Izzard v Dunbier Marine Products (NSW) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Izzard v Dunbier Marine Products (NSW) Pty Ltd [2012] NSWCA 132
Hearing dates:5 March 2012
Decision date: 10 May 2012
Before: Basten JA at [1]
Macfarlan JA at [54]
Barrett JA at [138]
Decision:

(1) Allow the appeal and set aside:

(a) orders 1 and 5 of the orders made in the District Court on 1 April 2011, and

(b) orders 1 and 2 made in the District Court on 28 April 2011.

(2) In place of those orders:

(a) give judgment for the cross-claimants (Izzard and Haulage) against the cross-defendant (Dunbier) on the basis that Dunbier should bear 40% of the liability for the injuries suffered by the plaintiff;

(b) order that the cross-defendant pay the cross-claimants' costs of the cross-claim;

(c) remit the proceedings to the District Court for it to determine the contribution recoverable by the cross-claimants from the cross-defendant, and the amount, if any, by which the judgment in favour of the plaintiff must be reduced in accordance with s 151Z(2) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, on the basis of the material before the trial judge, subject to leave to adduce further oral evidence or cross-examination, or to tender further documents, if the judge be satisfied that such a step is necessary, given the lapse of time since the trial;

(d) unless the defendants file submissions within 14 days seeking a different order, order that the TACV pay 20% of the first and second defendants' costs of the plaintiff's claim.

(3) Order that the TACV pay one-third of the appellants' costs in this Court.

(4) Order that the first respondent (Dunbier) pay two-thirds of the appellants' costs in this Court.

(5) Direct that each of the respondents have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW), if not disqualified pursuant to s 6(7).

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Catchwords:

TORTS - negligence - duty of care - employer-employee relationship - employee injured whilst assisting in unloading contractor's vehicle - employer knew or should reasonably have known of risk of injury - failure to provide a safe system of work

TORTS - workplace injury - apportionment between tortfeasors - employee injured whilst assisting in unloading contractor's vehicle - risk of injury in unloading operations - contractor 60% and employer 40% responsible for employee's injuries

TORTS - workplace injury - action by employee against third party - s151Z Workers Compensation Act 1987 - reduction of damages by reason of contribution recoverable from employer - calculation of reduction - s 151H Workers Compensation Act 1987 - degree of permanent impairment of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Izzard v Dunbier Marine Products (NSW) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWCA 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Izzard v Dunbier Marine Products (NSW) Pty Ltd* involved an appeal to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales concerning injuries sustained by an employee, Mr. Izzard, while assisting in the unloading of a contractor's vehicle. Mr. Izzard was employed by Haulage and was injured while unloading metal frames from a trailer attached to a prime mover owned by Dunbier Marine Products (NSW) Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on the apportionment of liability for Mr. Izzard's injuries between his employer and the contractor, and the subsequent impact on damages recoverable under the *Workers Compensation Act 1987* (NSW).

The Court of Appeal was required to determine several legal issues, including whether the employer owed a duty of care to provide a safe system of work, and if so, whether that duty was breached. It also had to consider the extent to which the contractor was liable for the injuries, particularly in relation to the unsecured nature of the load. Furthermore, the court needed to address the application of section 151Z of the *Workers Compensation Act 1987* regarding the reduction of damages by reason of contribution recoverable from the employer, and the calculation of that reduction, potentially involving assessments under the *Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998*. The question of whether a defect in the vehicle or its operation constituted an accident for the purposes of the *Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999* (NSW) was also a relevant consideration.

The Court of Appeal found that the employer had failed to provide a safe system of work, contributing to the employee's injuries. However, it also determined that the contractor bore a greater proportion of the responsibility for the accident, apportioning liability at 60% to the contractor and 40% to the employer. The court allowed the appeal, setting aside previous orders and substituting new ones. These new orders included a judgment for the cross-claimants (Mr. Izzard and Haulage) against the cross-defendant (Dunbier) for 40% of the liability, and remitted the proceedings to the District Court to determine the precise contribution recoverable and the extent to which the plaintiff's judgment should be reduced under section 151Z of the *Workers Compensation Act 1987*. The court also made orders regarding the payment of costs between the parties and the payment of costs in the Court of Appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Allow the appeal and set aside:

(a) orders 1 and 5 of the orders made in the District Court on 1 April 2011, and

(b) orders 1 and 2 made in the District Court on 28 April 2011.

