Jam Land Pty Ltd v Minister for the Environment

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Jam Land Pty Ltd v Minister for the Environment [2022] FCA 1058

File number: NSD 1367 of 2021
Judgment of: LEE J
Date of judgment: 12 September 2022
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – application for judicial review of remediation determination under s 480D(1) of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) (EPBC Act) and subsequent determination to affirm the remediation determination pursuant to s 480J(2) – where respondent determined that applicant had taken action likely to have a significant impact on a critically endangered ecological community in contravention of s 18(5) of the EPBC Act – whether ecological community validly listed per s 184 of EPBC Act – whether respondent’s delegates erred in law when making determinations under ss 480D and 480J of EPBC Act – whether remediation determination “specified” matters as required by s 480E(1) – application dismissed

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – whether s 184 of EPBC Act subject to implied condition of certainty – whether satisfaction of condition of certainty is a jurisdictional fact – survey of principles of statutory interpretation

EVIDENCE – admissibility of expert evidence in judicial review – admissibility of expert evidence on questions of statutory interpretation

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AB(1)(a)

Environment and Heritage Legislation Amendment Act (No 1) 2006 (Cth) Sch 1

Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) Pt 17 Div 14B; ss 3(1)(a), 18, 18(5), 18(5)(b), 178, 181, 183, 184, 184(a), 194E(1), 194E(3)(b), 194H, 194H(1)(a), 266B(1)–(2), 480D(1), 480E(1), 480E(1)(b), 480E(2)(e), 480J, 480J(1)–(3), 480L(2), 480M, 528

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37P(2)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 16.43

Explanatory Memorandum, Environment and Heritage Legislation Amendment Act (No 1) 2006 Bill (Cth)

Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995 (NSW) s 23(1)

Cases cited:

Anvil Hill Project Watch Association Inc v Minister for Environment and Water Resources [2007] FCA 1480; (2007) 243 ALR 784

Attorney-General (NSW) v Quin (1990) 170 CLR 1

Australasian Temperance & General Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd v Howe (1922) 31 CLR 290

Australian Retailers Association v Reserve Bank of Australia [2005] FCA 1707; (2005) 148 FCR 446

CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd (1997) 187 CLR 384

Comcare v Lilley [2013] FCAFC 121; (2013) 216 FCR 214

Cooper Brookes (Wollongong) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1981) 147 CLR 297

Corporation of the City of Enfield v Development Assessment Commission [2000] HCA 5; (2000) 199 CLR 135

Gedeon v Commissioner of the New South Wales Crime Commission [2008] HCA 43; (2008) 236 CLR 120

Hogan v Australian Crime Commission [2010] HCA 21; (2010) 240 CLR 651

Jolly v Yorketown District Council (1968) 119 CLR 347

K & S Lake City Freighters Pty Ltd v Gordon & Gotch Ltd (1985) 157 CLR 309

Life Insurance Co of Australia Ltd v Phillips (1925) 36 CLR 60

Mackenzie v Head, Transport for Victoria and Minister for Planning [2021] VSCA 100

Masson v Parsons [2019]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jam Land Pty Ltd v Minister for the Environment and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1058
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Jam Land Pty Ltd applied for judicial review of the remediation and affirmation determinations made by the Minister for the Environment under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth). The applicant, a landholder, sought to challenge the validity of the listing of a particular ecological community as critically endangered and the precision of the remediation determination. The Federal Court dismissed the application. The Court held that the listing of the ecological community was valid, and the delegates did not err in law by considering documents other than the Amending Instrument. The Court also found that the remediation determination was sufficiently precise. The Court rejected the admissibility of expert evidence in the judicial review process, as it was not relevant to the legal issues at hand.

