K & S Corporation Ltd v Sportingbet Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

K & S CORPORATION LTD v SPORTINGBET AUSTRALIA

[2003] SASC 96

Civil

BESANKO J:    

Introduction

  1. Dennis Craig Telford (“Telford”) was an employee of K & S Corporation Limited (“K & S Corporation”).  Telford gambled heavily on horse races.  In 2001 and early 2002 he placed large wagers with at least two sports bookmakers, one of whom is the defendant Sportingbet Australia Pty Ltd (“Sportingbet”) and its predecessor, Number One Betting Shop Limited (“NOBS”).  In early April 2002, and without the consent of his employer, Telford arranged for the sum of $3 million to be transferred from his employer’s bank account with the Australian and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (“the ANZ account”) to Sportingbet’s bank account with Westpac Banking Corporation (“the Westpac account”).  At the time of the transfer Telford owed Sportingbet the sum of $2,680,000.  After the transfer the records of Sportingbet show that Telford’s account with Sportingbet was in credit in the sum of $320,000.

    2               The fraud perpetrated by Telford was discovered shortly after the payment was made and a warrant was issued under the Criminal Assets Confiscation Act 1996. This led to the seizure of the monies. Orders made by this Court on 9 May 2002 resulted in the payment of the sum of $320,000 to K & S Corporation and the payment of the sum of $2,680,000 to an account with the Bendigo Bank under the control of the solicitors for K & S Corporation and the solicitors for Sportingbet. This action concerns the entitlement to the sum of $2,680,000 (“the disputed monies”).

  2. There were two other parties to the action, namely, the Director of Public Prosecutions and Telford.  In the course of the trial, I made an order by consent dismissing the plaintiff’s action against the Director of Public Prosecutions, who is the Administrator under the Criminal Assets Confiscation Act.  The Administrator is the person nominated by the Attorney-General to administer property forfeited or subject to restraining orders under the Act.  I made no order as to costs.  The third defendant, Telford, took no part in the action and the plaintiffs do not seek any orders against him. 

  3. At the start of the trial I made an order giving K & S Corporation leave to join K & S Group Pty Limited (“K & S Group”) as a plaintiff.  The action proceeded as an action by K & S Corporation and K & S Group against Sportingbet for the recovery of the disputed monies.  The principal basis of the plaintiffs’ claim is an assertion that there is a constructive trust over the disputed monies in their favour.  The plaintiffs assert that Sportingbet had the required level of knowledge or notice as to the source of the monies and the circumstances under which they were paid to make Sportingbet a constructive trustee of the monies.  Sportingbet denies that it had the required level of knowledge or notice.  In addition, it raises various defences including change of position, the provision of good consideration for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read K & S Corporation Ltd v Sportingbet Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 96
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

K & S Corporation Ltd, a holding company of various transport industry companies, brought an action against Sportingbet Australia, a sports bookmaker, seeking recovery of funds that were transferred from K & S Group's account at ANZ to Sportingbet's account at Westpac. The key issue was whether Sportingbet had knowledge of the misappropriation of funds by Telford, the chief financial officer of K & S Corporation, when it accepted the funds. The court needed to determine if Sportingbet had wilfully and recklessly failed to make inquiries that an honest and reasonable person would have made, thereby acquiring knowledge of the misappropriation.

The court examined several factors to ascertain Sportingbet's knowledge of the misappropriation. These included Sportingbet's failure to inquire about the source of funds, its interest only in Telford's past ability to settle debts, and the suspicious circumstances surrounding the payments. The court found that Sportingbet had indeed wilfully and recklessly failed to make the necessary inquiries, thereby acquiring the requisite knowledge. The court dismissed Sportingbet's defences of change of position and good consideration, as these defences required innocence, which was not present given Sportingbet's knowledge. The court concluded that Sportingbet was liable to return the misappropriated funds to K & S Corporation.

In light of the findings, the court ordered Sportingbet to pay K & S Corporation the sum of $1,667,000, representing the misappropriated funds, along with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from 15 April 2002 until the date of judgment, and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

