FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| FALKER & FALKER | [2017] FamCA 407 |
| FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – Valuation – Appointment of single experts – Where parties unable to agree on single experts to undertake valuations of business interests – Husband seeks orders for the Court to rely on previous valuation report prepared for the purpose obtaining a mortgage – Court cannot be satisfied provisions about single experts in Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth) satisfied – Orders for wife to provide names of suitable experts to husband and husband to choose expert from such list – Orders to confer for joint letter of instruction. |
| Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 79 |
| Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth) rr 15.45(3), 15.46, 15.54, 15.59, Part 15.5 Brogden v Metropolitan Railway Co (1877) 2 App. Cas. 666 | ||
| APPLICANT: | Mr Falker | |
| RESPONDENT: | Ms Falker |
| FILE NUMBER: | SYC | 6357 | of | 2013 |
| DATE DELIVERED: | 9 June 2017 |
| PLACE DELIVERED: | Sydney |
| PLACE HEARD: | Sydney |
| JUDGMENT OF: | McClelland J |
| HEARING DATE: | 28 April 2017 |
REPRESENTATION
| COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: | Mr Campton SC |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: | Mills Oakley Lawyers |
| COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: | Mr Lloyd SC |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: | Slater & Gordon Lawyers |
Orders
Within fourteen (14) days of the date of these Orders, the wife is to provide to the husband:
(a)A list containing the names of three (3) persons who, based on the persons’ specialised knowledge, training, study and/or experience, are appropriately qualified to provide a valuation report or updated valuation report in respect to the following properties:
(i)B Street, Suburb C NSW …
(ii)D Street, Suburb E NSW …
(iii)F Street, Suburb G
(b)A list containing the names of three (3) persons who, based on the persons’ specialised knowledge, training, study and/or experience, are appropriately qualified to provide a valuation report in respect to the following entities:
(i)The Falker Superannuation Fund;
(ii)The Falker Family Trust;
(iii)The H Unit Trust;
(iv)The I Unit Trust;
(v)J Pty Ltd;
(vi)K Pty Ltd;
(vii)L Pty Ltd;
(viii)M Pty Ltd;
(ix)N Pty Ltd;
(x)O Pty Ltd;
(xi)P Pty Ltd;
(xii)Q Pty Ltd;
(xiii)R Pty Ltd; and
(xiv)S Pty Ltd.
(c)A list containing the names of three (3) persons who, based on the persons’ specialised knowledge, training, study and/or experience, are appropriately qualified to provide a valuation report in respect to the value of the … equipment located at T Pty Ltd at F Street, Suburb G;
The lists referred to in Order 1 above should include details of the fees proposed to be charged in respect to that valuation report.
Within fourteen (14) days from the date of receipt of those lists of names provided by the wife in accordance with Order 1 above, the husband is to choose one person from each of those lists to prepare a valuation report in respect to the properties, entities and equipment.
Within twenty-one (21) days from the date of these Orders, the parties are to confer with a view to preparing a joint letter of instruction to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Falker and Falker and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FamCA 407
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court was tasked with determining the process for appointing single experts to provide these valuations. Specifically, the Court needed to establish a mechanism for identifying appropriately qualified individuals, for the parties to select from these identified experts, and for the preparation of joint letters of instruction to guide the experts' work. The Court also had to consider provisions for resolving any disagreements that might arise during this process.
McClelland J ordered that the wife was to provide lists of three appropriately qualified persons for each category of asset requiring valuation, including details of their proposed fees. The husband then had fourteen days from receipt of these lists to select one expert from each list. Within twenty-one days, the parties were to confer and prepare a joint letter of instruction for each appointed expert. The Court also granted liberty to apply on seven days' notice for further procedural orders, particularly if the parties could not agree on expert selection or the joint letter of instruction, or once the expected dates for the expert reports were known.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
Within fourteen (14) days of the date of these Orders, the wife is to provide to the husband:
(a) A list containing the names of three (3) persons who, based on the persons’ specialised knowledge, training, study and/or experience, are appropriately qualified to provide a valuation report or updated valuation report in respect to the following properties:
(i) B Street, Suburb C NSW …
(ii) D Street, Suburb E NSW …
(iii) F Street, Suburb G
(b) A list containing the names of three (3) persons who, based on the persons’ specialised knowledge, training, study and/or experience, are appropriately qualified to provide a valuation report in respect to the following entities:
(i) The Falker Superannuation Fund;
(ii) The Falker Family Trust;
(iii) The H Unit Trust;
(iv) The I Unit Trust;
(v) J Pty Ltd;
(vi) K Pty Ltd;
(vii) L Pty Ltd;
(viii) M Pty Ltd;
(ix) N Pty Ltd;
(x) O Pty Ltd;
(xi) P Pty Ltd;
(xii) Q Pty Ltd;
(xiii) R Pty Ltd; and
(xiv) S Pty Ltd.
(c) A list containing the names of three (3) persons who, based on the persons’ specialised knowledge, training, study and/or experience, are appropriately qualified to provide a valuation report in respect to the value of the … equipment located at T Pty Ltd at F Street, Suburb G;
2.
The lists referred to in Order 1 above should include details of the fees proposed to be charged in respect to that valuation report.
3.
Within fourteen (14) days from the date of receipt of those lists of names provided by the wife in accordance with Order 1 above, the husband is to choose one person from each of those lists to prepare a valuation report in respect to the properties, entities and equipment.
4.
Within twenty-one (21) days from the date of these Orders, the parties are to confer with a view to preparing a joint letter of instruction to be provided to each of the single experts appointed pursuant to Order 1 above.
5.
