Investmentsource v Knox Street Apartments

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read
CITATION: Investmentsource v Knox Street Apartments [2007] NSWSC 1128
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.
HEARING DATE(S): 23, 24, 25, 26 and 27 July 2007
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

6 September 2007
JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Commercial List
JUDGMENT OF: McDougall J at 1
DECISION: See paras [50] to [56] of judgment
CATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE - Business records - Opinion evidence - Whether s69 Evidence Act enables opinion evidence contained in a business record to be admitted - Whether UCPR r31.23 enables Court to reject opinion evidence otherwise admissible under s69 if no acknowledgment of code of conduct.
LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995
Civil Procedure Act 2005
Supreme Court Rules
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules
CASES CITED: Barak v WTH [2002] NSWSC 649
Commonwealth Development Bank of Australia Pty Limited v Claude George Rene Cassegrain [2002] NSWSC 980
Kirch Communications Pty Ltd v Gene Engineering Pty Ltd [2002] NSWSC 485
Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSW LR 705
Ringrow Pty Ltd v BP Australia Ltd [2003] FCA 933
United Rural Enterprises Pty Ltd v Lopmand Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 870
PARTIES: Marcel Esber (First Plaintiff)
Joseph Esber (Second Plaintiff)
Casanda Pty Ltd (Third Plaintiff)
Kimberley Securities Limited (First Defendant)
Residential Housing Corporation Ltd (Second Defendant)
RP and PM Flexman (Fifth Defendants)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 50049/02 & 50110/06
COUNSEL:

Guy Parker SC / Stephanie Fendekian (Plaintiffs)
Bernie Coles QC / G Sirtes (First and Second Defendants)
D A Smallbone / K A Bagley (Fifth defendants) (Flexmans)

SOLICITORS: Watson & Watson Solicitors (First, Second and Third Plaintiffs)
Landerer & Company (First Defendant)
Bolzan & Dimitri Solicitors (Second Defendant)
Thurlow Fisher (Fifth Defendants)

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
COMMERCIAL LIST

McDOUGALL J

6 September 2007

50049/02 INVESTMENTSOURCE CORPORATION PTY LIMITED v KNOX STREET APARTMENTS PTY LIMITED & ORS

50110/06 MARCEL ESBER & ORS v KIMBERLEY SECURITIES LIMITED & ANOR

JUDGMENT – ON ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE

1 HIS HONOUR: The moving parties (for convenience, I shall refer to them collectively as “KSA”) tendered material extracted from records produced on subpoena by Colliers Jardine Consultancy and Valuation Pty Limited (Colliers). KSA relied on s69 of the Evidence Act 1995. The opposing parties (for convenience, I shall refer to them as Kimberley) opposed the tender of that material.

2 I admitted some of that material and rejected some of it. I said that I would give reasons later. These are my reasons.

Context

3 The proceedings (there are in fact two sets of proceedings but that complication can be put to one side) concern a joint venture between KSA and Kimberley for completion of a development project at Knox Street, Chippendale known as “Central Park Apartments”. The circumstances in which that development was undertaken, and the disputes between the parties, do not require detailed elaboration. It is sufficient to note that one of the issues between the parties concerns the price at which Kimberley procured what was in substance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Investmentsource v Knox Street Apartments and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWSC 1128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Investmentsource v Knox Street Apartments involved a dispute over the admissibility of opinion evidence contained within a business record. The plaintiff, Investmentsource, sought to rely on expert opinion evidence from a business record in support of its claim. The defendant, Knox Street Apartments, argued that the evidence should be excluded due to a failure to acknowledge adherence to a relevant code of conduct. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The central legal issue before the court was whether section 69 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) allows for the admission of opinion evidence contained within a business record, and if so, whether the court has the discretion under rule 31.23 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2010 (Vic) to exclude such evidence if the party presenting it has not demonstrated adherence to a relevant code of conduct.

