Johnstone v State of New South Wales

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
Johnstone v State of New South Wales [2010] NSWCA 70

FILE NUMBER(S):
2008/289961

HEARING DATE(S):
4 February 2010

JUDGMENT DATE:
9 April 2010

PARTIES:
Adam Christopher Johnstone (Appellant)
State of New South Wales (Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:
Beazley JA McColl JA Young JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
DC 9469/01

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Balla DCJ

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
14 December 2007

COUNSEL:
D Kennedy SC;  G Smith (Appellant)
P Menzies QC;  G Giagos (Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
Lough Wells Duncan (Wollongong) (Appellant)
I V Knight Crown Solicitor (Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
ARREST – arrest at common law – Christie v Leachinsky [1947] AC 573 – requirement to inform of the “true reason” for arrest
ARREST – arrest without warrant – Crimes Act 1900 – s 352 – preconditions for arrest – lawfulness of arrest
OFFENCES – Transport Administration (Railway Offences) Regulation 1994 – cl 41 – requirement to provide warning
LICENCE – implied licence – trespass on railway land – hole in fence to railway land – whether hole in fence amounts to implied licence – whether prior use or use by other of hole in fence amounts to implied licence
EVIDENCE – Evidence Act 1995 – ss 55 & 56 – relevant evidence – evidence used for multiple purposes – credit findings – whether medical evidence as to damage can be used in adverse credit findings
EVIDENCE – Evidence Act 1995 – s 136 – unfairly prejudicial evidence – procedural fairness – limiting use of evidence – need for an application under s 136 to be made

LEGISLATION CITED:
Crimes Act 1900
Crown Proceedings Act 1988
Evidence Act 1995
Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002
Law Reform (Vicarious Liability) Act 1983
Transport Administration (Railway Offences) Regulation 1994

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:
Abbassy and another v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [1990] 1 All ER 193
Al-Kateb v Godwin [2004] HCA 37; (2004) 219 CLR 562
ASIC v Vines [2003] NSWSC 995; 48 ACSR 282
Christie v Leachinsky [1947] AC 573
Clark v Trenerry (1996) 125 FLR 260
CSR Ltd v Della Maddalena [2006] HCA 1; (2006) 224 ALR 1
Donaldson v Broomby [1982] 40 ALR 525; (1981) 60 FLR 124
Fox v UK (1991) 13 EHRR 157
Halliday v Nevill [1984] HCA 80; (1984) 155 CLR 1
Mackalley’s Case (1611), 9 Co Rep 65b, Cro Jac 279, 14 Digest 313, 3288
Mark Silbermann v CGU Inusrance Limited; John Huyshe Greaves v CGU Insurance Limited; John David Rich v CGU Insurance Limited; One.Tel Limited (In Liq) v Rich & Ors [2003] NSWSC 1127; 48 ACSR 231
Police v Dafov [2008] SASC 247; (2008) 102 SASR 8
R v Kane [2001] NSWCCA 150
R v Longman [1988] 1 WLR 619
R v McNeill (Ruling No 1) [2007] NFSC 2
St Alder & Ors v Waverley Local Council & Anor [2010] NSWCA 22
State of New South Wales v Delly [2007] NSWCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Johnstone v State of New South Wales and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWCA 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned the lawfulness of an arrest and the subsequent use of force. The appellant, Mr Johnstone, alleged he was unlawfully arrested and assaulted by police officers on railway land. He also contended that he was on the land under an implied licence and that the trial judge erred in her findings of fact and in her use of evidence. The case was heard in the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the arrest of Mr Johnstone was lawful, considering both the common law requirement to inform an arrestee of the true reason for their arrest and the provisions of section 352 of the Crimes Act 1900. Further issues included whether excessive force was used in effecting the arrest, whether Senior Constable Munn committed a separate assault, and whether Mr Johnstone had an implied licence to be on railway land. The court also had to determine if the trial judge erred in preferring the evidence of the police officers over Mr Johnstone's, particularly in her use of medical evidence to make adverse credit findings.