The primary legal issues were whether the listing of the ecological community was valid and whether the delegates erred in law when making the remediation determination. The Court examined the statutory framework of the EPBC Act and the principles of statutory interpretation to determine the validity of the listing. The Court also considered the admissibility of expert evidence and its relevance to the judicial review process. The Court found that the listing was valid, and the delegates did not err in law when making the remediation determination. The Court further held that expert evidence was not necessary to determine the legal issues in the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for judicial review be dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In brief, each ground fails for its attempt to read into the EPBC Act conditions and implications that might appear, at least superficially, logical or expedient, but require conjectural conclusions as to the slippery notion of legislative intent: Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22 (at 38 per Lord Watson); Wilson v Anderson [2002] HCA 29; (2002) 213 CLR 401 (at 418 [8] per Gleeson CJ). Be that as it may, to the extent that purpose can be ascertained as part of the legitimate process of construction, when properly understood, it favours the Minister’s contentions.B THE RELEVANT FACTS Orders were made for the preparation of a document entitled “Agreed Background Facts” for the purposes of s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). With the benefit of that document, my factual findings are as follows. Jam Land is the registered proprietor of land in Corrowong, in the Snowy Monaro region of New South Wales. The Minister administers the EPBC Act, s 181 of which requires the Minister to establish a list of threatened ecological communities (List) divided into the following categories: (a) critically endangered; (b) endangered; and (c) vulnerable. In July 2000, the Minister made an instrument entitled “Declaration under s 178, s 181, and s 183 of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth)” which, among other things, listed the Natural Temperate Grassland of the South Eastern Highlands of New South Wales and the Australian Capital Territory (NTG-SEH) in the “endangered” category. This instrument was effective from 16 July 2000. In March 2016, the Minister made a further instrument entitled “Amendment to the lists of threatened species, threatened ecological communities and key threatening processes under sections 178, 181 and 183 of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) (EC 152)” (Amending Instrument). The Amending Instrument was effective from 6 April 2016, and, relevantly: (1) deleted NTG-SEH from the “endangered” category; and (2) included NTG-SEH “as described in the Schedule to this Instrument” (Schedule) in the “critically endangered” category. The Schedule is a one-page document that provides, among other things:The Natural Temperate Grassland of the South Eastern Highlands ecological community occurs in and around the South Eastern Highlands bioregion, as defined by version 7 of the Interim Biogeographic Regionalisation of Australia (2012). The Interim Biogeographic Regionalisation of Australia (IBRA) is a key tool for identifying land for conservation, first developed in 1993–1994 and published in Thackway R and Cresswell I D (eds) An Interim Biogeographic Regionalisation for Australia: a framework for establishing the national system of reserves (Australian Nature Conservation Agency, 1995). As might be expected, the IBRA is updated from time to time. The current version (IBRA7) classifies Australia’s landscapes into 89 large, geographically distinct so-called “bioregions”, one being the South Eastern Highlands. The 89 bioregions are further refined into 419 subregions.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Amending Instrument included NTG-SEH in the List pursuant to s 184.D THE EXPERT EVIDENCE A controversy emerged at the hearing relating to adduction of expert evidence. Both parties filed expert evidence in the field of ecology. Jam Land filed a report of Dr David Robertson dated 26 April 2022, and the Minister a report of Mr Robert Speirs dated 10 June 2022. In the course of case managing the proceedings, I made orders for the provision of joint expert evidence pursuant to s 37P(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). I did this, in part, because I had some difficulty in understanding why opinion evidence would be relevant; so if it was proposed to be adduced, I considered that it should at least be directed towards agreed questions and be provided in the most convenient and least partisan form. Questions were settled upon, and both experts then participated in a joint expert conference. Out of this process, the experts usefully produced a joint report dated 30 June 2022 (Joint Report). The controversy has two aspects. First, Jam Land sought to tender the individual reports of Dr Robertson and Mr Speirs on the basis that the Joint Report was pitched at a “fairly high level of generality”, and senior counsel intended to identify purportedly relevant detail in the individual reports. I questioned this course and indicated that I would be inclined to accept the tender of the Joint Report only. The whole point of the expert conference process was for the parties to identify the facts in issue in respect of which Jam Land asserted opinion evidence was necessary. Those issues were reflected in a document titled “Factual Issues for Determination”, which the parties prepared jointly by order of the Court. Secondly, the Minister objected to the reception of any expert evidence on the basis that the three grounds of judicial review did not call for or permit the admission of expert evidence. In any event, I determined to receive into evidence only the Joint Report, which synthesises the opinions of the experts in relation to the matters which are said to be relevant, and to allow the concurrent cross-examination of both witnesses with respect to any additional issues of relevance. I also resolved to hear later any submissions as to whether the Joint Report had any place in determining the objective exercise to be undertaken with respect to each ground of review. As will become evident, the expert evidence was immaterial to my conclusions (and even if all expert material served had been received, my conclusions would have been unaltered). It is convenient now to turn to the grounds of review.E GROUNDS OF REVIEW Jam Land contends that the Remediation Determination and Affirmation Determination were invalid on the following three grounds:(1)NTG-SEH was not validly listed as a threatened ecological community because the Amending Instrument does not identify the community the subject of the listing with “sufficient certainty and precision” (Ground One). (2)The delegates erred in law by asking the wrong question: the question posed by ss 480D and 480J, read with s 18(5)(b), was whether there was a significant effect on NTG-SEH as described in the Amending Instrument. The delegates did not turn their mind to the Amending Instrument and instead looked at another document, the Conservation Advice (Ground Two). (3)The determinations failed to specify the action to be taken to repair or mitigate the damage with sufficient precision (Ground Three).