I turn now to an examination of the facts of the case.The FactsFacts Not Contested The plaintiffs and Sportingbet agreed a number of facts, and other facts were established by uncontested evidence. K & S Corporation is the holding company of a large group of companies based in Mount Gambier in the State of South Australia. K & S Corporation was previously known as Scott Corporation Limited. The group of companies operate a range of businesses in the transport industry and allied industries throughout Australia. K & S Corporation owns all the shares in K & S Group and Reid Bros Pty Ltd and those companies in turn own all the shares in a number of companies. K & S Corporation does not operate a bank account. K & S Group operates a bank account on behalf of the companies in the group. At all the relevant times, K & S Group owned and operated the ANZ account which was and is an account at the branch of that bank in Mount Gambier, South Australia. The Bank provided a facility to K & S Group enabling it to transfer funds electronically. It is agreed between the parties that K & S Group operated the ANZ account for the benefit of, and at the direction of, K & S Corporation. Telford became an employee of the K & S group of companies in about the middle of 1999. On 9 August 1999 Telford was appointed the chief financial officer of K & S Corporation and on 31 August 1999 he was appointed secretary of the company and K & S Group. He ceased to hold these three positions on 22 April 2002. He was one of seven employees with the authority to authorise the electronic transfer of funds from the ANZ account. Sportingbet is a subsidiary of Sportingbet PLC (“Sportingbet PLC”) a publicly listed company incorporated in the United Kingdom. Sportingbet has been a subsidiary of Sportingbet PLC since about April 2000. It was incorporated in the State of New South Wales and carries on business as a sports bookmaker under s 90 of the Racing and Betting Act 1983 (NT) pursuant to a licence issued by the Racing Commission of the Northern Territory of Australia. That licence was obtained on 8 January 2002 and as I understand it, Sportingbet carried on no business until it commenced operating as a sports bookmaker on or about 20 February 2002. In March 2001 Sportingbet PLC acquired the shares in NOBS, a company incorporated in Vanuatu. The purchase contract was tendered in evidence. It consists of a series of quite complex commercial documents. Many of the details of the transaction are not relevant to the issues in this action. It is sufficient to say that the vendor of the shares is Vanuatu International Trust Company Limited (“VITCO”) and that that company is a company substantially owned and controlled by Mr Alan Tripp or interests associated with him. Mr Tripp was the chief executive officer and driving force behind NOBS before the sale. He retained an important managerial role after the sale of the shares in March 2001. The consideration for the sale was to be paid over 2 years and was referred to in the evidence as an “earn out”. The consideration involved cash and shares in Sportingbet PLC. The cash payable was calculated by reference to turnover of the NOBS business minus payments for winning wagers and a provision for bad debts. The shares are shares in Sportingbet PLC. The purchase price is payable in instalments, the last of which was payable in March 2003.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Sportingbet relied on the decision of the House of Lords in Thomson v Clydesdale Bank Ltd [1893] AC 282. In that case, the appellants were trustees who had instructed a broker to sell shares which they held on trust. The broker was instructed to deposit the proceeds in certain colonial banks in the names of the appellants. The broker sold the shares but deposited the proceeds of sale in an overdrawn account in his name with the respondent. The appellants sought to recover the proceeds from the respondent. They were unsuccessful. Sportingbet relied in particular on certain observations of Lord Watson (at 289). It seems to me that the case is distinguishable on the facts from the present case. An important matter in Thomson v Clydesdale Bank Ltd was the fact that there was nothing to put the Bank on notice that the broker might be misappropriating the monies placed in his account. Even if the Bank knew that the monies were the proceeds of the sale of shares owned by the broker’s clients, that did not put the Bank on notice that the broker was misapplying the monies. It was not uncommon for a broker to pay his client in advance, and then to recoup his outgoing upon the sale of the shares. Nor was it uncommon for a broker to deposit the proceeds of the sale of shares in his own account and retain the proceeds in that account for an interval of more or less time for the purpose of reinvestment or otherwise. In other words, there were facts which put the Bank on notice that the monies paid into the broker’s account were monies resulting from the sale of shares owned by the broker’s clients, but there was nothing to put the Bank on notice that by paying the monies into his account, the broker was misapplying the funds. The position in this case is different. If there were facts putting Sportingbet on notice that the monies were not Telford’s monies, then on the facts in this case it must follow that there were facts putting Sportingbet on notice that the monies had been or were being misappropriated.Rulings on Evidence There were two issues which arose in the course of the trial which it is convenient to mention at this stage. First, the plaintiffs sought to argue that Sportingbet had acted in breach of condition 22 of its licence as a sports bookmaker under the Racing and Betting Act 1983 (NT). That condition provides as follows:“The Sports Bookmaker or any other Associates shall not appoint, employ or engage in any capacity (whether as director, employee, consultant, adviser, or any other capacity), or be otherwise involved, with former Number One Betting Shop owner, Mr Alan Tripp or any (sic) his Associates. Furthermore, the Sports Bookmaker will not allow Mr Tripp’s involvement or his Associates as a Material Shareholder of, or supplier to, the Sports Bookmaker or any of its associated entities.‘Material Shareholder’ means a person owning or controlling (whether directly or indirectly) at least 5% of the issued shares of company with an entitlement to vote.‘Associate’ has the same meaning as the Income Tax Assessment Act, but will specifically exclude his son, Mr Matthew Tripp.