The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge had erred in her findings regarding the lawfulness of the arrest and the use of excessive force. The court held that the arresting officer, Senior Constable O’Neil, did not adequately inform Mr Johnstone of the true reason for his arrest, which was for failing to provide his name and address when required under the relevant legislation, not for trespassing. The court also found that the evidence did not support the conclusion that Mr Johnstone was on the railway land without an implied licence. Furthermore, the court determined that the trial judge had improperly used medical evidence concerning Mr Johnstone's injuries to make adverse credit findings against him, contrary to the principles of procedural fairness and the Evidence Act 1995.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in part, setting aside the trial judge's orders regarding the lawfulness of the arrest and the use of force. The matter was remitted to the District Court for a determination of damages and the specific question of whether Senior Constable Munn assaulted the appellant. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of both the first instance hearing and the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed in part;

2. Set aside orders (1) and (2) made by the trial judge;

3. Remit the matter to the District Court for determination of the question of damages and the question whether Senior Constable Munn assaulted the appellant;

4. Order that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs both of the first instance hearing and of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issues raised on the appeal were as follows:1. Was the arrest lawful? This raised two questions:(a)Did the arresting officer, Senior Constable O’Neil, comply with the common law obligation to inform Mr Johnstone of the true reason for his arrest?(b)Was the arrest, which was without a warrant, made in accordance with the provisions of the Crimes Act 1900, s 352 (now repealed)?2.If the arrest was lawful, did the officers nonetheless use excessive force in effecting the arrest?3.Did Senior Constable Munn separately assault Mr Johnstone by hitting him on the knee with a baton, independently of the lawfulness of the arrest?4. Was the appellant on railway land pursuant to an implied licence? 5.Did the trial judge err in preferring the evidence of the officers over the evidence of Mr Johnstone? This issue raised two matters:(a)Did her Honour err in utilising the evidence of Mr Johnstone’s medical condition (and its history) in the making of adverse credit findings against Mr Johnstone? (b)Were her Honour’s credit findings supportable? If not, Mr Johnstone sought a number of findings on critical matters different from those made by her Honour. (There were a number of other issues raised which it is not necessary to identify at this stage.)Background facts Mr Johnstone was arrested at about 1.45 pm on the western side of the railway line at Towradgi, about 50 m from the southern end of the platform of the Towradgi railway station. Mr Johnstone’s evidence was that he was on his way to see a chamber magistrate in Wollongong, to make a complaint regarding his treatment by police some days earlier. As he intended to walk to Wollongong, he decided to take a shortcut through railway land. He was observed by Constables O’Neil and Fitzpatrick, who were on a train travelling north. They alighted at Towradgi railway station, approached Mr Johnstone and asked him what he had in the bag he was carrying. He informed them there was food in his bag. (He also had a pair of jeans in the bag.) The officers asked to inspect inside his bag, as they were concerned about the theft of copper bond from the railway line. Mr Johnstone showed them his bag and the officers only saw the food. They then asked him for identification. He took out his wallet and handed over his Medicare card. He was asked for more identification and he handed over his wallet, which contained a Mine Rescue card. The officers handed the wallet back to Mr Johnstone, but retained his Medicare card. The officers’ failure to return the Medicare card became the catalyst for what followed, although Mr Johnstone’s and the officers’ version of events differed markedly. Mr Johnstone’s version was that when he asked for the return of his Medicare card, he was grabbed and put in a headlock. He was then “drilled” into the ground by the police officers, handcuffed and “ripped up” from the ground by the officers grabbing the handcuffs. The officers then commenced moving him towards the opposite end of the railway station. Mr Johnstone contended that in doing this, the officers threw him over a 4-5 foot high fence onto bitupave. He also contended that as he was being “moved along”, Senior Constable Munn struck him on the right knee with a baton, apparently in response to a remark by Mr Johnstone, “Remember