Industrial Galvanizers Corporation Pty Ltd v Safe Direction Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Industrial Galvanizers Corporation Pty Ltd v Safe Direction Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1192

File number: NSD 600 of 2016
Judge: BURLEY  J
Date of judgment: 10 August 2018
Catchwords:

PATENTS – priority date – external fair basis – whether patent date deferred by subsequent amendment – held no real and reasonably clear disclosure in unamended specification of what was claimed as a result of the amendment

PATENTS – internal fair basis – whether claimed invention is fairly based on disclosure in the specification – held claims of Final patent fairly based on the specification

PATENTS – personal liability of director for infringement by company – joint tortfeasor – meaning of “authorise” under s 13 of the Patents Act – held no joint tortfeasorship or authorisation

CONSUMER LAW – misleading or deceptive conduct in contravention of the Australian Consumer Law – whether offer for sale, sale, distribution, advertisement, supply, exhibition and promotion of product constitutes a representation in trade or commerce that the purchaser will have a right to use the product – held no contravention of the Australian Consumer Law

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Schedule 2, s 18

Copyright Act 1958 (Cth)

Intellectual Property laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 (Cth), Schedule 1, part 3, cl 55

Patents Act 1990 (Cth), ss 13, 40, 43, 114, 122

Patents Regulations 1991 (Cth), reg 3.14

Cases cited:

Adelaide Corporation v Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd [1928] HCA 10; (1928) 40 CLR 481

Advanced Building Systems Pty Ltd v Ramset Fasteners (Aust) Pty Ltd & Ors [1995] FCA 236; (1995) AIPC 91-129

Allen Manufacturing Co Pty Ltd v McCallum & Co Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1838; (2001) 53 IPR 400

AstraZeneca AB v Apotex Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 99; (2014) 226 FCR 324

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Fortescue Metals Group Ltd [2011] FCAFC 19; (2011) 190 FCR 364

Bristol-Myers Squibb v FH Faulding [2000] FCA 316; (2000) 97 FCR 524

Cooper v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd [2006] FCAFC 187; (2006) 156 FCR 380

Heydon v NRMA Ltd [2000] HCA 374; (2000) 51 NSWLR 1

Inverness Medical Switzerland GMBH v MDS Diagnostics Pty Ltd [2010] FCA; (2010) 85 IPR 525

JR Consulting & Drafting Pty Ltd v Cummings [2016] FCAFC 20; 116 IPR 440

Jupiters Ltd v Neurizon Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 90; (2005) 65 IPR 86 at [67]

Keller v LED Technologies Pty Ltd [2010] FCAFC 55; (2010) 185 FCR 449

Kimberly-Clark Australia v Arico Trading [1998] FCA 1103; (1998) 42 IPR 111

Lockwood Security ProductsPty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 58; (2004) 217 CLR 274

Mentmore Manufacturing Co Ltd v National Merchandising Manufacturing Co Inc (1978) 89 DLR (3d) 195

Microsoft Corporation v Auschina Polaris Pty Ltd [1996] FCA 1069; (1996) 71 FCR 231

Performing Right Society Ltd v Ciryl Theatrical Syndicate Ltd [1924] 1 KB 1

Ramset Fasteners (Aust) Pty Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Industrial Galvanizers Corporation Pty Ltd v Safe Direction... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Industrial Galvanizers Corporation Pty Ltd (Ingal) brought an action against Safe Direction Pty Ltd (Safe Direction) and its director, Mr Wallace, for infringement of patent claims, breach of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), and personal liability under the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). The Federal Court was tasked with resolving several key issues, including whether the patent claims lacked novelty due to the Safe Direction patent, whether the invention was fairly based on the disclosure in the specification, and whether Mr Wallace was liable for the infringement. Additionally, the court examined whether Safe Direction was liable for additional damages and whether they contravened s 18 of the ACL by misleading consumers regarding their rights to use the patented product.