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the five matters which I have identified I think that NOBS and then Sportingbet wilfully and recklessly failed to make the inquiries an honest and reasonable man would have made. Sportingbet refrained from making any inquiries. The source of the monies was of no concern to it. Sportingbet was only interested in the fact that Telford had settled his debts in the past. Even making allowances for the nature of the industry in which Sportingbet operates, the circumstances surrounding Telford and his account were such that its failure to make inquiries was both wilful and reckless. In reaching this conclusion I have placed no weight on the alleged illegal involvement of Mr Tripp in Sportingbet’s business after 20 February 2002. It is unnecessary to do so, and in any event, I do not think the evidence is sufficiently clear to enable me to make such an important finding with such potentially serious consequences. Nor have I placed any weight on the evidence relating to G’s activities. I do not know all of the circumstances surrounding the relationship between NOBS/Sportingbet and G and in the absence of such evidence I would be reluctant to make any firm findings. At best, the evidence establishes that NOBS and then Sportingbet did not have in place at the relevant times a system which would reveal the fact that one of their clients was settling with monies to which they were not entitled. That is a fact which I think is established on the evidence leaving aside evidence of the relationship between NOBS/Sportingbet and G.Conclusions on Knowledge I am satisfied that shortly after the payment on 24 August 2001 NOBS had the required level of knowledge, namely, it wilfully and recklessly failed to make the inquiries an honest and reasonable man would have made and that subsequent events up to early April 2002 reinforce that conclusion. If I am wrong and NOBS did not have the required level of knowledge in August 2001, I am nevertheless satisfied that events between August 2001 and early April 2002 were such that immediately prior to the payment on 15 April 2002 Sportingbet had the required level of knowledge in that it had wilfully and recklessly failed to make the inquiries an honest and reasonable man would have made. I reject Sportingbet’s submission that inquiries are unlikely to have revealed the true position. If a member of the management team had only looked at the bank statements the position would have become fairly clear that Telford was not making payments with his own monies and a general inquiry about K & S Group would have revealed that he was not entitled to use that company’s monies.Defences Sportingbet raised a number of defences, namely, change of position, the provision of good consideration for the payment, estoppel and election.Change of Position and the Provision of Good Consideration for the Payment The plaintiffs seem to accept that change of position was a defence. In Koorootang v ANZ Banking Group, Hansen J expressed the view that the liability of a recipient of trust property is restitution-based and there is a strong argument that liability should be strict, subject to defences of bona fide purchase and change of position. However, in view of the way that case was conducted, it was unnecessary for his Honour to decide the point.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Sportingbet raised a number of defences, namely, change of position, the provision of good consideration for the payment, estoppel and election.Change of Position and the Provision of Good Consideration for the Payment The plaintiffs seem to accept that change of position was a defence. In Koorootang v ANZ Banking Group, Hansen J expressed the view that the liability of a recipient of trust property is restitution-based and there is a strong argument that liability should be strict, subject to defences of bona fide purchase and change of position. However, in view of the way that case was conducted, it was unnecessary for his Honour to decide the point. In Gertsch v Atsas & ors, Foster AJ said that as the imposition of a constructive trust was based on some degree of “blameworthiness” on the part of the defendant, and the defence of change of position was based on the innocence of the defendant, it was clear that the defence was not available to resist a claim for a constructive trust. I am inclined to agree with this view. I note also that in a claim asserting a trust over property which has passed from a trustee to a third party, the third party would ordinarily only have a defence if he could prove that he was a bona fide purchaser for value without notice. If that was the relevant defence in this case it could not be established because of the findings as to knowledge. As I have said, the plaintiff proceeded on the basis that the defence of change of position was available to Sportingbet. As it happens, I do not think that the defence can be made out on the facts and in those circumstances it is not strictly necessary for me to decide the point. In the ordinary case, a change of position must be an innocent change of position made on the faith of the receipt of the monies. The change of position asserted here cannot be considered innocent because of the findings I have made about knowledge. However, it is appropriate that I proceed to consider whether the three matters raised by Sportingbet could constitute a change of position. First, Sportingbet points to the fact that it has paid turnover tax. This submission fails. The turnover tax is paid on the wagers made not on whether they are ultimately paid (s 106 Racing and Betting Act). The liability to pay turnover tax was incurred when the wagers were accepted and they were accepted by Sportingbet in the belief that Telford would pay, not that he had paid. Secondly, Sportingbet points to the fact that it has paid the Goods and Services Tax on the receipt of the disputed monies. This submission fails. It is not entirely clear whether the tax is payable on the wager or on the payment. If it is the former (which it would seem to be) then the submission fails for the same reason as the submission in relation to turnover tax fails. Even if it is the latter there is no evidence excluding the possibility that the payment of tax may be recovered if it is found that Sportingbet has no entitlement to the disputed monies. Thirdly, there seemed to be an argument put that but for the seizure of the disputed monies they would have been remitted to the parent company in the United Kingdom. I cannot see how that constitutes a relevant change of position. Nor can I see how the mere fact that the funds remained in the Westpac account for a few days and normal trading continued can constitute a relevant change of position.