Each party is granted liberty to apply on seven (7) days’ notice to the Court and to the other party, for the making of further procedural orders:
(a) in the event that the parties are unable to agree upon the selection of a single expert or experts or the joint letter of instruction to be provided to that single expert or experts; or,
(b) after the parties ascertain the date that the experts’ reports will be provided to the parties.
Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.
Background
Background to the litigation
Upon receiving these lists, the husband must select one person from each list to prepare the respective valuation reports. The parties are then required to confer and prepare a joint letter of instruction for the experts selected, to be provided within twenty-one days of the court's orders. Each party is granted the right to apply for further procedural orders if they are unable to agree on the selection of experts or the joint letter of instruction, or if they ascertain the date when the experts' reports will be provided. The form of these orders is subject to the court’s final entry in its records.
The matter of Falker and Falker originated in the Family Court of Australia as a property settlement proceeding following the dissolution of the marriage of the parties. This case represents a first-instance hearing where the court was tasked with making binding determinations on the distribution of the matrimonial assets. Prior to this hearing, the parties had engaged in unsuccessful negotiations to reach a settlement agreement. Consequently, the wife filed an application for property settlement orders, which prompted the husband to respond with his own application seeking orders for the valuation of specific properties and entities. The court's role in this proceeding was to oversee the valuation process and direct the parties on the selection of experts to ensure that the valuations were conducted in a fair and unbiased manner. Throughout the proceedings, the court had to manage various procedural applications, including the appointment of experts for the valuation of real estate, business entities, and equipment. The court's orders in this case aimed to streamline the process and avoid further disputes by setting out clear timelines and responsibilities for both parties in selecting and instructing the experts.
Decision
Reasons for decision
ISSUES:
1. What are the qualifications and criteria required for the experts to be appropriately qualified to provide the valuation reports for the specified properties, entities, and equipment?
2. Should the lists provided by the wife include details of the fees proposed to be charged by the experts for the preparation of the valuation reports?
3. How should the selection process for the single expert from each list be conducted and who has the authority to make the final selection?
4. What are the obligations of the parties in preparing a joint letter of instruction for the appointed experts?
5. In what circumstances may the parties apply to the Court for further procedural orders?
Held
1. The court held that the wife must provide lists of appropriately qualified experts for the valuation of specified properties, entities, and equipment within fourteen days of the orders.
2. The court held that the lists provided by the wife must include details of the fees proposed to be charged by the experts.
3. The court held that the husband must choose one expert from each list provided by the wife within fourteen days of receiving those lists.
4. The court held that the parties must prepare a joint letter of instruction for the appointed experts within twenty-one days of the orders.
5. The court held that each party has the liberty to apply for further procedural orders if they are unable to agree on the selection of experts or the joint letter of instruction, or after ascertaining the date the experts' reports will be provided.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court in Falker and Falker has addressed several key issues concerning the qualifications and selection of experts for the preparation of valuation reports, the disclosure of fees, and the procedural obligations of the parties. The Court's reasoning provides clarity on the criteria for expert qualification, the necessity for fee disclosure, and the processes for expert selection and joint instruction preparation. Furthermore, the Court has outlined the circumstances under which further procedural orders may be sought.
In determining the qualifications and criteria required for experts to provide valuation reports for specified properties, entities, and equipment, the Court emphasised the importance of specialised knowledge, training, study, and experience. The Court mandated that the wife must provide lists of experts who meet these criteria, ensuring that each list includes three potential experts for each category of properties, entities, and equipment. This requirement underscores the need for impartiality and expertise in the valuation process, ensuring that the reports are credible and reliable. The Court did not specify a particular professional qualification or certification but focused on the expertise and relevant experience of the experts.
Regarding the inclusion of fees in the lists provided by the wife, the Court ruled that these lists must also detail the fees proposed to be charged by the experts for their services. This transparency ensures that both parties are aware of the financial implications and can make informed decisions regarding the selection of experts. The inclusion of fee details is crucial for avoiding disputes over costs and ensuring that the parties can budget appropriately for the valuation reports.
The Court outlined a clear process for selecting the experts from the lists provided by the wife. The husband was given fourteen days to choose one expert from each list to prepare the valuation reports. This process ensures that both parties have an opportunity to review the proposed experts and make a selection based on the provided information. The Court's decision to grant the husband the authority to make the final selection from the lists provided by the wife ensures a degree of fairness and balance in the process.
In terms of the obligations of the parties in preparing a joint letter of instruction for the appointed experts, the Court mandated that the parties must confer within twenty-one days to prepare this document. A joint letter of instruction is essential for providing clear and unified directives to the experts, ensuring that they understand the scope and requirements of their valuation reports. This collaborative effort fosters cooperation between the parties and helps to avoid potential conflicts that may arise during the valuation process.
Lastly, the Court addressed the circumstances under which the parties may apply for further procedural orders. The Court granted each party the liberty to apply for additional orders if they are unable to agree on the selection of experts or the content of the joint letter of instruction. Additionally, parties may seek further orders after ascertaining the date when the experts’ reports will be provided. This provision allows for flexibility and ensures that the Court can address any procedural issues that may arise during the valuation process.
In summary, the Court's decision in Falker and Falker establishes a structured and transparent process for the selection and instruction of experts in valuation matters. The Court emphasised the importance of expertise, transparency in fees, and collaborative preparation of instructions. Furthermore, the Court provided mechanisms for resolving any disputes or procedural issues that may arise during the valuation process. The ratio decidendi of this decision is the requirement for clear criteria for expert qualification, transparency in fees, and a structured process for expert selection and joint instruction preparation, with the ability to seek further procedural orders if necessary.