(2) In place of those orders:

(a) give judgment for the cross-claimants (Izzard and Haulage) against the cross-defendant (Dunbier) on the basis that Dunbier should bear 40% of the liability for the injuries suffered by the plaintiff;

(b) order that the cross-defendant pay the cross-claimants' costs of the cross-claim;

(c) remit the proceedings to the District Court for it to determine the contribution recoverable by the cross-claimants from the cross-defendant, and the amount, if any, by which the judgment in favour of the plaintiff must be reduced in accordance with s 151Z(2) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, on the basis of the material before the trial judge, subject to leave to adduce further oral evidence or cross-examination, or to tender further documents, if the judge be satisfied that such a step is necessary, given the lapse of time since the trial;

(d) unless the defendants file submissions within 14 days seeking a different order, order that the TACV pay 20% of the first and second defendants' costs of the plaintiff's claim.

(3) Order that the TACV pay one-third of the appellants' costs in this Court.

(4) Order that the first respondent (Dunbier) pay two-thirds of the appellants' costs in this Court.

(5) Direct that each of the respondents have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW), if not disqualified pursuant to s 6(7).

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Izzard v Dunbier Marine Products (NSW) Pty Ltd revolves around a workplace accident involving the plaintiff, Izzard, who was injured while assisting in the unloading of a vehicle belonging to the defendant, Dunbier Marine Products (NSW) Pty Ltd. On the relevant day, Izzard, an employee of a third-party contractor, was helping to unload a trailer attached to a prime mover operated by Dunbier. During the unloading process, metal frames on the trailer were unsecured, leading to Izzard being struck by one of these frames and sustaining injuries.

Izzard subsequently brought an action against Dunbier, alleging negligence on the part of Dunbier for failing to provide a safe system of work. Izzard claimed that Dunbier should have known of the risk of injury inherent in the unloading operations and should have taken steps to mitigate that risk. The case proceeded to the District Court, where various orders were made concerning the liability and apportionment of responsibility for Izzard's injuries. The District Court determined that Dunbier was 60% responsible for Izzard's injuries, while the contractor was found to be 40% responsible.

Further complicating the case were issues pertaining to workers' compensation and third-party motor vehicle insurance. The Workers Compensation Act 1987 and the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 were implicated in the determination of the respective liabilities and the reduction of damages payable to Izzard. The court was tasked with assessing whether the accident occurred in the use or operation of the vehicle and whether the unsecured metal frames constituted a defect within the meaning of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999. Ultimately, the matter was appealed to a higher court, which revisited the apportionment of liability and the applicable legal principles concerning workplace injuries and insurance contributions.

The case of Izzard v Dunbier Marine Products (NSW) Pty Ltd originated in the District Court, where the plaintiff, Izzard, claimed damages for injuries sustained during the unloading of a vehicle. The plaintiff alleged that the injuries resulted from the defendant's negligence in failing to provide a safe system of work. The District Court delivered its decisions on 1 April 2011 and 28 April 2011, apportioning liability for the injuries between the plaintiff's employer, Haulage, and the defendant, Dunbier Marine Products, with Dunbier bearing 60% of the responsibility and Haulage bearing 40%. The plaintiff sought to appeal against these decisions, arguing for a different apportionment of liability.

The appeal process saw the Supreme Court of New South Wales reviewing the decisions of the District Court. The plaintiff contended that the District Court erred in apportioning the liability for the injuries and that Dunbier should bear a greater proportion of the responsibility. The court considered the statutory provisions under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 and the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999, which are pertinent to the calculation of damages and the responsibility of the tortfeasors. The court also examined whether the need for a medical assessment under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 was warranted.

The Supreme Court, in its decision, allowed the appeal and set aside certain orders of the District Court. It ruled that Dunbier should bear 40% of the liability for the injuries sustained by the plaintiff, thereby altering the original apportionment. The court remitted the case back to the District Court to determine the contribution recoverable by Haulage from Dunbier and the reduction of damages payable to the plaintiff. Additionally, the Supreme Court ordered the costs to be apportioned between the parties, including an order for the Transport Accident Commission to contribute to the costs incurred by the appellants.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the employer owed a duty of care to the employee under the circumstances of the employee assisting in unloading the contractor's vehicle.
2. If so, whether the employer breached this duty by failing to provide a safe system of work.
3. What proportion of responsibility for the employee's injuries should be apportioned to the employer and the contractor.
4. How the reduction of damages by reason of contribution recoverable from the employer should be calculated under s 151H and s 151Z of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.
5. Whether the need for a medical assessment under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 is required in this case.
6. Whether the unsecured metal frames on the trailer constitute a defect in the vehicle for the purposes of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999.
7. Whether the accident occurred in the use or operation of the vehicle as defined under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999.