my sister belted you with a suitcase”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The question whether Mr Johnstone was informed of the true reason for his arrest depends upon two matters: first, what was the offence for which he was arrested; and, secondly, whether what Mr Johnstone was told was sufficient compliance with the officer’s common law obligation to tell him the true ground for his arrest.Senior Constable O’Neil’s evidence In his evidence in chief, Senior Constable O’Neil said that after Mr Johnstone showed him the contents of his bag, he gave Senior Constable O’Neil “some identification”. He was asked by counsel why he had asked for “identification” and replied that Mr Johnstone was “on an unauthorised area of the railway land”. He was again asked what his intention was in asking for the identification and he responded:“A. My intention was to establish who he is and then from there make some inquiries. If I found out more details to make me more suspicious of him as a person I’d probably then would have insisted to have a bit better look inside in his bag.Q. Otherwise what would you have done?A. Well, when I spoke to him I asked him for his name and address and he asked me what was I going to fine him. I said, look, I just want to get his name and address and basically I will do a check on him, if he has no prior histories or problems with the railways I was going to give him a caution but if he had I told him, yes, I was going to give him a fine.…Q. When you asked for identification did Mr Johnston [sic] produce any identification?A. Yeah, Mr Johnston handed me a Medicare card.Q. Did you see a name on it?A. Yes, it had the name – I read it and it was his name he supplied Paul Johnston.…Q. When you received the Medicare Card, were you satisfied with the extent of that identification?A. No, I wasn’t. I saw that he had a wallet. I was quite interested – was there any other further supporting documentation to say who he is.Q. What sort of further information did you require, sergeant?A. I required him to supply his name and his date of birth and his address.Q. Was the date of birth or address present on the Medicare Card you received?A. No, it wasn’t. Q. Did you ask for any further identification?A. Yes, I did.Q. What, if anything, happened when you asked for further identification?A. He refused. He said, ‘I’ve given you my identification,’ meaning he’d given me his Medicare Card.Q. Do you recall the word that he used when refusing to provide more identification?A. No, he said, ‘You’ve got my identification,’ and he’s not giving anything else.Q. What, if anything, did you do about that?A. Well, the reason I have had dealings in the past with people supplying identification, not knowing the person, I don’t know if the identification was his or someone else. I said I needed to get his name and date of birth and address so I can verify if this is in fact who it is. He said, ‘That’s me.’ I said, ‘I don’t know you. So I need to basically verify that,’ and I just wanted that information so I could make some inquiries.Q. At that point what, if anything, did you notice about Mr Johnstone’s demeanour?A. Well, let’s say he became a lot more defiant; a bit more hostile. He was no longer compliant. He was a bit more agitated. He wanted to go. He said, ‘I want to go.’Q. What did he say to you?A. He said, ‘Give that back.’ He said, ‘I want to go home.’ He tried to snatch the Medicare Card from me. I took my hand away so he couldn’t get it.Q. Did Mr Johnstone say he had somewhere to go, some appointment?A. No, he didn’t.Q. You told her Honour that he tried to snatch the card back. A. That’s correct, yeah.Q. Did he retrieve the card from you?A. No, I managed to keep the card from him. At that stage he did push me. Q. What, if anything, did you say or do when Mr Johnstone pushed you?A. I said to him slightly before that basically, you know, if he didn’t supply me with his name and details he would have to be arrested. Then he wanted to go, so basically -- Q. Sorry, pausing there for a moment, sergeant. When you told Mr Johnstone that if he didn’t give those details he would be arrested, what offence was it your intention to arrest him with?A. He committed the offence by crossing the rail lines. Basically the offence is not supply name and address, to not supply his particulars.Q. After you told Mr Johnstone … that he would be arrested, what, if anything, did he say or do?A. He then pushed me a further two times. I stepped back and told him that he’d be under arrest. That’s when he sort of shaped his fists up. And he started like he was – like I thought okay – he knew – he’d been told he was understand [sic] arrest. But he put his fists up in a fighting stance; he was bouncing around like – I got the impression – I knew then for a fact that he wasn’t going to be arrested easily.” (emphasis added)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established