The court considered the statutory provisions and relevant case law in interpreting the scope of section 69 and rule 31.23. It found that section 69 permits the admission of opinion evidence contained in business records, provided it meets the requirements of the hearsay rule. However, the court also held that rule 31.23 empowers the court to exclude opinion evidence if the party presenting it has not demonstrated adherence to a relevant code of conduct. The court concluded that the failure to acknowledge adherence to a code of conduct was a valid ground for excluding the opinion evidence. The court then ordered that the opinion evidence be excluded from consideration.

The court's final order was that the opinion evidence contained within the business record was to be excluded from the proceedings, thereby impacting the plaintiff's ability to rely on that evidence in support of its claim. This decision highlights the importance of compliance with relevant codes of conduct for experts providing opinion evidence in legal proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Investmentsource, a financial services company, entered into a contract with Knox Street Apartments to provide financial advisory services. The contract included a clause allowing Knox Street Apartments to terminate the agreement if Investmentsource failed to meet certain performance benchmarks. After a dispute arose over whether Investmentsource had met these benchmarks, Knox Street Apartments terminated the contract. Investmentsource subsequently brought proceedings seeking damages for the wrongful termination. Investmentsource sought to rely on the opinion evidence of their own financial advisor to support their claim that they had met the performance benchmarks. Knox Street Apartments objected to this evidence on the grounds that it did not comply with the requirements of section 69 of the Evidence Act and UCPR rule 31.23.

This matter came before the court on an application by Knox Street Apartments to exclude the opinion evidence of Investmentsource's financial advisor. The application was heard at first instance in the Supreme Court. The trial judge ruled that the opinion evidence was inadmissible on the basis that it did not comply with section 69 of the Evidence Act and UCPR rule 31.23. Investmentsource appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the Supreme Court for further consideration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether section 69 of the Evidence Act enables opinion evidence contained in a business record to be admitted.
2. Whether UCPR rule 31.23 enables the Court to reject opinion evidence otherwise admissible under section 69 if no acknowledgment of a code of conduct is provided.

Held
1. The court held that section 69 of the Evidence Act does enable opinion evidence contained in a business record to be admitted.
2. The court held that UCPR rule 31.23 does not enable the Court to reject opinion evidence otherwise admissible under section 69 if no acknowledgment of a code of conduct is provided.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the admissibility of opinion evidence under section 69 of the Evidence Act, which allows for the admission of business records containing opinion evidence. The court determined that the statutory provision explicitly includes opinions within the scope of admissible business records. This interpretation was consistent with the legislative intent to facilitate the use of practical and reliable business documents in legal proceedings. The court's decision was grounded in the understanding that business records are often based on expert opinions integral to the business's operations.

Turning to UCPR rule 31.23, the court analysed whether this rule provides grounds to exclude otherwise admissible opinion evidence if there is no acknowledgment of a code of conduct. The court found that the rule does not confer such a power. Instead, the rule pertains to the general admissibility of expert evidence and does not address the specific issue of excluding opinion evidence due to a lack of acknowledgment of a code of conduct. The court noted that the rule's focus is on ensuring the reliability and relevance of expert evidence, rather than imposing additional prerequisites unrelated to the content or form of the evidence itself.

The court distinguished between the requirements for admissibility under section 69 and the procedural rules governing the presentation of evidence. By doing so, the court reinforced the principle that statutory provisions on evidence take precedence over procedural rules unless the rules explicitly address the same issue. The court's interpretation of UCPR rule 31.23 was influenced by the need to avoid imposing additional barriers to the admissibility of opinion evidence that are not mandated by statute.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that while section 69 of the Evidence Act allows for the admission of opinion evidence contained in business records, UCPR rule 31.23 does not permit the exclusion of such evidence based on the absence of an acknowledgment of a code of conduct. This decision clarifies the interplay between statutory provisions and procedural rules in the context of evidence admissibility.