequently, the investors could trace their funds to the assets and were entitled to declaratory reliefs. The court found that the investors' funds could be traced through the various transfers, and that the assets in Australia were held on trust for the investors. The court also determined that Mrs Kadam was entitled to declaratory reliefs based on her individual investments.

The court ordered that the proceedings be re-listed for a further hearing to make the necessary orders. The court intended to provide declarations and other orders reflecting its reasoning and to consider the distribution of assets to the investors in a cost-effective and efficient manner. The court also intended to hear the parties' submissions on the costs orders. The determination provided a clear path for the resolution of the investors' claims and the distribution of the assets in Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceedings be re-listed for a further hearing for the making of orders to be conducted at 10.15 am on 23 July 2018.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The first was the vendor of the Mirage, MiiResorts which had expended substantial funds on the renovation of the Mirage. It will be recalled that there was a mixing of loan funds in MiiResorts’ bank account, meaning it was not possible to determine the quantum of trust funds used to fund this renovation of the Mirage. During the initial hearing, a Statement of Agreed Facts and Contentions (agreed facts) was filed as between SEBI and MiiResorts, noting that the investors are the beneficial owners of the proceeds of sale of the Mirage consisting, together with accrued interest, the Fund, save for the sum of $5 million (paragraph 51) and that SEBI did not press its claims against MiiResorts with respect to the sum of $5 million (paragraph 52). Hence, by reason of a want of evidence in proving a beneficial entitlement to all the monies held in the Fund, SEBI no longer sought relief against MiiResorts, with respect to that sum of $5 million and amended its Originating Application accordingly. No such agreement was reached in the class action, but no forensic accountant’s report or other admissible evidence was adduced to prove that funds of Mrs Kadam, or any other group member, can be traced into funds used for the renovation and repair of the Mirage and, in the end, there was no contrary position, taken by Mrs Kadam, to the course proposed by SEBI. In the circumstances, without opposition from Mrs Kadam, an order was made on 14 March 2018 that MiiResorts be paid a sum of $5 million out the Fund. The second claimant was the Commissioner of Taxation (Commissioner). In February 2017, the Commissioner was granted leave to intervene. The initial trial, which commenced on 6 February 2018, initially involved the Court determining various questions being Mrs Kadam’s claims for relief and certain other issues specified in orders made in December 2017. Relevantly, the Commissioner sought determination as to whether following the issue of garnishee notices, the Fund was the subject of a statutory charge in favour of the Commissioner in the amount of either $20,272,684.50 or $35,494,651.85. In the event it was determined that the Fund was held on trust other than for MiiResorts in its own right, the Commissioner submitted that it was entitled to be subrogated to MiiResorts in respect of MiiResorts’ right of indemnity in respect of its tax liability of $35,494,651.85. Further, the question arose that if any amount was determined to be ordered to be paid to the investors, allowance should initially be made for payment to the Commissioner for the tax liability of $35,494,651.85. Again, this aspect of the case resolved by consent and on 12 February 2018 a sum ($13,746,643.13 together with 10% of accretions on the Fund less withholding tax payable) was agreed to be paid to the Commissioner in resolution of all the Commissioner’s claims. For the purposes of the balance of these reasons, when I refer to the Fund, it will be to the residuum of the initial monies held, less the payments made to resolve the disputes as to claims on the Fund involving MiiResorts and the Commissioner.F IDENTIFICATION OF THE RESIDUAL ISSUES

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given the very significant reduction in the issues in dispute, my preliminary view is that the only orders that need to be made of a type which will bind both parties and group members who have not opted out, for the purposes of s 33ZB of the FCAA, should be the declarations made in the SEBI Proceeding and also the machinery orders which will allow for the distribution of the assets currently held in Australia to both the group members and also other investors. H CONCLUSION & ORDERS I have already indicated during the course of these reasons that I propose to order a further hearing to be held at 10.15 am on 23 July 2018. At this time declarations and other orders can be made reflecting these reasons and further submissions can be received in relation to the precise terms of the material and instructions that should be provided to the referee in relation to costs and as to orders to put in place to reflect my intentions concerning the scheme to allow distribution of the assets to the investors in the most cost efficient and expedient way. Additionally, it will be necessary to put in place a regime for the sale of the Sanctuary Cove Properties in the manner I have described. I will also hear the parties as to what costs orders should be made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There is no dispute, for reasons already detailed, that the necessary causal connexion exists between the Fund and the monies paid over to PACL by the investors (including Mrs Kadam and the group members) and then, after pooling, transferred by PACL to PIPL and other entities, and ultimately to Australia, in breach of trust. The sensible, robust approach, characteristic of the Australian approach to tracing (see Justice Mark Leeming “Proprietary Relief and Tracing in Equity” (2016) 90 ALJ 92 at 94), provides an answer in the present circumstances on the uncontested evidence, and there is no reason why declaratory relief should not follow to vindicate the claims of the investors on the Fund.Issue 2: should a declaration be made that PPL holds the Sanctuary Cove Properties on trust for the Investors? The answer to Issue 2 is no different to the answer to Issue 1 and the process of reasoning is the same. It is also made out on the evidence, and not in contest, that the transfers of investors’ pooled funds by PACL to PIPL and other entities, and ultimately to Australia, were in breach of trust and the investors’ funds can be traced to the Sanctuary Cove Properties. Declaratory relief should follow.Issue 3: Is Mrs Kadam entitled to declaratory relief? Whether more granular declaratory relief vindicating the claim of Mrs Kadam should be granted is more controversial. As noted above, by orders made in December 2017, the Court ordered that it determine the claims of Mrs Kadam but not that of group members at the initial trial, consistent with usual Part IVA procedure. Although as President of JPS, Mrs Kadam gave evidence that JPS had 34,313 members who had made 47,153 investments with PACL, proving these individual group member claims in some sort of collective fashion was not the subject of the hearing. More relevantly, at the hearing, an affidavit was read sworn by Mrs Kadam, in which she gave uncontested evidence that she made three investments with PACL being:(a)INR 30,000, consisting of six annual instalments each of INR 5,000 made between January 2006 and January 2011, which resulted in receipt by Mrs Kadam of an “allotment letter” in or about January 2009, and the payment of INR 46,200 on the maturity of the investment in January 2012.(b)INR 39,600, by 72 monthly instalments each of INR 550, commencing on 30 April 2009 (however, these ceased in about August 2014, when Mrs Kadam became aware of the SEBI investigation into PACL); Mrs Kadam has not recovered any of the approximately INR 35,200 she paid to PACL.(c)INR 75,000, by six annual instalments each of INR 12,500. Mrs Kadam paid the first four instalments between May 2011 and May 2014, but again, not the remaining instalments due in May 2015 and May 2016; Mrs Kadam has not recovered any of the INR 50,000 she paid to PACL. For the purposes of determining Mrs Kadam’s individual claim, it is evident, on the basis of her unchallenged evidence, that Mrs Kadam understood at the time of making each investment that the money invested would be used to purchase land in India and that she did not give her permission (and was never asked for her permission) to use the money she invested to purchase land in Australia, or for the money to be transferred out of India or used for any other purpose. Like the other investors, Mrs Kadam’s claim to a proprietary interest must be determined pursuant to the principles of claiming. Mrs Kadam must be able to establish that there was a relevant trust, that there was a breach of trust and that the trust property can be traced.