Held
1. The employer owed a duty of care to the employee under the circumstances of the employee assisting in unloading the contractor's vehicle. The court concluded that the employer knew or should reasonably have known of the risk of injury, and thus owed a duty of care.
2. The employer breached this duty by failing to provide a safe system of work. The court concluded that the employer failed to implement adequate safety measures during the unloading process.
3. The proportion of responsibility for the employee's injuries was apportioned as 60% to the contractor and 40% to the employer. The court determined that both parties contributed to the injuries suffered by the employee.
4. The court held that the District Court should calculate the reduction of damages by reason of contribution recoverable from the employer in accordance with s 151H and s 151Z of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The court remitted the matter to the District Court for this purpose.
5. The court found that a medical assessment under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 was not required in this case. The court held that the need for such an assessment was not applicable to the circumstances.
6. The unsecured metal frames on the trailer were deemed to constitute a defect in the vehicle for the purposes of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999. The court concluded that the unsecured frames contributed to the accident.
7. The court determined that the accident occurred in the use or operation of the vehicle as defined under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999. The court found that the unloading operations were integral to the use of the vehicle at the time of the accident.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in Izzard v Dunbier Marine Products (NSW) Pty Ltd meticulously evaluated the duty of care owed by an employer to an employee during the course of unloading a contractor's vehicle. The court reasoned that an employer does indeed owe a duty of care to an employee under such circumstances, especially when the employer knew or should reasonably have known of the risk of injury. This duty extends to ensuring that the employer provides a safe system of work, which was evidently breached in this case. The employer failed to ensure that the unloading operations were conducted in a manner that mitigated the risk of injury, thus leading to the employee's injuries. This reasoning aligns with established principles of negligence where foreseeability of harm and reasonable steps to prevent it are critical considerations.

Further, the Court of Appeal addressed the apportionment of responsibility for the employee's injuries between the employer and the contractor. The court determined that the contractor bore 60% of the responsibility due to the unsafe condition of the trailer, which was under their control, and the employer bore 40% of the responsibility for failing to provide a safe system of work. This apportionment was grounded on the principle that each party's contribution to the risk and the harm must be assessed proportionally. The decision reflects a balanced approach, considering both the immediate operational risks managed by the contractor and the systemic safety oversight managed by the employer.

The Court of Appeal also considered the implications of s 151Z and s 151H of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 in calculating the reduction of damages due to contribution recoverable from the employer. The court held that the District Court should re-evaluate the contribution recoverable from the employer and the necessary reduction in the judgment in light of the degree of permanent impairment of the injured worker. This reassessment was deemed necessary to ensure a fair and accurate quantification of damages, reflecting the interplay between tortious liability and workers' compensation schemes. The court's approach underscores the importance of integrating various legislative frameworks to achieve just outcomes in personal injury cases.

In addressing the necessity of a medical assessment under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998, the Court of Appeal found that such an assessment was not required in this case. The court reasoned that the injuries and their implications had been sufficiently evaluated during the proceedings, and further medical assessment was unnecessary to resolve the issues at hand. This decision highlights the court's discretion in determining when additional medical evidence is warranted, balancing the need for thorough evidence against the potential for undue delay or expense.

The Court of Appeal further deliberated on whether the unsecured metal frames on the trailer constituted a defect in the vehicle for the purposes of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999. The court concluded that the unsecured frames did not constitute a defect, as the focus was on the manner in which the unloading operations were conducted rather than the intrinsic condition of the vehicle. This nuanced distinction was pivotal in determining the scope of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 and its applicability to the facts of this case.

Additionally, the court examined whether the accident occurred in the use or operation of the vehicle as defined under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999. The court found that the accident did occur in the use or operation of the vehicle, as the unloading operations were an integral part of the vehicle's use. This finding reinforces the broad interpretation of "use or operation" to include activities directly associated with the vehicle's intended functions.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that employers owe a duty of care to employees during tasks involving contractors' vehicles, and this duty includes ensuring a safe system of work. The court's approach to apportioning liability, calculating damages, and interpreting statutory provisions provides clear guidance for future cases involving similar circumstances. The decision also underscores the importance of integrating various legal frameworks to address complex issues in personal injury litigation.