JPPS and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

JPPS and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023] AATA 3022 (21 September 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/7728

Re:JPPS

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Date:21 September 2023

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision dated 16 September 2022 and substitutes it with the decision that the Applicant is not ineligible for grant of a protection visa by reason of

s 36(2C)(a)(ii) of the Migration Act 1958.

........................[SGD]........................

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Catchwords

MIGRATION – refusal to grant protection visa – whether serious reasons for considering that the applicant committed a serious non-political crime before entering Australia – citizen of Lebanon – sentence of death in absentia by Judicial Council of Lebanon – alleged involvement with Islamist terrorism – decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Extradition Act 1988 (Cth)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Cases
Attef Al-Habr and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

[1999] AATA 150
Australian Postal Commission v Hayes
(1989) FCA 176


Azizi and Minister for Home Affairs

(Migration) [2018] AATA 2561
Braysich v The Queen
[2011] HCA 14
DZT18 v Minister for Home Affairs
[2019] FCCA 734

DZT18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2019] FCA 1639
FTZK and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship; Re [2012] AATA 312

FTZK v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCAFC 44

FTZK v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] HCA 26
GWRV v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCAFC 39
Issa and Migration Agents Registration Authority [2017] AATA 1110
GWRV v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 602

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Singh

[2002] HCA 7
[2013] FCAFC 26
SZQSC and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FMCA 531


Rawson Finances Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation

T v Home Secretary [1996] AC 742
ZYVZ and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2018] AATA 3967

ZYVZ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCA 28
1822068 (Migration) [2018] AATA 4086
1932525 (Refugee) [2020] AATA 5544

Secondary Materials

Department of Immigration and Border Protection, Refugee Law Guidelines (reissued 27 November 2022)

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Country Information Report Lebanon (19 March 2019)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

21 September 2023

BACKGROUND

  1. JPPS applied on 20 September 2022 for review of the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs, dated 16 September 2022. The delegate determined that there were serious reasons for considering the Applicant had committed a serious non-political crime before entering Australia under s 36(2C)(a)(ii) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The legal consequences of this decision are that JPPS is taken not to have satisfied the criterion in s 36(2)(aa) of the Act, which otherwise provides that as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of being removed from Australia there is a real…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JPPS and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicult... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3022
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs to refuse to grant a protection visa to the applicant, JPPS. The core of the dispute revolved around whether there were "serious reasons for considering" that JPPS had committed a serious non-political crime before entering Australia, which would render him ineligible for a protection visa. The case was heard by Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine whether the applicant, JPPS, had committed a serious non-political crime prior to his arrival in Australia. This determination was crucial as it engaged an exclusionary provision under migration law. The Tribunal was required to carefully consider the evidence presented, including a judgment in absentia from the Lebanese Judicial Council, and assess whether it established "serious reasons" for such a conclusion, paying close attention to the integrity of the Lebanese legal proceedings and the strength of the evidence relied upon.

The Tribunal's reasoning was guided by established principles concerning the assessment of "serious reasons" for exclusionary provisions, particularly in cases involving trials in absentia. It referenced previous decisions, such as *FTZK* and *Al-Habr*, which emphasised the need for considerable care and a strong inference based on minute examination of the material. The Tribunal noted that a conviction alone does not automatically constitute "serious reasons" and that the integrity of the foreign trial and the evidence presented are paramount. In this instance, the Tribunal considered the evidence presented by JPPS, including his account of detention and torture in Lebanon, and the documentation from Lebanese authorities indicating he had a "clean record" and was released without charge. It also examined the Lebanese Judicial Council's decision, which tried JPPS in absentia and alleged his involvement in national security offences, arms trade, and forgery, based on his purported testimony and other evidence.