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, and in support of the Minister’s position, VAW (Kurri Kurri) recognised that a degree of “vagueness and imprecision” in the definition of such a community is inevitable. The Approved Conservation Advice itself makes this point: see, for example, at p 4 [1.2]. Although there might be more apposite metaphors, as I said at the hearing, a grassland community is a moveable feast. Such imprecision must be tolerated if the object of the EPBC Act, namely, per s 3(1)(a), protecting vulnerable and changing ecological communities, is to be achieved: VAW (Kurri Kurri) (at 671–672 [231]–[234] per Hodgson JA, Spigelman CJ agreeing at 634 [4]). Conclusion In the light of the above, the Remediation Determination and, by extension, the Affirmation Determination, insofar as they relate to s 184, were validly made. Accordingly, Ground One must fail.E.2 Ground Two With respect to Ground Two, Jam Land contends that the delegates fell into jurisdictional error “by asking the wrong question”: Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf [2001] HCA 30; (2001) 206 CLR 323 (at 351 [82]). It is said that the question posed by ss 480D and 480J, read with s 18(5)(b), was whether there was a significant effect on NTG-SEH as described in the Amending Instrument. Two elements to this argument emerged: first, the contention that the delegates failed to consider the Schedule to the Amending Instrument; and second that the delegates placed inappropriate weight upon a “non-legislative document”, being the Conservation Advice, in lieu of looking at the Amending Instrument. Senior counsel for the Minister helpfully described these two limbs as “two sides of the same coin”. Indeed, the legal basis of Ground Two is difficult to discern, as Jam Land conceded, by way of the Agreed Background Facts (at [14]), that there was no contest as to whether either delegate had the state of mind required by ss 480D(1) and 480J(1) respectively. Furthermore, no “irrelevant consideration” ground was put. As such, the question is whether the delegates properly executed the statutory task before them by going beyond the description of NTG-SEH in the Amending Instrument.Consideration This is, once again, a matter of statutory construction. The construction of the statute in Section E.1 above is a complete answer to Ground Two. There is no warrant to read into s 480D a restriction to consideration of only the Amending Instrument. Even if I am wrong as to Ground One, Ground Two must also fail for the following reasons. First, it is not correct that the delegates did not have regard to the Schedule to the Amending Instrument when making the Remediation Determination and in making the Affirmation Determination. The Amending Instrument is referred to in the footnotes to [12] of the brief provided to both delegates. As I said recently in the context of judicial review in Roberts v Attorney-General (Cth) [2022] FCA 574 (at [43]), a cynic may speculate that such briefing documents and records of executive decision-making may sometimes suggest that what was going on was some sort of kabuki dance. But such an inference should not be drawn lightly, not least where the statute does not bestow upon any one source greater credence than another.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Two elements to this argument emerged: first, the contention that the delegates failed to consider the Schedule to the Amending Instrument; and second that the delegates placed inappropriate weight upon a “non-legislative document”, being the Conservation Advice, in lieu of looking at the Amending Instrument. Senior counsel for the Minister helpfully described these two limbs as “two sides of the same coin”. Indeed, the legal basis of Ground Two is difficult to discern, as Jam Land conceded, by way of the Agreed Background Facts (at [14]), that there was no contest as to whether either delegate had the state of mind required by ss 480D(1) and 480J(1) respectively. Furthermore, no “irrelevant consideration” ground was put. As such, the question is whether the delegates properly executed the statutory task before them by going beyond the description of NTG-SEH in the Amending Instrument.Consideration This is, once again, a matter of statutory construction. The construction of the statute in Section E.1 above is a complete answer to Ground Two. There is no warrant to read into s 480D a restriction to consideration of only the Amending Instrument. Even if I am wrong as to Ground One, Ground Two must also fail for the following reasons. First, it is not correct that the delegates did not have regard to the Schedule to the Amending Instrument when making the Remediation Determination and in making the Affirmation Determination. The Amending Instrument is referred to in the footnotes to [12] of the brief provided to both delegates. As I said recently in the context of judicial review in Roberts v Attorney-General (Cth) [2022] FCA 574 (at [43]), a cynic may speculate that such briefing documents and records of executive decision-making may sometimes suggest that what was going on was some sort of kabuki dance. But such an inference should not be drawn lightly, not least where the statute does not bestow upon any one source greater credence than another. Secondly, and in any event, it was not necessary for a copy of the Amending Instrument to be included in and specifically referred to in the delegates’ respective briefs. In Anvil Hill Project Watch Association Inc v Minister for Environment and Water Resources [2007] FCA 1480; (2007) 243 ALR 784 (at 798 [54]), Stone J rejected an argument that a delegate had not considered the relevant legislative instrument in the following terms: The applicant correctly points out that what constitutes a listed community must be determined by reference to the legislative instrument that included it in the list established under s 181 … The applicant points to the documents listed by the delegate … and notes that the instrument is not mentioned. One cannot, in my view, support the conclusion that the delegate did not consider the legislative instrument from that list. It is merely a list of the evidence and materials on which she based her finding of fact and which were included in the brief from the Department. It was no more necessary for the delegate to include the instrument in that list than it was necessary for her to include to [sic] the Act.