John Cousins v Construction Occupations Registrar (Occupational Discipline)

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

JOHN COUSINS v CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATIONS REGISTRAR (Occupational Discipline) [2024] ACAT 48

AT 54/2023

Catchwords:               ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – decision to issue rectification order in relation to renovations by builder and former owner of house - limitation period for order – meaning of ‘act that caused the contravention happened, or ended’ in limitation provision – amendment of limitation provision to extend limitation period for order – whether limitation period had ended before the amendment – presumption against retrospective legislation – whether amendment to limitation provision subject to presumption against retrospective legislation

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s 68

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s 7
Building Act 2004 ss 48, 69, 85
Building and Construction Amendment Act 2019
Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004 (R52) ss 34, 35, 38
Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004 (R53) ss 2, 6, 7, 34, 35, 123A, 123C
Legislation Act 2001 ss 6, 47, 84, 132

Subordinate

Legislation cited:        Construction Occupations (Licensing) Regulations 2004 ss 42A, 42B, Sch 4

Cases cited:Burns v Minister for Health [2012] WASCA 267

Chang Jeeng v Nuffield (Australia) Pty Ltd (1959) 101 CLR 629
Coleman v The Shell Company of Australia Limited (1943) 45 SR (NSW) 27
D’Arro v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2017] QCA 90
Esber v The Commonwealth (1992) 174 CLR 430
Koundouris v The Owners, Units Plan 1917 [2017] ACTCA 36

Maxwell v Murphy (1957) 96 CLR 261

Nicholas v Commissioner for Corporate Affairs [1988] VR 289

Rodway v The Queen (1990) 169 CLR 515

Re a Solicitors Clerk [1957] 1 WLR 1219

Yew Bon Tew v Kenderaan Bas Mara [1983] 1 AC 553

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Dennis Pearce, Statutory Interpretation in Australia (9th edition, 2019)

Diggory Bailey and Luke Norbury, Bennion, Bailey and Norbury on Statutory Interpretation (8th edition, 2020)

Tribunal:Senior Member R Orr KC

Date of Orders:  4 July 2024

Date of Reasons for Decision:      4 July 2024

Date of Publication:  11 July 2024

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AT 54/2023

BETWEEN:

JOHN BERNARD COUSINS
Applicant

AND:

CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATIONS REGISTRAR
Respondent

AND

ANDREW PURDON
First Party Joined

SARAH PURDON
Second Party Joined

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member R Orr KC

DATE:4 July 2024

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The decision by the respondent to issue to the applicant a rectification order dated 19 June 2023 is set aside, and a decision is made in substitution not to make a rectification order.

    ………………………………..

Senior Member R Orr KC

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. These proceedings concern a decision by the Australian Capital Territory Construction Occupations Registrar (Registrar or respondent) to issue to John Cousins (applicant, John Cousins or Mr Cousins) a rectification order on 19 June 2023 (rectification order or order) under section 38 of the Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004 (Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act or COLA) in relation to renovations to a house (renovations or works) which Mr Cousins had owned…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Cousins v Construction Occupations Registrar (Occupatio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACAT 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of John Cousins v Construction Occupations Registrar, the applicant, Mr Cousins, sought to have a rectification order set aside, which required him to bring his property up to compliance with the relevant building standards. The dispute primarily revolved around the interpretation of statutory provisions, specifically the Old Act, and the applicability of the presumption against retrospective legislation. The respondent, the Construction Occupations Registrar, argued that the order was valid and enforceable. The case was heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, and the primary issue for the tribunal was whether the rectification order could be issued under the Old Act, given the changes in legislation over time.

The tribunal considered whether the rectification order could be issued under the Old Act and if the changes in legislation over time, particularly the presumption against retrospective legislation, impacted the enforceability of the order. The tribunal examined the legislative history and the provisions of the Old Act, including the example provided in section 35, which discussed a scenario similar to Mr Cousins' situation. The tribunal also looked at the relationship between the rectification order and the expert report by Peak Consulting, which supported the order's references to poor structural integrity. However, the tribunal found that the terms of the Peak Consulting report could not be used to expand the terms of the rectification order beyond what was expressly or implicitly stated.

In its decision, the tribunal relied on significant case law supporting the presumption against retrospective operation of legislation, as outlined in the Legislation Act. The tribunal referenced Coleman v The Shell Company of Australia Limited and Maxwell v Murphy, where the courts had held that amending legislation would not revive a right to maintain an action that had been barred before the amendment was made. The tribunal concluded that the presumption against retrospectivity applied, and the rectification order could not be enforced under the Old Act.