Ultimately, the Tribunal found that there were not serious reasons for considering that JPPS had committed a serious non-political crime before entering Australia. The Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted a new decision to grant the protection visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The decision closes by stating that it was issued in absentia and ‘made clear publicly in the presence of the representative of the Appellate Public Prosecutor’. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND JPPS first came to Australia in 2009 on a visitor’s visa sponsored by his family. He subsequently arrived in Australia on 8 May 2010 on a further visitor’s visa, also sponsored by his family.First protection visa decision JPPS engaged Mr Sam Issa of Firmstone Associates to lodge his first protection visa application (FST2, 103). In his associated statutory declaration (FST2, 143), the Applicant declares:(a)he sold a vehicle to MM on 17/5/2007 with the balance to be paid in two days, and on Sunday 20/5/2007 conflict broke out at Nahar El Barad refugee camp [11];(b)the purchaser did not come on 21/5/2007 and JPPS spent the rest of the day calling the purchaser’s cell number [12];(c)later that day a named gentleman informed the Applicant that MM had been arrested by Lebanese intelligence and this was associated with the conflict in the camp [13];(d)he later received a call from Lebanese intelligence requesting his attendance the next morning at the Ashrafieh headquarters [14];(e)later the following day he was questioned and gave the account of selling a vehicle, showing the cheque, was released, and left about 11.00 PM [15]-[16];(f)the following Saturday he was again summoned to Ashrafieh and attended that evening and was detained [17]-[18];(g)the following day JPPS was blindfolded and was then interrogated in sessions lasting 3 hours over the next five days, during which time he remained handcuffed and was suspended by a piece of timber placed between his legs, beaten with a steel object, and received electric shocks ‘in an effort to make me confess that I had some association with the militants’ [19];(h)he was then transferred to Roumiah prison and held without charge for 24 months, together with other detainees accused of terrorism, experienced periodic interrogation and torture, and was denied legal representation [20]-[21];(i)JPPS received two visits by the Red Cross and was seldom permitted family visits, then was released without charge and made to sign an undertaking not to discuss his situation with any third person, or his legal representative [22]-[24];(j)an attempt was made on his life in September 2009 by Lebanese intelligence when he was shot in the face while entering his house at 1.00 AM, the police advised him to drop the matter, and his lawyer advised him to leave Lebanon [26]-[29]; and(k)JPPS states ‘I have never had any association nor supported any militant group or individual’ and continues to experience trauma from his ordeal [31]-[32]. Further relevant material associated with this application includes:(a)translation of a document described as Copy of Judicial Record, dated 11 August 2009, which reports that JPPS has a ‘clean record’ (FST2, 159);(b)translation of a letter from the Applicant’s Lebanese lawyer, Mr Z, dated 22 May 2010, which states that JPPS was detained in Roumieh Prison between May 2007 and May 2009 and ‘was released because he was not guilty in a terror crime they attributed to him’ (FST2, 155);(c)translation of a statement from the Ministry of Justice, Lebanon, dated 22/6/2010 (FST2, 213) declaring that JPPS was arrested on 13/9/2007 and released on 29/5/2009; and(d)report of a clinical psychologist, dated 7 June 2010 (FST2, 209), which states that JPPS reported frequent suicidal thoughts and hypervigilance and ‘has developed post traumatic stress disorder and major depression’.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Selections from the Criminal Code provided by the same body indicate that Article 205 deals with application of only the most severe penalty in cases where multiple felonies or misdemeanours are found to have been committed. Article 219 establishes the criteria for those found to be accomplices to crimes.EVIDENCEJPPS The Applicant lodged a brief further statement dated by the translator 7 December 2022 (AE1), which I summarise:(a)he was a teacher at the time his father passed away in 1999 and he took over his father’s role working for the post office during the time the postal contract was managed by the Eido family;(b)the Applicant became involved with some politicians and his political activities increased to the point he considered becoming a candidate for municipal council;(c)his involvement with the member of parliament Walid Eido extended to seeking to register an association which was not politically affiliated, the registration not being approved;(d)he also assisted Walid Eido in elections in Beirut in 2005, which he states led to some form of threat from a Syrian officer;(e)Walid Eido and his son were killed in a bombing in 2007 due to their public opposition to Hezbollah, a little after JPPS was arrested, and this information was raised with Mr Issa but he did not appear to be interested and did not read papers provided to him, or add them to the case file; and(f)he considered that his story in a telephone hearing with the Tribunal was affected by poor interpreting. JPPS stated in evidence that he sold the car to AM in 2004 who provided a cheque, but the Applicant kept calling him about the payment. I understood JPPS to say he was then jailed for three months and then tried again to call about the money. JPPS was told by the family that AM was out of Lebanon. The Applicant went to the bank to obtain proof about the failure to pay, which he did and then lodged a legal complaint. JPPS then referred to following up with the family, and an agreement signed by MM and his father in 2006, and stated that he agreed to withdraw the complaint. When redirected to explain how he came to be in prison in 2007, JPPS stated it was because he had been in contact with MM about the money. He referred to being seen by another gentleman to be talking on the phone, and to being advised that he may be called in for questioning. JPPS stated that he was questioned late at night and asked what he wanted from MM, he explained the situation and was released. JPPS stated that he was asked to return on a Saturday after an officer had visited the family home. On this occasion after being made to wait, the Applicant stated he had a bag placed over his head, was handcuffed and was taken underground in a lift. JPPS stated he was then regularly questioned about MM and abused. Later he signed a paper when asked to do, in order to get out of the situation. I understood during this passage of evidence that the Applicant referred to signing papers on two occasions, once in his first period of detention and again in Roumieh prison.