The court found that the claims of the Final Patent lacked novelty due to the Safe Direction Patent, indicating that the invention disclosed in the Complete Patent was sufficiently clear and complete. However, the court upheld the validity of the Final Patent, concluding that the claims were fairly based on the specification despite the absence of the axial alignment feature in the Complete Patent. The court also ruled that Mr Wallace was not liable as a joint tortfeasor or as someone who authorised Safe Direction's infringement of the patent. Furthermore, the court held that Safe Direction was not liable for additional damages and did not contravene s 18 of the ACL by implying consumers would have rights to use the patented product.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the detailed examination of patent law principles, particularly the requirements for novelty and fair basis, as well as the interpretation of statutory provisions regarding authorisation and joint tortfeasorship under the Patents Act. The findings on the ACL claim were based on the interpretation of consumer protection laws and the specific representations made by Safe Direction regarding the use of their product. The court's decision was comprehensive, addressing each of the issues raised by the parties with careful consideration of the evidence and legal arguments presented.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), until further order, these reasons:

(a) will be disclosed to the following persons only:

(i) any judge, employee or other personnel of this Court;

(ii) the First Respondents, including its employees, directors, shareholders and external legal representatives;

(iii) the Second Respondent and its external legal representatives;

(iv) external legal representatives of the Applicant who have signed a confidentiality undertaking in the form agreed between the Second Respondent and the Applicant; and

(v) such other persons authorised by the First or Second Respondents or as the Court may order;

(b) will not be open to public inspection or disclosed in open Court or disclosed in the open part of any Court transcript.

(2) Within 7 days of the date of this judgment, after conferring, the parties inform my chambers where, if at all, it is claimed that the reasons for judgment contain information in respect of which a non-publication order has been or should be made.

(3) Within 14 days of the date of this judgment, the parties endeavour to agree as to the appropriate form of orders (including as to costs) to be made reflecting the conclusions expressed in these reasons.

(4) In the event that no agreement is reached, within 21 days of the date of this judgment, the parties are to notify the Court as to the orders for which they contend (in mark-up) and supply written submissions of no more than 5 pages in length addressing their respective contentions and indicating whether they desire to be heard on the issues addressed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Industrial Galvanizers Corporation Pty Ltd (Ingal) initiated legal proceedings against Safe Direction Pty Ltd (Safe Direction) concerning patent infringement and potential breaches of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The dispute originated from Ingal's assertion that Safe Direction's products infringed upon their patented technology related to guard rail systems for roadside safety. Specifically, Ingal claimed that Safe Direction's products, which included posts and guard rail assemblies, violated the claims of Ingal's patent. Safe Direction contested these claims, arguing that Ingal's patent was invalid due to issues with its priority date and fair basis disclosure. Additionally, Ingal sought to hold an individual director of Safe Direction, Mr. Wallace, personally liable for the company's actions under the Patents Act and for misleading or deceptive conduct under the ACL.