As a result, the tribunal set aside the decision by the respondent to issue the rectification order to Mr Cousins and made a decision in substitution not to make a rectification order. This decision was based on the tribunal's finding that the rectification order could not be issued under the Old Act and that the presumption against retrospective legislation applied to the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The decision by the respondent to issue to the applicant a rectification order dated 19 June 2023 is set aside, and a decision is made in substitution not to make a rectification order.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent and party joined also referred to ‘example 2’ which was in section 35 of the Old Act for a period of time.[17] It is true that the example mentions certification. It is confusing in its terms. But it does seem to provide for several events: 1. original work that did not comply with technical standards 13 years ago and where there was no certification; 2. further work to bring the original work into compliance with the certification 9 years ago (that is 4 years after the original work); 3. then the Registrar may issue a rectification notice. It seems to me clear that it is the fact that the work only ended 9 years ago that provides a basis for issuing a notice. It has little to do with the certification. Even taking into account section 132 of the Legislation Act, this is no basis on which to override the clear words of the Old Act.Documentary and approvals evidence[17] Respondent’s submissions at [33]-[35]; party joined’s submissions at [10]-[13]. The example provided that:2. A licensee undertook work that did not comply with the required technical standards 13 years previously without obtaining or providing a required certification. The licensee did not bring the work into compliance with the relevant certification until 4 years after the work was complete. The registrar is not satisfied that the act that caused the contravention ended over 10 years ago and may issue the rectification order to the licensee. A fourth point concerns the drawings and approvals for various works. There was some confusion and dispute about these. The applicant stated that some renovation works were undertaken in 1999-2000.[18] Mr Cousins provided 1999 approved plans, which he says he carried out in 1999 to 2000.[19][18] Statement of John Cousins dated 8 February 2024, exhibit A1 at [8]-[17][19] Statement of John Cousins dated 8 February 2024, exhibit A1 at [8]-[17], pages 5-8 of the attached exhibit JC-1 He then says he did additional works in 2001-2003, and he provided plans for these.[20] A further version of these plans was tendered as exhibit A9.[20] Statement of John Cousins dated 8 February 2024, exhibit A1 at [18]-[23], pages 13-15 of the attached exhibit JC-1 These plans clearly show a new rear deck and enlarged deck for new front entry (see discussion of the decking at paragraphs [65]-[72] below); corrugated roof sheeting (see paragraphs [96]-[98] below); and reconfiguring of the bathroom and addition of an ensuite and new laundry (see paragraphs [107]-[109] below). Mr Cousins says that in December 2003 Don Waring as the appointed certifier did a final inspection, with a report dated 8 December 2003. This report includes a statement apparently by Mr Waring that:Extensive but minor alterations to previously approved plans noted including some variations not yet shown on amended plans provided by owner. Those amendments subsequently noted on plan (by hand). Site inspection of completed work noted all work, internally and externally, is fully completed and complies with requirements. All surfaces components finishes fittings and services fully operational.[21][21] Statement of John Cousins dated 8 February 2024, exhibit A1 at [23], page 16 of the attached exhibit JC-1