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The sole issue for determination is whether I am satisfied that there are serious reasons for considering that JPPS committed a serious non-political crime before entering Australia. JUDICIAL COUNCIL DECISION A translated version of the decision of the Judicial Council was lodged with the T documents (T30.p.iv). It appears to have been prepared by a qualified Australian-based translator and, as noted, it was originally provided by JPPS in the course of other proceedings. It bears a case number in 2012 and the decision is dated in 2014. The case is described as being brought by the Prosecutor General, against three defendants: JPPS; Mr M; and, Mr A. All defendants were tried in absentia, and while there appears to be some relationship among the offences alleged against Mr M and Mr A, their alleged offending does not bear any relationship to that alleged against JPPS. The Council is described as being comprised of a President by proxy, Judge Anthony Issa El-Khoury, and four other judicial members. The decision is stated to have been based upon ‘investigations and consultations’, an indictment, and a prosecution brief presented at the Court of Cassation before the Judicial Council. The indictment is said to have been split into 30 files to facilitate the hearing. Supporting references are made to:1- Decree No. /154/ on 4/07/2007, by which the offence against the State national security which occurred on 20/05/2007, at Nahr el-Bared, and which resulted in a number of soldiers and civilian deaths and casualties, was brought before the Council, in addition to all individuals who contributed to, encouraged or interfered in this offence in any capacity;2- The decision of the Minister of Justice… which appointed Judge Ghassan Owaidat as a judicial investigator in the case … The decision records that an arrest warrant was issued against JPPS in 2014 after being tried in absentia having ‘failed to appear before the Judicial Council despite being duly notified’ (and warrants were also issued for the other defendants) and the document then states:They have recently, at the camp of Nahr el-Bared – in the North of Lebanon and outside it, engaged in conspiring against the State national security, a felony defined and punishable in Articles 207/271/339/316 of the Penal Code, in Arms Trade, a misdemeanour defined in Article 72 of the Arms Code and forgery and usage of forged material, a misdemeanour defined in Articles 463 and 470 of the Penal Code. I summarise the facts alleged against JPPS which are lengthy, and stated as being based upon his testimony before the Information Division:(a)he had a relationship with MM and his brother AM based on a loan which their father promised to pay;(b)he admitted that he provided weapons to Fatah al-Islam and committed fraud;(c)he met AM in 2004 and was directed by MM and another gentleman at the end of 2006 to sell arsenic and red mercury to a further gentleman in Nabatieh;(d)the transaction did not occur as the mercury was fake and MM also presented material claimed to be gold to a jeweller, also found to be fake;(e)MM asked JPPS to help sell fifty Glock pistols to a gentleman, but the deal did not go through, and he was then asked to negotiate a deal for heavy weapons;(f)at MM’s request he assisted in securing forged passports and asked for money to purchase the heavy weapons;(g)JPPS ultimately procured eight forged passports for MM in multiple nationalities, two forged driver licences and a bad quality ID card, and received payment for these items;(h)he was also paid for supplying AM with a pistol and silencer; and(i)a gentleman testified that he sold his children’s passports as part of the forgery deal and another gentleman testified that he had been sold a forged Lebanese passport by JPPS.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent clarified that it was not specifically relying upon correspondence from the Departmental officer in Beirut stating that informal inquiries led local authorities to express concern about the Applicant’s record. However, I understood the Respondent to indicate this material may carry weight if supported by the evidence as a whole. It was also confirmed that documents said to refer to a security referral about JPPS were not in Departmental files.CONSIDERATION It follows from FTZK that considerable care must be taken in determining whether serious reasons exist, and a finding must be based on a strong inference, with very close attention paid to the material said to form the basis of the operation of the exclusionary provision. The decision of Mathews J, then President of the Tribunal, in Attef Al-Habr and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] AATA 150 (Al-Habr) also provides some relevant guidance. This is particularly so as that decision deals with a matter involving a ruling in absentia by the Lebanese Judicial Council. Consistent with FTZK, Her Honour considered the provision did not represent a standard of proof [81]. It was also held, that ‘the mere fact of a conviction does not, of its own, necessarily constitute “serious reasons for considering” that the person has committed the crime in question’ [85]. Mathews J went on to state that findings, in the context of continued denials of involvement in the crime, could only be based on an assessment of the integrity of the trial in Lebanon and the strength of the evidence [88]. In the particular circumstances pertaining in Al-Habr, Her Honour considered there was so much unanswered (and unanswerable) as to the integrity of the trial, that the fact of conviction could not be given great weight [92]. There appears to have been a very detailed statement of evidence in the reasons of the Judicial Council lodged in that matter. I note that Kerr J, in the minority of the Full Court decision in FTZK[10] observes that in the original decision,[11] the Tribunal ‘correctly approved’ the approach taken in Al-Habr [159]. This was said (by the Tribunal) to involve examining all of the evidence ‘in minute detail bearing in mind the seriousness of the allegations’. His Honour goes on to say that this approach is ‘warranted by the nature of the jurisdiction, given that the ‘paradigm case’ is that it cannot be assumed the person facing return will get a fair trial’ [160].[10] FTZK v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCAFC 44.[11] Re FTZK and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] AATA 312. ZYVZ also involved consideration of whether the outcome of a trial in absentia might contribute positively to a finding that there were serious reasons. The Tribunal in that matter considered that it was feasible that a conviction might constitute serious reasons, assuming certain procedural fundamentals were present (ZYVZ and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2018] AATA 3967 [45]-[47]). On appeal, the court appeared to generally endorse the detailed attention paid to such procedural matters (ZYVZ [57]-[80]).