The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. Prior to this hearing, Ingal and Safe Direction had engaged in several rounds of pleadings, including statements of claim, defences, and further amended statements of claim. Various expert witnesses were involved in the proceedings, providing affidavits and participating in expert reports concerning the technical aspects of the patent claims. Safe Direction filed motions seeking to strike out certain parts of Ingal's claims, which were considered during the hearing. The court had to determine several key issues, including the validity of the patent, the liability of the director, and potential ACL breaches.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is appropriate to note that the pleaded case for each of the parties raised a significant number of additional issues that, through the good sense and cooperation of the parties and their representatives, have fallen away. They are to be congratulated. The result is that the issues for determination were distilled by the parties to the following:(1)The external fair basis issue; (2)The internal fair basis issue;(3)Whether Mr Wallace is liable as a person who has (a) authorised pursuant to s 13(1) of the Act or (b) been engaged as a joint tortfeasor in respect of the conduct pleaded in paragraph 11 of the Further Amended Statement of Claim;(4)Whether the respondents are liable to an award of additional damages; and(5)Whether Safe Direction has contravened s 18 of the ACL.1.2 Summary of conclusions For the reasons more fully explained below I find in favour of Safe Direction on the external fair basis issue, with the consequence that the claims of the Final Patent lack novelty in light of the Safe Direction Patent. I do not accept Safe Direction’s internal fair basis challenge. Against the prospect that I am wrong in concluding that the Final Patent is invalid, I have considered the claims made against Mr Wallace and find that he is not (or rather, would not be) liable as a joint tortfeasor with Safe Direction or as a person who has authorised Safe Direction to infringe the Final Patent. I also find that Safe Direction would not be liable for additional damages. Finally, I reject Ingal’s claim that Safe Direction has contravened s 18 of the ACL. 1.3 The witnesses Wyndham John Davies is a solicitor in the employ of Sparke Helmore Lawyers, the solicitors acting for Ingal. He swore one affidavit in the proceeding, which puts into evidence documents relevant to Ingal’s claim. He was not cross-examined. Raphael Grzebieta is the expert witness retained by Ingal. He is a Professor, Road Safety, at the Transport and Road Safety Research, School of Aviation at the University of New South Wales. He is a Fellow of the Institute of Engineers Australia and a Fellow of the Australasian College of Road Safety. He has a Bachelor of Engineering with First Class Honours from Kosciuszko Technical University, Kraków, Poland. In 1991 he was awarded a PhD by Monash University. He has extensive experience in the areas of road safety, road safety barrier crashworthiness and vehicle crashworthiness. Professor Grzebieta gives evidence relating to the technical field of the invention and the construction of the relevant patent documents. He affirmed two affidavits in the proceeding and participated in the preparation of a joint expert report with Dr Plaxico. He was not cross-examined. Chuck Aldon Plaxico is the expert witness retained by Safe Direction. He is the Vice President and a Partner of RoadSafe LLC (RoadSafe), a company based in Canton, Maine, in the United States of America that provides a range of services to clients in the roadside and highway safety industries. Dr Plaxico was awarded a PhD in civil engineering from Worcester Polytechnic Institute in Massachusetts in 2003, a Master of Science degree from the University of Mississippi in 1995 and a Bachelor of Science degree in civil engineering from the University of Mississippi in 1992. He is RoadSafe’s Finite Element Analysis Group Leader and in that role uses finite element analysis to model and predict the complex dynamic event of vehicle collisions with roadside safety hardware systems, such as guardrails, to determine matters such as the extent of damage to both the hardware and the impacting vehicle. He has been practising and conducting research in the crashworthiness of roadside hardware using finite element analysis since 1993. He gives an overview of his knowledge of the features and functionality of roadside W-beam guard rail barrier systems, and the construction of the relevant patent documents. He swore one affidavit in this proceeding and participated in the preparation of a joint expert report with Professor Grzebieta. He was cross-examined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ingal submits that the evidence of Dr Plaxico is consistent with that of Professor Grzebieta.2.5 Consideration of external fair basis In considering the matter disclosed in the Complete Patent, one must have regard to the entirety of the disclosure of that document as it would be understood by the person skilled in the art armed with the common general knowledge as at the relevant priority date. There was no dispute between the parties that both of the experts were suitably qualified, or that they approached their task in light of the relevant common general knowledge as at the relevant date. The experts explain that the invention described in the Complete Patent is directed towards an improved post which assists the guard rail in better performing its function during a collision by allowing the guard rail to remain in place during a collision. This is done through the post being frangible or collapsible in a controlled manner as described in the specification. That is, the post releases the guard rail at an appropriate moment so as to facilitate redirection of the errant vehicle away from the hazard. For present purposes the essential question is whether the Complete Patent made a real and reasonably clear disclosure of what was claimed as a result of the amendments; AstraZeneca at [242]. This involves first considering claim 1 of the Final Patent and then comparing that with the matter disclosed in the Complete Patent. Claim 1 of the Final Patent is set out in [39] above. It is for a post and guard assembly consisting of a post that includes an elongated mounting hole for connecting the guard rail to the post using a bolt passing through the guard rail and the mounting hole, the mounting hole being located below the upper edge of the post and including one or more apertures or slots spaced from the mounting hole wherein one of the apertures or slots has a perimeter or perimeter length longer than that of the mounting hole. There is no dispute that the axial alignment feature is absent from this claim (and all other claims of the Final Patent, which are dependent on claim 1). The debate between the parties accordingly focusses attention on whether a combination that includes the limitations contained in that feature was in substance disclosed in the Complete Patent. In my view the disclosure of the Complete Patent is of a post for a guard rail system and a guard rail assembly that consists of a number of features and which includes a limitation that the apertures or slots be located above the mounting hole and that they by axially aligned with a central longitudinal axis of the mounting hole (that is, the axial alignment feature). The apparent purpose of the particular alignment of the apertures or slots is, as Dr Plaxico said, to create a pathway for the bolt and the lands between these slots which are meant to create resistance by impeding the bolt’s upward movement through the slots. In reaching this view I have regard to the whole of the disclosure of the Complete Patent.