Decision

Reasons for decision

The rectification order says that it is to be read in conjunction with the notice of decision in relation to the rectification order dated 19 June 2023 (notice of decision). The notice of decision refers to the Peak Consulting first report, which is attachment A to the notice of decision. The notice of decision then states that the decision maker gave due regard to that report, being produced by a professional with sufficient knowledge and experience to form such conclusions, and that they found this material relevant to making their decision.[36] The rectification order makes clear that the relevant defects are those identified in section 3 of the order; for the decks these are set out above in paragraph [65] above. The order does say after this list of defects: “Evidence considered by the delegate include: Attachment A: Special Purpose Inspection Expert Defect Report V1.1 – 9 Sep 2022”, that is the Peak Consulting first report. Most of the detail in the report is in relation to the structural defects identified in the rectification order. The Peak Consulting first report generally supports the order’s references to poor structural integrity. However also in the report, the executive summary states that “the rear pergola was not constructed in accordance with AS 1684.2 Residential timber frame constructed and lacks adequate falls to the corrugated polycarbonate roof sheeting, and flashings are not compliant”. The report itself also refers to the pergola, the pergola roof fall, and also one of the pergola roof support posts in relation to AS 1684.2.[37][36] Order, page 1, notice of decision, page 2, attached to the application[37] Peak Consulting first report, pages 5, 6 and 9 (exhibit A7), attached to the notice of decision, which is attached to the application This raises the issue of the relationship between the rectification order and the Peak Consulting first report. In my view it is clear from the rectification order itself and the notice of decision that the decision-maker had regard to the report as evidence on which the terms of the order were based, that is as evidence of the relevant contraventions. But I do not think that the terms of the Peak Consulting first report can be used to expand the terms of the rectification order; that is I do not think that because the report refers to the pergola, that this is therefore included in the rectification order, when the order itself neither expressly or implicitly refers to this. John Cousins was cross-examined in relation to the pergola and overlay (discussed immediately following at [79]-[85]), and he agreed these would increase the load on the decking.[38] But this does not suggest that the construction of these were acts that caused the contraventions. The contraventions were the poor structural integrity of the decks. The additions on top of the deck, or people standing or sitting on it, may have given rise to risks because of the poor structural integrity, but they would not cause that poor structural integrity.[38] Transcript of proceedings dated 1 March 2024, pages 28 and 29

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the ACT this rule has now been set out in the Legislation Act which provides:84 Saving of operation of repealed and amended laws (1) The repeal or amendment of a law does not—(a)revive anything not in force or existing when the repeal or amendment takes effect; or(b)affect the previous operation of the law or anything done, begun or suffered under the law; or(c)affect an existing right, privilege or liability acquired, accrued or incurred under the law.(2) An investigation, proceeding or remedy in relation to an existing right, privilege or liability under the law may be started, exercised, continued or completed, and the right, privilege or liability may be enforced and any penalty imposed, as if the repeal or amendment had not happened. …(5) This section is a determinative provision.(6) In this section:liability includes liability to penalty for an offence against the law.penalty includes punishment and forfeiture.privilege includes immunity.right includes capacity, interest, status and title. There are a number of sometimes difficult issues in relation to the presumption against retrospective operation of legislation. What does retrospective mean; what is a relevant right, privilege or liability; are there in effect exceptions for procedural provisions or provisions which provide for future acts based on past events? I deal with these below. But first I note that there is significant case law supporting the application of the presumption and section 84 in the circumstances of this case.Coleman Coleman v The Shell Company of Australia Limited[74] was a case with complex facts, somewhat different to those here. However, Jordan CJ of the NSW Supreme Court reviewed the authorities and stated:In the light of these considerations, I think it would be giving a retrospective operation to the Act of 1942 to hold that it enabled an action to be maintained in a case where it had ceased to be maintainable prior to the date when the Act came into force. So to hold would deprive the defendant company of a legal right to immunity from legal proceedings which had become vested in it prior to the Act. Maxwell[74] (1943) 45 SR (NSW) 27, at 31, Jordan CJ, Davidson and Halse Rogers JJ agreeing Maxwell v Murphy[75] (Maxwell) concerned compensation to relatives legislation. The relevant old Act provided that any action should be commenced within 12 months of the relevant death. Mr Maxwell died on 19 March 1951 as the result of an accident. An amending Act which commenced on 16 December 1953 omitted the reference to 12 months and inserted 6 years. His widow issued proceedings on 30 November 1954.[75] (1957) 96 CLR 261 The High Court held that the amendment did not operate to revive the plaintiff’s right to maintain an action which had been barred from 19 March 1952, before the amendment was made.[76] That is, the presumption against retrospectivity applied.[76] Dixon CJ, Williams, Kitto and Taylor JJ, Fullagar J dissenting. Dixon CJ stated that the general rule of the common law was that a statute changing the law ought not, unless the intention appears with reasonable certainty, to be understood as applying to facts or events that have already occurred in such a way as to confer or impose or otherwise affect liabilities which the law had defined by reference to the past events. This was in contrast to laws regulating the manner, practice or procedure in which liabilities are to be enforced (sometimes called procedural laws).[77] Dixon CJ stated that the facts in Maxwell fell within the presumptive rule of construction against retrospective operation. The right of action was lost before the amending Act was passed; a remedy had been conferred and a bar had been imposed:If the passing of the [amending Act] … revived her remedy that means that it revived a right which had ceased to exist and reimposed a liability on the respondent from which he had been discharged.[78][77] Maxwell at 267[78] Maxwell at 268