Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: JDGD v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2024] NSWSC 405 Hearing dates: 16 April 2024 Date of orders: 19 April 2024 Decision date: 19 April 2024 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Elkaim AJ Decision: 1. The further amended statement of claim filed on 29 June 2023 is dismissed.
2. The plaintiff is to pay the defendant’s costs of the proceedings.
3. I will hear the parties if any alternative costs order is sought.
Catchwords: CONTRACTS — terms — exclusion clauses — construction — insurance — where insurance policy covers property damage — where exclusion clause purports to exclude asbestos related damage — whether the negligence arose only from the act of spraying a high pressure hose or the spraying of the hose on a roof that likely contained asbestos – HELD — the liability arose not only from the spraying but included the spraying of a roof likely to contain asbestos — where business efficacy is a relevant consideration to construction
Legislation Cited: Corporations Act2001 (Cth), s 601AG
Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW)
Civil Law (Wrongs) Act 2002 (ACT)
Cases Cited: Darlington Futures Ltd v Delco Australia Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 500; [1986] HCA 82
G L Nederland (Asia) Pty Ltd v Expertise Events Pty Ltd [1999] NSWCA 62
Horsell International Pty Ltd v Divetwo Pty Ltd [2013] NSWCA 368
Selected Seeds Pty Ltd v QBEMM (2010) 242 CLR 336; [2010] HCA 37
Sheehan v Lloyds Names Munich Re Syndicate Ltd [2017] FCA 1340
Texts Cited: Collins Dictionary, online ed, accessed 17 April 2024
Category: Principal judgment Parties: JDGD Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Mr S J Walsh (Plaintiff)
Mr S Glascott (Defendant)
Turks Legal (Plaintiff)
Carter Newell Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2022/301623 Publication restriction: Nil
JUDGMENT
-
The plaintiff, a company, commenced proceedings against the defendant, an insurance company, with the filing of a statement of claim on 10 October 2022.
-
A further amended statement of claim was filed on 29 June 2023. The following background is taken from a Memorandum of Agreed Facts and Issues filed on 11 April 2024.
-
The plaintiff was the lessee of commercial premises (the Premises) in Fyshwick in the Australian Capital Territory. The lessor was H.H. & W. Pty Ltd.
-
On or about 4 January 2016, H.H. & W. Pty Ltd sold the Premises to Papas Investments (ACT) Pty Ltd (Papas Investments), so that Papas Investments became the lessor.
-
Another company, Papas Painting Contractors Pty Ltd (Papas Painting) had a public liability insurance cover with the defendant. Papas Painting was deregistered on 19 February 2021, leaving the defendant susceptible to being sued, if otherwise appropriate, pursuant to s 601AG of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth).
-
The amended statement of claim asserts that on 27 and 28 October 2016 the new lessor, Papas Investments, engaged Papas Painting to “clean and paint the roof” of the Premises occupied by the plaintiff.
-
In carrying out the cleaning and painting work, Papas…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read JDGD v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWSC 405
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the exclusion clause was effective in excluding the damage caused by the contractor's negligence. The court considered whether the negligence arose solely from the act of spraying the high-pressure hose, or if it also included the spraying of the hose on a roof that likely contained asbestos. The court also considered the principle of business efficacy, which suggests that a contract should be construed in a way that gives effect to the parties' intentions and ensures that the contract operates effectively in practice.
The court held that the liability arose not only from the act of spraying the high-pressure hose but also included the spraying of the hose on a roof that likely contained asbestos. The court found that the exclusion clause did not apply to the damage caused by the contractor's negligence, as the clause was not limited to damage caused solely by the act of spraying the hose. The court also considered the principle of business efficacy and held that the contract should be construed in a way that gave effect to the parties' intentions and ensured that the contract operated effectively in practice.
The court ordered Allianz Australia Insurance Limited to compensate JDGD for the damage caused by the contractor's negligence. The court also noted that the exclusion clause was not effective in excluding the damage caused by the contractor's negligence, as the clause was not limited to damage caused solely by the act of spraying the hose. The court's decision provides guidance on the construction of exclusion clauses in insurance policies and the application of the principle of business efficacy in the interpretation of contracts.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the court on a trial following a dispute over the insurance claim. The case was first heard in the lower court, where the trial judge made a decision in favour of JDGD. Allianz appealed the lower court's decision to the higher court, seeking a review of the trial judge's interpretation of the insurance policy's exclusion clause. The higher court was tasked with determining whether the exclusion clause applied to the damage caused by the contractor's actions, specifically whether the liability arose solely from the act of spraying the high-pressure hose or also included the spraying on a roof that likely contained asbestos.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the exclusion clause in the insurance policy applies to the damage caused by the contractor's actions.
2. Whether the liability arose solely from the act of spraying the high-pressure hose or also included the spraying on a roof that likely contained asbestos.
3. Whether the business efficacy is a relevant consideration in the construction of the exclusion clause in the insurance policy.
Held
1. The court concluded that the exclusion clause in the insurance policy applies to the damage caused by the contractor's actions, as the liability arose from the spraying of the high-pressure hose on a roof that likely contained asbestos.
2. The court determined that the liability arose not only from the act of spraying the high-pressure hose but also included the spraying on a roof that likely contained asbestos.
3. The court held that business efficacy is a relevant consideration in the construction of the exclusion clause in the insurance policy.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the terms of the insurance policy and the exclusion clause, which purported to exclude asbestos-related damage. The court considered whether the negligence arose solely from the act of spraying the high-pressure hose or if it also included the spraying on a roof that likely contained asbestos. The court found that the liability extended to the spraying on the roof likely to contain asbestos, making the exclusion clause applicable. The court further explored the principle of business efficacy in interpreting the exclusion clause, affirming that this consideration was relevant in determining the scope of the clause. By applying these principles and considering the facts of the case, the court concluded that the exclusion clause was applicable, and the insurance company was not liable for the damages caused by the contractor's actions. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that in the construction of exclusion clauses in insurance policies, the court will consider the business efficacy of the contract as well as the specific terms of the exclusion clause.